khtl;l Efh;Bthh; FiwjPh; kd;wk;, BtY]h;,  BtY]h; khtl;lk;

         Kd;dpiy jpU.m. rk;gj;, gp.v. gp.vy;.      jiyth;

         jpUkjp. $p. kyh;tpHp, gp.n.,               cWg;gpdh;-1

         jpU. jahsK}h;j;jp, gp.v!;.rp.,               cWg;gpdh;-2

                        rp.rp.vz;.40/2004

          2010-Mk; tUlk; $Piy jpA;fs; 7-Mk; ehs; g[jd; fpHik.

v!;. Bfrtd;,

j/bg. Bf. Rhkd;dd;,

fhfA;fiu, jpUg;gj;J]h; jhY]f;fh,

BtY]h; khtl;lk;.                                       .. kDjhuh;

                ..vjph; ..

1. khepy th;j;jf Bkyhsh;,

   kcwpBfh rpl;!; ypkpl;,

      P.B.No.1165, 83,rk;ge;jk; BuhL,

   Mh;.v!;.g[uk;,

   Bfhak;g[j;J]h;  61 002.

2. v!;.Bf. oBulh;!;,

   7v, gHdpag;gd; BuhL,

   jpUg;gj;J]h;,

   BtY]h; khtl;lk;.                            .. vjph; kDjhuh;fs;

         ne;j KiwaPL nWjp tprhuizf;F 15.6.2010 Bjjpapy; vA;fs; Kd;dpiyapy; te;J, KiwaPl;lhsUf;fhf jpU.vy;.ghz;LuA;fd;, tHf;fwpqh; mth;fs; vjph;KiwaPl;lhsUf;fhf jpU.b$.fhq;rdh, Kd;dpiyahfp KiwaPl;L, vjph; ciu, gpukhz thf;FK}yk; kw;Wk; MtzA;fis ehA;fs; fz;L ghprPyid bra;J ne;j kd;wk; nWjpahf gpwg;gpf;Fk;

M iz a[ iu

jpU. m. rk;gj;, jiyth;

1.                         kDjhuhpd; kDciu RUf;fk; gpd;tUkhW:-

        kDjhuh; 15.7.03-y; gUj;jp tptrhak; bra;tjw;fhf U}gha; 600/-f;F 1fpByh gUj;jp tpij 2-k; vjph;kDjhuhplk; tptrhak; bra;a Muk;gpj;jhh;.  tpijfs; brofshft[k;, g{, gpq;Rfshf cUthfpd.    BghJkhd ghrd trjp nUe;Jk; gpq;Rfs; fha;fshf khwhky; cjph;e;J tpGe;jd.  nij mwpe;J mjph;r;rpaile;j kDjhuh; gUj;jp tpij thA;fpa 2k; vjph;khDjhuhplk; Behpy; g[fhh; bfhLj;jhh;.   2k; vjph;kDjhuhpd; ghpe;Jiuapd; Bghpy; g{r;rpbfhy;yp kUe;J thA;fp bjspg;ghd; K}yk; gad;gLj;jpdhh;, nUe;Jk; gpq;Rf;s cjph;e;J tpisr;ry; Vw;glhjjhy; filf;fhuh; kcwpBfh epWtdj;jpd; fsg;ggzpahsh; kw;Wk; Ma;t[g; gphpt[f;F  17.1.04 md;W jfty; mspj;jjd; Bghpy; K}d;W egh;fs; te;J Ma;t[ bra;jdh;.   Ma;t[ bra;jth;fs; gUj;jp bro ey;y Kiwapy; tsh;e;Js;sjht[k;  tpijapy; gpur;rid nUg;gjhy;  eph;thf naf;Fehplk; jfty; bfhLj;J kDjhuUf;F epthuzk; fpilf;f Vw;ghL bra;tjhf Twptpl;L brd;wdh;.  gpwF mth;fsplkpUe;J ve;j tpsf;fKk; epthuzKk; fpilf;fhj gl;rj;jpy; kDjhuh; gFjp Btshz;ik tphpthf;f mYtyh; jpU. kBfe;jpud; mth;fsplk; gaph; tpisr;riyg;gw;wp rhd;wspf;FkhW Bfl;Lf;bfhz;lhh;.   Btshz;ikj; Jiw mjpfhhpfspd; MByhridapd; Bghpy; BtY]h; tpijr; rhd;W naf;Feh; gUj;jp gaph; tpisr;riy ghh;itapl;L Kisg;g[j;jpwdpy; FiwghL ny;iy vdt[k;,  kfR{y; tuhjjw;F ePjpkd;wj;jpd; K}yk; epthuzk; bgWA;fs; vd Twptpl;lhh;.   vdBt kDjhuh; XR}{h; rpg;fhl;-2 Efh;Bthh; ghJfhg;g[ FGtpd; K}yk; 1-k; vjph;kDjhuUf;F 3.3.04 md;W g[fhh; kD mDg;gpdhh;. 1k; vjph;kDjhuhplkpUe;J xR{h; rpg;fhl;-2 Efh;Bthh; ghJfhg;g[ FGtpw;F tpsf;fk; fojk; fpilj;jJ.  mjpy; epthuzk; gw;wp vJt[k; Fwpg;gplhjhy; kPz;Lk; epthuzk; Bfl;L 1k; vjph;kDjhuUf;F fojk; mDg;gg;gLk;.  nJtiu ve;jtpj tpsf;fKk; epthuzKk; fpilf;ftpy;iy.  MfBt kDjhuUf;F gUj;jp tptrhaj;jjhy; nHe;j tUkhdk; U}.45,000/-k; kw;Wk; gUj;jp tptrhaj;jhy; Vw;gl;l bryt[ U}.15,000/-k;, BkYk; tHf;F brytpw;fhf U}.5000/-k; 1k; kw;Wk; 2-k; vjph;kDjhuh;fs; tHA;fpl cj;jput[ gpwgpf;FkhW Btz;lg;gLfpwJ.

