Maharashtra

Wardha

CC/08/35

Arun Narayanrao Bhende - Complainant(s)

Versus

Wardha Zilha Central Co-op. Bank Employees Credit Society Limited - Opp.Party(s)

Adv. A.M.Gadapale

28 Jul 2008

ORDER


District Consumer Forum
Sewagram Road, Opposite Yashwant College
consumer case(CC) No. CC/08/35

Arun Narayanrao Bhende
...........Appellant(s)

Vs.

Wardha Zilha Central Co-op. Bank Employees Credit Society Limited
...........Respondent(s)


BEFORE:
1. Sau.Sushama W/O Pradeep Joshi 2. Shri Ramlal Bhavarlal Somani

Complainant(s)/Appellant(s):
1. Arun Narayanrao Bhende

OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
1. Wardha Zilha Central Co-op. Bank Employees Credit Society Limited

OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
1. Adv. A.M.Gadapale

OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
1. Adv. R.M.Guru



ORDER

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.

ftYgk xzkgd rØkj fuokj.k eap] o/kkZ

 

 rØkj izdj.k Øekad % 35@2008                             nk[ky fnukad          % 12-05-2008

                                                                                    uksVhl rkehyhpk fn-% 29-05-2008

  fudky fnukad         % 28-07-2008

                        izdj.kkpk dkyko/kh   % 1 e- 29 fnol

 

v#.k ukjk;.kjko HksaMs]                                                             ---rØkjdrkZ

o; % 57 o”kZs] O;olk; % lsokfuo`Rr]

jk-‘kkjnkuxj] ,l-Vh-dkWyuh]

lkbZuxjtoG]  o/kkZ-

  

             & fo  #  /n  &

 

            o/kkZ ftYgk lsaVªy dks&vkWi- cWad ,EykWbZt ØsfMV                               ----fo#/ni{k

            lkslk;Vh fyfeVsM] ekQZr iz’kkld] o/kkZ ftYgk

            lsaVªy dks&vkWi- cWad izeq[k dk;kZy;kph bekjr]

            esu jsYos LVs’kutoG] o/kkZ-

 

 

U;k;eap x.kiqrhZ                         %                  Jh- jkeyky Hk-lksek.kh] ek-v/;{k

                                                            lkS- lq”kek  iz- tks’kh] ek-lnL;k

 

vtZnkj  ;kaps rQsZ                    %            vWM- Jh- xMkikys-

fo#/n Ik{kkrQsZ                                     %                  vWM- Jh- jkmr-

 

 

 

%%%   vk  ns   ‘k   %%%

¼ ikjhr fnukad % 28-07-2008½

 

Jh- jkeyky Hk- lksek.kh] ek- v/;{k] ;kaps dFkukuqlkj-  

 

1-                 rØkjdR;kZus lnj rØkj xzk-la-dk-1986 dye 12 vUo;s rØkj nk[ky dsysyh vlwu rØkj FkksMD;kr v’kh vkgs dh] fo#/ni{k ir laLFskpk rØkjdrkZ lHkkln gksrk o R;kus o/kkZ ftYgk lsaVªy dks&vkWijsfVOg cWad fyfeVsM o/kkZ ;sFkwu fn-13-07-2007 yk LosPNk fuo`Rrh ?ksryh vkf.k R;kus R;kph tek vlysyh jDde #-70]197@&ph fo#/ni{kkdMs ekx.kh dsyh- fn-20-02-2008 jksth R;kyk fo#/ni{kkdMwu ,d Ik= izkIr >kys vkf.k R;kr uewn dsys dh] lHkkln Jherh j.kfils ;kaps geh/kkjd rØkjdrZs vlY;kus R;kaps tksi;Zar dtZ ijrQsM gksr ukgh rksi;Zar jDde R;kauk ns; gks.kkj ukgh- dsoG ;k lanHkkZr Ik=O;ogkj >kyk-

 

