The Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd; Dada Joshi Building, Shivaji Cross Rd; Shrirampur Ta V/S Dinesh Alfred Shrisundar, (Judge) Deulgaon Raja court, Tal Deulgaonraja, Dist Buldhana. - Consumer Court Case

Maharashtra

Ahmednagar

CC/10/16

Dinesh Alfred Shrisundar, (Judge) Deulgaon Raja court, Tal Deulgaonraja, Dist Buldhana. - Complainant(s)

Versus

The Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd; Dada Joshi Building, Shivaji Cross Rd; Shrirampur Ta - Opp.Party(s)

Adv.Deokar,Barde, Bawane

21 Jun 2010

ORDER


District Consumer ForumParag Building, Opp To Collector Office, District Ahmednagar. Maharashtra
CONSUMER CASE NO. 10 of 16

1. Dinesh Alfred Shrisundar, (Judge) Deulgaon Raja court, Tal Deulgaonraja, Dist Buldhana.Deulgaon Raja, BuldhanaBuldhana						...........Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. The Branch Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd; Dada Joshi Building, Shivaji Cross Rd; Shrirampur Tal Shrirampur Dist Ahmednagar. Shivaji Cross Rd; ShrirampurAhmednagar						...........Respondent(s)

For the Appellant :

Adv.Deokar,Barde, Bawane, Advocate for

For the Respondent :

Dated : 21 Jun 2010

ORDER

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended

Highly recommended!

5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended

Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.

ãä•ãÊÖã ØãÆãÖ‡ãŠ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ãÌããÀ¥ã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã,‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ.

½ãã.‚ã£¾ãàã : Ñããè.Ôãì£ãã‡ãŠÀ.‡ãñŠ.ãäºã¶ãÌã¡ñ.

½ãã.ÔãªÔ¾ãã : ‚ãù¡.Ôããõ.½ããä¶ãÓãã ‡ãõŠËãÔã Œã¡ã½ã‡ãŠÀ.

----------------------------------------------

Ôããè.¹ããè.†.¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ‰ãŠ½ããâ‡ãŠ : 16/2010.

¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ªãŒãË ãäª¶ããâ‡ãŠ : 14/01/2010.

¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ã‡ãŠãËãè ãäª¶ããâ‡ãŠ : 21/06/2010.

-----------------------------------------------

ãäª¶ãñÎã ‚ãÊ¹ãÆñŠ¡ ÑããèÔãìâªÀ [¶¾ãã¾ãããä£ãÎã] ----- ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ.

ÖÊËãè ½ãì.ªñ…ßØããâÌã Àã•ãã ‡ãŠãñ›Ã,

¦ãã.ªñ…ßØããâÌãÀã•ãã,ãä•ã.ºãìË¤ã¥ãã.

ãäÌãÁ£ª

ãäª.ºãÆúÞã ½ãù¶ãñ•ãÀ, ----- Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ.

‚ããñãäÀ†¶›Ë ƒ¶ÎãìÀâ¶Ôã ‡ãâŠ¹ã¶ããè ãäË.,

ªãªã •ããñÎããè ãäºãÊ¡ãéØã,ãäÎãÌãã•ããè ‰ãŠãùÔã

Àãñ¡,ÑããèÀã½ã¹ãîÀ,¦ãã.ÑããèÀã½ã¹ãîÀ,

ãä•ã.‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ.

„¹ããäÔ©ã¦ããè

[¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ ¾ããâÞãñ Ìã‡ãŠãèË : Ñããè.¤Øãñ.]

[Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞãñ Ìã‡ãŠãèË : Ñããè.ºãâØã.]

................................................................................................

ãä¶ã‡ãŠãË¹ã¨ã

{ ´ãÀã : ½ãã.‚ã£¾ãàã,Ñããè.Ôãì£ãã‡ãŠÀ.‡ãñŠ.ãäºã¶ãÌã¡ñ.}

......................................................................................

[1] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¹ãÆÔ¦ãì¦ãÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ½ããË‡ãŠãèÞãñ ÌããÖ¶ã ‰ãŠ½ããâ‡ãŠ †½ã.†Þã.17 ÌÖãè 1809 Ëã ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ãã¦ã ¢ããËñÊ¾ãã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ããèÞããè ãäÌã½¾ããÞããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ãä½ãß¥¾ããÔããŸãè ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËãè ‚ããÖñ. ¦¾ããâÞãñ ½Ö¥ã¥ãñ ©ããñ¡‡ã‹¾ãã¦ã ŒããËãèË ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ ‚ããÖñ.

