Karnataka

Bangalore 4th Additional

CC/09/2876

P.K.Surendran S/o R.Ramakrishnan, Aged About 59 Years - Complainant(s)

Versus

The Divisional Manager, Central Railway - Opp.Party(s)

P.C.George Kutty

22 Jun 2010

ORDER


BEFORE THE IV ADDITIONAL DISTRICT CONSUMERS DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM, BANGALORE URBAN,Ph:22352624
No:8, 7th floor, Sahakara bhavan, Cunningham road, Bangalore- 560052.
consumer case(CC) No. CC/09/2876

P.K.Surendran S/o R.Ramakrishnan, Aged About 59 Years
...........Appellant(s)

Vs.

The Divisional Manager, Central Railway
...........Respondent(s)


BEFORE:
1. Anita Shivakumar. K 2. Ganganarsaiah 3. Sri D.Krishnappa

Complainant(s)/Appellant(s):


OppositeParty/Respondent(s):


OppositeParty/Respondent(s):


OppositeParty/Respondent(s):




Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.

ORDER

•ÐÖ¤ÐÔ •Ñ“ÄѕР¸¹Ñ‘Ð: 05-12-2009 „•ÙÓÆÐÀѕР¸¹Ñ‘Ð: 22-06-2010 ¾Ù–ÐÎÐÖ¤ÐÔ ¹Ð–ФР4¹ÙÓ ƒ»Ð¤Ð £ÄÑö –ÑõÌБФРÀÙÓ¸‘Ù ¹Ð.8, ÊÐÌБѤР¾°ÐÀйÐ, 7¹ÙÓ ÀÐÔÌЯ, ‘кýÌÑô ¤ÐÊÙê, ¾Ù–ÐÎÐÖ¤ÐÔ-52 Ë.Ë.¹Ð.2876/2009 ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 22¹ÙÓ ¸¹Ð ¡Ö¹ý 2010 ‡»ÐËë³Ð¤ÐÔ: ÇõÓ. ¯.‘ÐØÈÐé»Ðï, ƒ•°Ðô‘Ðù¤ÐÔ ÇõÓ.–Ё–йФÐÊЁ¦ÐÔô, ÊЕÐÊÐô¤ÐÔ ÇõÓÀÐÔ´ ƒº³Ñ ÇÀБÐÔÀЦѤÐ.‘Ù., ÊЕÐÊÐô¤ÐÔ ¼.‘Ù.ÊÐÔ¤ÙӁ•Ðõ¹ý, ¿¹ý ÄÙÓªý ¤ÑÀÐԑÐØÈÐé¹ý, ÀЁ¦ÐÔÊÐÔú 59 ÀÐÈÐþ, ÀÑÊÐ: ¹Ð.45/2, ¯ËŠ ‘с»Ùöӑýú, •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ •ÙÖÀÐÔóÃÖ¤ÐÔ, 2¹ÙÓ ÌЁ³Ð, ¾Ù–ÐÎÐÖ¤ÐÔ-07 ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ¸ ¯Á£¹ÐÄý ÀЦÑô¹ÙÓ¡¤ý, Êف©õÄý ¤ÙÚÄÙ÷, Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¹Ñ–лÐÔ¤ý-440001 „ •ÙÓ ÆÐ ÇõÓ –Ё–йФÐÊЁ¦ÐÔô, ÊЕÐÊÐô¤ÐÔ ¼°¤Ñô¸•Ñ¤Ð¤ÐÔ –ÑõÌБФРÊЁ¤Ð‘Ðù²Ñ ‘с¦ÙÔì 1986¤Ð ‘ÐÁ 12 ¤Ð³Ù •ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ÊÐÅö˕Ñì¤Ù. 2. •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФРÁ¤ÐԕÐì ÊÐÅöˤÐÔÀÐ † •ÐÖ§¹Ð „¤ÙÖӻРÊЁ’ù»ÐêÀї ‹¹Ù•Ð¤Ù, ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 29-1-2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ ¹Ñ–лÐԤи•Ð ¾Ù–ÐÎÐÖ§–Ù ÌÙ֤ЮÐÔÀÐ ¤ÙÚŹÐÅö »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒÊÐÔÀÐ ‡•ÙìÓÆи•Ð ›ÐÄÑÀв٠…¤ÐÔÀÐ «‘ÙÓªý »Ð®Ù•ÐÔ »Ð´î¦ÐÔ ¢Ùֳف¦ÐÔÅö ¾ÙÖӗ¦ÐÔÅö ‘ÐÔÏ´¤ÐÔÀіР¤ÙÚÃÔ ÌÙ֤ЮÐÔÀÐ ÊÐÀÐԁ¦ÐԕÐÅö ‘ÐÎÐü¤ÐÔ ¾ÙÖӗ–Ù ƒ¹Ð¸°‘ÐسÐÀї »ÐõÀÙÓÇË •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФР»Ð´î¦ÐÔÀФÐÔ •°Ð§Ë•Ðì ÀЦс–ÐÃô ›ÙÚ¹ý¹ÐÔî ’³ÐÔê‘Ùց®ÐÔ ›ÐÅÊÐÔ´ê¤ÐÔÀÐ ¤ÙÚź•Ð »Ð¤Ñ§¦Ð¦Ñ—¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. …•Ð¤Ð ½–ÙÞ ÀÐÔԁ¸¹Ð ¤ÙÚÃÔ ºÄÑ챕ÐÅö •ÐÖ¤ÐÔ •Ñ“ÅÊÐÄї »Ðõ¦ÙÖÓ¡¹ÐÀіЕ٠…•Ñì–Ð ¸¹Ñ‘Ð28-3-2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù »Ð³Ðõ ½¤Ù•Ñ–Ð, Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ƒ•Ð‘ÙÜ ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 13-4-2009¤Ð•ÐÔ •ÐÖ§¹Ð ½–ÙÞ ÊÐ֑Ðê ‘ÐõÀÐÔÀйÐÔî „¤Ð¿°ÊÐÄіÐÔÀÐՕف•ÐÔ ‡³Ðê¤Ð ºÓ¯ ÊёÐÈÐÔå ÊÐÀÐԁ¦ÐÔÀѕФÐÔ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐՕÙÓ »Ð§ÌѤР•Ù֤ف¦Ðԕ٠…•ÐÔì•Ð§•Ð ÌіÐÖ •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¤ÙÚŹÐÅö »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒÊÐÃÔ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù Ìб »ÑÀд ÀЦѯ ›ÐÄÑÀв٠…¤ÐÔÀÐ «‘ÙÓªý »Ð®Ù¸ì•Ð¤ÐÔ »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±Ò‘Ч–Ù Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¤Ð‘Ðù²Ù¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî •Ð—ÊЕ٠ÊÙÓÀÑ ‘Ù֤г٠‡©ÔÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐՕЧ•Ð ³ÐÀÐÔó •Ð֤йÐÔî »ÐÔ¤ÐÊÐÜ§Ë 26 –Ñõ œ¹Ðî•Ð ÀЦс–ÐÃô ›ÙÚº¹Ð ¾ÙÄÙ ¤ÐÖ.39,000/- –ÐÎйÐÔî »Ð´î¦ÐÔÀФРÀЦѹÐˑРÀÙӕйٖ٠»Ð§ÌѤÐÀї ¤ÐÖ.5,00,000/- –ÐÎÐÔ ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê •ÐÖ§¹Ð “›ÐÔþ ¤ÐÖ.2,000/- –ÐÎйÐÔî »ÑÀдÊÐÔÀЁ³Ù „•ÙÓÇÊоÙӑف•ÐÔ ‘ÙÖÓ§•Ñì¤Ù. 3. Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ÀÙÓ¸‘ÙÂԁ•Ð ¹Ùց•ÑÂԳР„›Ù¦ÐÔ ÀÐÔÖÑР¹ÙÖÓ«Êý ¢Ñ§ÀЦѮÐÄї Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ÀВÓäРÀÐÔԔс³Ð¤Ð ÌÑ¡¤Ñ— Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ³Ð‘ФѤйÐÔî ÊÐÅöË •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐ ŠÄÑö „¤ÙÖӻЖÐÎÐÔ ƒÃö–ÐÎف¦ÐÔÔ³Ñê, •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФР»Ð´î¦ÐÔÀФÐÔ »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±•Ð ÊÐÀÐԁ¦ÐԕÐÅö ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐՕÙÓ ¾ÙÄÙ ¾ÑÎÐÔÀÐ ÀÐÊÐÔê –ÐÎйÐÔî ‘ÐÎٕÐԑÙց®Ð¤Ù Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¡ÀѾÑì¤Ð¤Ñ–ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö ƒ•Ð¤Ð ½–ÙÞ Ë „¤ý ¼ Ë ¦Ðԁ³Ù •ÐÖ¤ÐÔ •Ñ“ÅÊÐÃÔ ƒÀБÑÆÐÁ•Ù ÌіÐÖ ¤Ñ¡ô ÊБÑþ¤ÐÀÐÕ „ •ÐÖ§¹Ð ½–ÙÞ Á›Ñ¤Ð²Ù ¹Ð®ÙË ƒ»Ñ¸°³Ð¤Ð¹ÐÔî ½¸°Ë ƒÀЧ•Ð ‘ÐÎÐÀѕРÀЦÑÃԖÐÎйÐÔî ÀÐÆлЯˑÙց®ÐÔ •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ́¸¤ÐԗÊÐÔÀÐ ¡ÀѾÑì¤Ñ—¤ÐÔÀÐՕЧ•Ð Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐՕÙÓ ÊÙÓÀÑ ‘Ù֤гف¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ‡©Ô ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸ÃöÀف•ÐÔ ´ÏÊÐÔ³Ñê, ½Ô‘ý ÀЦѯ•Ð ÖÙÞÓ¢ý ‘ÐÎÐÀї•Ðì¤Ù 1987¤Ð ¤ÙÚÄÙ÷Êý ‘ÙöÿÚÀЦý «õ½Ôô¹ÐÄý¹ÐÅö ÀЦѳÐõ •ÑÀف¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî •Ñ“ÅË »Ð§ÌѤР»Ð®Ù¦ÐÔ½ÌÐԕÙÓ Á¹Ð: ¾ÙÓ¤Ù ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐՕÙÓ ¹Ñô¦Ð¦ÑÁ¦ÐÔ/ÀÙÓ¸‘ف¦ÐÔÅö •ÑÀÙ •Ñ“ÅÊÐÃÔ ¤ÙÚÄÙ÷ ‘ÑÂԕ٠1989¤Ð ÊّÐùÈйý 13 ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê 13 ÊّÐùÈйý 15 ¤Ð³Ù ƒÀБÑÆÐÁÃö•Ð직•Ð, † •ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ƒ£þ¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî Ìٜà¹Ð ÀٛÐà•Ùց¸–Ù ÀТіÙÖÏÊÐÔÀЁ³Ù ‘ÙÖÓ§¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. 4. •ÐÖ§¹Ð Á›Ñ¤Ð²Ù ÊÐÀÐԁ¦ÐԕÐÅö •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó •ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ƒÆЖÐÎйÐÔî »ÐԹФý ‡›Ðà§ÊÐÔ³Ñê »ÐõÀЦѱ »Ð´õ‘Ù ÊёÐùÿôÀйÐÔî ÊÐÅö˕Ñì¤Ù, •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ •ÐÖ§¹Ð ¢Ùֳف¦ÐÔÅö ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 29-1-2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ Š»°ý Œ „¤ý •Ñ“Å˕Рƒ£þ »Ðõ´ ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 28-3-2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ½¤Ù•Ð »Ð³Ðõ•Ð »Ðõ´, Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 13-4-2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ ºÓ¯•Ð ‡³Ðê¤Ð »Ð³Ðõ•Ð »Ðõ´, ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 8-2-2009¤Ð ÀÐÔ¹ÙÖÓ¤ÐÀÐÔ ¸¹Ð »Ð´õ‘ف¦ÐÔ ‡•Ñì¤Ð²Ñ ¾°Ñ–ЕРƒ–Ðö ¾°ÑÈс³Ð¤Ð »Ðõ´ ÌіÐÖ ÀѕРÀÐԁ¯ÊÐÔÀіР¾°Ñ¤Ð³Ð ÊÐÀÙ×þ›Ðà ¹Ñô¦Ð¦ÑÁ¦ÐԕР„•ÙÓÆÐ ÌіÐÖ ¤ÑÉåÿõӁ¦ÐÔ –ÑõÌБФР„¦ÙÖӖЕР„•ÙÓÆÐ »Ðõ´¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯˤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФР»Ð¤ÐÀї ÀВÓäÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ³Ð‘Фѧ¹Ð ƒÆЖÐÎйÐÔî »ÐԹФý ‡›Ðà§ÊÐÔ³Ñê »ÐõÀЦѱ »Ð´õ‘Ù ÊёÐùÿôÀйÐÔî ÊÐÅö˕Ñì¤Ù. 5. ‡¾°Ð¦ÐÔ »Ð‘Ðù‘ѤФРÀВÓäÐԖÐÎÐ ÀѕÐ-ÁÀѕЖÐÎйÐÔî ‘ÙÓÏ ‘ЮгÐÀйÐÔî »Ð§ÇÓÅ˕Ðì¤Ð ÀÙÔÓÄÙ ‘ÙÎБЁ®Ð ÁÀѕсÆЖÐÎÐÔ ¹ÐÀÐÔó ´ÓÀЦÑþ¹Ð‘ÙÜ ‡•ÐòÁÊÐÔ³ÐêÀÙ. 