2.  2-k; vjph;kDjhuh; Vw;Wf;;bfhs;sg;gl;L 1-k; vjph;kDjhuh; jug;gpy; vjph; ciuapy; cs;s RUf;fk;  gpd;tUkhW:

    kDtpy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;l mk;rA;fspy; Fwpg;ghf xg;g[f;bfhz;Ls;sit jtpu kw;w mk;rA;fs; midj;ija[k; kDjhuBu epU}gpf;f Toath; Mthh;.   kDjhuuhy; thA;fg;gl;ljhf  Twg;gLk; gUj;jp tpijf;fhd tpiyg;gl;oay; kw;Wk; gUj;jp tpiy Fwpj;jhd tptuk; jhf;fy; bra;ag;gltpy;iy.  fsg;gzpahsh; 17.1.04 Bjjpa Ma;tp;d; BghJ gUj;jp brofs; 95% tsh;r;rp bgw;W nUg;gjhft[k; gUj;jp tpijia Fwpj;Bjh mjDila Kisg;g[ jd;ikapd; FiwghL Fwpj;Bjh, vJt[k; bjhptpf;fhj epiyapy;, 1k; vjph;kDjhuh; epWtdj;jplk;  thA;fg;gl;l gUj;jp tpij ey;y juj;Jld; nUe;jJ vd;gJ bjspthfpd;wJ. gUj;jp bro ed;F tsh;r;rp mile;j epiyapy;  kfR{y; fpilf;fhky; Bgha;tpl;ljhf fsg;gzpahsBu bjhptpj;Js;s epiyapy;, ed;F tsh;r;rp mile;j gUj;jp brof;F Beha; jLg;g[, g{r;rp jLg;g[ Bghd;wtw;wpw;F chpa kUe;ij thA;fp gad;gLj;j jtwpajd; K}yk; kfR}{y; fpilf;fhjjw;F kDjhuBu bghWg;ghthh;.  gUj;jp tpij Kisj;J bro ed;F tsh;e;j epiyapy; kfR{y; fpilf;fhky; Bghdjw;F gUj;jp tpijapd; jd;ik kl;LBk fhuzkhf nUf;f KoahJ vdt[k;, Fwpg;gpl;l gUt  epiyapy; gUj;jp tpisa Toa kz;zpy; kw;Wk; Rw;Wg[w R{Hy; ghh;j;;J gUj;jp tpijia  el;L, BghJkhd chpa cuk;, jz;zPh; gad;gLj;jp, broahf tsh;e;j gpwF Beha; kw;Wk; g{r;rp, Mfpatw;wpy; ghJfhf;Fk; bghUl;L chpa kUe;J bjspe;J guhkhpj;J te;jhy; ey;y kfR{y; fpilf;Fk;.   kDjhuhpd; eph;thf jpiwikapd;apd; fhuzkhfjhd; ed;F tsh;r;rp mile;j gUj;jp broapy; kfR{y; fpilf;fhky; Bgha;tp;l;lJ.  kfR{y; fpilf;fhjjw;F gUj;jp tpijia tpepBahf bra;j vjph;kDjhuh;fs; bghWg;ghf KoahJ.   mjd;go nk;kD js;Sgo bra;a ToajhFk;. 

