NCDRC

NCDRC

FA/1818/2017

M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR. - Complainant(s)

Versus

REENA BHARGAVA & 5 ORS. - Opp.Party(s)

MS. ARCHANA PATHAK DAVE

26 Apr 2018

ORDER

NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION
NEW DELHI
 
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1714 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 77/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERST WHILE PARTNER.C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR
2. ARUN BANSAL
S/O. LATE SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. G-2, PARK VIWE SCHEME, 8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PVT. LTD.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO. 22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04
4. SHRI. PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDERLASHKARI. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR. 281, GOVIND NAGAR (EAST), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. AJAY TYAGI & 5 ORS.
S/O. SHRI. S.K. TYAGI. 306 HATSHAL VILLAGE, UTTAM NAGAR.
NEW DELHI
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991
3. .
.
.
4. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S./O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
5. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN, PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR UN NABI KHAN. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
6. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
7. AMAY HOME SERVICES LTD.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR ROHIT SURI AT PRESENT IN CENTRAL JAIL/JAIL SUPERINTENDENT, CENTRAL JAIL, GHAT GATE JAIPUR. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1814 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 78/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8017/2018(Placing Record),IA/15636/2017(Stay),IA/15637/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH IERSWHILE PAETNER. C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR.
2. ARUN BANSAL.
S/O. LATE SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, 8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-04.
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04
4. shri. pawan lashkari.
S/O. SHRI SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR(EAST), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. MANJU KALANI & 5 ORS.
W/O. BRIJ MOHAN SHARMA. R/O. C-101, TRIMURTY APARTMENT, TRIMURTY MARG, MALVIYA NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
RAJASTHAN
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS..
S/O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR UN NABI KHAN. R/O. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICES LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, ROHIT SURI AT PRESENT IN CENTRAL JAIL. R/O. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1815 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 80/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8018/2018(Placing Record),IA/15638/2017(Stay),IA/15639/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER. C-24,BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR.
2. ARUN BANSAL.
S/O. LATE SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, 8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHN VILLA APARTMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04
4. SHRI. PWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. ITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR (EAST), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. AMIT BANSAL & 5 ORS.
S/O. SHRI. G.K. BANSL. R/O. 131, CENTRAL SCHOOL SCHEME, AIR FORCE.
JODHPUR
RAJASTHAN.
2. HDFC LTD.
OTHROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991.
3. SHANKAR M.JETHANI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR UN NABI KHAN. R/O. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICES LIMITED.
THROUGHITS DIRECTOR, ROHIT SURI AT PRESENT IN CENTRAL JAIL. R/O. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1816 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 81/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8019/2018(Placing Record),IA/15640/2017(Stay),IA/15641/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER, REGD. OFFICE : C- 24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME, JAIPUR
2. ARUN BANSAL S/O. LATE SHRI R.N. BANSAL R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME,
8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD, JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, REGD. OFFICE: SHOP NO. 22-23, THIRD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO. 4, SODALA, JAIPUR04
4. SHRI PAWAN LASHKARI S/O. SHRI SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI
R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY, JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL
S/O. SHRI RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR (EAST), AJMER ROAD, JAIPUR-04
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. ANURAG BHARGAVA & 5 ORS.
S/O. SHRI PRAMOD BHARGAVA, R/O. C-32, PEEYUUS PATH, BAPUAGAR JAIPUR, RAJASTHAN
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER, O-19-A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME, JAIPUR-302991
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI
PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS S/O. SHRI M.R. JETHANI R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES, JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN
PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS S/O. SHRI NISAR NABI KHAN R/O. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR, JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI,
PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI, R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR, JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICE LIMITED
F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR, JAIPUR
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1817 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 84/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8020/2018(Placing Record),IA/15642/2017(Stay),IA/15643/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER. C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR
2. ARUN BANSAL.
S/O. LATE. SHRI. R.N. BANSAL.R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, 8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DIPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04
4. SHRI PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR (EAST), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. PALLAV JAIN & 5 ORS.
S/O. ASHOK JAIN. R/O. 113, SUNCITY ROORKEE ROAD.
MEERUT.
U.P.
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991.
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, PARTNER, M/S.GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. JETHANI M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06.
4. MERAJ UN NA BI KHAN, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR UN NABI KHAN. R/O. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O.. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A*-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICES LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, ROHIT SURI AT PRESENT IN CENTRAL JAIL. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG , RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1818 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 87/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8021/2018(Placing Record),IA/15644/2017(Stay),IA/15645/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER.C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR.
2. ARUN BANSAL.
S/O. LATE SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME,8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04.
4. SHRI. PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR(EAST),AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. REENA BHARGAVA & 5 ORS.
W/O. SHRI. ANANT BHARGAVA. R/O. G-1, PRADISE APARTMENT, D-148, DURGA MARG, BANI PARK.
JAIPUR.
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991.
