Tamil Nadu

Vellore

CC/09/18

D. Balu S/o Duraikannan - Complainant(s)

Versus

Thiru. B. Logesh, Magenthira Tractors Agent - Opp.Party(s)

D.Balu party-in-person

22 Mar 2010

ORDER


District Consumer Disputes Redressal ForumSathuvachari , vellore-632009.
Complaint Case No. CC/09/18
1. D. Balu S/o Duraikannan 2/41, North big street, Moothur village and Post Arakkonam Taluk VelloreTamil Nadu ...........Appellant(s)

Versus.
1. Thiru. B. Logesh, Magenthira Tractors Agent Nirma Tractors, 29, 1st East Prirthana salai, Gandhi Nagar, Vellore 632 006VelloreTamil Nadu ...........Respondent(s)



BEFORE:

PRESENT :

Dated : 22 Mar 2010
JUDGEMENT

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.

khtl;l Efh;Bthh; FiwjPh; kd;wk;, BtY]h;,  BtY]h; khtl;lk;

 

           Kd;dpiy jpU.m. rk;gj;, gp.v.gp.vy;.      jiyth;

 

           jpUkjp. $p. kyh;tpHp, gp.n.,              cWg;gpdh;-1

 

           jpU. jahsK}h;j;jp, gp.v!;.rp.,              cWg;gpdh;-2

 

                        rp.rp.vz;.18/2009

                        

          2010-Mk; tUlk; khh;r; jpA;fs; 22-Mk; ehs; jpA;fs;fpHik

 

o. ghY,

j/bg. Jiuf;fz;zd;,

2/41A tlf;F bghpa bjU,

K}J]h; fpuhkk; & mq;ry;,

muf;Bfhzk; tl;lk;,

BtY]h; khtl;lk; 632 003.                           .. kDjhuh;

 

                ..vjph; ..

 

jpU. gp.ByhBf&;,

(kBfe;jpuh ouhf;lh; Vb$z;l;),

eph;kh ouhf;lh;!;,

29, 1tJ fpHf;F gpujhd rhiy,

fhe;jp efh;,

BtY]h; 632 006.                                  .. vjph; kDjhuh;

 

 

kDjhuh; rhh;ghf:                                  … o.ghY,

                                                           (party-in-person)                                                                                                              

 

vjph;kDjhuh; rhh;ghf:                              .. xU jiygl;rk;.

 

 

M iz a[ iu

 

jpU. m. rk;gj;, jiyth;

 

1. kDjhuhpd; kDciu RUf;fk; gpd;tUkhW:-

 