[2] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ÌãÀ ¶ã½ãîª ‡ãñŠËñÊãñ ÌããÖ¶ã ŒãÀñªãè ‡ãñŠÊ¾ãã ¶ãâ¦ãÀ ¦¾ããÞãã ãäÌã½ãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ „¦ãÀãäÌãËã. ¦¾ãã ãäÌã½¾ããÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠãËãÌã£ããè½ã£ãñ ½Ö¥ã•ãñÞã ãäª.16/02/2009 Þ¾ãã ¹ãÖã›ñ ‚ãâªã•ãñ 3.30 Ìãã•ã¦ãã ¦¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè Ìã †‡ãŠã ½ããñ›ãÀÔãã¾ã‡ãŠËÞããè £ã¡‡ãŠ ¢ããÊ¾ãã¶ãñ ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ã ¢ããËã. ¦¾ãã ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ãã½ã£ãñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞãñ ºãÀñÔãÞãñ ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ã ¢ããËñ. ¦¾ãã ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ãã Ôãâª¼ããÃ¦ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¹ããñËãèÔã Ô›ñÎã¶ãËã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ¶ããòªãäÌãËãè. ¦ãÔãñÞã ¦¾ãã ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ããÞããè ÔãîÞã¶ãã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ãã ªñŒããèË ãäªËãè. ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞãñ ÔãÌãóàã‡ãŠ Ñããè.ªñÌã‡ãŠÀ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¾ãñ…¶ã ¦¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè ¹ããÖ¥ããè ‡ãñŠËãè. ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ½Ö¥ã¥¾ãã ¶ãìÔããÀ Ñããè.ªñÌã‡ãŠÀ ¾ããâ¶ããè ÔããâãäØã¦ãÊ¾ããÌãÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè ¦ã¹ããÔã¥ããè £ãì¦ã ½ããñ›ÔãÃ ‚ããõÀâØããºããª ¾ããâÞ¾ãã ‚ããä£ã‡ãðŠ¦ã ÔãÌãóàã‡ãŠã ‡ãŠ¡î¶ã ‡ãŠÁ¶ã Üãñ¦ãËãè. ¦¾ããÌãñßãè ¦¾ãã ÔãÌãóàã‡ãŠã¶ãñ ÌããÖ¶ã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÔããŸãè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.5,92,208/- ŒãÞãÃ ‚ã¹ãñàããè¦ã ‚ãÔãÊ¾ããÞãã ‚ãÖÌããË ãäªËã. ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ ªãŒãË ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ãäÌã½ãã À‡ãŠ½ãñÞããè ½ããØã¥ããè ‡ãñŠËãè. ¹ãÀâ¦ãî Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞ¾ãã ãäÌã½¾ããÞããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ãäªËãè ¶ãÔãÊ¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦¾ããâ¶ãã ¹ãÆÔ¦ãì¦ãÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ªãŒãË ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ ¼ããØã ¹ã¡Ëñ.

