Karnataka

Mandya

CC/09/147

Smt.Mamatha - Complainant(s)

Versus

Tata Finance Ltd., - Opp.Party(s)

Sri.Yogananda

26 Feb 2010

ORDER


DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM, MANDYA
D.C.Office Compound, Opp. District Court Premises, Mandya - 571 401.
consumer case(CC) No. CC/09/147

Smt.Mamatha
...........Appellant(s)

Vs.

Tata Finance Ltd.,
Urs Car Service Centre Pvt. Ltd.,
Urs Car,
...........Respondent(s)


BEFORE:
1. Smt.A.P.Mahadevamma2. Sri.M.N.Manohara3. Sri.Siddegowda

Complainant(s)/Appellant(s):


OppositeParty/Respondent(s):


OppositeParty/Respondent(s):


OppositeParty/Respondent(s):




Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.

ORDER

£ÄÑö –ÑõÌБФРÀÑô¡ô–ÐÎÐ »Ð§ÌѤРÀÙÓ¸‘Ù, ÀÐԁ®Ðô G¥À¹Üw: 1. ²æÃ.¹zÉÝÃUËqÀ, ©J¸ïì¹., J¯ïJ¯ï©., CzsÀåPÀëgÀÄ, 2. ²æÃ.JA.J£ï.ªÀÄ£ÉÆúÀgÀ, ©.J., J¯ïJ¯ï©., ¸ÀzÀ¸ÀågÀÄ, 3. ²æêÀÄw.J.¦.ªÀĺÁzÉêÀªÀÄä, ©J¸ïì¹., J¯ïJ¯ï©., ¸ÀzÀ¸ÀågÀÄ DzÉñÀ JArJ¥sï/¹.¹.¸ÀASÉå.147/2009 DzÉñÀ ¢£ÁAPÀ:26£Éà »°Ù½õÀЧ 2010 ÇõÓÀÐÔ´ ÀÐÔÀÐԳР‘ÙÖӁ Àف‘ЩÊÑ÷ÁÔ, ÀÙÔÓ: ¦ÐÔÖº« „–ÙÖõÓ Êف©¤ý, Š.¼.ŠÀЦý.Ë. „–ÙÖõÓ Êف©¤ý, ÀÐԁ®Ðô Ë«. (ÇõÓ.¦ÙÖӖйЁ•Ð., ÀВÓäÐÔ) -¦ügÁåzÀÄzÁgÀgÀÄ «gÀÄzÀÞ 1. ÆÑ”Ñ ÀÐôÀÐÊÑë»Ð‘ФÐÔ, ªÑªÑ »°Ùڹѹýú ÅÁÔªÙ®ý, «.ŠÀЦý.ŠÄý »°Ùڹѹýú ÊÐÁÓþÊý ÅÁÔªÙ®ý, ¹Ð.189, 10 ‘Ù ‘ѹÐþ¤ý ÊÙÖåÓ¤ý, ¤ÑÀÐÔÁÄÑÊý ¤ÙÖÓ®ý, ‘Ù.„¤ý.ÀÙÖÌÐÄÑö, ÀÙÔÚÊÐÖ¤ÐÔ. 2. ƒ¤ÐÊý ‘Ѥý ÊÐÁÓþÊý Êف©¤ý »ÙõÿÚ., Å., Ë.Ìٛý 47, ¸Àѹýú ¤ÐÊÙê, ÒùÿóÓ»ÐÔ¤ÐÀЦý, ÀÙÔÚÊÐÖ¤ÐÔ. 3. ƒ¤ÐÊý ‘Ѥý, —õÓ¹ý »ÑôÄÙÓÊý Š•ÐÔ¤ÐÔ, Š.Ë.¤ÐÊÙê, ÀÐԁ®Ðô. …•Ð¤Ð »Ðõ´º¸° ÀÐôÀÐÊÑë»Ð‘ФÐÔ. (ÇõÓ.£.¿.ƒ¤ÐÔ²ý ‘ÐÔÀЦѤý., ÀВÓäÐÔ) … JzÀÄgÀÄzÁgÀgÀÄ zÀÆgÀÄ ¢£ÁAPÀ 03.12.2009 £ÉÆÃn¸ï eÁjAiÀiÁzÀ ¢£ÁAPÀ 21.12.2009 CAwªÀÄ DzÉñÀzÀ ¢£ÁAPÀ 26.02.2010 MlÄÖ CªÀ¢ü 2 wAUÀ¼ÀÄ 5 ¸ÀÐÊЖÐÎÐÔ CAwªÀÄ DzÉñÀ 1. ¼°¤Ñô•Ð¹ÐÔî † ‘ÙÎБЁ®Ð³Ù »ÐÔ¤ÐÊÐܧ˕ÙìÓÀÙ. 2. ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¤ÐÖ.745/- –ÐÎйÐÔî 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù »ÑÀд ÀЦѮгБÐܕÐÔì, ¹Ð³Ð¤Ð 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÀÑÌйЕРÀÙÔÓŹРƒ®ÐÀЦѹР¤Ð•ÐÔì»Ð¯Ë „¤ý.Ë., Š¹ý..Ë. ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ÀÑÌйЕР’Ó¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ‘Ù֮гБÐܕÐÔì. 3. 2 ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê 3 ¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФРÁ¤ÐԕÐì ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐ „•ÙÓÆÐÁ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. ²æêÀÄw.J.¦.ªÀĺÁzÉêÀªÀÄä., ÀÐÔÍÎÑ ¸ÀzÀ¸ÀågÀÄ 1. ¦ügÁåzÀ£ÀÄß UÁæºÀPÀ ¸ÀAgÀPÀëuÁ PÁÄzÉ 1986gÀ PÀ®A 12gÀ jÃvÁå zÁR®Ä ªÀiÁr¤ÐÔ³Ðê•Ù. 2. ¦ügÁåzÀÄ«£À ¸ÀAQë¥ÀÛ ¸ÁgÁA±À EAwzÉ:- ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ªÑªÑ …¯‘Ñ ‘Ѥý ¹Ð½¤ý ‘Ù.Š-11-Š-1729 ¹ÐÔî 2¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÅö ‘Ùց¯¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ•Ð ‘ѤйÐÔî ‘ÙÖÎÐÔüÀÐՕБÑܗ ÊÑà »Ð®Ù¸•ÐÔì, ÊÑÕРÀÑ»ÐÊÑ´–Ñ— ‘ФѤйÐÔî ÀЦѯ‘Ùց¯•ÐÔì, ‘Фѧ¹Ð ÊЁ”Ùô:5000007033 „—•ÐÔì, „ ‘ФѤÐÔ ¸:07.10.2006 §•Ð ¢Ñ§¦ÐÔÅö¤ÐÔ³Ðê•Ù. ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÌіÐÖ 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФР»ÐЕР§Ó³Ðô ÊÑÕР‘Ð³ÐԖÐÎйÐÔî º–и³Ð ÊÐÀÐԁ¦ÐԕÐÅö ÀÐÔ¤ÐÔ»ÑÀд ÀЦѯ•Ðì¤ÐÖ ‘ÐÖ®Ð, ÀÑÌйЕР„¤ý.Ë, ’Ó, ’ö¦ÐÔ¤Ù¹ýú ÊЫþ¼°Ó‘ÙÓªý¹ÐÔî ºÓ¯¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. ÌÐÃÀѤÐÔ ¾Ñ§ 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФР‘ÐÙÓ§–Ù ƒÄٕѯ•Ð¤ÐÖ ºÓ¯¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. ƒ•Ð‘Ñܗ ¸:27.10.2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ ÅӖÐÄý ¹ÙÖÓ«ÓÊý ‘Ù֯˕ÐÔì, ƒ•ÐÔ “Ô•ÐÔì ¢Ñ§¦Ð¦Ñ—¤ÐÔ³Ðê•Ù. Íӗ•Ðì¤ÐÖ ÀÑÌйЕР¹ÙÖӁ•Ð±Ò »Ð³Ðõ, ’Ó ÌіÐÖ ÀÑÌйЕРÀÙÔÓŤÐÔÀÐ ƒ®ÐÀЦѹÐÀйÐÔî ¤Ð•ÐÔì ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. …•Ð§•Ð ³Ð¹Ð–Ù ‡ªÑ•Ð ÀЦѹÐˑР́Êٖ٠»Ð§ÌѤР‘ÙÖ¯ÊоÙӑف•ÐÔ ÌіÐÖ ÀÑÌйЕРÀÙÔÓŹРƒ®ÐÀЦѹР¤Ð•ÐÔì»Ð¯Ë, „¤ý.Ë, Š¹ý..Ë. ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ÀÑÌйЕР’Ó¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ‘ÙÖ¯ÊÐÔÀЁ³Ù ‘ÙÖÓ§, † ¼°¤Ñô•ÐÔ •Ñ“ÄÙ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. 3. 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÌÑ¡§•ÐÔì ÀБÑóý Ìђ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù, „•Ð¤Ù ³ÐÀÐÔó ³Ð‘ФѤйÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯˤÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. 4. 2¹ÙÓ ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê 3¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ³Ð‘ФѤÐÔ ÊÐÅö˕ÐÔì, ³Ð‘Фѧ¹Ð ÊЁ’ù»Ðê ÊѤсÆÐ † ‘ÙÎБЁ®Ð³Ù …¤ÐÔ³Ðê•Ù;- ¼°¤Ñô¸¹ÐÅö¤ÐÔÀÐ ŠÄÑö ÊЁ–д–ÐÎйÐÔî ƒÃö–ÙÎÙ¸¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ, ¼°¤Ñô¸¹Ð »Ñô¤Ð 6 ¤ÐÅö ÌÙÓϤÐÔÀЁ³Ù ³ÑÀÐÕ 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ•Ð ÊÑà »Ð®Ù¦ÐÔÔÀЁ³Ù ´ÏËÃö ÌіÐÖ ƒÀФÐÔ 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ÊÑà ÀÐÔ¤ÐÔ »ÑÀдÊÐÔÀÐ ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ªÑªÑ …¯‘Ñ ‘ѧ¹Ð ’Ó, ’ö¦ÐÔ¤Ù¹ýú ÊЫþ¼°Ó‘ÙÓªý ‘Ù֮Е٠…¤ÐÔÀÐ ÊЁ–д¦ÐÔÖ ÊÐÌÐ –ÙÖ´êÃö. ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¸:27.10.2009 ¤Ð•ÐÔ ÀВÓ灕Р1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ÌіÐÖ ³ÐÀÐԖ٠¹ÙÖÓ«ÓÊý ºÓ¯¤ÐÔÀÐ ÊЁ–д¦ÐÔÖ –ÙÖ´êÃö. ³ÑÀÐÕ ªÑªÑ ÀÙÖӪѤýú ‘ѧ¹Ð ÀЦѤѩ–ѤФÐÔ ÀЦѳÐõ „—•ÐÔì. ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ‘ѤйÐÔî ÀЦѳÐõ ÀЦѤѩ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³ÙêÓ¹Ù. ‡Ï‘Ù ÊЁ–д–ÐÎÐÔ ³ÐÀÐԖ٠–ÙÖ´ê¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. ƒ•Ð직•Ð ¼°¤Ñô•Ð¹ÐÔî “›ÐÔþ ÊÐͳРÀТÑÀЦѮоÙӑف•ÐÔ »ÑõþˤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. 5. ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó »ÐõÀЦѱ»Ð´õ‘Ù ÌіÐÖ ºÆѹÙ.Ë.1 §•Ð Ë.3 •Ñ“ÄٖÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯˤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. 6. »Ðõ‘ФбÀйÐÔî º±þÂÔÊÐÃÔ ‡•ÐòÁÊÐÔÀÐ ƒÆЖÐÎÐÔ …´ÀÙ:- 1. ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ, 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ•Ð ¼°¤Ñô¸¹ÐÅö ‘ÙÓϤÐÔÀÐ •Ñ“ÄÑ´ »Ð®Ù¦ÐÔÃÔ ƒÌÐþ¤ÙÓ? 2. ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÀЦѹÐˑР́Êٖ٠»Ð§ÌѤР»Ð®Ù¦ÐÔÃÔ ƒÌÐþ¤ÙÓ? 3. „•ÙÓÆÐ ‹¹ÐÔ? 7. 1 & 2¹ÙÓ ƒÆЖÐÎÐ ÀÙÔÓÄÙ:- ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ¼°¤Ñô¸¹Ð ƒÆЖÐÎйÐÔî ÊÐÀÐÔþÊÐÃÔ ºÆѹÙ.Ë.1 §•Ð Ë.3(a) ¤Ð •Ñ“ÄٖÐÎйÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐÔÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. ºÆѹÙ.Ë.1 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÀЦѯ‘Ùց®Ð »ÐР»Ð³ÐõÀї¤ÐÔ³Ðê•Ù. ºÆѹÙ.Ë.2 ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÅö ÊÑà ÊЁ”Ùô:2000059756 ¤ÐÅö ÊÑà »Ð®Ù•ÐÔ »Ðõ´ ´–ÐÎÐÖ ÊÑÕР‘Ð³ÐԖÐÎйÐÔî ÀÐÔ¤ÐÔ »ÑÀд ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. „•Ð¤Ù ÊÑÕРŠÄÑö ÌбÀйÐÔî ÀÐÔ¤ÐÔ »ÑÀд ÀЦѯ ¤ÐÖ.745/- –ÐÎйÐÔî ¾Ñ’ ‡ÏˑÙց¯¤ÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. † ‡Ï‘Ù Ìб•Ð ½–ÙÞ ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ¼°¤Ñô¸¹ÐÄÑö–ÐÅ ƒµÐÀÑ ³ÐÀÐÔó »ÐõÀЦѱ »Ð³Ðõ‘ف¦ÐÔÄÑö–ÐÅÓ ÌіÐÖ Á›Ñ¤Ð²Ù¦ÐÔÄÑö–ÐÅÓ ‹‘Ù † ÌбÀйÐÔî ¾Ñ’ …•Ù Š½ ÊЁ–д¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ÌÙÓϤÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö, ƒµÐÀÑ 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÀÙÓ¸‘ف¦ÐÔÅö ÌÑ¡§•ÐÔì ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ, ¼°¤Ñô¸¹ÐÅö ÌÙÓϤÐÔÀЁ³Ù ŠÄÑö ÌбÀйÐÔî »ÑÀд ÀЦѯÃö Š½ ÊЁ–д¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ƒÃö–ÙÎÙ¸¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ³ÐÀÐÔó ¼°¤Ñô¸¹ÐÅö ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê »ÐõÀЦѱ »Ð´õ‘ف¦ÐÔÅö ŠÄÑö ÌбÀйÐÔî »ÑÀд ÀЦѯ•ÙìÓÀÙ Š•ÐÔ ÌÙÓÎÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. „•Ð¤Ù ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÙÓ ÌÑ¡¤ÐÔ ÀЦѯ¤ÐÔÀÐ ºÆѹÙ.