ftYgk xzkgd rØkj fuokj.k eap] o/kkZ

 rØkj izdj.k Øekad % 66@2008                            nk[ky fnukad          % 28-08-2008

                                                                                    uksVhl rkehyhpk fn-% 25-04-2008

  fudky fnukad         % 25-06-2008

                      izdj.kkpk dkyko/kh  % 2eghus

Jherh yhyk eksguyky Vkojh]                                      ---rØkjdrkZ

O; % 67 o”kZs]

Jk- ^^vkf’kokZn**]fØ”.kk uxj] o/kkZ-

     & fo  #  /n  &

----fo#/ni{k@xSjvtZnkj

1½ jhyka;l baMfLVªt fyfeVsM]

      , jftLVMZ daiuh] frljk ekGk] 2222]

      esdj psacj] ujheu ikbZaV] eqacbZ 400021

      }kjk eWusftax Mk;jsDVj] eqacbZ-

2½  doZs dkWEI;wVj ‘ks;j izk;-fy-]

      doZs gkml] 46] ,OgsU;w 4] LVªhV 1]

      catkjk fgy] gSnzkckn]vka/kz izns’k

      }kjk tujy eWustj] gSnzkckn ¼vka/kz izns’k½-

U;k;eap x.kiqrhZ                         %                  Jh- jkeyky Hk-lksek.kh] ek-v/;{k

                                                            lkS- lq”kek  iz- tks’kh] ek-lnL;k

                                                            Jh- v#.k dqyd.khZ] ek- lnL;-

vtZnkj ;kaps rQsZ                 %      vWM- Jh- ,l-,-flDdk-

fo#/n Ik{k Ø- 1 rQsZ             %      xSjgtj-

fo#/n Ik{k Ø- 2 rQsZ             %      xSjgtj-

                                                         %%%   vk  ns   ‘k   %%%

                                           ¼ ikjhr fnukad % 25-06-2008½

Jh- v#.k dqyd.khZ] ek- lnL;] ;kaps dFkukuqlkj-

1-                vtZnkj T;s”B eghyk xzkgdkauh lnj rØkj ‘ks;j daiuhfo#/n dsysyh vlwu vtZnkjkaps LoxZoklh irhus izFker% Lor% o vtZnkj iRuhP;k ukokus [kjsnh dsysys ‘ks;lZ vtZnkjkP;k ukokoj gLrkarjhr u dsY;kcn~ny o R;kiksVh mn~HkoysY;k uqdlkukcn~ny xSjvtZnkjkfo#/n nks”kiw.kZ lsok fnY;kcn~ny dsysyhs vkgs o ekx.kh dsyh vkgs dh]

¼1½            xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 o 2 g;kauh ‘ks;lZ Ø- 259397719 & 259397732 ,dw.k 14 ‘ks;lZ] ‘ks;lZ Ø- 331665899&899 ,d ‘ks;j o ‘ks;lZ Ø-331685901&901 ,d ‘ks;j vls ,dw.k 16 ‘ks;lZ o R;kojhy 16 cksul ‘ks;lZ vtZnkjkP;k ukokus gLrkarjhr djkos-

¼2½            xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 o 2 g;kauh ojhy gLrkarjhr u >kysY;k ‘ks;lZoj o”kZ 1998 rs 2006 ikosrks fMOghMaM |kok-

¼3½            vtZnkjkl tks ekufld =kl >kyk R;kcn~ny xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 o 2g;kauh #-10]000@& vtZnkjkl |kos-

¼4½            xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 o 2 gs tj vtZnkjkph ojhy ekx.kh iw.kZ d# ‘kdr ulrhy rj 32 ‘ks;lZph fdaer #-64]000@&] #-5]000@& fMOghMaMiksVh] #-10]000@& ekufld =klkiksVh vls ,dw.k #-79]000@& vtZnkjkl |kos-

¼5½      lnj rØkjhpk [kpZ #-3]000@& xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 o 2 g;kauh  vtZnkjkl |kok-

¼6½      ek- eapkl ;ksX; okVsy rks ekscnyk vtZnkjkl ns.;kr ;kok-

            ojhy ekx.khuqlkj vtZnkjkph rØkj FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks---------