[3] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞããè ‡ãõŠãä¹ãŠ¾ã¦ã ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.14 Ëã ªãŒãË ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ „¦ãÀãäÌãÊ¾ããÞãñ ½ãã¶¾ã ‡ãñŠËñ. ¦ãÔãñÞã ¦¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÔã ãäª.16/02/2009 Àãñ•ããè ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ã ¢ããÊ¾ããÞãñÖãè ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ½ãã¶¾ã ‡ãñŠËñ. ¦ã©ãããä¹ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ÌããÖ¶ããÞ¾ãã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ããè Ôãâª¼ããÃ¦ã ‡ãñŠËñËñ ‡ãŠ©ã¶ã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¶ãã‡ãŠãÀËñ. ¾ãã Ôãâª¼ããÃ¦ã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞãñ ‚ãÔãñ ½Ö¥ã¥ãñ ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÔã ¢ããËñÊ¾ãã ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ããÞããè ÔãîÞã¶ãã ãä½ãßãÊ¾ãã ºãÀãñºãÀ ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ÔãÌãóàã‡ãŠ Ñããè.Ôããä¦ãÎã ªñÌã‡ãŠÀ ¾ããâÞããè ¶ãñ½ã¥ãî‡ãŠ ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ÌããÖ¶ããÞãñ Ô©ãß ãä¶ãÀãèàã¥ã ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ããÔã ÔããâãäØã¦ãËñ. ¦¾ãã ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè ¦ã¹ããÔã¥ããè ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâÞãã ‚ãÖÌããË ãäª.22/02/2009 Àãñ•ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ ÔããªÀ ‡ãñŠËã. Ñããè.ªñÌã‡ãŠÀ ¾ããâ¶ããè ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè ¹ããÖ¥ããè ‡ãŠÀ¦ã ‚ãÔã¦ããâ¶ãã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ‚ããÌãÎ¾ã‡ãŠ ¦ãñ ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ã Ìã ÌããÖ¶ã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÔã ‚ã¹ãñàããè¦ã ‚ãÔãËñÊ¾ãã ŒãÞããÃÞãñ ‚ãâªã•ã¹ã¨ã‡ãŠãÔãÖ ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ªãŒãË ‡ãŠÀãÌãã ‚ãÔãñ ÔããâãäØã¦ãËñ. ¦¾ãã¶ãìÔããÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ØãìÁ¶ãã¶ã‡ãŠ ‚ããù›ãñ ½ããñºããƒÃÊã,ÑããèÀã½ã¹ãìÀ Ìã £ãì¦ã ½ããñ›ÔãÃ ‚ããõÀâØããºããª ¾ããÞãñ‡ãŠ¡î¶ã ÌãñØãÌãñØãß¾ãã À‡ãŠ½ãñÞãñ ªãñ¶ã ÌãñØãÌãñØãßñ ‚ãâªã•ã¹ã¨ã‡ãŠ ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËñ. ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè Ñããè.¶ãÀò³ ËãñÖã¡ñ ¾ããâÞããè ÔãÌãóàã‡ãŠ ½Ö¥ãî¶ã ¶ãñ½ã¥ãî‡ãŠ ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâ¶ãã ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ãØãÆÔ¦ã ÌããÖ¶ããÞ¾ãã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ããèÞããè ½ããñ•ãªãª ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ããÔã ÔããâãäØã¦ãËñ. ¦¾ãã¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ÌããÖ¶ããÞ¾ãã ¢ããËñÊ¾ãã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ããèÞããè ½ããñ•ãªãª ‡ãñŠËãè Ìã ¦¾ããâÞãã ‚ãÖÌããË ÔããªÀ ‡ãñŠËã. ¦¾ãã ‚ãÖÌããËã ¶ãìÔããÀ Ñããè.¶ãÀò³ ËãñÖã¡ñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ªìÁÔ¦ããè ¦ã¦ÌããÌãÀ [On repairs basis] À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.1,30,000/- ãä¶ããäÎÞã¦ã ‡ãñŠËãè. ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè ªìÁÔ¦ããè ‡ãŠÁ¶ã Üãñ¥¾ããÔã ÔããâãäØã¦ãËñ Ìã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÔããŸãè ‚ããËñÊ¾ãã ŒãÞããÃÞããè ãäºãËñ ªãŒãË ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ããÔã ÔããâãäØã¦ãËñ. ¹ãÀâ¦ãî ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ‚ãª¾ãã¹ã ¹ããÌãñ¦ããñ ÌããÖ¶ã ªìÁÔ¦ã ‡ãñŠÊ¾ããÞããè ãäºãËñ ªãŒãË ¶ã ‡ãñŠÊ¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦¾ããâÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ‚ãª¾ãã¹ãÖãè ¹ãÆËâºããè¦ã ‚ããÖñ. ¾ãã ÔãÌãÃ ‡ãŠãÀ¥ããÌãÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ Àªªá ‡ãŠÀãÌããè ‚ãÎããè ÎãñÌã›ãè ãäÌã¶ãâ¦ããè ‡ãñŠËãè.

