Complaint Case No. CC/80/2013 | ( Date of Filing : 18 Nov 2013 ) |
| | 1. Surendra Mohan Padhi & others | At-Qtrs. No. B/655,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | Angul | 2. Sri Bijay Ku.Sahoo | At/P.O.Kandasar,P.S.Nalco Nagar,S.D/Dist.Angul. | 3. Sri Girija Shankar Panda | At-Qtrs. No. C/224,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul | 4. Sri Susant Ku.Mishra | At-Qtrs. No. B/2124,Nalco Nagar,Township, P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 5. Sri Purna Ch.Sundi | At-Qtrs. No. B/1161,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 6. Sri Janak Ku.Samal | At-Qtrs. No. B/1230,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 7. Smt.Bidulata Biswal | At-Qtrs. No. B/1230,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 8. Sri Joginath Mudali | At-Muduli Sai,Kandasar,P.O/P.S.Nalco Nagar,S.D/Dist.Angul | 9. Sri Bidyadhar Nahak | At-Qtrs. No. B/1163,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 10. Sri Purna Ch,Behera | At-Qtrs. No. B/531,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 11. Sri Mangala Hembram | At-Qtrs. No. B/531,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 12. Sri Shamu Munda | At-Qtrs. No. BH-2 Study Room,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul | 13. Sri Lingaraj Behera | At-Qtrs. No. B/471,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 14. Sri Rajendra Narayan Sahoo | At-Qtrs. No. TC/19,Nalco Nagar,Township, P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.-Angul. | 15. Sri C.R.B.Singh | At-Qtrs. No. B/1566,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 16. Sri Rajendra Kumar Nayak | At-Balramprasa ,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 17. Sri Bijan Kumar Dalbehera | At/P.O.Kulad,P.S.-Nalco Nagar, S.D/Dist.-Angul | 18. Sri Basant Kumar Behera | At-Qtrs. No. TB/28,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 19. Sri Prasant Kumar Biswal | At-Qtrs. No. B/693,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:-Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 20. Sri Shruti Rajan Behera | At- New GET Hostel Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 21. Dr.(Smt) Susama Behera | At- New GET Hostel Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 22. Sri Abhya Ku.Naik | At-Qtrs. No. B/323,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 23. Sri Arup Ku.Naik | At-Qtrs. No. B/323,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 24. Smt.R.Dei | At-Qtrs. No. B/323,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 25. Smt.Manjushree | At-Qtrs. No. B/666,Nalco Nagar,Township,P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.Angul. | 26. Sri Debananda Khadiratna | At-Qtrs. No. C/316, Nalco Nagar Township, P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.-Angul. | Angul | 27. Smt. Basanti Khadiratna | At-Qtrs. No. C/316, Nalco Nagar Township, P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.-Angul. | Angul | 28. Sri Prafulla Ch.Mallick | At-Qtrs. No. B/1181,Nalco Nagar Township,P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.-Angul. | 29. Minati Das | At/P.O-52,Budhanagar,Bhubaneswar,P.O/P.S/SD/Dist.-Bhubaneswar. | Khordha | 30. Smt.Tursi Tudu | At-Qtrs. No. B/2128,Nalco Nagar Township, P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar,S.D./Dist.-Angul. | 31. Sri Gatish Ku,Sahoo | At/P.O/P.S- NTPC ,Kaniha,SD/Dist.-Angul. | 32. Smt. Rukhmani Kosaria | At-Qtrs. No. C/203,Nalco Nagar Township, P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar, S.D./Dist.-Angul. | 33. Sri G.C.Kosaria | At-Qtrs. No. C/203,Nalco Nagar Township, P.O/P.S:- Nalco Nagar, S.D./Dist.-Angul. | 34. Sudarsan Sahu | AT/P.O-NTPC, Kaniha, Dist.-Angul. |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
Versus | 1. REJOICE LIVING & TRADING Pvt. Ltd | Registered Offfice:- 59/936,Mukut Nagar, Raipur- 492001 (Chhatisgarh), Represented through its Managing Director Mr. Sarad Ch,Sharma, S/O.Sri Ripudama Sharma, At present residing at-House No.316,Kargil Chowk, Sundar Nagar, Raipur-492103.P.O.Sundarnagar,P.S.Purani Basti,Thona, Aminpara,Raipur-49200 |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
|
|
Final Order / Judgement | Sri S.K.Sahoo, President. This is a joint complaint filed by a group of complainants U/s. 12 of C.P.Act,1986. 2. The case of the complainants is that they are residing under the jurisdiction of this Forum i.e. Nalco Nagar, Angul. The opp. party and his senior members used to come to Nalco Nagar on various occasions for development of scheme offering overseas tour package in low cost. To induct new members and the development scheme, the opp. party had arranged a meeting at Hotel Swagat situated at Nalco Nagar in the month of Septem,ber,2010 All the complainants attended the said meeting . As per the scheme of the opp. party, if any body will become a member by paying Rs.9,000.00 towards registration fee he or she will be a qualified member and thereafter he/she will only have to pay Rs.15,000.00 more for availing six days and five nights foreign tour to Thailand via Kolkata with free fooding and lodging during the tour. After thorough study of the scheme and being circulated by the opp. party, the complainants paid Rs.9,000.00 each through money transfer from SBI, Kandasar branch and ICICI Bank Ltd. Angul branch to the account of the opp. Party and became a member of the opp. party. After receipt of the said amount from the complainants