     kDjhuh; tptrhaj;jpw;fhf ouhf;lh; thA;f Btz;o 4.1.2008 md;W vjph; kDjhuiu re;jpj;jhh;.   vjph; kDjhuuhd jpU.gp.ByhBf&; mth;fs;, mh;$Pd; 50HP 555 khly; kBfe;jpuh ouhf;lh; gw;wpa tpguA;fis bjhptpj;jhh;.  ohf;lhpd; tpiy U}.5,32,150/- vdt[k;, ouhf;lUf;F 2 tUl Bfuz;oa[k;, cld; nytrkhf U}.84,000/- kjpg;g[s;s be.1 mthL fk;bgdp buhlhBtl;lh; 1 tUl Bfuz;oa[ld; jUtjhft[k;, buhlhBtl;lh; Bjit ny;iy vd;why; U}.84,000/- fHpj;Jf;bfhz;L kPjp gzj;ij fl;odhy; BghJk; vd bjhptpj;jhh;.  ouhf;lUk;, buhlhBtl;lUk; kDjhuUf;Fj; Bjitg;gLtjhy; nuz;LBk jukhdjhft[k; Bfuz;oa[lDk; bfhLA;fs; vd Bfl;L, mjw;F vjph;kDjhuh; cj;juthjk; mspj;jjd; Bghpy,; vjph; kDjhuh; bjhptpj;jgo, gzk; brYj;jp 4.1.08 md;Bw, 555 mh;$Pd; 50HP ouhf;lUk;, mjw;Fj; Bjitahd bghUl;fSld; buhlhBtl;liua[k; bgw;Wf;bfhz;lhh;.  ouhf;lh; kw;Wk; buhlh Btl;lUf;fhd  Bfuz;o fhh;Lfs; fk;bgdpapy; bgw;Wj;jUtjhf vjph; kDjhuh; bjhptpj;jhh;.   xUtUl Bfuz;o[a[ld; bfhLj;j buhlh Btl;lh; Rkhh; 40 kzp Beuk; kl;LBk Xoa epiyapy; gGjhfptpl;lJ.  mJ Fwpj;J vjph; kDjhuUf;F bjhptpj;J mth; te;J ghh;j;jBghJ buhlh Btl;lhpy; cs;s K}d;W fPh;fspy; xd;W cile;jpUg;gJ bjhpate;jJ.  Bkw;go gHij ePf;fp rhp bra;J jUkhW Bfl;ljw;F jw;bghGJ cA;fsJ brytpy; rhp bra;J bfhs;SA;fs; fk;bgdpf;Fj; bjhptpj;J bryt[ bjhifia thA;fpj;jUtjhf bjhptpj;jjpd; Bghpy; vjph; kDjhuhpd; filapByBa mjw;F Bjitahd bghUl;fis thA;fp rhp bra;ag;gl;lJ.  rpy ehl;fs; fHpe;J Bkw;go bryt[f;fhd gzj;ijg; bgw Btz;o vjph; kDjhuiu re;jpj;Jf; Bfl;lBghJ K}d;W fPh;fspy; cile;j fPUf;F cj;juthjk; ny;iy, kw;w nuz;L fPUf;F kl;Lk; jhd; cj;juthjk; cz;bld Twpdhh;.  njd;K}yk; vjph; kDjhuh; Fwpg;gpl;lgo U}.84,000/- j;jpw;fhd buhlh Btl;liu bfhLf;fhky;, U}.70,000/- kjpg;g[s;s jukw;w buhlh Btl;liu bfhLj;J kDjhuhplk; U}.14,000/- Bkhro bra;Js;shh; vd;gBjhL, jukw;w buhlhBtl;luhy; Vw;gl;l nHg;ig rhp bra;a U}.14,000/- e&;lj;ija[k; Vw;gLj;jp cs;shh;.  nJFwpj;J fle;j 10.10.08 Bjjp md;W xg;g[if ml;il nize;j gjptq;ry; K}yk; vjph;kDjhuUf;F mwptpg;g[ xd;iw mDg;gpa[s;shh;.  Bkw;go mwptpg;g[ vjph; kDjhuhpd; mYtyfj;jpy; bgwg;gl;L cld; mDg;gpa xg;g[if ml;ilahy; ifbahg;gkplg;gl;L jdf;F jpUk;gpf; fpilj;jJ.   mjd;gpwF vjph; kDjhuh; kDjhuiu re;jpj;J Bky; eltof;if vJt[k; vLf;f Btz;lhk; fk;bgdpapy; bjhptpj;J chpa nHg;gPL bgw;Wj; jUtjhf bjhptpj;jhh;.  fle;j 17.1.09 Bjjpad;W vjph; kDjhuiu re;jpj;J nHg;gPL Fwpj;J Bfl;lBghJ, nHg;gPL vJt[k; ju KoahJ cA;fshy; Koe;jij bra;J bfhs;SA;fs; vd bjhptpj;jhh;.  vjph;kDjhuhpd; Bkhroahy; Vw;gl;l nHg;g[k; e&;lKk; kDjhuiu kpft[k; kdBtjidf;Fk; Jd;gA;fSf;Fk; Ml;gLj;jpa[s;sJ.   vdBt, ne;j kDtpy;; vjph;kDjhuplkpUe;J kDjhuUf;F Bru Btz;oa U}.28,000/- jpUk;g ju cj;jputpl;Lk;, kd cisr;rYf;fhf U}.10,000/-k;, kw;Wk; nt;tHf;F bryt[f;fhf U}.2,000/-k; Mf bkhj;;jk; U}.40,000/- tHA;f Btz;oa[k; tHf;F bjhlug;gl;Ls;sJ. 

 2.  vjph; kDjhuh; Behl;o!; bgw;W bfhz;L M$uhfhjjhy; xU jiygl;rkhf nt;tHf;F jPh;khdpf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ. 