[4] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ Ìã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ½Ö¥ã¥¾ããÞ¾ãã ¹ãðÓ›¾ã©ãÃ ¹ãìÀãÌãã ½Ö¥ãî¶ã Íã¹ã©ã¹ã¨ã Ìã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ã ¹ãÆ‡ãŠÀ¥ãã¦ã ªãŒãÊã ‡ãñŠÊãñ ‚ããÖñ¦ã. ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞãñ ãäÌã´ã¶ã Ìã‡ãŠãèÊã Ñããè.¤Øãñ Ìã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ ¾ããâÞãñ ãäÌã´ã¶ã Ìã‡ãŠãèÊã Ñããè.ºãâØã ¾ããâ¶ããè ‡ãñŠÊãñÊãñ ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌããª †ñ‡ãŠÊãñ. ªãñ¶ÖãèÖãè ¹ãàã‡ãŠãÀãâ¶ããè ªãŒãÊã ‡ãñŠÊãñÊãñ Íã¹ã©ã¹ã¨ã Ìã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ã ¦ãÔãñÞã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã Ìããä‡ãŠÊããâÞãã ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌããª †ñ‡ãŠÊ¾ããÌãÁ¶ã ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞ¾ãã ãäÌãÞããÀã©ãÃ ŒããÊããèÊã ½ãìªªáñ „¹ããäÔ©ã¦ã Öãñ¦ãã¦ã.

½ãìªªáñ : ãä¶ãÓ‡ãŠÓãÃ :

[‚ã] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ªñ¥¾ããÞ¾ãã

ÔãñÌãñ½ã£ãñ ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ŸñÌãËãè ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠã¾ã ? : Öãñ¾ã.

[ºã] ‡ãŠã¾ã ‚ããªñÎã ? : ‚ãâãä¦ã½ã ‚ããªñÎãã ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ.

‡ãŠãÀ¥ãñ :

[5] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ½ããË‡ãŠãèÞããè Ôãú›Èãñ ‡ãŠãÀ ¶ããòª¥ããè ‰ãŠ½ããâ‡ãŠ †½ã.†Þã. 17-ÌÖãè-1809 ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞãã ãäª.29/12/2008 ¦ãñ 28/12/2009 ¾ãã ‡ãŠãËãÌã£ããèÔããŸãè ãäÌã½ãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ „¦ãÀãäÌãÊ¾ãã ºãªªáË ¦ãÔãñÞã ¦¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÔã ãäª.16/02/2009 Àãñ•ããè ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ã ¢ããÊ¾ãã ºãªªáË „¼ã¾ã¹ãàãã¦ã Ìããª ¶ããÖãè. ¹ãÆ‡ãŠÀ¥ãã¦ã ªãŒãË ¢ããËñÊ¾ãã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÌãÁ¶ã ‚ãÔãñ ãäªÔã¦ãñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÔã ¢ããËñÊ¾ãã ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ããÞããè ÔãîÞã¶ãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ãã ãäªÊ¾ãã ¶ãâ¦ãÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè Ñããè.Ôããä¦ãÓã ªñÌã‡ãŠÀ ÔãÌãóàã‡ãŠ ¾ããâÞããè ¶ãñ½ã¥ãî‡ãŠ ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâ¶ãã ¦¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞãñ Ô©ãß ãä¶ãÀãèàã¥ã ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ããÔã ÔããâãäØã¦ãËñ. ¦¾ãã ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ ¦¾ããâ¶ããè Ô©ãß ãä¶ãÀãèàã¥ã ‡ãñŠËñ. ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÔã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÔããŸãè ‚ã¹ãñàããè¦ã ‚ãÔãËñÊ¾ãã ŒãÞããÃÞãñ ‚ãâªã•ã¹ã¨ã‡ãŠ [ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.17/4] ÔãìÁÌãã¦ããèËã ØãìÁ¶ãã¶ã‡ãŠ ‚ããù›ãñ½ããñºããƒÃÊÔã ÑããèÀã½ã¹ãîÀ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡î¶ã ‡ãŠÁ¶ã Üãñ¦ãËñ Ìã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ÌããÖ¶ã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÔããŸãè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.3,21,550/- ŒãÞãÃ ‚ã¹ãñàããè¦ã ‚ãÔãÊ¾ããÞãñ ¦¾ãã ‚ãâªã•ã¹ã¨ã‡ãŠã½ã£ãñ ¶ã½ãîª ‡ãñŠËñ. ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ÔÌã¦ã:Öî¶ã ¦¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞ¾ãã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÔã ¾ãñ¥ãã-¾ãã ŒãÞããÃÞãñ ªìÔãÀñ ‚ãâªã•ã¹ã¨ã‡ãŠ [ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.5/2] £ãì¦ã ½ããñ›ÔãÃ, ‚ããõÀâØããºããª ¾ããâÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠ½ãÃÞãã-¾ããâ‡ãŠ¡î¶ã ‡ãŠÁ¶ã Üãñ¦ãËñ. ¦¾ãã ‚ãâªã•ã¹ã¨ã‡ãŠã ¶ãìÔããÀ ÌããÖ¶ã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÔããŸãè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.5,92,208/- ‚ã¹ãñàããè¦ã ‚ãÔãÊ¾ããÞãñ ¦¾ãã¦ã ¶ã½ãîª ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËñ. ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌããªãÞãñ ªÀ½¾ãã¶ã ªãñ¶ÖãèÖãè ¹ãàã‡ãŠãÀãâÞ¾ãã ãäÌã´ã¶ã Ìã‡ãŠãèËãâ¶ãã ãäÌãÞããÀËñÌãÁ¶ã ‚ãÔãñ ‡ãŠßãËñ ‡ãŠãè, ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ãØãÆÔ¦ã ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè ‚ãª¾ãã¹ãÖãè ªìÁÔ¦ããè ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËñËãè ¶ããÖãè. ¦ãÔãñÞã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ‚ãª¾ãã¹ãÖãè ½ãâ•ãîÀ ‚ã©ãÌãã ¶ãã½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãñŠËñËã ¶ããÖãè. ¾ãã ¹ããÎÌãÃ¼ãìãä½ãÞ¾ãã ‚ãã£ããÀñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ Ìã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã ¹ãÀÔ¹ãÀ ãäÌãÀãñ£ããè ‡ãŠ©ã¶ããÞãã ãäÌãÞããÀ ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ ØãÀ•ãñÞãñ ‚ããÖñ.

