Kerala

Ernakulam

CC/11/184

SHIBIN P.S, - Complainant(s)

Versus

SARITA CINEMA THEATRE - Opp.Party(s)

LAL.K.JOSEPH

29 Oct 2011

ORDER

 
Complaint Case No. CC/11/184
 
1. SHIBIN P.S,
S/O P.M.SALIM, H/NO:48/1834D, PUTHENPURA ROAD, ELAMAKKARA, KOCHI-682026
2. ISHFAQ ISMAIL,
S/O V.H.ISMAIL, H/NO.XI/730, VALIYAVEETIL HOUSE, PATTALAM, KOCHI-682001
3. SHARON M GAFOOR, S/O ABDUL GAFOOR
14/1593, MULAKKAL HOUSE, KARUVELIPADY, KOCHI 682005
4. YOUSUF ASFAQ,
S/O AHAMED THAHAR, VEMBADY HOUSE, 13/976, R.K.PILLAI ROAD COCHIN-682005
5. ABISH P.A,
S/O A.B ABDUL RAHIMAN, 1/2042, Y.M.C.A ROAD,COCHIN-682001
6. HISHAM T.H
S/O T.M.HANEEF, 12/812A, KAPALANDIMUKKU ROAD, COCHIN-682002
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. SARITA CINEMA THEATRE
XI/4208,BANERJEE ROAD, ERNAKULAM NORTH, ERNAKULAM-682018REP. BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR
2. MANAGING DIRECTOR
SARITA CINEMA THEATRE XI/4208, BANERJEE ROAD, ERNAKULAM NORTH, ERNAKULAM-682018
3. MANAGER, SAVITHA THEATRE
SARITA CINEMA THEATRE, XI/4208, BANERJEE ROAD, ERNAKULAM NORTH, ERNAKULAM-682018
4. ISSAC & SONS KP ISSAC
KURITHADAM BUILDING, ST. ALBERTS C OLLEGE ROAD, BANERJEE ROAD ERNAKULAM-6880018
............Opp.Party(s)
 
BEFORE: 
 HONORABLE MR. A.RAJESH PRESIDENT
 HONORABLE MR. PROF:PAUL GOMEZ Member
 HONORABLE MRS. C.K.LEKHAMMA Member
 
PRESENT:
 
ORDER

XNCekgUb pfïe GhsYeÞ= l&Êhjfnej sHeNb cgúexk

2011-eb EÜd ZkdsBey& cemb 29öeb lrQlf

hjelf HQÀ xVî lrQlf : 04ö04ö2011

nep& :

          ^Mr. X. jespTd                :    ^hmf[éd   

          ^Mr. sheÏ siecmd             :    xcú&

          ^Mrclf. mf.xk. suK              :    xcú&

 

mf.mf. vú& : 184/11

1. TfyfÅ hf.Xmd,             :   hjelfÊe&

  XÅpfvrQ&,                   (Ds[A. ueÀ xk spemHd

  hf.Xb. mufb ckÅ,             xTjrHd Ds²emfsQNNdmd

  Jr¿g vb.48/1834[f,              41/318ömf, xke»fQfÀ yfÀ[fÙd

  hgÛÅ hgj sNe[d,                  cgïs«jf kveufvg mcrhb

  XUcÊj, xkeÃfö682 026.         VfNNt& sNe[d, xkeÃfö682 011)

 

2. FTdHekd FmdcQfÀ, yfmfvmd,

  Jf.XÃd FmdcQfÀ ckÅ,

  Jr¿g vbh& Xkdmd1d730,

  JufQJr¿fÀ JrBd, h¿eUb,

  xkeÃfö682 001.

 

3. TesjeÌ Xb KHt&,

  yfmfvmd, DëgÀ KHt& ckÅ,

  14d1593, cgUÊÀ nqmd,

  kjgsJufÓBf, xkeÃfö 682 005.

 

4. QtmHd DmdHek,d

  yfmfvmd, DnÂod ln& ckÅ,

  xJbheBf JrBd, 13/d976,

  E& xk, hfUU sNe[d,

  xkeÃfÅö682 005.

 

5. DyfTd hf.X,

  X.yf. DëgÀ NnfceÅ ckÅ,

  1/2042, xxJ.Xb.mf.X sNe[d.

  xkeÃfÅö682 001.