2-                 rØkjdR;kZyk iq<s vls dGys dh] fn-13-11-2001 iklwu vktrkxk;r dtkZm jdesps #-4]000@& izek.ks ,dgh gIrk olqy >kysyk ukgh- tsOgh dh] vkti;Zar 95 VDds jDde olqy >kyh Ogko;kl ikfgts gksrh- fo#/ni{kkdMs #-1]41]000@& dtZ/kkjd lHkklnkps Fkdhr vlY;kps rØkjdR;kZyk dGys vkf.k ;kdjhrk rØkjdR;kZyk tckcnkj /kjrk ;sr ukgh- fo#/ni{kkus eqnrhP;k vkr dkjokbZ d#u jDde olqy dsyh ukgh- lnj dtZ/kkjd v|kigh uksdjhr vkgs- frP;k osrukrwu o brj QaMkrwu lnj dtkZph olqyh gksm ‘kdrs- rlsp dtZ ekx.kh vtkZr v’kh dks.krhgh vV fdaok ‘krZ ukgh dh] dtZ/kkjdkps dtkZph olqydjhrk fdaok iw.kZi.ks dtkZph ijrQsM gksbZikosrks geh/kkjdkps vFkkZr vtZnkjkph lnj ir laLFksdMs vlysyh jDde FkkacfoY;k tkbZy-

 

3-                 #-12]000@& ‘ks;lZph jDde] #-8]036@& tek vlysyh jDde] #-50]161@& lDrhph tek jDde v’kh ,dw.k #-70]197@& jDde 24 VDds O;ktklg feGkoh] #-10]000@& uwdlku HkjikbZ ] rØkjhpk [kpZ #-5]000@& feGkosr v’kk ekx.;k dsysY;k vkgsr- rØkjdR;kZus vkiY;k Eg.k.;kP;k iq”VÓFkZ 6 dkxni=s nk[ky dsysyh vkgsr-

 

4-                 fo#/ni{kkus gtj gksmu vkiys ys[kh mRrj 27-07-2008 yk nk[ky d#u rØkjdR;kZps vk{ksi QsVkGys- dtZ vtZ fu-Ø-11 ¼ ekdZ ^^,**½ oj lnj vV ueqn vkgs- rØkjdR;kZph tek vlysY;k jdesckcr okn ukgh- dtkZph ijrQsM gksbZi;Zar rØkjdR;kZph jDde rs jks[kw ‘kdrkr- cWadsps dtZ vlY;kus rØkjdR;kZph jDde rs xksBfor vkgs- laLFksps dkjHkkj iz’kkld useY;kus R;kaP;kdMs vkyssys vkgsr- R;keqGs jftLVªkj ;kaP;k ijokuxhf’kok; laLFksfo#/n dkjokbZ djrk ;sr ukgh- fo#/ni{kkus vkiY;k mRrjklkscr lkS-j.kfils g;kapk dtZ feG.;kdjhrk nk[ky dsysyk vtZ] djkjukek] laerh o vf/kdkji=] tekjrnkjkps laerhi= o opu fpB~Bh rlsp fu-Ø-16 lkscr lkS-j.kfils g;kaP;kdMwu ?ks.ks vlysY;k jdespk rif’ky nk[ky dsyk vkgs-

 

5-                 mHk; i{kkus vkiyk ys[kh ;qDrhokn nk[ky dsyk vlwu fo#/ni{kkus West Bengal State Consumer Commission, “Calcutta III (2000) CPJ 75 Subrata Roy Vs. Tapan Kumar Bhattacharjee”,  “AIR 2000 Karnataka 201, Smt.K.S.Nagalambika Vs. M/s. Corporation Bank, Virajpet”  gs fuokMs nk[ky dsys vkgsr- rlsp lnj rØkj [kpkZlg [kkjht djkoh v’kh fouarh dsyh vkgs-

 