[6] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀãè½ã£ãñ £ãì¦ã ½ããñ›ÔãÃ ¾ããâÞãñ ‡ãŠ½ãÃÞããÀãè Ñããè.ÔãªããäÎãÌã ¼ããØããèÀ©ã Îã½ããÃ ¾ããâ¶ããè ÌããÖ¶ããÔã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÔããŸãè ¾ãñ¥ãã-¾ãã ŒãÞããÃÞãñ ‚ãâªã•ã¹ã¨ã‡ãŠ [ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.5/2] Ìã ¦¾ããâÞãñ Îã¹ã©ã¹ã¨ã ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.25 Þ¾ãã ‚ãã£ããÀñ ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ãØãÆÔ¦ã ÌããÖ¶ããÞ¾ãã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ã ¼ãÀ¹ããƒÃÞ¾ãã ãäÌã½¾ããÞããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ½Ö¥ãî¶ã À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.6,82,208/- Þããè ½ããØã¥ããè ‡ãñŠËãè ‚ããÖñ. ¹ãÀâ¦ãî ¦¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞãã •ããñ ãäÌã½ãã „¦ãÀãäÌã¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËã Öãñ¦ãã ¦¾ããÞããè ¹ããùãäËÔããè ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.5/12 Þãñ ‚ãÌãËãñ‡ãŠ¶ã ‡ãñŠËñ ‚ãÔã¦ãã ‚ãÔãñ ãäªÔã¦ãñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞãã ãäÌã½ãã „¦ãÀãäÌã¦ãñ Ìãñßãè •ããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ÜããñÓããè¦ã ‡ãñŠËãè Öãñ¦ããè ¦ããè Á.2,84,000/- ‚ãÎããè Öãñ¦ããè. ¾ãã À‡ãŠ½ãñÌãÀÞã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ãäÌã½ãã ÎãìÊ‡ãŠ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ãã ãäªÊ¾ããÞãñ ‡ãŠãØãª ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.5/13 ÌãÁ¶ã Ô¹ãÓ› Öãñ¦ãñ. ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ‡ãŠ¡î¶ã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞ¾ãã ãäÌã½¾ããÞ¾ãã À‡ãŠ½ãñ¹ããñ›ãè •ããÔ¦ããè¦ã •ããÔ¦ã À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.2,84,000/- ½ããØã¥¾ããÞãã ¹ãŠ‡ã‹¦ã Ö‡ã‹‡ãŠ ‚ããÖñ. ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¾ãã À‡ãŠ½ãñ¹ãñàãã •ããè •ããªãÞããè ½ããØã¥ããè ‡ãñŠËãè ‚ããÖñ ¦¾ããÞãã ãäÌãÞããÀ ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ããÞããè ØãÀ•ã ¶ããÖãè.