1. •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù •ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ºÓ¯•Ðì¤ÐÖ, ƒ•Ð‘ÙÜ »Ð§ÌѤР•Ð—ÊЕ٠Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÊÙÓÀÑ ‘Ù֤г٠‡©Ô ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐՕйÐÔî •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÊÑ¿Ó³ÐԻЯˤÐÔÀФÙÓ? 2. •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐ »Ð§ÌѤБÙÜ „ÌÐþ¤ÐÔ? 6. ÀÙÔÓŹРÁÀѕсÆЖÐϖ٠‡³Ðê¤Ð–ÐÎÐÔ: 1¹ÙÓ »ÐõÆÙî: ÊБФѳÐó‘ÐÀї ‡³Ðê§Ë•Ù 2¹ÙÓ »ÐõÆÙî: ƒ´ÀÐÔ „•ÙÓÆÐÀйÐÔî ¹ÙÖÓ¯ ‘Ѥб–ÐÎÐÔ 7. •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 29-1-2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ ¹Ñ–лÐԤР¸•Ð ¾Ù–ÐÎÐÖ§–Ù ¤ÙÚŹÐÅö »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒÊÐÃÔ ›ÐÄÑÀв٠…¤ÐÔÀÐ «‘ÙÓªý »Ð®Ù•ÐÔ »Ð´î¦ÐÔ ¢Ùֳف¦ÐÔÅö ¾ÙÖӗ¦ÐÔÅö »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒˤÐÔÀÐ ½–ÙÞ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐՕÙÓ ÁÀѕÐÁ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö, …•Ð¹ÐÔî Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÊÐÌÐ ¼ï¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ »Ð´î¦ÐÔ ¢Ùֳف¦ÐÔÅö ¾ÙÖӗ¦ÐÔÅö ‘ÐÔÏ´¤ÐÔÀіР¤ÙÚÃÔ ÌÙ֤ЮÐÔÀÐ ÊÐÀÐԁ¦ÐԕÐÅö ‘ÐÎÐü¤ÐÔ ¾ÙÖӗ–Ù ƒ¹Ð¸°‘ÐسÐÀї »ÐõÀÙÓÇË •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФР»Ð´î¦ÐÔÀФÐÔ •°Ð§Ë•Ðì ÀЦс–ÐÃô ›ÙڹйÐÔî ’³ÐÔê‘Ùց®ÐÔ ›ÐÅÊÐÔ´ê¤ÐÔÀÐ ¤ÙÚź•Ð »Ð¤Ñ§¦Ð¦Ñ—¤ÐÔÀÐ ½–ÙÞ •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯˤÐÔÀÐ ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 29-1-2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù Š»°ý Œ „¤ý •Ñ“Å˕Рƒ£þ »Ðõ´Âԁ•Ð ‘Ё®ÐÔ½¤ÐÔ³Ðê•Ù …•Ð¹ÐÔî ÊÐÌÐ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ƒÃö–ÐÎÙ¸¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 29-1-2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù Š»°ý Œ „¤ý •Ñ“Å˕Ðì¤ÐÖ, ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐՕÙÓ »Ðõ¦ÙÖÓ¡¹ÐÀіЕ٠¸¹Ñ‘Ð 28-3-2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ³Ð÷§³ÐÀї ‘ÐõÀÐÔ ‘ÙږÙց®ÐÔ »Ð§ÌѤР•Ð—ÊÐÔÀЁ³Ù‘ÙÖÓ§•Ðì¤ÐÔ ƒ•Ð‘ÙÜ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 13-4-2009¤Ð ‡³Ðê¤Ð »Ð³Ðõ•ÐÅö ÊÐ֑Ðê ‘ÐõÀÐÔÀйÐÔî „¤Ð¿°ÊÐÔÀЁ³Ù ͧ¦ÐÔ Á¾°Ñ–ЕР¤Ð‘Ðù²Ñ ‘ÐÀÙԁ®Ùªý ¤ÐÀЧ–Ù •ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ‘ÐÎÐÔÍÊÐÄї•Ù ÌіÐÖ –ÐÊÐÔê¹ÐÔî ÌٜàÊÐÄї•Ù Š•ÐÔ ÊÐ֜ÊÐÄї•Ù ƒ•Ð¤Ù •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù † ¸¹Ð•ÐÀФٖ٠ƒ´ÀÐÔ ÀЦÑÍ´¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÊÐÅöÊЕ٠Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÊÙÓÀÑ ‘Ù֤г٠‡©ÔÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐՕйÐÔî •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÊÑ¿°³ÐÔê ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤЧ•Ð ¹Ñ–лÐԤР¸•Ð ¾Ù–ÐÎÐÖ§–Ù ¤ÙÚŹÐÅö »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒÊÐÃÔ »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ± ÆÐÔÃÜÀйÐÔî »Ð®Ù¸¤ÐÔÀіР•ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФРÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ƒÀФР»Ð´î¦ÐÔÀФР»Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ± »ÐÖ±þ ‘ÑÄÑÀи°¦ÐÔÀФٖ٠»Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±Ò‘ФÐԖÐÎÐ ¤Ð‘Ðù²Ù¦ÐÔ ¡ÀѾÑì§ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФРÀÙÔÓÄÙ …•Ðì¤ÐÖ ÊÐÌÐ ƒ•Ð¹ÐÔî ºÀÑþÌв٠ÀЦѮЕ٠³ÐÀÐÔó ¡ÀѾÑ직¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ¤Ñ¡ô ÊБÑþ¤Ð•Ð ÀÙÔÓÄÙ –ÙÖ¾Ù ‘ÐÖ§ÊÐÔÀÐ ¾ÙÓ¡ÀоÑì§ ÌÙÓϑ٠º¯¤ÐÔÀÐՕÐÔ ÆÙÖӛк¦ÐÔÀї¤ÐÔÀÐՕÐÃö•Ù † ¸¹Ð•ÐÀФٖ٠•ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФР•ÐÖ§¹Ð ½–ÙÞ ‘ÙږÙց®Ð ‘ÐõÀÐԕР½–ÙÞ •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ÀЦÑÍ´ ºÓ®Ð•Ù …¤ÐÔÀÐՕÐÔ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФР‘Ñ¦ÐÔþÀÙړ§–Ù ¾ÙÎБÐÔ ›ÐÃö³Ðê•Ù. ¹Ð³Ð¤Ð Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ½Ô‘ý ÀЦѯ•Ð ÖÙÞÓ¢ý –ÐÎÐÔ ‘ÐÎÐÔÀї•Ðì¤Ù ÀЦѳÐõ 1987¤Ð ¤ÙÚÄÙ÷Êý ‘ÙöÿÚÀЦý «õ½Öô¹ÐÄý¹ÐÅö •ÑÀف¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî •Ñ“ÅË »Ð§ÌѤР»Ð®Ù¦ÐÔ½ÌÐԕÙÓ Á¹Ð: ¾ÙÓ¤Ù ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐՕÙÓ ¹Ñô¦Ð¦ÑÁ¦ÐÔ/ÀÙÓ¸‘ف¦ÐÔÅö •ÑÀÙ ÌÙÖ®ÐÃÔ ¤ÙÚÄÙ÷ ‘ÑÂԕ٠1989¤Ð ÊّÐùÈйý 13 ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ÊّÐùÊйý 15 ¤Ð³Ù ƒÀБÑÆÐÁÃöÀف½Ô•Ð¤Ð ½–ÙÞ •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯˤÐÔÀÐ ¾°Ñ¤Ð³Ð ÊÐÀÙ×þ›Ðà ¹Ñô¦Ð¦ÑÁ¦ÐԕР„•ÙÓÆЕР¸¹Ñ‘Ð 8-4-2008 ÌіÐÖ ¤ÑÉåÿõӁ¦ÐÔ –ÑõÌБФР„¦ÙÖӖЕР¸¹Ñ‘Ð 2-2-2009¤ÐÅö ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ‘Ð¹Ñþ©‘Ð ¤Ñ¡ô –ÑõÌБФР„¦ÙÖӖЕРƒ•ÙÓÆÐ: (SCDRC, Karnataka) [SCDRC, Bangalore] South Western Railways –vs- Smt. Pinky Gupta – Appeal No.1437 of 2007 – 20th November 2007. Railways – Deficiency in service – Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – Section 2 (1) (g) – Section 2 (1) (o) – complainant holding a confirmed berth in a reserved compartment traveled