BEFORE A.P STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION AT HYDERABAD

 C.C.NO.91 OF 2011

Between:

M/s Ramakrishna Electronics
rep. by its Managing Partner V Shop No.29, 30, 31, Municipal Shopping Complex
Park Road, Kurnool                             

United India Insurance Co., Ltd. Divisional Office D.No.40/304,

Counsel for the complainant                 Counsel for the opposite parties 

QUORUM:  

                       SRI THOTA ASHOK KUMAR, HON’BLE MEMBER

Oral Order (As per Sri                                       1.            `53,38,269/- out of which an amount of`39,37,278/- is towards loss of stocks of the complainant firm and a sum of`5,47,951/- towards past rent and security charges till 1.7.2011 and future monthly rent and security charges at`16,500/- and`10,000/- respectively with interest thereon.  

2.      `18 lakh and furniture, fixtures and fitting in it for an amount of`2 lakh for a total amount of`20 lakh. `7 `3

3.     

4.    `8,99,591/- for damage caused to the stock in show room and another for`30,37,687/- for the loss caused to the stocks in`39,37,278/-.   

5.       

6.     The complainant again submitted the required documents to the second surveyor with a copy of letter marked to the opposite party.   

7.       

8.           `24,12,096/- subject to policy excess and under shop keepers policy to an amount of`6,55,388/- a total amount of`29,23,779/- which the opposite party ready to settle towards full and final settlement of the claim.  

9.        

10.   

11.   

i)            Whether the complainant-company is entitled to the amount sought for?

ii)          Whether the repudiation of the claim is arbitrary?

iii)         To what relief?

12.           

         `47,90,318/- towards loss of the stocks. 

13.        

14.    `24,12,096/- subject to policy excess and under shop keepers policy to an amount of`6,55,388/- a total amount of`29,23,779/- which the opposite party ready to settle towards full and final settlement of the claim. 

15.    `29,23,779/-.     

16.              

17.             `29

18.   

1.  Lucknow

2.  C.N.Anantharam

3.  United India Insurance

4.  National Insurance Company Limited

19.           

20.              

21.            

22.             

23.                 

24.           `29,23.779/-`5,000/-. 

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           కె.ఎం.కె.*

APPENDIX OF EVIDENCE

WITNESSES EXAMINED

For complainant                                                 

NIL                                                                  EXHIBITS MARKED

For complainant

Ex. A1      

of

Ex. A2      

Ex. A3      Ex. A4      

valid

Ex. A5      

estimating

stocks/itemsEx. A6      

estimating

 Ex.A7       

(C.T.), Kurnool from 01.04.2009 to 30.09.2009

 Ex.A8                      

               Ex.A9             

Ex.A10     

Ex.A11     

Ex.A12                    

Ex.A13                    

Ex.A14     

Ex.A15     

Ex.A16     

Ex.A17     

Ex.A18     

Ex.A19     

Ex.A20     

Ex.A21     

Ex.A22     

Ex.A23     

Ex.A24     

For opposite parties

Ex.B1       

Ex.B2       

Ex.B3       

Ex.B4       

Ex.B5       

Ex.B6       

Ex.B7       

Ex.B8       

Ex.B9       

Ex.B10      

Ex.B11      

Ex.B12      

Ex.B13      

Ex.B14      

Ex.B15      

Ex.B16      

Ex.B17      

Ex.B18      

Ex.B19      

Ex.B20      

Ex.B21      

Ex.B22      

Ex.B23      

Ex.B24      

Ex.B25      

Ex.B26      

Ex.B27      

Ex.B28