3.   kDjhuh; jug;gpy; gpukhz gj;jpuA;fs; jhf;fy; bra;agl;lJ.  ne;j kDtpy; kDjhuh; jug;gpy; k.rh.M1 Kjy; k.rh.M-10 tiu jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.  vjph;kDjhuh; jug;gpy; rhd;whtzA;fd; vJt[k; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gltpy;iy. 

 

4.  ghprPyidf;Fhpa tpdhf;fs; gpd;tUkhW:-

 

    m. vjph;kDjhuh; jug;gpy; Britf;FiwghL VBjDk; cs;sjh?.

 

    M. kDjhuh;  bgwjFe;j ghpfhuA;fs; vd;d?

 

 

5. jPh;t[f;Fhpa tpdh - m:

 

 

     mh;$Pd; 50 HP  555 khly; kBfe;jpuh ouhf;lh; kw;Wk; buhlhBtl;lh; Mfpaitfis Fwpj;j tptuA;fs; kw;Wk; mjw;Fhpa tpiyia bjhptpj;jd; Bghpy; kh.rh.M.2 kw;Wk; kh.rh.M-3 Mfpa bghUs;tptug;gl;oapd;go  4.1.08 md;W U}.5,32,150/- ouhf;lUf;fhft[k; U}.84000/- buhlhBtl;lhh;f;fht[k; vjph;kDjhuhplk; brYj;jp  Bkw;go ouhf;lh; kw;Wk; buhlhBtl;lh; Mfpaitfis nuz;L tUl Bfuz;oa[ld; fpuakhf bgw;Wf;bfhz;L jdJ epyj;jpy; Vh; cH Muk;gpj;jjhft[k;,  xU tUl Bfuz;oa[ld; bfhLj;j be.1 mth;L fk;bgdp buhlhBtl;lh;  Rkhh; 40 kzp Beuk; kl;LBk Xoa eppiyapy; gGjhfptpl;ljhft[k; vdBt, U}.70,000/- kjpg;g[s;s jukw;w buhlhBtl;liu bfhLj;J U}.14,000/- e&;lk;; Vw;gLj;jptpl;ljhft[k; BkYk; vjph;kDjhuhpd; fk;bgdpaplk; gGjile;j bghUl;fis khw;wpajw;fhd bryt[bjhifia  gpw;ghL thA;fp jUtjhf Twp mj;bjhifiaa[k;; fk;bgdpaplkpUe;J vjph;kDjhuh; bgw;W bfhLf;ftpy;iy vdt[k;, vdBt, kDtpy; Bfhhpagoahd bjhifia tHA;f cj;jutpl Btz;Lbkd kDjhuuhy; bjhptpf;fg;gl;lJ.

6. nU tUl Bfuz;oa[ld; Toa 50 HP  555 khly; kBfe;jpuh ouhf;lUf;fhf U}.5,32,150/-a[k; kw;Wk; 1tUl Bfuz;oa[ld; Toa No.1 mthh;L fk;bgdp bulhBtl;lUf;fhf U}.84,000/-k; vjph;kDjuhuplk; kDjhuuhy; bfhLf;fg;gl;L  mjw;fhf k.rh.M.2- kw;Wk; k.rh.M3 bghUl;fs; tptugl;oay; thA;fg;gl;L, Bkw;go thfdA;fs; thA;fg;gl;ljhf kDjhuh; jug;gpy; Twg;gl;l BghjpYk; kBfe;jpuh khly; 50 HP  555  Ory; mf;hpfy;ruy; ouhf;lh; tpiy U}.5,32,150/-vd k.rh.M2-Yk; bulhBtl;lh; U}.70,000/- vd k.rh.M-3Yk; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;sJ.  No.1 mthh;L fk;bgdp 1 tUl Bfuz;oa[ila bulhBtl;lh; U}.84,000/- vd vjph;kDjhuuhy;  bjhptpf;fg;gl;ljhf kDjhuuhy; Twg;gLtJ rk;ge;jkhd Quotation Bill  Bghd;w MtzA;fs; vija[k; vjph;kDjhuuhy; tHA;fg;gl;ljhf kDjhuh; jug;gpy;; bjhptpf;fg;gltpy;iy.  kh.rh.M-7 Mtzj;jpy;  vjph;kDjhuhpd; tpyhrBkh, ifbaGj;Bjh vJt[k; ny;yhky; bulhBtl;lh; Free U}.84,000/- vd Fwpg;gplg;gl;L nUf;fpwJ.  vdBt, k.rh.M7 Mtzj;ij itj;J kl;Lk; U}.84,000/- kjpg;g[s;s bulhBtl;lUf;F gjpyhf U}.70000/- kjpg;g[s;s jukw;w buhBtl;lh; vjph;kDjhuuhy; tpw;fg;gl;ljhf kDjhuhy; Twg;gLtJ Vw;fToajhf ny;iy.  kh.rh.M-2-d; bghUs;tptug;gl;ogo mh;$Pd; 50 HP  555 khly; kBfe;jpuh ouhf;lh; U}.5,32,150/- vdt[k; kh.rh.M-3 bghUs;tptug;gl;oapd;go No.1 mthh;L fk;bgdp bulhBtl;lh; U}.70,000/- vd;gJk; bjspthf Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;sJ.    mjd;go U}.84,000/- kjpg;g[s;s b;ulhBtl;lhUf;F gjpyhf U}.70,000/- kjpg;g[s;s jukw;w bulhBtl;lh; tHA;fg;gl;ljd; K}yk; U}.14,000/- vjph;kDjhuh; Bkhro bra;ag;gl;ljhf Twg;gLk; kDjhuhpd; Tw;W epU}gpf;fg;gltpy;iy.  

