Karnataka

StateCommission

RA/153/2023

THE ASST PROVIDENT FUND COMMISSIONER - Complainant(s)

Versus

SRI G S DESHMUKH - Opp.Party(s)

K S VENKATARAMANA

18 Nov 2023

ORDER

Date of Filing: 26.09.2023, 04.10.2023    

05.10.2023, 06.10.2023, 31.10.2023

     Date of Disposal: 18.11.2023

 

 

BEFORE THE KARNATAKA STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION, BANGALORE (PRL BENCH)

 

 

DATED:18.11.2023

 

PRESENT

 

HON’BLE Mr JUSTICE HULUVADI G RAMESH : PRESIDENT

 

Mr K B SANGANNANAVAR: JUDICIAL MEMBER

 

Mrs DIVYASHREE M:LADY MEMBER

 

 

 

REVIEW APPLICATION Nos.107/2023 to 116/2013 118/2023 to 125/2023 & 153/2023

 

The Asst. Provident Fund Commissioner,
Bhavishyanidhi Bhavan,

Sub Regional Office,

Aland Road, No.97,

Behind Remand Home,

Gulbarga-585 101.

Represented by its Authorised person

(By Mr K S Venkataramana, Advocate)

(Review Petitioner is same in

all the Review Petitions)                                                   Petitioner

 

-Versus- 

 

 

1.Review Application No.107/2023

Mr Basawaraj Swamy,
S/o Mr Sangayya Swamy,

Aged:73 years,

H No 9-5-594/1,

Adarsh Colony,

Chindri Road, Bidar-585 401.                                       Respondent

 

2.Review Application No.108/2023

Mr Sudhakar.
S/o Mr Govindarao Kulkarni.

Aged:75 years,

H No1-29/29, LIG 5 KHB Colony,

Behind District Court,

Gulbarga – 585103.                                                       Respondent

3.Review Application No.109/2023

Mr Dattatray Padaki,

S/o Mr Pandurang Padaki,

Aged:76 years,

R/o Killa Muddebihal,

Tq:Muddebihal,

District Bijapur-586 212                                                  Respondent

 

4.Review Application No.110/2023

Mr Krishna Kumar,
S/o Mr Narayanarao,

Aged about:76 years,

H No 7-101-39/A,

1^st Floor, State Bank Colony,

Nehru Gunj, Gulbarga-585 104.                                     Respondent

 

5.Review Application No.111/2023

Mr Basawaraj,
S/o Mr Sharanappa ‘

Aged about 75 years,

H No 9/587/7/80,

J R Nagar, Aland Road,

Gulbarga – 585103.                                                         Respondent

 

6.Review Application No.112/2023

Mr Channabasappa,

S/o Mr Sharappa,
Aged about: 80 years,

R/o Halahalli,

Tq:Bhalki Dist: Bidar-585 328.                                       Respondent

 

7.Review Application No.113/2023

Mr Sharmoddin,

S/o Mr Abdulkareem,
Aged about:77 years,

Plot No.38, Near Taj Kiran Store,

Umar Colony,

Azadpur Road,

Gulbarga, Karnataka-585 102.                                         Respondent

 

8.Review Application No.114/2023

Mr Anil Kumar,
S/o Mr Sheshagiri Rao,

Aged about:75 years

R/o No.133, SBI Colony,

Opp. P & T Colony, Gulbarga-585 102                           Respondent

 

9.Review Application No.115/2023

Mr Prakash,

S/o Mr Venkanna,

Aged about:71 years,

R/o H No 10/262,

Lower Lane Brahmpur,

Gulbarga-585 103                                                                 Respondent

 

10.Review Application No.116/2023

Mr Kamshetty
S/o Mr Manik Rao,

Aged about 72 years,

R/o Mahesh Nilaya,

Defence Colony,

Naubad Post,

Bidar -585 401.                                                          Respondent

 

11.Review Application No.118/2023

Mr Shivaraj,
S/o Mr Bheemarao Mahajan,

Aged about:70 years,

R/o Yallaing Colony,

Navabag Bidar,

Dist: Bidar -585 401                                                   Respondent

 

12.Review Application No.119/2023

Mr Ram Shetty,

S/o Mr Anneppa Malage,

Aged about:74 years,

R/o H No17-4-177,

Chanabasava Nilaya,

Vishweshwarayya Colony,

Bidar-585 403.                                                                 Respondent

 

13.Review Application No.120/2023

Mr Azeemuddin
S/o Mr Abdul Kareem,

Aged about:75 years,

R/o H No 5-408/4M/A,

Baitul Azeem Khaja Colony,

Near Bibiraza College,

Gulbarga-585 104.                                                         Respondent

 

 

 

14.Review Application No.121/2023

Mr Irranna B Kodli,

S/o Basavanappa
Aged about: 75 years,

R/o HNo1-1495/G/1/1A,

Mallikarjun Nilaya,

Plot No.1/A,

Godutai Nagar, Gulbarga -585 102                               Respondent

 

15.Review Application No.122/2023

Mr G Laxman,
S/o Mr Ghalappa

Aged about: 68 years,

R/o H No10-3-326,

Pakala Chal,

Near Subhash Circle,

Bidar - 585 412                                                              Respondent

 

16.Review Application No.123/2023

Mr Basavaraj,
S/o Kanteppa,

Aged about: 66 years,

R/o Sangameshwar Colony,

Chidri Road,

Bidar District, Bidar-585 226                                        Respondent

 

17.Review Application No.124/2023

Mr Md. Hissammuddin
S/o Mr Md Azizuddin,

Aged about: 77 years,

R/o H No.2-1-110,

Tolum Siddique Sha,

Opp Urdu Hall,

Bidar-585 401.                                                                 Respondent

 

18.Review Application No.125/2023

Mr Shankar,
S/o Mr Hanumayya,

Aged about:75 years,

R/o Behind Ganesh Maidan,

PlotNo.91, New Adarsh Colony

Bidar-585 401                                                            Respondent

 

 

 

19.Review Application No.126/2023

Mr Veerabasappa,
S/o Mr Rayangouda Briadar,

Aged about:75 years,

R/o Ganga Agro Sales,

Bhamin Galli,

Chincholli, Gulbarga-585 307                                     Respondent

 

20.Review Application No.153/2023

Mr G.S. Deshmukh
S/o Mr Sango Pandith,

Aged aboutabout 73 years,

R/o No.8-11-110/32 (old) Sangam,

Raghavendra Colony,

Bidar District, Bidar-585 403                                        Respondent

 

: COMMON ORDER :

 

Mr JUSTICE HULUVADI G RAMESH : PRESIDENT

 

 

 

01.     These Review Petitions are filed under Section 50 of Consumer Protection Act 2019, to review the Order dated 31.07.2023 & 24.07.2023 passed in Appeal Nos. 547, 544, 97, 548, 543, 542, 541, 553, 559, 545, 556, 550, 552, 549, 551, 560, 558, 557, 554 and 561/2017 respectively. Since the case of the Petitioners in all these cases and that the Review Petitioner is common in all these cases, besides the grounds, allegations and facts involved in all these cases are also similar, they are taken up together for consideration.

02.     Heard the learned Counsel for the Review Petitioner.   Considering the nature of the case, issuance of the Notice to the Respondents in all the Petitions are dispensed with to avoid further delay and more than anything else, the age of the Petitioners and the vintage of the matters.

03.      The prayer sought in these Review Applications is to modify the Order dated 31.07.2023 & 24.07.2023 passed in Appeal Nos. 547, 544, 97, 548, 543, 542, 541, 553, 559, 545, 556, 550, 552, 549, 551, 560, 558, 557, 554 and 561/2017 respectively, arising out of the Order dated 07.01.2016 & 25.01.2017 passed in Complaint Nos. 97/2015, 94/2015, 22/2014 98/2015, 92/2015, 91/2015, 102/2015, 104/2015, 112/2015, 95/2015, 107/2015, 100/2015, 103/2015, 99/2015, 101/2015, 114/2015, 109/2015, 108/2015, 105/2015 and 115/2015 by the District Forum, Kalburgi.

 

04.        This Commission on 24.07.2023 and 31.07.2013 held that the Impugned Order passed by the District Forum is just and proper, for the reasons recorded therein and that it does not call for any interference.  Hence, we did not find any grounds to review the order dated 31.07.2023 & 24.07.2023 passed by this Commission for the grounds of Review Application under Section 50 of Consumer Protection Act 2019.  If at all, the Appellant/Review Petitioner has already revised the entitled Monthly Pension of the Complainants by giving weightage of two years and also paid the consequential arrears to the Complainants/Respondents herein and if there is no provision for extending of minimum assured benefits, both for past service and present service separately, the same has to be raised before the District Forum in Execution proceedings. 

 

05.   With the forgoing observations, RA No.107 to 116/2023, 118 to 126/2023 and 153/2023 stands disposed off.

 

06.     Keep the Original of this Order in RA No.107/2013 and copy thereof, in rest of the Review Applications.

07.    Send a copy of this Order to the District Commission as well as to the parties concerned, immediately.

 

Lady Member                     Judicial Member                   President

*s