6. nfTeb.Bf.XÃd,

  Bf.Xb nvrHdd ckÅ,

  1/812 X, kÓuÜfcgÊg sNe[d,

  xkeÃfö682 002.

 

                             Vs

 

1. mjfl mfvfc lfsQNN&            :    Xlf&k#fkÏ

  Xkdmd1/4208, yev&pf sNe[d,            (nepjeQfï)

  XNCekgUb sve&Ûd,

  XNCekgUbö682 018

  xN^h. xxy cesvpfÙd [QNkdB&.  

 

2. cesvpfÙd [QNkdB&.

  mjfl mfvfc lfsQNN&     

  Xkdmd1/4208, yev&pf sNe[d,

  XNCekgUb sve&Ûd,

  XNCekgUbö682 018.

 

3. cesvp&

  mJfl  lfsQNN&,

  mjfl mfvfc lfsQNN&

  Xkdmd1/4208, yev&pf sNe[d,

  XNCekgUb sve&Ûd,

  XNCekgUbö682 018.

 

4. xXmkd Eéd mÌmd,

  xk.hf. xXmkd,

  kgjflBb yfÀ[fbÙd,

  xméd EÀy&¿dmd skesUpd sNe[d,

  yev&pfsNe[d, XNCekgUbö680 018.

 

GÛjJd

sheÏ siecmd, xcú&.

      hjelfÊe&Êd hNQevg» JmdlglkÏ FJQeCd :

     hjelfÊe& JfJfOljbyf²fv²fÀ S&xÓ¿g prJfÊgÎg. ^kfmdl=Å ^yso}dmd XÎ scenÅueÀ Vf^lb keCeÅ DJ& ZeÌ xxuÅ ygÊfbid vBÛf.  Dlfvg» hCb x[yfNdNg ke&[g J}f cgÅktNeQf DBígkQgcgÜeQf.  mfvfc lgBÙgÎlfvg cgúdg DJjgxB BfÊNdNd JeÙgJeÅ xVÎsÓeÏ DJ&Êd vfjeMxÓBgÛgÎ DvgYJceCgÜeQld.  DJxj mfvfc keCeÅ DvgJofÃfï. hfsNNÎg JjeveCd cesvp& DeJM=xÓ¿ld. QgJeÊUgb Z¿gb sceMÊejekeÅ kg¿eÊfQfï. DJ& svxjsheQld sheurmdsNNTvfÀ hjelfQgceQeC.d DlgxkeÜgb DjfMb lrjeùeCd DJ& GhsYeÞ= skeBlfxQ mcfhfÃfjfÊgÎl.d mfvfc BfÊNdNd ygÊg xVîlfvgb lfQNNNfÀ sheQlfvgb sJÜfxVuJeQ hCb lfjfxk kf¿gÎlfxveÓb lxÎ DJjvgYJfà csvesJovíd vñhjfnejb, skeBlfxÃuJd XÎfJQgb hjelfQfÀ DeJM=xÓ¿f¿gÜd.

 

     2. Xlf&k#fÊd DQÃ sve¿rmd xxkÓNNeÅ kt¿eÊfQfï.  DlgxkeÜg lxÎ cNghBf mc&ÓfÃf¿fï. sHeNÛfxu vBhBfksUeBd Xlf&k#fkÏ hgNb lfjfùt  vfÀÊgkQeCgÜeQld.

     3. hejelfÊe& xlUfJgml=JÙdctubmc&ÓÃg. DJjgxB YeiÛd veug^hceCÙÏ X1 cglÀ X4 EQf DBQeUxÓBgÛf. xlUfJfÀ mArkjfÊgkQgÜeQf. Xlf&k#fkxU Xkdmd he&¿fQeQf ^hK=ehfÃg hjelfÊe& mA×b JeoilfkÏ X}glf mc&ÓfÃg.  DJxj skÏÊgkQgb xVîg.

     4. lrjgcevÛfvg JfsOQcesÊÜ ^hMdvÙÏ FJQeCd

     X. hjelfÊexj mfvfc keCeÅ DvgJofÊelfjgÎld vfQchjceQf MjfQeQ ^hJ=ÛfQesCe?

     yf. GÛjb DïxQÎexCØfÀ, hjelfÊe&ÊvgJofÊeJgÎ vfJ=ÛfkÏ Xx×exÊ?