7.   xU tUl Bfuz;oa[ld; Toa bulhBtl;lh; Rkhh; 40 kzp Beuk; kl;Lk; Xoa epiyapy; gGjile;jtpl;lJ.  mijFwpj;J vjph;kDjhuhplk; bjhptpj;jBghJ gGjile;j bghUl;fSf;Fhpa cjphp ghfA;fis thA;fp bulhBtl;liu rhpbra;Jbfhs;Sgoahft[k; gpw;ghL vjph;kDjhuh; gGjile;j bghUl;fSf;fhd bjhifia fk;bgdpaplk; thA;fp vjph;kDjhuh; bfhLg;gjhf kDjhuuhy; Twg;gLtJ rk;ge;jkhf  kh.rh.M.4 Kjy; kh.rh.M-6 tiuapyhd vjph;kDjhuhpd;  Spare parts cash bills jhf;fy; bra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.  kh.rh.M-4 26.6.08 Bjjpapl;l Spare parts cash bill-d;go  U}.1004/-f;;Fk;, kh.rh.M5 20.5.08 Bjjpapl;l Spare parts cash bill-d;go  U}.500/- fHpt[ Bghf U}.9275/-f;;Fk;, kw;Wk; kh.rh.M.6, 24.9.08 Bjjpapl;l Spare parts cash bill-d;go  U}.3111/-k;  gGjile;j ghfA;fSf;F Bjitahd cjphp ghfA;fs; vjph;kDjhuaplkpUe;J kDjhuuhy; fpiuak; bgwg;gl;Ls;sJ vd;gJ bjhpa tUfpd;wJ.  kh.rh.M.4 Kjy; kh.rh.M6 tiua[s;s Spare parts cash bill-d;go  cjphp ghfA;fs; kDjhuuhy; fpiuak; bgwg;gl;L bulhBtl;lh; gGJ ghh;f;fg;gl;Ls;sJ.  Bkw;go MtzA;fspd; goahd bjhifia fk;bgdpaplkpUe;J vjph;kDjhuh; bgw;W kDjhuuplk; bfhLf;ftpy;y mjd;go vjph;kDjhuh; jug;gpy;   BritFiwghL Vw;gl;Ls;sbjd Kot[ bra;J tpdh vz;.(m)-f;F tpilaspf;fg;gLfpwJ.   

 

 

8.   tpdh vz;. (M):

bulhBtl;lh; gGjile;jjw;F Bjitahd cjphp ghfA;fs; fpuak; bgw;wjw;fhd  kh.rh.M.4 Kjy; kh.rh.M.6 tiuapyhd Spare parts cash bill-d;goahd   bjhiffs; U}.1,004/- + U}.9,275 + U}.3,111/- Mf bkhj;jk; U}.13,390/- vjph;kDjhuhplkpUe;J kDjhuUf;F fpilf;f ToaJ vdt[k; kDtpy; TwpathW U}.28,000/- fpilf;f Toajpy;iy vdt[k; Kot[ bra;ag;gLfpwJ.  BkYk; bulhBtl;lh; gGjile;jjpdhy; Bjitahd cjphp ghfA;fs; thA;fp gGJ bra;ag;gl;ljd; mog;gilapy; kDjhuUf;F Vw;gl;l kd cisr;rYf;fhf U}.1000/-Kk; BkYk; tHf;F bryt[ bjhif U}.500/-Kk; kDjhuUf;F fpilf;f Toabjd Ko[t[ bra;J tpdh vz;.(M)-f;F tpilaspf;fg;gLfpwJ.

