DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM, MANDYA No.2083/1, Subhash Nagar, 1st Cross, Mandya-571401 consumer case(CC) No. CC/09/10
Sri.Javaraiah Chikkonu ...........Appellant(s) Vs. The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd., Oriental Insurance Co., Ltd., ...........Respondent(s)
BEFORE: 1. Smt.A.P.Mahadevamma 2. Sri.M.N.Manohara 3. Sri.Siddegowda
Complainant(s)/Appellant(s):
OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
ORDER
2. ÀÐôÀÐÊÑë»ÐФÐÔ, §¦ÐÔ©Äý
¹ÐÖúÿô¤Ù¹ýú лк ÅÓ., ÆÑÑ ÐÙÓ§, ½¸Û®Ð ½®ÑÀвÙ, ÀÐÔ®Ðô.
(Exparte)
JzÀÄgÀÄzÁgÀgÀÄ
zÀÆgÀÄ ¢£ÁAPÀ 27.01.2009
£ÉÆÃn¸ï eÁjAiÀiÁzÀ ¢£ÁAPÀ 04.02.2009
CAwªÀÄ DzÉñÀzÀ ¢£ÁAPÀ 23.03.2009
MlÄÖ CªÀ¢ü 1 wAUÀ¼ÀÄ 19 ¢£ÀUÀ¼ÀÄ
CAwªÀÄ DzÉñÀ ¼°¤ÑôйÐÔî ¾°ÑÐÆÐ: »ÐÔ¤ÐÊÐÜ§Ë ÙÓÆÐ ÀЦѯÙìÓÀÙ.
ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ, ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤЧ٠¤ÐÖ.27,377/- ÐÎйÐÔî ¸:25.05.2007 §Ð »ÑÀд ÀЦѮÐÔÀÐ ¸¹ÑÐÐÀФÙÐÖ 9% ¤Ð³Ù ½¯ç ÊÙÓ§Ë »ÑÀдÊÐÔÀÐÕÐÔ ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤЧ٠»Ð§ÌѤÐÀÑ ¤ÐÖ.2,000/- ÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑÐÖ »ÐõФбРÐÔþ ¤ÐÖ.500/- ÐÎйÐÔî »ÑÀдÊгÐÐÜÐÔì.
²æêÀÄw.J.¦.ªÀĺÁzÉêÀªÀÄä.,
ÀÐÔÍÎÑ ¸ÀzÀ¸ÀågÀÄ
1. ¦ügÁåzÀ£ÀÄß UÁæºÀPÀ ¸ÀAgÀPÀëuÁ PÁÄzÉ 1986gÀ Cr PÀ®A 12gÀ jÃvÁå zÁR®Ä ªÀiÁr¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ.
2. ¦ügÁåzÀÄ«£À ¸ÀAQë¥ÀÛ ¸ÁgÁA±À EAwzÉ:-
¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ Ù..02-.¿.9765 Äѧ¦ÐÔ ÀЦÑÅÓФÑÐÔì ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧРÁÀÐ¦Ñ »ÑÅË »Ð®Ù¸¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. »ÑÅË ÊÐÙô:412000131/2007/15522 ÐÔì ¸:08/03/2007 §Ð ¸:17/11/2007 ¤ÐÀФÙÙ ÑÅê¦ÐÔÅö¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ. ¸:19.05.2007 ¤ÐÐÔ Äѧ¦ÐÔÔ .¯.Ë. »°ÑôÐå§, Ù »ÑÎÐô, ÀÙÔÚÊÐÖ¤ÐÔ ¤ÐÖ»ýÀÙÓ ½Ï ÀÑÌйР»ÐѳÐÀÑÐÔì, ФР½ÙÞ ¿®Ð¸ »ÙÖÅÓÊý Ѳ٦ÐÔÅö ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ÑÄѤÐÔ³ÐêÙ. ÁÈЦÐÔÀйÐÔî ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧÐÖ ÊÐÌÐ ´ÏËÐÔì ФÐÔѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý¤ÐÀФйÐÔî ÐÎÐÔÍË ³Ð»ÑÊв٠ÀÐ¦Ñ¯Ë ÁÀÐ¦Ñ ÀÙÖ³ÐêÀйÐÔî ÙÖ®ÐÔÀÐÕÑ ´ÏˤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ¹Ð³Ð¤Ð ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÙÓÏÐ ÄÑö ÑÄÙ ÐÎйÐÔî ÙÖ«åÐì¤ÐÖ, ÁÀÐ¦Ñ ÌбÀйÐÔî »ÑÀд ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö, ÀÑÌйÐÀÐ× »ÐѳÐÀÑÐ ¹Ð³Ð¤Ð ³ÐÔ¾Ñ ¸¹ÐÐÎÐÔ §»Ù º´¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ. ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ »°Ùڹѹýú лкÂÔÐ Äѧ ÙÖÎÐüÃÔ ÊÑà ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù, ÊÑÃÀйÐÔî ³ÐÔ½ÔÀг٠³ÑêÂÔˤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù, ³ÐÀÐÔÙ ÊлÑйÙ
ÃöРѤб »°Ùڹѹýú лк٠Ìб »ÑÀд ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö,
ЧР¹Ð¹ÐÙ ³ÐÔ¾Ñ ¹ÐÈÐåÀѤÐÔ³ÐêÙ. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФйÐÔî ÌÐÃÀѤÐÔ ¾Ñ§ ÙÓÏФÐÔ ÁÀÐ¦Ñ ÌбÀйÐÔî ºÓ¯¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. Êн°Ð ¸:20.10.2008 ¤ÐÐÔ ÀÐÓçР¹ÙÖÓÑÂԳР٠ÀÐÔÔÙÓ± ÅÓÐÄý ¹ÙÖÓ«Êý ºÓ¯Ðì¤ÐÖ ÊÐÌÐ ÁÀÐ¦Ñ ÌбÀйÐÔî ÙÖ«å¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö,
ÐÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФРÊÙÓÀÑ ¹ÐÖô¹Ðô³Ù¦Ð¦Ñ¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ ÌÑÐÖ
ЧРÀЦѹÐËÐ ÍÊÙ ªÑ¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ. Ðì§Ð ³ÑÀÐÕ ÀÑÌйР§»Ù ÐÔþ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐ Ìб ¤ÐÖ.87,534/- ÐÎÐ ÀÙÔÓÄÙ ÆÙÓ.18% ¤Ð³Ù ½¯ç ³ÐÀÐÔÙ ªÑÐ ÀЦѹÐËÐ ÍÊÙÙ ªÑÐ ¤ÐÖ.20,000/- ÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑÐÖ þÑ ¤ÐÖ.5,000/- ÐÎйÐÔî ÙÖ¯ËÙÖ®ÐÔÀг٠ÙÖÓ§ ¼°¤ÑôйÐÔî ÑÃÔ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù.
3. »ÐõФÐбÀйÐÔî ÓÐ§Ë ÁѤвÙÙÐÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠¹ÙÖÓ«Êý ÙÓÆÐ ÀЦѯ³ÐÔê, ¹ÙÖÓ«Êý »Ð®Ù¸Ðì¤ÐÖ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÙÚ¤ÐÔ ÌÑ¡¤Ñ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù, Êн°Ð »ÐõФбÀйÐÔî лÐùÓ¦ÐÔÀÙÐÔ »Ð§Ð±ÒÊÐÄÑÙ.
4. ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ »ÐõÀЦѱ»Ð´õÙ ÌÑÐÖ ÑÄÙÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐÔ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ÀÐÓäÐÔ ÌÑ¡§¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö ÌÑÐÖ ÀÑÐ ÀÐԯˤÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö.