     5. ^hMdvb (X)  Eo=sc hNùgxke»x¿, sHeNÛfÀ hjelf mc&ÓfÊxÓ¿lfxvÛgB&Îd DQà sve¿rmd  xxkÓNNeÅ sheugb JfmÂlfà Xlf&k#fQgxB xhjgceNNb Z}fJesÊÜleQfjgÎg XÎd hNQelfjfÊeÅ JË. sve¿rmd xxkÓNNfQf¿d JjelfjfÊgÎlgb skeBlfQfÀvfÎQÊgÎ DNfQfÓd lfkùvf¼sQexBxxkÓNNeÅ JfmÂlfÊgÎlgb   ZÎgshexu keCeÅ k}fQfï. hqjsyeOcg» E&Êgb lxÎ vfQcJe}dÃxQ cevfÊelfjfÊeÅ k}fQfï.

     Dxl×gcekx¿, lldkeub vcgÊldcNÊeb;  vÂgxB cgbhfug» hjelfQgxB JfMoebMÛfsuÊg Jjeb.  mfvfcxQmdsvnfÊgkQgb scenÅueufxv EjeOfÊgkQgb xVËgÎ ZjgmbIb QgJmgn=ÛgÊUeCd Fq hjelfQgceQf sHeNxÛ mcfhfÃfjfÊgÎld.  scenÅueÀ Vf^lceQ k=mdl=Å ^yso}mdlfQNNNgkUfxuÛf, jÜeb ofJmb lxÎ Vf^lb keCevg» EsJMÛfÀ DJ& ENg BfÊNNgkÏ ygÊgxVîg hglfQ lucgNQfÀxÓ¿JjeQlgxkeÜekeb, hjbhjeil xxMufQfÀvfÎgb J=l=mdlceQf EOgvfk mesØlfk Jfo=QgxB mneQÛfueQfsÊes¿ ygÊf*id XÎd DJ& kjglf. ZeÌ xxuÅ xJydxxmNNfÀ19ö08ö2011Å 8.0 hfd.Xb xé ^ho&MvÛfveQf¿eCd yfÊf*d vBÛfQld ce^lJgcï xX.mf.xX.mf.xX x[yfNdNg ke&[ghsQeifÃd 495 jthcgÅktNeQf DBídkgkQgb xVîg.  FxlexÊ xheUfJVvÙUïexQÎg keCfÊeÅ DJ& BfÊNNgygÊf*d FÅsJeQdmd XÎ ^hceCJgb yØd søNNgxcégb nepjeÊfQf¿gÜd. DJ QLe^kcb ^hceCÙÏ X1Gb, X4Gb EQf sjKxÓBgÛfQJQeCd DJ& mfvfckeCgJeveQf mfvfceMeuQfÀ kesukt¿fÛxÎDsÎ ofJmb sheQfjgÎgxJÎg keCfÊgJeÅ ^hceCb X2 EQf sjKxÓBgÛxÓ¿ ke&he&Êf*d jmfld vÂgxB cgbhfugÜd.  DlfÀ sjKxÓBgÛxÓ¿ mcQb7.45 hf.Xb ECd XÎld ^MÁfÊxÓsBÜ JmdlglQeCd. ygÊfÙd DvgmjfÃg» BfÊNNd svjf¿gJeÙeÅ sJÜfQekeb DJ& svjsÛ lxÎ ÷uxÛÛfQld.