2-                g;kr vlrkauk vtZnkjkP;k irhus xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 ps 50 ‘ks;lZ #-179-50 izrh ‘ks;j ;k njkus egs’k Qk;ukaf’k;y lfOgZl] iqyxko g;kaP;k e/;LFkhus #-8]975@& nsmu Lor%P;k o vtZnkj iRuhP;k ukokoj ?ksrys- vtZnkjkus fodr ?ksrysys ‘ks;lZph ekydh iwohZ [kkyhy O;DrhaP;k ukokus gksrh-

¼1½     pank pOgk.k && 18 ‘ks;lZ

¼2½     pank pOgk.k vkf.k eukstdqekj pOgk.k && 7 ‘ks;lZ

¼3½            eukstdqekj pOgk.k vkf.k g”kZdqekj pOgk.k  && 25 ‘ks;lZ

            ;kosGhs vtZnkjkP;k irhus loZ ‘ks;lZ vkiY;k o iRuhP;k ukokus gLrkarjhr gks.;kdjhrk xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 dMs ‘ks;lZ VªkalQj QkWeZ] fMyhOgjh eseks] ‘ks;lZP;k eqG izrh fn-26-12-1997 jksth egs’k Qk;ukaf’k;y lfOgZl] iqyxko g;kaP;k ekQZr ikBfoys vkf.k R;k xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 g;kauh fn-05-01-1998 jksth izkIr >kY;kps fun’kZukl ;srs- vtZnkjkP;k irhP;k lqpusuqlkj xSjvtZnkjkus 34 ‘ks;lZ vtZnkjkP;k ukos gLrkarjhr d#u vtZnkjkP;k irhl fn-11-01-1999 jksth ijr ikBfoys- ijarw moZfjr 16 ‘ks;lZ vktikosrks xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 o 2 us vtZnkjkP;k ukokoj gLrkarjhr dsys ukgh- fn-10-03-2006 jksth xSjvtZnkj Ø- 2 g;kauh vtZnkjkl gLrkarj.kkph ikorh] fMyhOgjh pkyku] iksfylkr fnysyh rØkj bR;knh xks”Vh nk[ky dj.;kl lkafxrys- ;sFks uewn dj.ks vko’;d vkgs dh] vtZnkjkps ‘k;lZ d/khgh gjfoys ukgh fdaok pqdhus nqljhdMs BsoY;k xsys ukgh rsOgk ojhy xks”Vh ikBfo.;kpk iz’up mn~Hkor ukgh- fn-05-05-2006 jksths vkf.k fn-04-01-2007 jksth xSjvtZnkj Ø- 2 us vtZnkjkl MÓqIyhdsV ‘ks;lZ ns.;kdjhrk ojhy xks”Vh ekx.;kl ijr Ik= ikBfoys tsOgk dh] xSjvtZnkj  Ø- 1 dMs eqG ‘ks;lZ vkgsr- ojhy 16 ‘ks;lZ vtZnkjkP;k ukokoj gLrkarjhr >kys vlrs rj vtZnkjkl 16 cksul ‘ks;lZ o fMOghMaM xSjvtZnkjkdMwu izkIr >kys vlrs- xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 o 2 P;k nks”kiw.kZ lsoseqGs vtZnkjkps vkfFkZd uqdlku >kys vkgs o vtZnkjkl ‘kkfjfjd o ekufld =kl ns[khy >kysyk vkgs- iqjkO;knk[ky vtZnkjkus ‘kiFki=klg ys[kh ;qDrhokn vls ,dw.k 21 nLrkost nk[ky dsys vkgs-

