BEFORE THE IV ADDITIONAL DISTRICT CONSUMERS DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM, BANGALORE URBAN,Ph:22352624 No:8, 7th floor, Sahakara bhavan, Cunningham road, Bangalore- 560052. consumer case(CC) No. CC/09/2876
P.K.Surendran S/o R.Ramakrishnan, Aged About 59 Years ...........Appellant(s) Vs. The Divisional Manager, Central Railway ...........Respondent(s)
BEFORE: 1. Anita Shivakumar. K 2. Ganganarsaiah 3. Sri D.Krishnappa
Complainant(s)/Appellant(s):
OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
ORDER ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ÑÄÑÐ ¸¹ÑÐ: 05-12-2009 ÙÓÆÐÀÑÐ ¸¹ÑÐ: 22-06-2010 ¾ÙÐÎÐÖ¤ÐÔ ¹ÐФР4¹ÙÓ »Ð¤Ð £ÄÑö ÑõÌÐФРÀÙÓ¸Ù ¹Ð.8, ÊÐÌÐѤР¾°ÐÀйÐ, 7¹ÙÓ ÀÐÔÌЯ, кîýÌÑô ¤ÐÊÙê, ¾ÙÐÎÐÖ¤ÐÔ-52 Ë.Ë.¹Ð.2876/2009 ¸¹ÑÐ 22¹ÙÓ ¸¹Ð ¡Ö¹ý 2010 »ÐËë³Ð¤ÐÔ: ÇõÓ. ¯.ÐØÈÐé»Ðï, °ÐôÐù¤ÐÔ ÇõÓ.ÐйФÐÊЦÐÔô, ÊÐÐÊÐô¤ÐÔ ÇõÓÀÐÔ´ º³Ñ ÇÀÐÐÔÀЦѤÐ.Ù., ÊÐÐÊÐô¤ÐÔ ¼.Ù.ÊÐÔ¤ÙÓÐõ¹ý, ¿¹ý ÄÙÓªý ¤ÑÀÐÔÐØÈÐé¹ý, ÀЦÐÔÊÐÔú 59 ÀÐÈÐþ, ÀÑÊÐ: ¹Ð.45/2, ¯Ë Ñ»ÙöÓýú, ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÙÖÀÐÔóÃÖ¤ÐÔ, 2¹ÙÓ ÌгÐ, ¾ÙÐÎÐÖ¤ÐÔ-07 ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ¸ ¯Á£¹ÐÄý ÀЦÑô¹ÙÓ¡¤ý, ÊÙ©õÄý ¤ÙÚÄÙ÷, ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¹ÑлÐÔ¤ý-440001 ÙÓ ÆÐ ÇõÓ ÐйФÐÊЦÐÔô, ÊÐÐÊÐô¤ÐÔ ¼°¤Ñô¸Ñ¤Ð¤ÐÔ ÑõÌÐФРÊФÐÐù²Ñ ѦÙÔì 1986¤Ð Ðà 12 ¤Ð³Ù ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ÊÐÅöËÑì¤Ù. 2. ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФРÁ¤ÐÔÐì ÊÐÅöˤÐÔÀÐ ÐÖ§¹Ð ¤ÙÖӻРÊÐù»ÐêÀÑ ¹ÙФÙ, ¸¹ÑÐ 29-1-2009 ¤ÐÐÔ ¹ÑлÐԤиР¾ÙÐÎÐÖ§Ù ÌÙ֤ЮÐÔÀÐ ¤ÙÚŹÐÅö »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒÊÐÔÀÐ ÙìÓÆиРÐÄÑÀвÙ
¤ÐÔÀÐ «ÙÓªý »Ð®ÙÐÔ »Ð´î¦ÐÔ ¢ÙÖ³Ù¦ÐÔÅö ¾ÙÖÓ¦ÐÔÅö ÐÔÏ´¤ÐÔÀÑÐ ¤ÙÚÃÔ ÌÙ֤ЮÐÔÀÐ ÊÐÀÐÔ¦ÐÔÐÅö ÐÎÐü¤ÐÔ ¾ÙÖÓÙ ¹Ð¸°ÐسÐÀÑ »ÐõÀÙÓÇË ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФР»Ð´î¦ÐÔÀФÐÔ °Ð§ËÐì ÀЦÑÐÃô ÙÚ¹ý¹ÐÔî ³ÐÔêÙÖ®ÐÔ ÐÅÊÐÔ´ê¤ÐÔÀÐ ¤ÙÚźР»Ð¤Ñ§¦Ð¦Ñ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù.