3..   kDjhuh; jug;gpy; gpukhz thf;FK}yk; jhf;fy; bra;J,  k.rh.M1 Kjy; k.rh.M-5 tiuapyhd rhd;whtzA;fis FwpaPL bra;ag;gl;lJ. vjph;kDjhuhfs; jug;gpy; gpukhz thf;FK}yk; jhf;fy; bra;J, rhd;whtzA;fs; vJt[k; FwpaPL bra;ag;gl;ltpy;iy.  nU jug;gpdUk;, tha;bkhHp rhl;rpak; vJkpy;iy.  

4.  ghprPyidf;Fhpa tpdhf;fs; gpd;tUkhW:-

    m) vjph;kDjhuh;fs; jug;gpy; Britf;FiwghL VBjDk; cs;sjh?.

    M) kDjhuh;  bgwjFe;j ghpfhuA;fs; vd;d?

5. jPh;t[f;Fhpa tpdh - m:

    kDjhuh; jug;gpy; 1-k; vjph;kDjhuh; epWtdj;jplkpUe;J thA;fg;gl;l gUj;jptpijia kDjhuh; epyj;jpy; el;L brofshf tsh;e;j epiyapy; BghJkhd ghrd trjp nUe;Jk; mr;brofspy; nUe;j gpq;Rfs; fha;fshf khwhky; cjph;e;J Bgha;tpl;ljhft[k;, 2k; vjph;kDjhuhpd; ghpe;Jiuapd; Bghpy; g{r;rp bfhy;yp kUe;J thA;fp bjspj;Jk; gad; ny;yhky; Bgha;tpl;ljht[k; vdBt vjph;kDjhuh;fs; jukw;w gUj;jp tpijia tpw;gid bra;jjd; K}yk; kDjhuUf;F bgUj;j e&;lKk; tUkhd nHg;g[k; kw;Wk; kdcisr;rYk; Vw;gl;Ls;sjht[k;, mjid NLbra;a[k; tifapy; kDtpy; Bfhhpagoahd epthuz bjhifia vjph;kDjhuh;fsplkpUe;J fpilf;f cj;jputpl Btz;Lbkd Btz;lg;gLfpwJ.

6.  vjph;kDjhuh;fs; jug;gpy;, kDjhuuhy; gUj;jp tpij vJt[k; 2-k; vjph;kDjhuhplkpUe;J fpiuak; bra;ag;gltpy;iy,  kDjhuhpd; jfg;gdhh; rk;gd;dd; vd;gth; bgahpy; gUj;jp tpij thA;fg;gl;L tptrhak; bra;ag;gl;L nUe;j BghjpYk; me;j gUj;jp tpijfs; Kisj;J brofshf ed;F tsh;r;rp mile;j epiyapy; mitfspy; cUthd fha;fs; cjph;e;J Bghdjhf Twg;gLtjw;F gUj;jp tpij kl;LBk fhuzkhf nUf;f KoahJ vdt[k;, chpa gUtj;jpy;, gUj;jp tpisr;rYf;F Vw;w kz;zpy; gUj;jp tpijia el;L, BghJkhd jz;zPh; kw;Wk; cuk; gad;gLj;jp, bro tsh;rpr mile;j epiyapy; Beha; kw;Wk; g{r;rp MfpafspypUe;J fhghw;wp chpa kUe;ij bjspj;J ed;F guhkhpj;J te;jhy; jhd; ey;y kfR{y; vjph;ghh;f;f Koa[k; vdt[k;, gUj;jp tpij Kisj;J gpd; brofshf ed;F tsh;r;rp mile;j epiyapy; kDjhuh; guhkhpf;f jtwpajhy;jhd; mtUf;F kfR{y; fpilf;fhky; Bgha; nUf;fyhk; vdt[k; thjplg;gl;L mjw;F Mjuthf Bjrpa Efh;Bthh; Mizaj;jpd; fPH;f;fz;l jPh;g;g[fis Rl;o fhl;lg;gl;lJ.