3-                 rØkjdR;kZP;k fouarho#u R;kus eapkl fnysY;k xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 P;k ufou iR;kojgh uksVhl ikBfo.;kr vkyh- xSjvtZnkj Ø- 2 g;kauk uksVhl ctkowugh R;kauh ys[kh mRrj nk[ky dsys ukgh fdaok lacaf/kr dkxni=s o ;qDrhokn nk[ky dsys ukghr- okjaokj la/kh feGwugh xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 o 2 g;kauh rØkjhph n[ky ?ksryh ukgh- rsOgk ;k U;k; eapkus lnj rØkj izdj.k ,drQhZ pkyfo.;kpk fu.kZ; ?ksryk- 

dkj.ks o fu”d”kZ

4-            vtZnkjkus nk[ky dsysyk ;qDrhokn okpyk- R;kauh nk[ky dsysY;k dkxni=kaps ckjdkbZus] l[kksy] dkGthiwoZd voyksdu dsys vlrk vls fun’kZukl ;srs dh] vtZnkjkaP;k LoxZoklh irhus xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 ps 50 ‘ks;lZ egs’k Qk;ukaf’k;y lfOgZl] iqyxko g;kaP;kekQZr fodr ?ksrys- lnj ‘ks;lZ #-179-50 izrh ‘ks;j ;k njkus ,dw.k #-8]975@& nsmu Lor% o R;kaP;k iRuhP;k ukokoj ?ksrys- ‘ks;lZ fodr ?ks.;kiwohZ ‘ks;lZps ekydh [kkyhyizek.ks gksrh-

¼1½     pank pOgk.k && 18 ‘ks;lZ

¼2½     pank pOgk.k vkf.k eukstdqekj pOgk.k && 7 ‘ks;lZ

¼3½            eukstdqekj pOgk.k vkf.k g”kZdqekj pOgk.k  && 25 ‘ks;lZ

            vtZnkj o frP;k irhP;k ukos ‘ks;lZ gLrkarjhr dj.;kdjhrk o ukokr QsjQkj dj.;kdjhrk vtZnkjkP;k irhus fn-26-12-1998 jksth VªkalQj QkWeZ] fMyhOgjh eseks] ‘ks;lZP;k eqG izrh xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 g;kauk ikBfoys- fn-05-01-1998 jksth xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 g;kauk rs izkIr >kys-  xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 us 11-01-1999 jksth 34 ‘ks;lZ gLrkarjhr d#u ukokr QsjQkj d#u vtZnkjkP;k irhP;k ukokus ikBfoys- ijarw 16 ‘ks;lZ vktikosrks xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 P;k rkC;kr vkgsr o vtZnkjkP;k ukos gLrkarjhr gks.ks ckdh vkgs- toGikl lkMs vkB o”kkZpk dkyko/kh yksVY;kojgh xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 us ukokr QsjQkj d#u moZfjr 16 ‘ks;lZ vtZnkj o frP;k irhP;k ukokus gLrkarjhr dsys ukgh- gh nks”kiw.kZ lsok fnY;kps fun’kZukl ;srs- rlsp vuqfpr O;kikj izFkspk voyac dsY;kps fun’kZukl ;srs-

4-                 xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 ghs vRa;r ukoktysyh daiuh vlwu R;kauh xaqro.kqdnkjkauk osGksosGh fMOghMaM o cksul ‘ks;lZ fnysys vkgs- rsOgk vtZnkjkaps cksul ‘ks;lZ ekx.ks o R;kojhy fMOghMaM ekx.ks gs jkLr okVrs- lnj izdj.kkr xSjvtZnkj Ø- 2 g;kaP;k cjkscj dkgh vkfFkZd O;ogkj >kysys ukgh- djhrk xSjvtZnkj Ø- 2 g;kaP;kfo#/n dsysyh ekx.kh gs eap vekU; djhr vkgs- dkj.k R;kP;kcjkscj dkghgh vkfFkZd O;ogkj >kysyk ukgh- rlsp xSjvtZnkj Ø- 2 gs xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 ps ,taV vlY;kps fun’kZukl ;srs rsOgk xSjvtZnkj Ø- 2;kaphns[khy tckcnkjh xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 oj ;srs- vtZnkjkus nk[ky dsysys fuokMs gs lnj izdj.kh ykxw gksrkr vkf.k rs [kkyhyizek.ks vkgsr-

Castrol India Ltd. Vs. Mahesh Takhtani “2007 (3) CPR 357 (NC)

CPA,1986-Sec.21(b) & 2(1)(g), 2(1) (r) – complaint about deficiency in share service-Controversy about issue/nonissue of 20 Rights Share to the Original holder who had sold the original to the complainant-complainant having lost-Stay order obtained from Court-Company acknowledge in letters dtd.12.2.1988 and 20.11.1992, still rights exercised was given to original allottee (seller) State Commission holding it deficiency in service as well as unfair trade practice as despite stay order the Company insisted the complainant to obtain no objection from original share holder-Revision against-National Commission sought affidavit-Company gave a non-convincing affidavit-whether appellate order of state Commission suffers from any material irregularity ? (No)- Revision dismissed.