     hs# hfÎrBd mbYJfÃxlexÊ DJxj lfkÃgb vfjeMxÓBgÛgÎ ^hlfkjCÙUeQfjgÎg. BfÊNdNg kqÜ& DBùg kfBÊgÎlgkÜsÓeÏ, Esje vÀkfQ vf&sºMcvgmjfÃd DJ& Y#CMeuQfÀ xVÎvATfÃsÓeÏ DJfxBQg»QeUgkÏ xxkcu&ÛfkQkQfjgÎg. s^keOJgb vfjeMQb vfQ^×fÊeÅ heBgxh¿ E QgJeÊÏ cesvpxj mcrhfÃsÓeÏ DsºnÛfxé ^hlfkjCb lCgÓveQfjgÎg. hfÎrBJ& xnÀhdxxuÅ vbhjeQ 9020484040xQ MjCb ^hehfÃsÓeÏ DsÙÛuídufÀ vfÎgbkf¿fQld cgB×Å v=eQÙÏ ce^lceCd mfvfc keCgJevg» ^Ye×ceQ EsJMÛfÀ DJ& JrÜgb cesvpxj kÜgxJØfugb Qexlejg HuJgcgÜeQfxïÎg ce^lcï, DJ& cgÅkt¿f ygÊfbÙd ZÎgb vBÛfQfs¿QfïxQÎ JUxj JfVf^lceQ vfuheBeCd mArkjfÃld. XÎgce^lJgcï, ygÊgxVîhCb lfjfxk ljfïxQÎ ^hskehvhjceQ vfuheBd mArkjfÊgkQgb xVîg. XjflrQfÀ X±xQe}fÊgÎshexu Dsºnb hNùld hfsNNÎg xVïeveCd DjfMJgb vfjeMQgb htÜ EQgJeÊÏ JUxj cev=ceQgb mbQcvsÛexBQgceCd xhjgceNfQld.  XÎgsJCb DJjgxB hfÎrBg» vBhBfQfÀ vfÎgb DvgcevfÊeÅ. meOejCilfQfÀ ENgsh&sV&Î QgJeÊUgxB mbIb FÛjb m¼&YÛfÀ m=ñfÊeJgÎ veBkrQjbÙÏxÊeÎgb lxÎ vfÀkexl DJ& mceOevhjceQf hfjfùg sheJgkQgbvfQchjceQf lÙÏÊg uY=ceQ Xïe^hlfJfOfkUgb slBgkQgceCgÜeQld.  Flg JUxj MdUeIvrQceQ xhjgceNNcexCÎg hNsQÜfJjgb. DJ& sxvj sheQld sheurmdsmdNNTvfsuÊeCd, DJ& sheurmd smNNTvfÀ mc&Ófà hejelfQgxB hk&Ód vÂgxB cgbhfïgÜd. DleCd ^hceCb X3. DJ& mfvfceMeuQfÀ DveJM=ceQ jbiÙÏ  m=ñfÃfjgÎgxJÙdkfÀ vfcfTÙÏÊkb DBgÛglxÎQg» sheurmd smNNTvfÀ n&pfQgceQf kBÎgxVïeÅ xxOj=xÓBgceQfjgÎfï.

     ^hskehvhjceQ mnVj=ÛfÀ JUxj DÃBÊsÛexB mbQcvb heufÃd cev=ceQ xhjgceNNb ke}dV Jà Zjgkt¿b xVNgÓÊejgxB vrlfÊgsJÜfQg» v=eQJgb cflJgceQ sheje¿ceCd Fq hjelfQfÀ ^hlfHufÊgÎld. ^hLco=ñ=ev=eQceQ DJjgB EJM=sÛeBd DvgYeJht&ÚecesQejg vfuheBg mArkjfÊgÎlfvg hkjb GqlfJr&Óà cfL=YfcevsÛexB_eÅ hfBfà cgQufvd  xkebhg ctÎd XÎ vfuheBeCdEo=b cglsu Xlf& k#fkÏ mArkjfÃld; Dld lfkÃgb vf&Yei=kjcexCÎghNQx¿. hjelfÊe&  nepjeÊfQ xlUgJgkÏ mAQb mbmejfÊgÎJQeCd  mbYJÛfvgd cgúgb hfúgcg» DJjgxB ^hJ&ÛvÙÏ  DJjgxB vfuheBgd MjfQexCÎg DBfJjQfBgÎg. FlfxveÊ ckgBb Ve&ÛeÅ Xlf&k#fQgxB vf²nkjCb clfQeQf. FqJmdlgkxUïb ktBf kt¿fJeQfÊgbsheÏ 19ö03ö2011vXlf&k#flfQNdNNfÀscenÅueÀ Vf^lb keCgÎlfÀ hjelfÊe& hjepQxÓ¿gxJØfugb Ekej=ÛfÀ DJx vfjeMxÓBgÛfQJ&xÊlfxj FqsHeNÛfÀ mc&Ófà hjelfQfÀ DvgktuceQ GÛjJg mbheofÊgÎkej=ÛfÀ E&Êgb lB²b vfÀÊeÅ k}fQfï, ^hslRkfÃgb Xlf&k#fkUgxB DYeJÛfÀ.