6-                 mHk; Ik{kkps ‘kiFksoj ys[kh Eg.k.ks] nk[ky dkxnksi=h iqjkos] ys[kh o rksaMh ;qDrhoknkps lq{e voyksdu dsY;koj eap [kkyhy fu”d”kkZoj vkys-

fu”d”kZ

7-                 rØkjdR;kZpk o fo#/ni{kkpk rØkjdR;kZP;k tek jdesckcr o lkS- j.kfils g;kaP;k dtkZckcr o Fkfdr jdesckcr okn ukgh- rØkjdR;kZus LosPNk fuo`Rrh ?ksryh  vkgs- fo#/ni{kkP;k nk[ky dkxni=ko#u Li”V gksrs dh] njegk #-4]000@& olqy dj.;kP;k vVhoj #-2]00]000@&gh jDde 84 efgU;kr ijr dj.;kP;k vVhoj lkS-j.kfils g;kauh dtZ ?ksrys vkgs vkf.k R;koj rØkjdrkZ vkf.k brj lHkkln tekurnkj vkgsr- dtkZlaca/khpk djkjukek lkS- j.kfils ;kaP;k’kh fo#/ni{kkus dsysyk vkgs- R;koj tekurnkjkph lgerh Eg.kwu Lok{kjh vkgs vkf.k R;ke/;s vV Ø- 7 e/;s ¼^^iksV fu;ekizek.ks ek÷;k tekurnkjkps lHkklnRo laLFksrwu jn~n >kY;kl vxj dk;Zdkjh eaMGkps ers rks tekurnkj v;ksX; vkgs vls okVY;kl ek÷;koj dk;Zdkjh eaMGkus fnysY;k eqnrhP;k vkr nqljk tekurnkj ns.;kph tckcnkjh ek>h jkghy-**½ rlsp vV Ø- 10 e/;s  ¼^^tj ek>h cnyh laLFksps dk;Z{ks=kckgsj >kyh rj vxj eyk uksdjhrwu deh dsys rj ek>sdMhy ;s.ks vlysys dtZ ek>s ‘ksoVps ixkjkrwu cksul] xzWP;qbZVh] flD;jhVh fMikWf>V] lqV~Vhpk ixkj rlsp laLFksrhy ek>h Bso] fgLls o lcLØhI’ku ;krwu olwy dj.;kr ;sbZy-**½

 

8-                 osruke/kwu njegk #-4]000@& dikr dj.;kpk vf/kdkj lkS-j.kfils ;kaP;k dk;kZy;kus fnysyk vkgs- v’kk ijhfLFkrhr 84 eghus 13-11-2008 yk iw.kZ gksrkr- Eg.ktsp ;k dkyko/khr laiw.kZ dtZ ijrQsM gks.ks xjtsps gksrs- ijarw fo#/ni{kkus uewn dsY;kizek.ks #-1]21]655@& eqn~ny o R;koj O;kt lkS- j.kfils ;kaP;kdMwu ?ks.ks ckdh vkgs-

 