from New Delhi to Bangalore by Rajdhani Express – She had chained her two suitcase underneath her berth – Both her suitcase were taken away by someone after cutting the chain – District Forum allowed her complaint holding the Railways deficient in service and directing them to compensate her by paying her Rs.50,000/-- Appeal – Held, after having collected the reservation fee, a duty is cast on the railways to provide sufficient safety to the passengers and also to their luggage in reserved compartments – Appeal dismissed- impugned order of the lower forum affirmed. (After having collected the reservation fee, the Railway department is duty bound to provide sufficient safety to the passengers and their luggage in the reserved compartments) ºÓ¯•Ð „•ÙÓÆÐÀйÐÔî Š´êͯ¸¤ÐÔ³Ðê•Ù ÌіÐÖ …•ÙÓ §Ó´¦ÐÔ ƒ¹ÙӑР»Ðõ‘Фб–ÐÎйÐÔî ¤Ñ¡ô ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ¤ÑÉåÿõӁ¦ÐÔ „¦ÙÖӖЖÐÎÐÔ »Ð§ÇÅË „•ÙÓÆЖÐÎйÐÔî ºÓ¯¤ÐÔÀÐՕЧ•Ð 2008 CTJ 596 (CP) (NCDRC) [Mrs. Bala Chandrakant –vs- Northern Railway – Revision petition No.1561 of 2006 (arising from the order dated 14-2-2006 of the Delhi State Commission in Appeal No.A-1066 of 2001) – 18th February 2008. Railways – Deficiency in service – Consumer Protection Act 1986 – Section 2 (1) (g) – Section 2 (1) (o) – complainant boarded the train at the New Delhi Railway station and went on to occupy a window seat – As the train started moving some urchin from the outside snatched her gold chain with mangalsutra by stretching him arm through the window – Her complaint dismissed by the district forum – Aggrieved she appealed to the State commission which awarded her an amount of Rs.5,000/- despite her submission that the gold chain had a weight of five tolas- Revision petition for enhancement of compensation – Considering her submission about the weight of the gold chain, a consolidated amount of Rs.25,000/- awarded to her – Revision petition allowed. 8. Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФР„‘Ùùӻвف¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ³ÐÏüÌёÐÄї•Ù. ƒ£þ•Ñ¤Ð¤ÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó •ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ƒ£þ¦ÐÔÅö ‘ÐÎÐÀѕРÀЦс–ÐÃô ›ÙÚº¹Ð ¾ÙÄÙ ¤ÐÖ.39,000/- –ÐÎف•ÐÔ ´ÏˤÐÔÀÐՕйÐÔî Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐՕÙÓ „‘Ùùӻвف¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÀÐô‘Ðê»Ð¯Ë¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö.„•Ð직•Ð ÊЕЧ ÀЦс–ÐÃô ›ÙÚº¹Ð ¾ÙÄف¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ¾°Ð§ÊÐÔÀЁ³Ù ´ÓÀЦÑþºÊÐÄї•Ù. 9. † ÀÙÔÓÃ܁®Ð „ÆЖÐÎЁ³Ù ÌіÐÖ ‡ÄÙöӕÊÐÄѕР„•ÙÓÆЖÐÎЁ³Ù Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐՕÙÓ ÊÙÓÀÑ-‘Ù֤г٠ŠÊЗ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸ÃöÀف•ÐÔ † ÀÙÓ¸‘Ù ÀÐÔԁ•Ù ÌÙÓϑÙց®ÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó¹ÐÔî ³ÑÀÙÓ ÊÐÀÐÔ¶þˑÙÖÎÐÔü´ê¤ÐÔÀÐՕÐÔ ƒÊÐÀÐԁ¡ÊÐÀٺˤÐÔÀÐՕÐÃö•ÙÓ ³ÐÀÐÔó ƒ•°Ðô ‘гÐþÀÐô ÀйÐÔî »ÐÖ¤ÙÚÊÐÃÔ ÊÐÌÐ Á»°ÐÃÀї¤ÐÔÀÐՕÐÔ •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÊÑ¿°³ÐÔê ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. „•Ð직•Ð •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤФР† „¤ÙÖӻР–ÐÎйÐÔî »ÐÔ¤ÐÊÐܧÊÐÔÀÐՕФÐÅö ¹ÑÀÐÕ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐՕÙÓ §Ó´¦ÐÔ º¾°Ðþ•Ð–ÐÎйÐÔî ‘Ñ±ÃÔ ƒ–ÐÔ´êÃöÀف•ÐÔ ´ÓÀЦÑþ¹Ð‘ÙÜ ½•ÐÔ † ‘ÙÎБЁ®Ð ƒ•ÙÓÆÐÀйÐÔî ÀЦѮÐÔ´ê•ÙìÓÀÙ. „ •ÙÓ ÆÐ •Ð֤йÐÔî »ÐÔ¤ÐÊÐܧ˕Ù. Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ † „•ÙÓÆÐÀѕР30 ¸¹Ð–ÐÎÐ ÎЖї •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ¤ÐÖ.39,000/- –ÐÎйÐÔî ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 29-1-2009 §•Ð ÆÑŁ¦Ð¦Ñ¹Ð ÆÙӑЮР9 ¤ÐÖ»ÑÂԁ¦Ðԁ³Ù ½¯ç¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÊÙÓ§Ë »ÑÀдÊгБÐܕÐÔì, „ ƒÀи°¦ÐÔÅö »ÑÀдÊÐÃÔ Á»°ÐäѕÐÅö ½¯ç¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÆÑŁ¦Ð¦Ñ¹Ð ÆÙӑЮР12 ¤ÐÖ»ÑÂԁ¦Ðԁ³Ù ÊÙÓ§Ë »ÑÀдÊгБÐܕÐÔì. Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ † „•ÙÓÆÐÀѕР30 ¸¹Ð–ÐÎÐ ÎЖї •ÐÖ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù † •ÐÖ§¹Ð “œþ–Ñ— ¤ÐÖ.2,000/- ¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî »ÑÀдÊгБÐܕÐÔì † „•ÙÓÆЕР¹Ð‘ÐÃÔ »Ðõ´¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ‡œ³ÐÀї ‡¾°Ð¦ÐÔ »Ð‘Ðù‘ѤЧ–Ù ‘ѹÐÖº¹Ð »Ðõ‘ѤРºÓ®Ð³Ð‘ÐܕÐÔì (ÇӘÐõż–ѤЧ–Ù ‡‘ÐêÄÙӓ¹ÐÀйÐÔî ÌÙÓϕіРƒÀФÐÔ ƒ•Ð¹ÐÔî ½¤Ù•ÐԑÙց®ÐÔ ³Ð¡ÔþÀÙԖÙÖÏË ‡‘ÐêÄÙӓ¹ÐÀйÐÔî ˕Ðì»Ð¯Ë•Ðì¹ÐÔî ¸ ƒÀÐÆÐôÁ•ÐìÅö ´•ÐÔì»Ð¯–ÙÖÏË ³Ù¤Ù•Ð Êо°Ñ–б•ÐÅö ¸¹Ñ‘Ð 22¹ÙÓ ¡Ö¹ý 2010 ¤Ð•ÐÔ »Ðõ‘ЫÊÐÄÑÂÔ³ÐÔ) ÊЕÐÊÐô¤ÐÔ ÊЕÐÊÐô¤ÐÔ ƒ•°Ðô‘Ðù¤ÐÔ




......................Anita Shivakumar. K
......................Ganganarsaiah
......................Sri D.Krishnappa