[7] ¹ãÆ‡ãŠÀ¥ãã¦ã ªãŒãË ¢ããËñÊ¾ãã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÌãÁ¶ã ÖñÖãè Ô¹ãÓ› Öãñ¦ãñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÔããŸãè ¾ãñ¥ãã-¾ãã ŒãÞããÃÞãñ •ãñ ªãñ¶ã ÌãñØãÌãñØãßñ ‚ãâªã•ã¹ã¨ã‡ãŠ ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËñ ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè Ñããè.¶ãÀò³ ËãñÖã¡ñ ÔãÌãóàã‡ãŠ ¾ããâÞããè ¶ãñ½ã¥ãî‡ãŠ ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâ¶ãã ¦¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ãã¦ã ¢ããËñÊ¾ãã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ããèÞããè ½ããñ•ãªãª ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ããÔã ÔããâãäØã¦ãËñ. ¦¾ãã ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè ¦ã¹ããÔã¥ããè ãäª.25/04/2009 Àãñ•ããè ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâÞãã ‚ãÖÌããË [ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.17/7] ¦¾ããâ¶ãã ãäªËã. ¦¾ãã ‚ãÖÌããËãÌãÁ¶ã ‚ãÔãñ ãäªÔã¦ãñ ‡ãŠãè, Ñããè.ËãñÖã¡ñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÔã ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ãã¦ã ¢ããËñÊ¾ãã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ããèÞ¾ãã ãäÌã½¾ããÞããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.1,30,000/- ãä¶ããäÎÞã¦ã ‡ãñŠËãè. ¾ãã ãäŸ‡ãŠã¥ããè Öñ ¶ã½ãìª ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ ½ãÖ¦ÌããÞãñ ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè Ñããè.¶ãÀò³ ËãñÖã¡ñ ¾ããâÞãã Öã ‚ãÖÌããË ‡ãŠã ÔÌããè‡ãŠãÁ ¶ã¾ãñ ¾ãã ºãªªáË ‡ãŠÔãËñÖãè Ôãâ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ã‡ãŠ ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ãäªËñËñ ¶ããÖãè. ¦ãÔãñÞã ƒ¦ãÀ ‡ãŠãñ¥ã¦¾ããÖãè ‚ããä£ã‡ãðŠ¦ã Ìã ¹ãÀÌãã¶ãã £ããÀ‡ãŠ ÔãÌãóàã‡ãŠãÞãã ‚ãÖÌããË ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¹ãÆ‡ãŠÀ¥ãã¦ã ªãŒãË ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞ¾ãã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÔããŸãè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.1,30,000/- ¹ãñàãã •ããÔ¦ã ŒãÞãÃ ‚ã¹ãñàããè¦ã ‚ãÔãÊ¾ããÞãñ ªãŒãÌãî¶ã ãäªËñ ¶ããÖãè. ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ãä¶ããäÎÞã¦ã ‡ãŠÀ¦ãñÌãñßãè Ñããè.¶ãÀò³ ËãñÖã¡ñ ÔãÌãóàã‡ãŠ ¾ããâ¶ããè ãäªËñÊ¾ãã ‚ãÖÌããËãÌãÀ [ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.17/7] ãäÌãÔãâºãî¶ã ÀãÖ¥¾ãã ãäÎãÌãã¾ã ªìÔãÀã ¹ã¾ããÃ¾ã ¶ããÖãè.