Ë.2 ¤ÐÅö ¤ÐÖ.745/- –ÐÎÐÔ ¾Ñ’ Š•ÐÔ ³ÙÖӧˤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù, † ÊЁ–д¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ƒÃö–ÙÎÙ¸¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö, ƒ•Ð¤Ù ºÆѹÙ.Ë.2 ¤ÐÅö 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ³Ð»ÐÔï ÄّÐܛѤРÀЦѯ•Ñì¤Ù ÌіÐÖ ÌٛÐÔà ÌбÀйÐÔî ³ÙÖӧ˕Ñì¤Ù•ÐÔ ³ÑÀÐÕ ‘ÙÖ®ÐÃÔ ½¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö Š½ ÊЁ–д¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî º¤ÐּˤÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. ¼°¤Ñô¸¹ÐÅö ³ÐÀÐԖ٠‡ªÑ•Ð ÀЦѹÐˑР́Êٖ٠¤ÐÖ.50,000/- –ÐÎÐ »Ð§ÌѤР‘ÙÓϤÐÔ³Ñê¤Ù. „•Ð¤Ù ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÙÓ ºÆѹÙ.Ë.2 ¹ÐÔî ÌÑ¡¤ÐԻЯ˕ÐÔì, ‡Ï‘Ù Ìб ºÓ®Ð¾Ùӑї¤ÐÔÀÐՕЧ•Ð ÀЦѹÐˑР́Êٖ٠»Ð§ÌѤР»Ð®Ù¦ÐÔÃÔ ƒÌÐþ¤Ñ—ÃöÀف•ÐÔ »Ð§–бÒÊÐÄї•Ù. 2¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÅö ‘ѤйÐÔî ‘Ùց®Ð ÊЁ–д ¿©å¤Ù ¾ÙÓ¤Ù ÊЁ–д–ÐÎйÐÔî „¤ÙÖӼˤÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. 8. 3¹ÙÓ ƒÆЕРÀÙÔÓÄÙ:- 1 ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê 2¹ÙÓ ƒÆЕÐÅö º±þÂÔˤÐÔÀЁ³Ù ƒ´ÀÐÔ „•ÙÓÆÐ † ‘ÙÎБЁ®Ð³Ù …¤ÐÔ³Ðê•Ù. „•ÙÓÆÐ 1. ¼°¤Ñô•Ð¹ÐÔî † ‘ÙÎБЁ®Ð³Ù »ÐÔ¤ÐÊÐܧ˕ÙìÓÀÙ. 2. ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤФÐÔ ¤ÐÖ.745/- –ÐÎйÐÔî 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤЧ–Ù »ÑÀд ÀЦѮгБÐܕÐÔì, ¹Ð³Ð¤Ð 1¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФÐÔ ÀÑÌйЕРÀÙÔÓŹРƒ®ÐÀЦѹР¤Ð•ÐÔì»Ð¯Ë „¤ý.Ë., Š¹ý..Ë. ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê ÀÑÌйЕР’Ó¦ÐÔ¹ÐÔî ¼°¤Ñô•ÐԕѤЧ–Ù ‘Ù֮гБÐܕÐÔì. 3. 2 ÀÐÔ³ÐÔê 3 ¹ÙÓ Š•ÐÔ¤ÐԕѤФРÁ¤ÐԕÐì ¦Ð¦ÑÀÐ „•ÙÓÆÐÁ¤ÐÔÀÐÕ¸Ãö. (²ÃWÀæ°¦UÁgÀjUÉ GPÀÛ¯ÉÃR£À ¤Ãr, ¨ÉgÀ¼ÀZÀÄÑ ªÀiÁr¹, vÀ¥ÀÄàUÀ¼À£ÀÄß £ÉÆÃr ¸Àj¥Àr¹ CAwªÀÄ DzÉñÀªÀ£ÀÄß 26¹ÙÓ »°Ù½õÀЧ 2010 gÀAzÀÄ vÉgÉzÀ £ÁåAiÀiÁ®AiÀÄzÀ°è WÉÆøÀ¯ÁÄvÀÄ). (CzsÀåPÀëgÀÄ) (¸ÀzÀ¸ÀågÀÄ) (¸ÀzÀ¸ÀågÀÄ)




......................Smt.A.P.Mahadevamma
......................Sri.M.N.Manohara
......................Sri.Siddegowda