ФР½ÙÞ ÀÐÔÔ¸¹Ð ¤ÙÚÃÔ ºÄÑì±ÐÅö ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ÑÅÊÐÄÑ »Ðõ¦ÙÖÓ¡¹ÐÀÑÐÙ
ÑìÐ ¸¹ÑÐ28-3-2009 ¤ÐÐÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠»Ð³Ðõ ½¤ÙÑÐ, ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÐÙÜ ¸¹ÑÐ 13-4-2009¤ÐÐÔ ÐÖ§¹Ð ½ÙÞ ÊÐÖÐê ÐõÀÐÔÀйÐÔî ¤Ð¿°ÊÐÄÑÐÔÀÐÕÙÐÔ ³Ðê¤Ð ºÓ¯ ÊÑÐÈÐÔå ÊÐÀÐÔ¦ÐÔÀÑФÐÔ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ »Ð§ÌѤРÙÖ¤Ù¦ÐÔÙ
ÐÔìЧРÌÑÐÖ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¤ÙÚŹÐÅö »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒÊÐÃÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠Ìб »ÑÀд ÀЦѯ ÐÄÑÀвÙ
¤ÐÔÀÐ «ÙÓªý »Ð®Ù¸ìФÐÔ »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒЧ٠ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¤ÐÐù²Ù¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÐÊÐÙ ÊÙÓÀÑ Ù֤г٠©ÔÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕЧР³ÐÀÐÔó Ð֤йÐÔî »ÐÔ¤ÐÊÐÜ§Ë 26 Ñõ ¹ÐîÐ ÀЦÑÐÃô ÙÚº¹Ð ¾ÙÄÙ ¤ÐÖ.39,000/- ÐÎйÐÔî »Ð´î¦ÐÔÀФРÀЦѹÐËÐ ÀÙÓйÙÙ »Ð§ÌѤÐÀÑ ¤ÐÖ.5,00,000/- ÐÎÐÔ ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ÐÖ§¹Ð ÐÔþ ¤ÐÖ.2,000/- ÐÎйÐÔî »ÑÀдÊÐÔÀг٠ÙÓÇÊоÙÓÙÐÔ ÙÖÓ§Ñì¤Ù. 3. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠ÀÙÓ¸ÙÂÔÐ ¹ÙÖÑÂԳР٦ÐÔ ÀÐÔÖÃÐ ¹ÙÖÓ«Êý ¢Ñ§ÀЦѮÐÄÑ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ÀÐÓäРÀÐÔÔѳФРÌÑ¡¤Ñ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ³ÐФѤйÐÔî ÊÐÅöË ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐ ÄÑö ¤ÙÖÓ»ÐÐÎÐÔ ÃöÐÎÙ¦ÐÔÔ³Ñê, ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФР»Ð´î¦ÐÔÀФÐÔ »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±Ð ÊÐÀÐÔ¦ÐÔÐÅö ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ ¾ÙÄÙ ¾ÑÎÐÔÀÐ ÀÐÊÐÔê ÐÎйÐÔî ÐÎÙÐÔÙ֮Ф٠ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¡ÀѾÑì¤Ð¤ÑÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö ФР½ÙÞ Ë ¤ý ¼ Ë ¦ÐÔ³Ù ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ÑÅÊÐÃÔ ÀÐÑÆÐÁÙ ÌÑÐÖ ¤Ñ¡ô ÊÐÑþ¤ÐÀÐÕ ÐÖ§¹Ð ½ÙÞ ÁѤв٠¹Ð®ÙË »Ñ¸°³Ð¤Ð¹ÐÔî ½¸°Ë ÀЧРÐÎÐÀÑÐ ÀЦÑÃÔÐÎйÐÔî ÀÐÆлЯËÙÖ®ÐÔ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠͸¤ÐÔÊÐÔÀÐ ¡ÀѾÑì¤Ñ¤ÐÔÀÐÕЧРÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ ÊÙÓÀÑ Ù֤г٦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ©Ô ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸ÃöÀÙÐÔ ´ÏÊÐÔ³Ñê, ½Ôý ÀЦѯРÃÙÞÓ¢ý ÐÎÐÀÑÐì¤Ù 1987¤Ð ¤ÙÚÄÙ÷Êý ÙöÿÚÀЦý «õ½Ôô¹ÐÄý¹ÐÅö ÀЦѳÐõ ÑÀÙ¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÑÅË »Ð§ÌѤР»Ð®Ù¦ÐÔ½ÌÐÔÙÓ Á¹Ð: ¾ÙÓ¤Ù ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ ¹Ñô¦Ð¦ÑæÐÔ/ÀÙÓ¸Ù¦ÐÔÅö ÑÀÙ ÑÅÊÐÃÔ ¤ÙÚÄÙ÷ ÑÂÔÙ 1989¤Ð ÊÙÐùÈйý 13 ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê 13 ÊÙÐùÈйý 15 ¤Ð³Ù ÀÐÑÆÐÁÃöÐì§Ð, ÐÖ¤ÐÔ £þ¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÌÙà¹Ð ÀÙÐàÙÖ¸Ù ÀТÑÙÖÏÊÐÔÀг٠ÙÖÓ§¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. 4. ÐÖ§¹Ð ÁѤв٠ÊÐÀÐÔ¦ÐÔÐÅö ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ÆÐÐÎйÐÔî »ÐԹФý Ðà§ÊÐÔ³Ñê »ÐõÀЦѱ »Ð´õÙ ÊÑÐùÿôÀйÐÔî ÊÐÅöËÑì¤Ù, ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÐÖ§¹Ð ¢ÙÖ³Ù¦ÐÔÅö ¸¹ÑÐ 29-1-2009 ¤ÐÐÔ »°ý ¤ý ÑÅËÐ £þ »Ðõ´ ¸¹ÑÐ 28-3-2009 ¤ÐÐÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠½¤ÙÐ »Ð³ÐõÐ »Ðõ´, ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¸¹ÑÐ 13-4-2009 ¤ÐÐÔ ºÓ¯Ð ³Ðê¤Ð »Ð³ÐõÐ »Ðõ´, ¸¹ÑÐ 8-2-2009¤Ð ÀÐÔ¹ÙÖÓ¤ÐÀÐÔ ¸¹Ð »Ð´õÙ¦ÐÔ Ñì¤Ð²Ñ ¾°ÑÐÐ Ðö ¾°ÑÈѳФР»Ðõ´ ÌÑÐÖ ÀÑÐ ÀÐÔ¯ÊÐÔÀÑÐ ¾°Ñ¤Ð³Ð ÊÐÀÙ×þÐà ¹Ñô¦Ð¦ÑæÐÔÐ ÙÓÆÐ ÌÑÐÖ ¤ÑÉåÿõÓ¦ÐÔ ÑõÌÐФР¦ÙÖÓÐÐ ÙÓÆÐ »Ðõ´¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯˤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФР»Ð¤ÐÀÑ ÀÐÓäÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ³ÐФѧ¹Ð ÆÐÐÎйÐÔî »ÐԹФý Ðà§ÊÐÔ³Ñê »ÐõÀЦѱ »Ð´õÙ ÊÑÐùÿôÀйÐÔî ÊÐÅöËÑì¤Ù. 5. ¾°Ð¦ÐÔ »ÐÐùѤФРÀÐÓäÐÔÐÎÐ ÀÑÐ-ÁÀÑÐÐÎйÐÔî ÙÓÏ Ð®Ð³ÐÀйÐÔî »Ð§ÇÓÅËÐì¤Ð ÀÙÔÓÄÙ ÙÎÐЮРÁÀÑÑÆÐÐÎÐÔ ¹ÐÀÐÔó ´ÓÀЦÑþ¹ÐÙÜ ÐòÁÊÐÔ³ÐêÀÙ. 1. ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ºÓ¯Ðì¤ÐÖ, ÐÙÜ »Ð§ÌѤРÐÊÐÙ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÊÙÓÀÑ Ù֤г٠©Ô ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕйÐÔî ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÊÑ¿Ó³ÐԻЯˤÐÔÀФÙÓ? 2. ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐ »Ð§ÌѤÐÙÜ ÌÐþ¤ÐÔ? 6. ÀÙÔÓŹРÁÀÑÑÆÐÐÏÙ ³Ðê¤ÐÐÎÐÔ: 1¹ÙÓ »ÐõÆÙî: ÊÐФѳÐóÐÀÑ ³Ðê§ËÙ 2¹ÙÓ »ÐõÆÙî: ´ÀÐÔ ÙÓÆÐÀйÐÔî ¹ÙÖÓ¯ ѤбÐÎÐÔ 7. ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¸¹ÑÐ 29-1-2009 ¤ÐÐÔ ¹ÑлÐԤР¸Ð ¾ÙÐÎÐÖ§Ù ¤ÙÚŹÐÅö »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒÊÐÃÔ ÐÄÑÀвÙ