[8] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞãñ ãäÌã´ã¶ã Ìã‡ãŠãèË Ñããè.ºãâØã ¾ããâ¶ããè ¾ãã Ôãâª¼ããÃ¦ã ‚ãÔãã ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌããª ‡ãñŠËã ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã Ñããè.ËãñÖã¡ñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã ‚ãÖÌããËã¶ãìÔããÀ ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè ªìÁÔ¦ããè ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ããÔã ÌãñßãñÌãñßãè ÔããâØãî¶ã ªñŒããèË ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ããè ªìÁÔ¦ããè ‡ãŠÁ¶ã Üãñ¦ãËãè ¶ããÖãè ãä‡ãâŠÌãã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÞããè ãäºãËñ ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËãè ¶ããÖãè¦ã. ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ‚ãª¾ãã¹ãÖãè ¹ãÆËâºããè¦ã ‚ããÖñ. ¦ããñ ªãÌãã ¹ãÆËâºããè¦ã ÀãÖ¥¾ããÔã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ Öñ ½ãìŒ¾ã¦Ìãñ ‡ãŠÁ¶ã •ãºããºãªãÀ ‚ãÔãÊ¾ãã½ãìßñ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ªñ¥¾ããÞ¾ãã ÔãñÌãñ¦ã ‡ãŠÔãËãèÖãè ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ŸñÌãËñËãè ¶ããÖãè. ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ‡ãñŠÌãß ¾ãã ‡ãŠãÀ¥ããÌãÁ¶ã ¶ãã½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãŠÀãÌããè ‚ãÎããè ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ÎãñÌã›ãè ãäÌã¶ãâ¦ããè ‡ãñŠËãè. ¹ãÀâ¦ãî ¹ãÆÞãËãè¦ã ¶¾ãã¾ã¦ã¦ÌããÞãã ãäÌãÞããÀ ‡ãŠÀ¦ãã ‚ãù¡.Ñããè.ºãâØã ¾ããâ¶ããè ‡ãñŠËñËã Öã ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌããª ÔÌããè‡ãŠãÀ¥¾ãã ÔããÀŒãã ¶ããÖãè ‚ãÔãñ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ ½ã¦ã ‚ããÖñ. ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ‚ãù¡.Ñããè.ºãâØã ¾ããâ¶ããè ¾ãã ºããºã¦ã ãäÌã½ãã ‡ãŠÀãÀã½ã£ãñ „¼ã¾ã¹ãàãã¦ã ŸÀËñËãè ‚ã› ãä‡ãâŠÌãã Îã¦ãÃ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞ¾ãã ãä¶ãªÎãÃ¶ããÔã ‚ãã¥ãî¶ã ãäªËñËãè ¶ããÖãè. ¾ãã „Ë› ¹ãÆÞãËãè¦ã ¶¾ãã¾ã ¦ã¦Ìãã¶ãìÔããÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ¾ããñØ¾ã ‡ãŠãËãÌã£ããè½ã£ãñ ãä¶ããäÎÞã¦ã ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ããÞããè •ãºããºãªãÀãè Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËòÌãÀ ‚ããÖñ. ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞ¾ãã ªìÁÔ¦ããèÞããè ãäºãËñ ªãŒãË ¶ã ‡ãñŠÊ¾ãã½ãìßñ •ãÀ ãäÌã½ãã ‡ãŠÀãÀã¦ããèË ‚ã›ãè Ìã Îã¦ããëÞãã ¼ãâØã Öãñ¦ã ‚ãÔãñË ¦ãÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ¾ããñØ¾ã ¦¾ãã ‡ãŠãËãÌã£ããè½ã£ãñ ¶ãã‡ãŠãÀ¥ãñ ‚ããÌãÎ¾ã‡ãŠ Öãñ¦ãñ. ¹ãÀâ¦ãî Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ããñ ªãÌãã ‚ãª¾ãã¹ãÖãè ¶ãã‡ãŠãÀËñËã ¶ããÖãè. ¾ããÞããÞã ‚ã©ãÃ ‚ãÔãã ‡ãŠãè, Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ªñ¥¾ããÞ¾ãã ÔãñÌãñ¦ã ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ŸñÌãËñËãè ‚ããÖñ. ½Ö¥ãî¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞ¾ãã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ããèÞ¾ãã ãäÌã½¾ããÞããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ½ããØã¥¾ããÞãã ãä¶ããäÎÞã¦ãÞã Ö‡ã‹‡ãŠ ¹ãÆã¹¦ã Öãñ¦ããñ. ¾ãã ÔãÌãÃ ºããºããéÞãã ãäÌãÞããÀ ‡ãŠÀ¦ãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ªñ¥¾ããÞ¾ãã ÔãñÌãñ¦ã ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ŸñÌãËãè ‚ãÔãñ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ ½ã¦ã ‚ããÖñ.