1.                                                             II  (2005) CPJ 94 (NC)

SONEKARAN GLADIOLI GROWERS

Versus

BABU RAM

Wherein the Hon’ble N.C.D.R.Commisison, New Delhi is held that

Consumer Protection Act, 1986 – Secions 2(1) (g0 and 21 (b) – Agriculture – Seeds – Sub-standard – Absence of clear finding regarding quality of sseeds supplied – No inference can be drawn against petitioner – Non-standared quality of see not proved – Complaint dismissed by  Forum – Order set aside in appeal – Restored in revision.

2.                                                            II 92007) CPJ 148 (NC)

INFDO AMERICAN HYBRID SEEDS & ANR

Versus

VIJAYAKUMAR SHANKARAO & ANR.

Wherein the Hon’ble N.C.D.R.Commisison, New Delhi is held that

Consumer Protection Act 1986 – Sectons 2(1)(r ) - Seeds – Defective – Sale of – Evidence – Seeds – producted by OP – Purhased from M/s. Soni Foods, not made party in complaint against OP – Crop growth not upto expecations – Report of agricultureal authorities indicating only 10% of crop properly developed – No words in report against or about quality of seeds supplied – Variation in yield dependent on external considerations like climate, pesticides, etc. – No evidence on record indicating seeds to be of non-standard quality – Courts to be led by evidence and proof on subject –  In absence of evidence, un fair practice not proved.

7.  kDjhuhpd; kDtpYk;, gpukhz thf;FK}yj;jpYk;, 15.7.03 Bjjpapl;l kh.rh.M-1 urPjpy; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;sgoahd gUj;jp tpijia 2k; vjph;kDjhuh; epWtdj;jplkpUe;J fpiuak; bgw;W, tptrhak; bra;jBghJ, gUj;jp tpijfs; brofshf ed;F tsh;r;rp mile;j epiyapy; g{ g{j;J fha;fshf khwhky; cjph;e;J Bghdjhft[k;, fsgzpahsh; Ma;t[ bra;J gUj;jp tpij ed;F Kisj;J brofshf cUthfp nUg;gjhy;, kfR{y; tuhjjw;F tpijfs; gpur;ridahf nUg;gjhf bjhptpj;jjht[k;, mjd; mog;gilapy; epthuzk; Bfl;fg;gl;oUg;gjhf Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;sJ.   2k; vjph;kDjhuh; epWtdj;jplkpUe;J fpiuak; bgw;w gUj;jp tpijfs; Kisj;J brofs; ed;F tsh;r;rp mile;j BghjpYk; mitfspy; fha;fs; Kisf;fhky; Bghdjw;F jukw;w tpijfs; vd kDjhuh; jug;gpy; Twg;gLtjw;F rhd;whtzk; vJt[k;  jhf;fy; bra;ag;gltpy;iy.  2k; vjph;kDjhuh; epWtdj;jplkpUe;J thA;fg;gl;l gUj;jp tpij ed;F Kisj;J brofshf ed;F tsh;r;rp mile;J nUe;jjht[k;, Kisg;g[ jpwdpy; FiwghL ny;iy vdt[k; fsgzpahsBu Ma;t[ bra;J bjhptpj;jjhft[k; kDtpYk; kw;Wk; gpukhzthf;FK}yj;jpYk; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;sJ.   gUj;jp tpij Kisf;f Toa kz;zpy; chpa gUtj;jpy; kw;Wk; naw;if R{H;epiyapy; gUj;jp tpijia el;L BghJkhd ghrd trjp bra;J BghJkhd jz;zPh; Cw;wp mt;tpij Kisf;f bra;j gpd; brofs; tsh;r;rp mila[k; epiyapy; mitfis  Beha; kw;Wk; g{r;rp bfhy;;ypia jLf;Fk; tifapy; chpa kUe;J bjspj;J, Kiwahf brofis ftdpj;J tUk; gl;rj;jpy; ey;y kfR{y; fpilf;f tha;g;g[ cz;L.  ne;j tHf;fpy; kDjhuh; chpa gUtj;jpy; gUj;jp tpisa Toa kz;zpy; kw;Wk; R{H;epiyfSf;F Vw;g gUj;jp tpijia el;L, mg;gUj;jp tpij Kisj;J ed;F brofshf ed;F tsh;e;J tUk; epiyapy; Beha; kw;Wk; g{r;rp bfhy;yp nd;wp mr;brofis ghJfhf;Fk; chpa kUe;ij bjspj;J kw;Wk; mr;brofis ed;F eph;tfpj;J te;jjhfBth kDjhuh; jug;gpy; MtzA;fs; K}ykhf ePUgpf;fgltpy;iy.  2-k; vjph;kDjhuhplkpUe;J thA;fg;gl;l gUj;jp tpij ed;F Kisj;J brofshf tsh;rpr mile;Js;sJ vd;gij fsgzpahsBu bjhptpj;jjhf kDjhuBuh xg;g[ bfhz;Ls;shh; mjd;go 2-k; vjph;kDjhuhhplkpUe;J thA;fg;gl;l gUj;jp tpij ey;y juj;Jld; nUe;jJ vd;gJ bjspthd;fpd;wJ.