5. »ÐõФбÀйÐÔî º±þÂÔÊÐÃÔ ÐñÁÊÐÔÀÐ ÆÐÐÎÐÔ
´ÀÙ:-
1. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÊÙÓÀÑ ¹ÐÖô¹Ðô³Ù ÊÐÑì¤Ù ½ ÆÐÀйÐÔî ÊÑ¿Ó³ÐԻЯËÑì¤Ù¦ÙÔÓ?
2. ¼°¤ÑôÐÔÁ¹ÐÅö ÙÓϤÐÔÀÐ »Ð§ÌѤÐÀйÐÔî »Ð®Ù¦ÐÔÃÔ ÌÐþ¹ÑÙìÓ¹Ù ÐÔ ÊÑ¿Ó³ÐÔ »Ð¯ËÑì¤Ù¦ÙÔÓ?
3. ÙÓÆÐ ¹ÐÔ?
6. 1 ¹ÙÓ ÆÐÐÐ ÀÙÔÓÄÙ:- ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ¼°¤ÑôйÐÔî ÊÐÀÐÔµÐþ¹ÙÑ »ÐõÀЦѱ»Ð´õÙ ÌÑÐÖ ¹ÐÐÃÔ ÑÄÙÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯˤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ºÆѹÙ.Ë.1 §Ð 12 ¤ÐÀФÙÙ ÐÔ¤ÐÔ´ÊÐÄÑÂÔ³ÐÔ. ºÆѹÙ.Ë.1 ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФРлкÂÔÐ »Ð®ÙÐ »ÑÅË Ñ¼ ¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ. ºÆѹÙ.Ë.3 ÀÑÌйР»ÐѳÐÐ ½ÙÞ ºÓ¯Ð »ÐõµÐÀÐÔ ÀгÐþÀЦѹРÀФи¦Ð¦Ñ¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ. ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ¼°¤ÑôÐÔ ÌÑÐÖ »ÐõÀЦѱ »Ð´õÙ¦ÐÔÅö »ÐѳР¹Ð®ÙÐ ¹Ð³Ð¤Ð ³Ñ¹ÐÔ ÀÑÌйÐÀйÐÔî §»Ù ¿«åÐÔì, §»ÙÓ§ ÐÔþ ¤ÐÖ.87,534/- ÐÎÐÔ ÐÔ ÌÙÓϤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. Êн°Ð ºÆѹÙ.Ë.10, 11 & 12 ÑÄÙÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐÔÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ÑÄÙÐÎÐÔ ÀÙÖÓªÙ ¾Ñ¯ ¿Äýç ÀÐýúþ ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ÊÐÁþÊý ÊÙåÓÈйý¹Ð ÙÖªÙÓÈйý »Ðõ´ÐÎѤÐÔ³ÐêÀÙ. ÙÖªÙÓÈйý Ë.10 ¤ÐÅö ¤ÐÖ.38,930/- ÐÎÐÔ, Ë.11 ¤ÐÖ.18,625/- ÐÎÐÔ, Ë.11 ¤ÐÅö ¤ÐÖ.29,979/- ÐÎÐÔ ÌÑÐÖ ©Ôå ÀÙÖ³Ðê ¤ÐÖ.87,534/- ÐÎÐÔ ÐÔ ¹ÐÀÐÔÖÐÔ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ¼°¤ÑôÐÔ ÌÑÐÖ »ÐõÀЦѱ»Ð´õÙ¦ÐÔÅö ÐÔþ ©Ôå ¤ÐÖ.87,534/- ÐÎÐÔ ÐÔ ÌÙÓÏ ÐÙÜ Êн¸°Ëг٠ÙÓÀÐà ºÆѹÙ.Ë.10 §Ð Ë.11 ÑÄÙ ÐÎйÐÔî ÀЦѳÐõ ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯÊÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù¦ÙÔÓ Á¹Ð: ÐÙÜ Êн¸°ËгÐÌÐ §»ÙÓ§ ¿ÄýÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐÔ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. §»ÙÓ§ ¿ÄýÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐÔ ÀЦѮÐÙ ÙÓÀÐà ÙÖÓªÙÓÈйý ѤÐÐ ÀÙÔÓÄÙ ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤЧ٠¤ÐÖ.87,534/- ÐÎÐÔ ýþ Ù ÐÔ ¹Ð½ÃÔ ½¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö.
7. ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ »ÐѳРÁÈЦÐÔÀйÐÔî ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧÐÖ ´ÏËÐÔì, ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФРлк¦ÐÔ ÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý¤ÐÀФÐÔ ½ÐÔ ÊÐÀÙþ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù, ФÐÖ Ð֮Р³ÐÀÐÔÙ §»ÙÓ§ ÐÔþ ÙÖ«å¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФРÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý ½ÐÔ ÀÑÌйР³Ð»ÑÊв٠ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕÐÙÜ ºÆѹÙ.Ë.12 ¹ÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐÔ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ºÆѹÙ.Ë.12 ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÙÖ©å ÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý ÀФи¦Ð¦Ñ¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ. ÀФи¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ¸:25.05.2007 ¤ÐÙ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù, Ф٠ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠ÀÑÌйР»ÐѳÐÐ ÁÈЦÐÔ ¸:25.05.2007 ¤ÐÙ ÙÖ´ê¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ, ÌÑÐÖ ÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý ÀФи¦ÐÔÅö ©Ôå ÀÐÌѹÐÐ §»ÙÓ§ ÐÔþ ¤ÐÖ.27,377/- ÐÎÐÔ ÐÔ ÀЦѳÐõ ºÑþ¤Ð²Ù ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ÊÐд ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤЧÐÖ ÊÐÌÐ ÙÖ´ê¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ, Ф٠¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó »ÐõÀЦѱ »Ð´õÙ ÌÑÐÖ ÐÖ§¹ÐÅö ÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý ³Ð»ÐÊÐ²Ñ ÀФи ºÓ¯¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù ÐÔ ÌÙÓϤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФРÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý ÀФи ºÓ¯¤ÐÔÀÐÕÐÔ ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤЧÐÖ ÊÐÌÐ ÙÖ´ê¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ. Ф٠¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ ÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý ÀФи ÊЧÂÔÃöÀÙÐÔ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ ÑÄÙÐÎйÐÔî ÙÖ©Ôå ÊÐÀÐÔµÐþ¹Ù ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö ÌÑÐÖ ³ÐÀÐÔó ¼°¤ÑôÐÔÁ¹ÐÄÑöÐÅÓ µÐÀÑ »ÐõÀЦѱ»Ð´õÙ¦ÐÔÄÑöÐÅÓ ÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý¤ÐÀФРÀФи¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî º¤ÑФв٠ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. Ðì§Ð ÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý ÀФи¦ÐÔÅö ЮÐÔ½¤ÐÔÀÐ ¹ÐÈÐåÀйÐÔî ¹Ð½¾ÙÓÑÐÔ³ÐêÙ. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÊÐÀÙþ¦ÐÔ¤ý ÀФи¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî »Ð®Ù¸Ðì¤ÐÖ ÊÐÌÐ ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФРÁÀÐ¦Ñ Ìб ÙÖ«å¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ Êн°Ð ÀÐÓäР¹ÙÖÓ«ÓÊý ºÓ¯Ðì¤ÐÖ ÊÐÌÐ ÀÑÌйÐÐ §»ÙÓ§ Ìб ¤ÐÖ.27,377/- ÐÎйÐÔî »ÑÀдÊÐÙ ÊÙÓÀÙ ¹ÐÖô¹Ðô³Ù ÊÐÑì¤ÙÓ ÐÔ 1¹ÙÓ ÆÐÀйÐÔî ÊÐѤѳÐóÐÀÙÐÔ º±þÂÔÊÐÄÑÙ.