     6.^hMdvb(yf) ZÎeb ^hMdvb hjelfÊe&ÊvfktuceQfYJfÃlfxé xJUfÃÛfÀ Fvf vÂgxB cgbhfug» kejRb DJ&ÊvgJofÊeJgÎ vfJ=ÛfkÏ ECd hceCb X4 DvgmjfÃd DJ& Fq EJMRÛfvd 495 hfÅJufÃleQf keCeÅ k}fQgb. ^hceCb X2 ke& he&Êfid jmrleCd DlfÀ vfÎgb DJ& keNfueCd mfvfceMeuQfsuÊg JÎld XÎvgcevfÊeb. Dlfvg» xVuJeQf SksoMb 200 jth kCÊeÊeJgÎleCd DJjgxB mA×b JenvceQfjfÊgb XÎtnfÊgÎg. Zsj h¿CÛfxé JfJfO÷uÙUfÀ lecmfÊgÎ QgJeÊÏ ZjgcfÃd JUxj ^hlr#sQexB mfvfc keCexcÎ scenJgceQf  mfvfceMeuQfÀ XÛgbsheÏ DJxjxQïeb ZÎgshexu vfjeMxÓBgÛgΠ DvgYJceCJ&ÊgÜeQld.  E ogjvgYJÛfugÜeQ cevmfk ^hQemb X^lQe}Ûfug»lexCÎg cv²fueÊeÅ DJ& GBÅlxÎ sheursøTvfÀ mc&Ófà n&pf clfQekgb. DlgxkeÜg DJ&ÊgÜeQ MejrjfkceQgb cevmrkJgceQ ^hQemÙÏÊgb kñheBgkÏÊgb clfQeQ hjfnejb xVËevg» yeÁRl Xlf&k#fkÏÊgÜd. DlgshexulxÎ Fq JRJnejJgb DJxj DBfsÃÀÓfÃlexCÎg hNsQÜfJjgb hjelfÊexj  DvgvQfÓfÃd DJ&ÊgÜeQ  cevmfk ^hQemÛfvd clfQeQ hjfnejb keCevg» mÑv²d Xlf&k#fkÏ keCfÃfjgÎgxJØfÀ Fq GÛjJgdX}gslÜfJjgceQfjgÎfï. DlgxkeÜd. Xlf&k#fkÏ hjelfÊe&Êd JRJnejxÃuJgb vÀskÜleCd.

     VgjgÊÛfÀ Fq hjelf Fvf hNQgÎ JfOb DvgJofÃg ÛjJekgÎg.

    (1)    Xlf&k#fkÏ mbQgÞceQgb xJsÚNQeQgb hjelfÊe&xÊïeceQf 695 jth vÀskÜleCd.

    (2)    Xlf&k#fkÏ mbQgÞceQgb xJsÚNQeQgb hjelfÊe&xÊïeceQf DJjvgYJfà MejrjfkJgb cevmfkJgceQ ^hQemÙÏÊd hjfnejceQf 1,000 jth vÀskÜleCd.

    (3)    Xlf&k#fkÏ mbQgÞceQgb xJsÚNQeQgb hjelfÊe&xÊïeceQf JRJnejxÃuJfvÛfÀ 1,000 jth vÀskÜleCd.

 

       2011-eb EÜd ZkdsBey& cemb 29öeb lrQlfQfÀ sHeNÛfÀ hjm=ceÊxÓ¿ GÛjJd.                                                                 ZÓd 

                                           sheÏ siecmd, xcú&.

GÛjJfÅ ^hkejb,

                                                ZÓd  

mrvfQ& mt^hÜd.                            X. jespTd, ^hmf[éd.

                                                  ZÓd

mf.xk. suKÂ, xcú&.

                                                                                                

                     


 

DvgyÍb

 

hjelfÊejÅ Yeib ^hceCÙÏ   :

1.    X1  ö                  :    BfÊNNd Nfm&sJTÅ

                                    [rxNNQfÀmd

2.    X2  ö                  :    ke& he&Êfid jmrld

3.    X3  ö                  ;    19ö03ö2011 lrQlfxu kÛd

4.    D4  ö                  :    msNNNNgxcéfxé skeÓf

 

 

Xlf&k#f Yeib ^hceCb       :    Fï.

 

 

hjelfÊejÅ Yeib me#f       :   

 

 

 
 
[HONORABLE MR. A.RAJESH]
PRESIDENT
 
[HONORABLE MR. PROF:PAUL GOMEZ]
Member
 
[HONORABLE MRS. C.K.LEKHAMMA]
Member

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.