8.  gUj;jp tpij Kisj;J brofshf tsh;r;rp mile;j gpd; g{ g{j;J mitfs; fha;fshf khwhky; cjph;e;J tpl;ljhf kDjhuh; jug;gpy; TwgLtjw;F jukw;w gUj;jp tpij kl;LBk fhuzkhFk; vd Twg;gLtJ kDjhuh; jug;gpy; MtzA;fs; hPjpahf epUg;gpf;fgltpy;iy.  BkYk; vjph;kDjhuh;fs; jug;gpy; Rl;ofhl;lg;gl;l Bkw;go Bjrpa Efh;Bthh; ghpfhuk; BfhUk; Mizaj;jpd; jPh;g;g[iu nt;tHf;fpd; bghUz;ikf;Fk; kw;Wk; R{H;epiyf;Fk; bghUe;jToajhf mike;Js;sJ. 

9.  kD, vjph;ciu, gpukhz thf;FK}yk;, kw;Wk; MtzA;fis ghprPyid bra;jjd;go BghJkhd kfR{y; fpilf;fhjjw;F 2-k; vjph;kDjhuhpkpUe;J thA;fg;gl;l jukw;w gUj;jp tpij fhuzbkd Twg;gLk; Tw;iw epU}gpf;f chpa rhd;whtzA;fs; kw;Wk; rhl;rpak; kDjhuh; jug;gpy; Kd;dpiygLj;jg;gltpy;iy mjd;go Bghjpa kfR{y; fpilf;fhky; kDjhuUf;F tUkhd nHg;g[ kw;Wk; ghjp;g;g[k;, kDtpy; Twg;gl;lthW vjph;kDjhuh;fs; BritFiwghL vJt[k; Vw;gLj;jgltpy;iybad Kot[ bra;J tpdh vz; (m)f;F tpilaspf;fg;gLfpwJ.

10.   jPh;t[f;Fhpa tpdh M:-

     vjph;kDjhuhpd; Brit FiwghL Tw;W kDjhuh; jug;gpy; epUgpf;fg;gltpy;iybad tpdh vz;.(m)tpy; Kot[ bra;jjpd;go nk;kDtpy; kDjhuUf;F ghpfhuk; vJt[k; fpilf;f Toajpy;iy vd Kot[ bra;J tpdh vz;.(M)-f;F tpilaspf;fg;gLfpwJ.

11.  nWjpapy; nk;kD js;Sgo bra;ag;gLfpwJ.  bryt[ bjhif ny;iy.

ne;j cj;jut[ jiyth; mth;fshy; RUf;bfGj;J jl;lr;rhplk; bkhHpjy; bra;ag;gl;L, jl;lr;rpy; tof;fg;bgw;W, jiyth; mth;fshy; ghh;itaplg;gl;L gpiHjpUj;jA;fs; bra;J, 2010-Mk; Mz;L $Piy jpA;fs; 7-k; ehshfpa nd;W nj;jpwe;j kd;wj;jpd; Kd; gfug;gLfpwJ.       

cWg;gpdh;-1                 cWg;gpdh; - 2                        jiyth;.

kDjhuh; jug;g[ rhd;whtzA;fs;: -

k.rh.M1-     --    - bghUs;tptugl;oapd; efy;.

k.rh.M2-     --    - vjph;kDjhuh; Behpy; ghh;itapl;lJ bjhlh;ghd foj efy;

k.rh.M3- 3.3.04   - XR{h; rpg;fhl;-2 ghJfhg;g[ FG mDg;gpa foj efy;.

k.rh.M4- 7.4.04   - 1k;vjph;kDjhuaplkpUe;J fpilj;j foj efy;.

k.rh.M5-     --    - gUj;jp tptrhak; bra;jw;fhd rhd;wpd; efy;.

vjph;kDjhuh;fspd; jug;g[ rhd;whtzA;fs;:       .. ny;iy. .

cWg;gpdh;-1                 cWg;gpdh; - 2                        jiyth;.