¤ÐÔÀÐ «ÙÓªý »Ð®ÙÐÔ »Ð´î¦ÐÔ ¢ÙÖ³Ù¦ÐÔÅö ¾ÙÖÓ¦ÐÔÅö »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒˤÐÔÀÐ ½ÙÞ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ ÁÀÑÐÁ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö,
йÐÔî ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÊÐÌÐ ¼ï¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ »Ð´î¦ÐÔ ¢ÙÖ³Ù¦ÐÔÅö ¾ÙÖÓ¦ÐÔÅö ÐÔÏ´¤ÐÔÀÑÐ ¤ÙÚÃÔ ÌÙ֤ЮÐÔÀÐ ÊÐÀÐÔ¦ÐÔÐÅö ÐÎÐü¤ÐÔ ¾ÙÖÓÙ ¹Ð¸°ÐسÐÀÑ »ÐõÀÙÓÇË ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФР»Ð´î¦ÐÔÀФÐÔ °Ð§ËÐì ÀЦÑÐÃô ÙڹйÐÔî ³ÐÔêÙÖ®ÐÔ ÐÅÊÐÔ´ê¤ÐÔÀÐ ¤ÙÚźР»Ð¤Ñ§¦Ð¦Ñ¤ÐÔÀÐ ½ÙÞ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯˤÐÔÀÐ ¸¹ÑÐ 29-1-2009 ¤ÐÐÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠»°ý ¤ý ÑÅËÐ £þ »Ðõ´ÂÔРЮÐÔ½¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ
йÐÔî ÊÐÌÐ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÃöÐÎÙ¸¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¸¹ÑÐ 29-1-2009 ¤ÐÐÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠»°ý ¤ý ÑÅËÐì¤ÐÖ, ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ »Ðõ¦ÙÖÓ¡¹ÐÀÑÐÙ ¸¹ÑÐ 28-3-2009 ¤ÐÐÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠³Ð÷§³ÐÀÑ ÐõÀÐÔ ÙÚÙÖ®ÐÔ »Ð§ÌѤРÐÊÐÔÀгÙÙÖÓ§Ðì¤ÐÔ ÐÙÜ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¸¹ÑÐ 13-4-2009¤Ð ³Ðê¤Ð »Ð³ÐõÐÅö ÊÐÖÐê ÐõÀÐÔÀйÐÔî ¤Ð¿°ÊÐÔÀг٠ͧ¦ÐÔ Á¾°ÑÐÐ ¤ÐÐù²Ñ ÐÀÙÔ®Ùªý ¤ÐÀЧ٠ÐÖ¤ÐÔ ÐÎÐÔÍÊÐÄÑÙ ÌÑÐÖ ÐÊÐÔê¹ÐÔî ÌÙàÊÐÄÑÙ ÐÔ ÊÐÖÊÐÄÑ٠Ф٠ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠¸¹ÐÐÀФÙÙ ´ÀÐÔ ÀЦÑÍ´¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÊÐÅöÊÐÙ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÊÙÓÀÑ Ù֤г٠©ÔÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕйÐÔî ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÊÑ¿°³ÐÔê ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤЧР¹ÑлÐԤР¸Ð ¾ÙÐÎÐÖ§Ù ¤ÙÚŹÐÅö »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒÊÐÃÔ »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ± ÆÐÔÃÜÀйÐÔî »Ð®Ù¸¤ÐÔÀÑÐ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФРÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ÀФР»Ð´î¦ÐÔÀФР»Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ± »ÐÖ±þ ÑÄÑÀи°¦ÐÔÀФÙÙ »Ðõ¦Ð¦Ñ±ÒФÐÔÐÎÐ ¤ÐÐù²Ù¦ÐÔ ¡ÀѾÑì§ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФРÀÙÔÓÄÙ
Ðì¤ÐÖ ÊÐÌРйÐÔî ºÀÑþÌв٠ÀЦѮÐÙ ³ÐÀÐÔó ¡ÀѾÑ짦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ¤Ñ¡ô ÊÐÑþ¤ÐÐ ÀÙÔÓÄÙ ÙÖ¾Ù ÐÖ§ÊÐÔÀÐ ¾ÙÓ¡ÀоÑì§ ÌÙÓÏÙ º¯¤ÐÔÀÐÕÐÔ ÆÙÖÓк¦ÐÔÀѤÐÔÀÐÕÐÃöÙ ¸¹ÐÐÀФÙÙ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФРÐÖ§¹Ð ½ÙÞ ÙÚÙ֮РÐõÀÐÔÐ ½ÙÞ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠ÀЦÑÍ´ ºÓ®ÐÙ
¤ÐÔÀÐÕÐÔ ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФРѦÐÔþÀÙÚ§Ù ¾ÙÎÐÐÔ ÐÃö³ÐêÙ. ¹Ð³Ð¤Ð ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ½Ôý ÀЦѯРÃÙÞÓ¢ý ÐÎÐÔ ÐÎÐÔÀÑÐì¤Ù ÀЦѳÐõ 1987¤Ð ¤ÙÚÄÙ÷Êý ÙöÿÚÀЦý «õ½Öô¹ÐÄý¹ÐÅö ÑÀÙ¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÑÅË »Ð§ÌѤР»Ð®Ù¦ÐÔ½ÌÐÔÙÓ Á¹Ð: ¾ÙÓ¤Ù ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ ¹Ñô¦Ð¦ÑæÐÔ/ÀÙÓ¸Ù¦ÐÔÅö ÑÀÙ ÌÙÖ®ÐÃÔ ¤ÙÚÄÙ÷ ÑÂÔÙ 1989¤Ð ÊÙÐùÈйý 13 ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ÊÙÐùÊйý 15 ¤Ð³Ù ÀÐÑÆÐÁÃöÀÙ½ÔФР½ÙÞ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯˤÐÔÀÐ ¾°Ñ¤Ð³Ð ÊÐÀÙ×þÐà ¹Ñô¦Ð¦ÑæÐÔÐ ÙÓÆÐÐ ¸¹ÑÐ 8-4-2008 ÌÑÐÖ ¤ÑÉåÿõÓ¦ÐÔ ÑõÌÐФР¦ÙÖÓÐÐ ¸¹ÑÐ 2-2-2009¤ÐÅö ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê йÑþ©Ð ¤Ñ¡ô ÑõÌÐФР¦ÙÖÓÐÐ ÙÓÆÐ: (SCDRC, Karnataka) [SCDRC, Bangalore] South Western Railways vs- Smt. Pinky Gupta Appeal No.1437 of 2007 20th November 2007. Railways Deficiency in service Consumer Protection Act, 1986 Section 2 (1) (g) Section 2 (1) (o) complainant holding a confirmed berth in a reserved compartment traveled from New Delhi to Bangalore by Rajdhani Express She had chained her two suitcase underneath her berth Both her suitcase were taken away by someone after cutting the chain District Forum allowed her complaint holding the Railways deficient in service and directing them to