 

9.   nWjpapy; nk;kD gFjp mDkjpf;fg;gLfpwJ.  kh.rh.M-4 Kjy; kh.rh.M-6 tiuapyhd Spare parts cash bill-d;go cjphpghfA;fs; thA;fpajw;fhd fpuaj;  bjhif U}.1004/- + U}.9275/- U}.3111/- Mf bkhj;jk; U}.13390/- kDjhUf;F vjph;kDjhuh; bfhLf;f Btz;Lk; vdt[k;, kDtpy; Twpagoahd bjhif U}.28,000/- kDjhuUf;F fpilf;f Toajpy;iy vdt[k;, BkYk; bulhBtl;lh; gGjile;jjpdhy; Bjitahd cjphp ghfA;fs; thA;fp gGJ bra;ag;gl;ljd; mog;gilapy; Vw;gl;l kd cisr;rYf;fhf U}.1000/-k;, tHf;F bryt[ bjhiff;fhf U}.500/-k; Mf bkhj;jk; (U}.13390 + 1000 + 500) U}.14890/-  kDjhuUf;F vjph;kDjhuh; bfhLf;f Btz;Lk; vdt[k; Kot[ bra;J cj;jputplg;gLfpwJ.  Bkw;go bjhif U}.14890/-I ne;j cj;jutpd; efy; fpilf;fg;gl;l xU khjj;jpw;Fs; vjph;kDjhuh; brYj;j Btz;Lbkd;Wk;, mt;thW brYj;j jtWk;gl;rj;jpy; Bkw;gobjhifa[ld; 9% tl;oa[k; Brh;j;J vjph;kDjhuh; brYj;j Btz;Lbkd;W cj;jut[ tHA;fg;gLfpwJ.

ne;j cj;jut[ jiyth; mth;fshy; RUf;bfGj;J jl;lr;rhplk; bkhHpjy; bra;ag;gl;L, jl;lr;rpy; tof;fg;bgw;W, jiyth; mth;fshy; ghh;itaplg;gl;L gpiHjpUj;jA;fs; bra;J, 2010-Mk; Mz;L khh;r; jpA;fs; 22-k; ehshfpa nd;W nj;jpwe;j kd;wj;jpd; Kd; gfug;gLfpwJ.        

 

 

cWg;gpdh;-1                 cWg;gpdh; - 2                        jiyth;.

 

kDjhuh; jug;g[ rhd;whtzA;fs;: -

 

k.rh.M1 –  4.1.08 - Delivery Challan-d; efy;.

k.rh.M2-  16.1.08 - ohf;lUf;fhd nd;tha;!;-d; efy;.

k.rh.M3-  11.1.08 - buhlhBtl;lUf;fhd nd;tha;!;-d; efy;.

k.rh.M4-  26.6.08 - tpiyg;gl;oaypd; efy;.

k.rh.M5-  30.5.08 - tpiyg;gl;oaypd; efy;.

k.rh.M6-  24.9.08 - tpiyg;gl;oaypd; efy;.

k.rh.M7-  2.1.08  - vjph;kDjhuh; vGjpf;bfhLj;j urPjpd; efy;.

k.rh.M8-  21.1.08 - ouhf;lUf;fhd gjpt[ rhd;wpjHpd; efy;.

k.rh.M9-  10.10.08 - mwptpg;gpd; efy;.

k.rh.M10- 11.10.08 - mwptpg;g[ bgw;Wf;bfhz;ljw;fhd xg;g[if ml;il efy;.

 

vjph; kDjhuh; jug;g[ rhd;whtzA;fs;:      .. ny;iy.

 

 

 

 

cWg;gpdh;-1               cWg;gpdh; - 2                      jiyth;.