8. 2¹ÙÓ ÆÐÐ ÀÙÔÓÄÙ:- ³ÐÀÐÔóÙ ªÑÐ ÀЦѹÐËÐ ÍÊÙÙ ¤ÐÖ.20,000/- ÐÎÐÔ ÌÑÐÖ ÐÔþ ¤ÐÖ.5,000/- ÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑÐÖ
³Ð¤ÙÓ ÀÙÐàÐÎйÐÔî ÙÖ¯ÊоÙÓÙÐÔ ÙÖÓ§¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤФÐÔ ¤ÐÖ.20,000/- ÐÎÐ þ¹Ð ¾Ñ½Ôê ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ ÑÄÙÐÎйÐÔî ºÓ¯¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö, ФÐÖ ÊÐÌÐ ÀФР¼°¤Ñô¸¹ÐÅö ÌÑÐÖ »ÐõÀЦѱ»Ð´õÙ¦ÐÔÅö ÌÐÃÀѤÐÔ ¾Ñ§ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФРÐÙÓ§Ù ÌÙÖÓ ÙÓÏÐì¤ÐÖ ÙÖ«åÃö ÐÔ ÌÙÓϤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù ÌÑÐÖ ºÆѹÙ.Ë.2 ÀÐÓäР¹ÙÖÓ«Êý ÌÑ¡¤ÐÔÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ÊÐдÐÎÐ °Ñ¤ÐÐ ÀÙÔÓÄÙ ÀЧ٠ªÑÐ ÀЦѹÐËÐ ÍÊÙÙ ¤ÐÖ.2,000/- ÐÎйÐÔî Ù֮нÌÐÔÙÐÔ »Ð§Ð±ÒÊÐÄÑÙ.
ÙÓÆÐ
1. ¼°¤ÑôйÐÔî ¾°ÑÐÆÐ: »ÐÔ¤ÐÊÐÜ§Ë ÙÓÆÐ ÀЦѯÙìÓÀÙ.
2. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ, ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤЧ٠¤ÐÖ.27,377/- ÐÎйÐÔî ¸:25.05.2007 §Ð »ÑÀд ÀЦѮÐÔÀÐ ¸¹ÑÐÐÀФÙÐÖ 9% ¤Ð³Ù ½¯ç ÊÙÓ§Ë »ÑÀдÊÐÔÀÐÕÐÔ ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ¼°¤ÑôÐÔѤЧ٠»Ð§ÌѤÐÀÑ ¤ÐÖ.2,000/- ÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑÐÖ »ÐõФбРÐÔþ ¤ÐÖ.500/- ÐÎйÐÔî »ÑÀдÊгÐÐÜÐÔì.
(²ÃWÀæ°¦UÁgÀjUÉ GPÀÛ¯ÉÃR£À ¤Ãr, ¨ÉgÀ¼ÀZÀÄÑ ªÀiÁr¹, vÀ¥ÀÄàUÀ¼À£ÀÄß £ÉÆÃr ¸Àj¥Àr¹ CAwªÀÄ DzÉñÀªÀ£ÀÄß 23¹ÙÓ ÀЦÑýþ 2009 gÀAzÀÄ vÉgÉzÀ £ÁåAiÀiÁ®AiÀÄzÀ°è WÉÆøÀ¯ÁÄvÀÄ).
(CzsÀåPÀëgÀÄ)
(¸ÀzÀ¸ÀågÀÄ) (¸ÀzÀ¸ÀågÀÄ)
......................Smt.A.P.Mahadevamma ......................Sri.M.N.Manohara ......................Sri.Siddegowda
Consumer Court Lawyer
Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.
Bhanu Pratap
Featured
Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)
Bhanu Pratap
Featured
Recomended
Highly recommended!
Experties
Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes
Phone Number
7982270319
Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.