compensate her by paying her Rs.50,000/-- Appeal Held, after having collected the reservation fee, a duty is cast on the railways to provide sufficient safety to the passengers and also to their luggage in reserved compartments Appeal dismissed- impugned order of the lower forum affirmed. (After having collected the reservation fee, the Railway department is duty bound to provide sufficient safety to the passengers and their luggage in the reserved compartments) ºÓ¯Ð ÙÓÆÐÀйÐÔî ´êͯ¸¤ÐÔ³ÐêÙ ÌÑÐÖ
ÙÓ §Ó´¦ÐÔ ¹ÙÓÐ »ÐõФбÐÎйÐÔî ¤Ñ¡ô ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ¤ÑÉåÿõÓ¦ÐÔ ¦ÙÖÓÐÐÎÐÔ »Ð§ÇÅË ÙÓÆÐÐÎйÐÔî ºÓ¯¤ÐÔÀÐÕЧР2008 CTJ 596 (CP) (NCDRC) [Mrs. Bala Chandrakant vs- Northern Railway Revision petition No.1561 of 2006 (arising from the order dated 14-2-2006 of the Delhi State Commission in Appeal No.A-1066 of 2001) 18th February 2008. Railways Deficiency in service Consumer Protection Act 1986 Section 2 (1) (g) Section 2 (1) (o) complainant boarded the train at the New Delhi Railway station and went on to occupy a window seat As the train started moving some urchin from the outside snatched her gold chain with mangalsutra by stretching him arm through the window Her complaint dismissed by the district forum Aggrieved she appealed to the State commission which awarded her an amount of Rs.5,000/- despite her submission that the gold chain had a weight of five tolas- Revision petition for enhancement of compensation Considering her submission about the weight of the gold chain, a consolidated amount of Rs.25,000/- awarded to her Revision petition allowed. 8. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФРÙùӻв٦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ³ÐÏüÌÑÐÄÑÙ. £þѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ÐÖ¤ÐÔ £þ¦ÐÔÅö ÐÎÐÀÑÐ ÀЦÑÐÃô ÙÚº¹Ð ¾ÙÄÙ ¤ÐÖ.39,000/- ÐÎÙÐÔ ´ÏˤÐÔÀÐÕйÐÔî ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ Ùùӻв٦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÀÐôÐê»Ð¯Ë¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö.Ðì§Ð ÊÐЧ ÀЦÑÐÃô ÙÚº¹Ð ¾ÙÄÙ¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ¾°Ð§ÊÐÔÀг٠´ÓÀЦÑþºÊÐÄÑÙ. 9. ÀÙÔÓÃܮРÆÐÐÎг٠ÌÑÐÖ ÄÙöÓÊÐÄÑÐ ÙÓÆÐÐÎг٠ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ ÊÙÓÀÑ-Ù֤г٠ÊФÐÔÀÐÕ¸ÃöÀÙÐÔ ÀÙÓ¸Ù ÀÐÔÔÙ ÌÙÓÏÙÖ®ÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó¹ÐÔî ³ÑÀÙÓ ÊÐÀÐÔ¶þËÙÖÎÐÔü´ê¤ÐÔÀÐÕÐÔ ÊÐÀÐÔ¡ÊÐÀٺˤÐÔÀÐÕÐÃöÙÓ ³ÐÀÐÔó °Ðô гÐþÀÐô ÀйÐÔî »ÐÖ¤ÙÚÊÐÃÔ ÊÐÌÐ Á»°ÐÃÀѤÐÔÀÐÕÐÔ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÊÑ¿°³ÐÔê ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. Ðì§Ð ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤФР¤ÙÖӻРÐÎйÐÔî »ÐÔ¤ÐÊÐܧÊÐÔÀÐÕФÐÅö ¹ÑÀÐÕ ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐÕÙÓ §Ó´¦ÐÔ º¾°ÐþÐÐÎйÐÔî ѱÃÔ ÐÔ´êÃöÀÙÐÔ ´ÓÀЦÑþ¹ÐÙÜ ½ÐÔ ÙÎÐЮРÙÓÆÐÀйÐÔî ÀЦѮÐÔ´êÙìÓÀÙ. ÙÓ ÆÐ Ð֤йÐÔî »ÐÔ¤ÐÊÐܧËÙ. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÙÓÆÐÀÑÐ 30 ¸¹ÐÐÎÐ ÎÐÑ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠¤ÐÖ.39,000/- ÐÎйÐÔî ¸¹ÑÐ 29-1-2009 §Ð ÆÑŦЦѹРÆÙÓЮР9 ¤ÐÖ»ÑÂÔ¦ÐÔ³Ù ½¯ç¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÊÙÓ§Ë »ÑÀдÊгÐÐÜÐÔì, Àи°¦ÐÔÅö »ÑÀдÊÐÃÔ Á»°ÐäÑÐÅö ½¯ç¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÆÑŦЦѹРÆÙÓЮР12 ¤ÐÖ»ÑÂÔ¦ÐÔ³Ù ÊÙÓ§Ë »ÑÀдÊгÐÐÜÐÔì. ÐÔ¤ÐÔѤФÐÔ ÙÓÆÐÀÑÐ 30 ¸¹ÐÐÎÐ ÎÐÑ ÐÖ¤ÐÔѤЧ٠ÐÖ§¹Ð þÑ ¤ÐÖ.2,000/- ¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî »ÑÀдÊгÐÐÜÐÔì ÙÓÆÐÐ ¹ÐÐÃÔ »Ðõ´¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ³ÐÀÑ ¾°Ð¦ÐÔ »ÐÐùѤЧ٠ѹÐÖº¹Ð »ÐõѤРºÓ®Ð³ÐÐÜÐÔì (ÇÓÐõżѤЧ٠ÐêÄÙÓ¹ÐÀйÐÔî ÌÙÓÏÑÐ ÀФÐÔ Ð¹ÐÔî ½¤ÙÐÔÙÖ®ÐÔ ³Ð¡ÔþÀÙÔÙÖÏË ÐêÄÙÓ¹ÐÀйÐÔî ËÐì»Ð¯ËÐì¹ÐÔî ¸ ÀÐÆÐôÁÐìÅö ´ÐÔì»Ð¯ÙÖÏË ³Ù¤ÙÐ Êо°ÑбÐÅö ¸¹ÑÐ 22¹ÙÓ ¡Ö¹ý 2010 ¤ÐÐÔ »ÐõЫÊÐÄÑÂÔ³ÐÔ) ÊÐÐÊÐô¤ÐÔ ÊÐÐÊÐô¤ÐÔ °ÐôÐù¤ÐÔ
......................Anita Shivakumar. K ......................Ganganarsaiah ......................Sri D.Krishnappa
Consumer Court Lawyer
Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.
Bhanu Pratap
Featured
Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)
Bhanu Pratap
Featured
Recomended
Highly recommended!
Experties
Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes
Phone Number
7982270319
Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.