[9] ÌãÀ ¶ã½ãîª ‡ãñŠÊ¾ãã ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ Ñããè.¶ãÀò³ ËãñÖã¡ñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ÌããÖ¶ããÞããè ªìÁÔ¦ããè ¦ã¦ÌããÌãÀ ãäÌã½¾ããÞããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.1,30,000/- ãä¶ããäÎÞã¦ã ‡ãñŠËãè ‚ããÖñ. ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã Öãè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ªñ¥¾ããÞãã ‚ããªñÎã ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ ¶¾ãã¾ããÞãñ ÒÓ›ãè¶ãñ ¾ããñØ¾ã ÖãñƒÃË ‚ãÔãñ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ ½ã¦ã ‚ããÖñ. ¾ãã ÔãÌãÃ ºããºããéÞãã †‡ãŠ¨ããè¦ã ãäÌãÞããÀ ‡ãŠÀ¦ãã Öñ ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã ŒããËãèË ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ ‚ããªñÎã ‡ãŠÀãè¦ã ‚ããÖñ.

‚ããªñÎã

[‚ã] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ‚ãâÎã¦ã: ½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËãè ‚ããÖñ.

[ºã] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ÔãªÀ ãä¶ã‡ãŠãËãÞãñ ¦ããÀŒãñ ¹ããÔãî¶ã ¹ãì¤ãèË 45 ãäªÌãÔããâÞãñ ‚ãã¦ã.

[1] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ¦¾ããâÞãñ ÌããÖ¶ã ‰ãŠ.†½ã.†Þã.17-ÌÖãè-1809 Ëã ‚ã¹ãÜãã¦ãã¦ã ¢ããËñÊ¾ãã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ããèÞ¾ãã ãäÌã½¾ããÞããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ½Ö¥ãî¶ã Á.1,30,000/- [Á.†‡ãŠ ËãŒã ¦ããèÔã Ö•ããÀ ½ãã¨ã] ª¾ããÌãñ¦ã.

[2] ÌãÀ ¶ã½ãîª ‡ãñŠËñÊ¾ãã ½ãìª¦ããè¦ã ‚ãÎããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ¶ã ãäªÊ¾ããÔã ¦¾ãã À‡ãŠ½ãñÌãÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ªãŒãË ¦ããÀŒãñ ¹ããÔãî¶ã ¦ãñ Ôãâ¹ãî¥ãÃ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ÌãÔãìË ÖãñƒÃ¹ã¾ãÄ¦ãÞãñ ‡ãŠãËãÌã£ããèÔããŸãè ª.Ôãã.ª.Îãñ.10 ›‡ã‹‡ãñŠ ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ Ì¾ãã•ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ª¾ããÌãñ.

[3] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ªñ¥¾ããÞ¾ãã ÔãñÌãñ¦ã ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ŸñÌãËãè ½Ö¥ãî¶ã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ã ¼ãÀ¹ããƒÃ¹ããñ›ãè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.12,000/- [Á.ºããÀã Ö•ããÀ ½ãã¨ã] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ª¾ããÌãñ¦ã.

[4] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ½ãã¶ããäÔã‡ãŠ ¨ããÔã Ìã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀãèÞãã ŒãÞãÃ ½Ö¥ãî¶ã †‡ãîŠ¥ã À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.3,000/- [Á.¦ããè¶ã Ö•ããÀ ½ãã¨ã] ª¾ããÌãñ¦ã.

[‡ãŠ] Ôãâºãâãä£ã¦ããâ¶ãã ‚ããªñÍã ‡ãŠßãäÌã¥¾ãã¦ã ¾ããÌãã.

‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ.

ãäª¶ããâ‡ãŠ : 21/06/2010.

{‚ãù¡.Ôããõ.½ããä¶ãÓãã ‡ãõŠËãÔã Œã¡ã½ã‡ãŠÀ} {Ñããè.Ôãì£ãã‡ãŠÀ.‡ãñŠ.ãäºã¶ãÌã¡ñ}

ÔãªÔ¾ãã ‚ã£¾ãàã

ãä•ãÊÖã ØãÆãÖ‡ãŠ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ãÌããÀ¥ã ãä•ãÊÖã ØãÆãÖ‡ãŠ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ãÌããÀ¥ã

¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã,‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ. ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã,‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ.


,	HONORABLE test, PRESIDING MEMBER	,