9-                 fo#/ni{kkps fuokMs izLrqr izdj.kh ykxw gksr ukgh- dkj.k tek vlysY;k jdescn~ny gk okn vlwu fo#/ni{k nsr vlysY;k lsose/;s eksMrks vkf.k nks”kiw.kZ lsok fnyh vlY;kl ;k eapkyk rØkj pkyfo.;kpk vf/kdkj vkgs-  “AIR 2000 Karnataka 201, Smt.K.S.Nagalambika Vs. M/s. Corporation Bank, Virajpet”   gk fuokMk ;sFks ykxw gksr ukgh- dkj.k lnj fuokM;ke/;s “Contract Act (9 of 1872), D.171-Bank loan-Banker’s lien-Right of-Extends generally also over fixed deposits of customer including that of his/her spouse-Bank entitled to adjust amount towards the loan account. vls uewn dsys vkgs- ;ko#u eapkps Li”V er vkgs dh] T;kaph Bso fdaok ‘ks;lZ v’kk izdkjph dks.krsgh gDd xksBfo.;kps vf/kdkj fo#/ni{kkyk fnysys ukgh- ijarq gsgh rso<sp [kjs dh] dtkZph ijrQsM iw.kZ gks.ks vkgs- ijarw lnj djkj 13-11-2008 Ik;Zar ykxw vkgss- v’kk ifjfLFkrhr eapkP;k ers uSlfxZd U;k; rRokP;k n`”Vhus lsok fuo`Rr >kysY;k deZpk&;kyk R;kyk ns; vlysyh jDde ;ksX;osGh feG.ks xjtsps vlwu dk;ns’khj vkgs gsgh foljrk ;sr ukgh dh] fo#/ni{kkus lnj dtZnkj lkS-j.kfils ;kauk] rØkjdR;kZpk jDde ekx.;kpk vtZ vkY;koj brj tkfeunkj miyC/k d#u ns.;kcn~ny d/khgh dqByhgh lqpuk dsysyh fnlr ukgh- ;ko#u fo#/ni{kkpk mn~ns’k Li”V gksrks- Eg.kwu eapkps vls Li”V er vkgs dh] fo#/ni{kkus rØkjdR;kZyk R;kph ns; vlysyh jDde lnj 13-11-2001 pk djkj laiq”Vkr vkY;kuarj ijr dj.;kph r;kjh u n’kZowu nks”kiw.kZ lsok fnysyh vkgs- gs lq/nk Li”V gksrs dh] fo#/ni{k laLFkspk dkjHkkj gk iz’kkldkdMs vkysyk vkgs- dnkfpr vkfFkZd O;ogkj cjkscj ulY;kdkj.kkus lapkyd eaMGkdMwu dk<wu Vkd.;kr vkysys vkgs- ;ko#u vls fnlwu ;srs dh] lnj dtZnkj lkS-j.kfils ;kaP;kdMwu fdaok R;kaps tekurnkj ;kauk d/khgh dks.krhgh dtZ olqyh gksr ulY;kcn~ny fdaok lnj dtZnkj Fkdhr vlY;kcn~ny lqpuk fnyh xsyh ukgh fdaok rlk dkxnksi=h iqjkok eapkr nk[ky dsyk ukgh- v’kk ifjfLFkrhr fo#/ni{kkP;k laLFksdMwu fdaok iz’kkldk}kjs dkjokbZ u dsY;k xsY;keqGs izLrqr ijhfLFkrhr mn~Hkoysyh vkgs vkf.k ;ksX;osGh dtZ olqyh >kyh vlrh rj rØkjdR;kZyk tkLr dkG okV igkoh ykxyh ulrh- Eg.kwu eapkP;k ers fo#/ni{kkus rØkjdR;kZyk nks”kiw.kZ lsok fnysyh vkgs- Eg.kwu eap [kkyhyizek.ks vkns’k ikfjr djhr vkgs-

vkns’k

 

            rØkjdR;kZph rØkj va’kr% eatwj dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-

            fo#/ni{kkus rØkjdR;kZyk R;kph tek vlysyh jDde lnj 13-11-2001 pk djkj laiq”Vkr vkY;kuarj ns; dj.;kph r;kjh u n’kZowu nks”kiw.kZ lsok fnyh vkgs-

            fo#/ni{kkus rØkjdR;kZyk R;kph tek vlysyh jDde #-70]197@& fn-13-11-2008 uarj 7 fnolkps vkr ns; djkoh-

            fo#/ni{kkus lnj dtZnkj lkS-j.kfils ;kauk fn-13-11-2008 uarj dtZ pqdrs dj.;kph eqHkk fnY;kl brj tekurnkj miyC/k dj.;kph lqpuk nsmu rØkjdR;kZyk tkfeu eqDr djkos-

            fo#/ni{kkus rØkjhpk [kpZ #-1]000@& rØkjdR;kZyk ns; djkok-

       mHk; Ik{kkauk ;k vkns’kkph lgh f’kDD;kph izekf.kr izr fu%’kqYd ns.;kr ;koh-

            eapke/;s ek- lnL;kadjhrk fnysys ¼c½ o ¼d½ QkbZYlP;k izrh rØkjdR;kZauh ?ksowu tkO;kr-

 

 

¼lkS- lq”kek tks’kh½                     ¼jkeyky lksek.kh½

                           lnL;k                                     v/;{k

 

 




......................Sau.Sushama W/O Pradeep Joshi
......................Shri Ramlal Bhavarlal Somani