the opp. party has issued computerised receipts in token of membership. It was also provided in the scheme that after becoming a member, of the said member can sponsor four members and thereafter he /she will be treated a qualified member and not required to pay the amount of Rs.15,000.00 .A qualified member is to be entitled to get the tour package within one year from becoming qualified member. Some of the complainants sponsored new members to get that benefits. For the first time in the month of May, 2012 the opp. party had given tour package of five days and four nights to ten members instead of six days and five nights as promised in the scheme. The complainants raised complaint and claimed for the tour package, for which the opp. party promised to give tour package for twenty-five members in between 28.10.2012 to 03.11.2012.The opp. party also forced the complainants to deposit the differential amount of Rs.21,000.00 for non-qualified members and Rs.6,000.00 for qualified members by deviating the terms and conditions of the scheme. The opp. party has adopted unfair trade practice in doing so. The complainants being eager for a foreign tour have paid the extra amount of Rs.6,000.00 each as per the demand of the opp. party keeping faith on the promise made by the opp. party. The opp. party never acted upon on his promise. Hence the complaint, 3. Notice was issued to the opp. party in his office address and also in his present address through Regd. post with A.D on 27.11.2013 . Both the letters returned to this Forum without service. So the complaints were directed to give a paper publication in local daily news paper of Raipur and accordingly there was paper publication in Hindi Navabharat , in which the opp. party was directed to appear before this Forum on 20.03.2014 at 10.30A.M. Inspite of such notice published in the news paper the opp. party did not turn up. Hence he was set exparte vide order dtd. 20.03.2014. 4. It is the specific case of the complainants that the opp. party persuaded them to join in a scheme for foreign tour to Thailand and arranged a meeting in Hotel Swagat in the month of September 2010 at Angul. It is also the case of the complainants that they have attended the said meeting and deposited an amount of Rs.9,000.00 each for the said tour. They have filed the photo copy of the electronic receipts which shows as follows:- Sl.No. | Complainant Name | Amount Deposit | Date of Deposit | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 01 | Surendra Mohan Padhi | 9000 | 29.01.2012 | 02 | Bijay Kumar Sahu | 9000 | 07.06.2011 | 03 | Girija Shankar Panda | 9000 | 07.06.2011 | 04 | Sukanta Kumar Mishra | 9000 | 30.09.2011 | 05 | Purna Chandra Sundhi | 9000 | 28.09.2011 | 06 | Janak Biswal | 9000 | 07.06.2011 | 07 | Bidulata Biswal | 9000 | 17.09.2011 | 08 | Joginath Muduli | 9000 | 28.09.2011 | 09 | Bidyadhar Nahak | 9000 | 30.09.2011 | 10 | Purna Chandra behera | 9000 | 30.09.2011 | 11 | Mangla Hembram | 9000 | 11.01.2012 | 12 | Shamu Munda | 9000 | 31.01.2012 | 13 | Lingaraj Behera | 9000 | 31.01.2012 | 14 | Rajendra Narayan Sahoo | 9000 | 04.01.2012 | 15 | Chitta Ranjan Bikram Singh | 9000 | 14.09..2011 | 16 | Rajendra Kumar Nayak | 9000 | 29.07.2011 | 17 | Bijan Kumar Dalabehera | 9000 | 31.01.2012 | 18 | Basanta Kumar Behera | 9000 | 31.01.2012 | 19 | Susama Behera | 9000 | 31.12.2011 | 20 | Abhaya Kumar Naik | 9000 | 27.01.2012 | 21 | Arup Kumar Naik | 9000 | 31.01.2012 | 22 | Manjushree Nayak | 9000 | 27.01.2012 | 23 | Debananda Khadiratna | 9000 | 30.09.2011 | 24 | Praful Chandra Mallick | 9000 | 17.09.2011 | 25 | Akhaya Kumar Das | 9000 | 29.01.2012 | 26 | Tursi Tudu | 9000 | 30.09.2011 | 27 | Rukhmani Kosaria | 9000 | 30.09.2011 | 28 | Santram Ghasiram Kosaria | 9000 | 09.04.2011 | 29 | Sudarsan Sahoo | 9000 | 28.12.2011 |
The complaint petition was verified by the complainants and supported with affidavit of one Surendra Mohan Padhi i.e complainant No.1.The fact of deposit of Rs.9,000.00 by each of the complainant shown in the table as supported by the copy of invoice obtained from the computer. From the materials on record it is clear that the complainants named in the table have deposited Rs.9,000.00 each on the dates mentioned in Column No. 4(Four) The opp. party had promised to give the tour package to the complainants but did not provide the same It amounts to deficiency in service and adoption of unfair trade practice. Hence the complainants shown in the table are entitled for the return of the amount deposited by them along with interest. The false promise by the opp. party also caused mental agony to the complainants and they are forced to come for the litigation which continue from 2013 to till today. So the complainants are also entitled to compensation for mental agony and entitled for litigation expenses. 5. Hence ordered :- : O R D E R : The case be and the same is allowed exparte against opp. Party. The opp. party is directed to return the amount deposited by the complainants shown in Column No.2 along with interest @ 9% per annum from the date of deposits until it is actually paid . The opp. party are further directed to pay each of the complainants an amount of Rs.3,000.00 (Rupees Three Thousand) only towards compensation for unfair trade practice and mental agony. The opp. party is also directed to pay Rs.3,000.00 (Rupees Three Thousand ) only towards cost of litigation to the complainants. | |