IMPORTANT POINT :- Sending rights share to the original shareholder who had sold to the complainant, against whom stay was obtained and sent to the company is a deficiency in service of the company.

Reliance Industries Ltd. Vs. K.V.Mahalingam, 2006 (2) CPR 385 (Tamilnadu State Commission, Chennai)

CPA,1986-Sections 14(1)(d) and 15-Deficiency in allotment of 100 shares of Reliance Co.-Claim of compensation at 30,000/- D.F.awarded Rs.25,000/- Appeal-Whether complainant is entitled to reasonable compensation?(yes)-What is reasonable in this case? (Rs.20,000/-)-Appeal partly allowed.

IMPORTANT POINT :- Reasonable compensation for late allotment of 100 shares in Reliance Industries in Rs.20,000/- as against claim of Rs.30,000/- and award of 25,000/- by D.F.

Lknj izdj.kh xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 g;kauh vtZnkjkl nks”kiw.kZ lsok nsmu vuqfpr O;kikj izFkspk voyac dsY;kps fun’kZukl ;srs- djhrk eap [kkyhyizek.ks ,drQhZ vkns’k ikfjr djhr vkgs-

vkns’k

1½            vtZnkjkph rØkj va’kr% eatwj dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-

2&v½            xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 g;kauh vtZnkjkyk gLrkarjhr u >kysYks 16 ‘ks;lZ] R;koj o”kZ 1998 iklwu rØkj nk[ky djsi;Zar xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 us fuxZfer dsysys cksul ‘ks;lZ vtZnkjkP;k ukokoj uksanfo.;kr ;kos o fnys xsysys loZ fMOghMaM 9 VDds O;ktklg o brj loZ ykHk gLrkarjhr d#u n;kos-

vFkok

2&c½            vtZnkjkyk gLrkarjhr u >kysys 16 ‘ks;lZ o R;kojhy lu 1998 iklwu ns.;kr vkysY;k cksul ‘ks;lZph ¼rØkj nk[ky fnukad½fn-28-08-2008 jksthph fdaer o ;k rkj[ksi;Zarps loZ fMOghMaM o brj ykHk vtZnkjkyk laiw.kZ jDde pqdrh gksbZi;Zar n-lk-n-‘ks-9 VDds O;kt njklg xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 us ns; djkoh-

3½            ‘kkjhjhd o ekufld =klkiksVh xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 g;kauh vtZnkjkl #-5]000@& o rØkjhpk [kpZ #-1]000@& |kok-

4½        ojhy vkns’kkps ikyu  xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 g;kauh vkns’kkph izr feGkY;kiklwu 30 fnolkP;k vkr djkos vU;Fkk vkns’khr laiw.kZ jDde n-lk-n-‘ks-15 VDds O;kt njklg vtZnkjkl ns; jkghy- xSjvtZnkj Ø- 2 g;kauh lnj vkns’kkP;k vaeyctko.khdjhrk xSjvtZnkj Ø- 1 g;kauk enr djkoh-

5½        mHk; Ik{kkauk vkns’kkph lgh f’kDD;kph izekf.kr izr fu%’kqYd ns.;kr ;koh- nksUgh xSjvtZnkj gs eapkr vuqifLFkr vlY;kus R;kauk vkns’kkph izr iksLVk}kjs ikBfo.;kr ;koh-

6½            eapke/;s ek- lnL;kadjhrk fnysys ¼c½ o ¼d½ QkbZYlP;k izrh rØkdR;kZauh  ?ksowu tkO;kr-

¼lkS-lq”kek tks’kh½            ¼MkW- v#.k dqyd.khZ½                ¼jkeyky lksek.kh½

                 lnL;k                                  lnL;                               v/;{k