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, PARTNER,M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN, PARTNER, /S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR UN NABI KHAN. R/O. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VASHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICES LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, ROHIT SURI. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1819 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 91/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8022/2018(Placing Record),IA/15646/2017(Stay),IA/15647/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER. C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR.
2. ARUN BANSAL
S/O. LATE. SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, GANTHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR=21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PVT. LTD.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR.SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04.
4. SHRI PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR(EAST), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. PRIYA SHARMA & 5 ORS.
W/O. SHRI NAVIN SHARMAAGED. R/O. 152/52, SHIPRA PATH, MANSAROVAR.
JAIPUR
RAJASTHAN.
2. HDFC LTD.
OTHROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991.
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN, PART NER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR KHAN. R./O. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS NUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1820 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 92/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8023/2018(Placing Record),IA/15648/2017(Stay),IA/15649/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER, REGD. OFFICE : C- 24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME, JAIPUR
2. ARUN BANSAL S/O. LATE SHRI R.N. BANSAL R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME,
8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD,
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, REGD. OFFICE: SHOP NO. 22-23, THIRD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO. 4, SODALA, JAIPUR04
4. SHRI PAWAN LASHKARI S/O. SHRI SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI
R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY, JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL
S/O. SHRI RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR (EAST), AJMER ROAD,
JAIPUR-04
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. SHWETA AHLUWALIA & 5 ORS.
W/O. SHRI AKASH KHZANCHI R/O. SL 13, INCOME TAX COLONY, TONK ROAD, JAIPUR
RAJASTHAN
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER, O-19-A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME,
JAIPUR-302991
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI
PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS S/O. SHRI M.R. JETHANI R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES,
JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN
PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS S/O. SHRI NISAR NABI KHAN R/O. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR,
JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI,
R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR,
JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICE LIMITED
F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR,
JAIPUR
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1821 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 95/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8024/2018(Placing Record),IA/15650/2017(Stay),IA/15651/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER, REGD. OFFICE : C- 24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME, JAIPUR
2. ARUN BANSAL S/O. LATE SHRI R.N. BANSAL R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME,
8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD, JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PRIVATE LIMITED
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, REGD. OFFICE: SHOP NO. 22-23, THIRD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO. 4, SODALA, JAIPUR04
4. SHRI PAWAN LASHKARI S/O. SHRI SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI
R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY, JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL
S/O. SHRI RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR (EAST), AJMER ROAD, JAIPUR-04
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. GYANENDRA SHARMA & 5 ORS.
S/O. SHRI B.P. SHARMA, R/O. FLAT NO. 101, PLOT NO. 1-7-15/3, VAMSEE KUTEER, KAMLA NAGAR, ECIL POTS
HYDERABAD-500063
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER, O-19-A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME, JAIPUR-302991
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI
PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS S/O. SHRI M.R. JETHANI R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES, JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN
PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS S/O. SHRI NISAR NABI KHAN R/O. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR, JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI,
R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR, JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICE LIMITED
F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR, JAIPUR
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1822 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 97/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8025/2018(Placing Record),IA/15652/2017(Stay),IA/15653/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER. C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR.
2. ARUN BANSAL
S/O. LATE. SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, GANTHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLAAPARTMENTS PVT. LTD.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR.SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04.
4. SHRI. PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR(EAST), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. SHWETA GOYAL & 5 ORS.
D/O. SHRI. S.S. GOYAL. R/O. A-115, SUBHASH NAGAR, SHOPPING CENTRE.
JAIPUR
RAJASTHAN.
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991.
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR KHAN. R./O. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICES LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, ROHIT SURI AT PRESENT IN CENTRAL JAIL. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1880 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 76/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8026/2018(Placing Record),IA/15654/2017(Stay),IA/15655/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ESTWHILE PARTNER. C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR.
2. ARUN BANSAL
S/O. LATE SHRI R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, 8GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PVT. LTD.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL,NEAR DISPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04.
4. .
.
.
.
5. SHRI . PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
6. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR(E), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. CHETAN BHALLA & 5 ORS.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR BHALLA. 94/53, GOKHLKE MARG, MANSROVAR.
JAIPUR
RAJASTHAN.
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS..
S/O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR UN NABI KHAN. R.O. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICES LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1881 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 85/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8027/2018(Placing Record),IA/15656/2017(Stay),IA/15657/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER. C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR.
2. ARUN BANSAL.
S/O. LATE R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, 8 GANDHI PATH,QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENT PRIVATE LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04.
4. SHRI. PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL.E/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR(EAST), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. GAURAV SHARMA & 5 ORS.
S/O. SHRI. R.C. SHARMAAGED. R/O. 289, VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
RAJASTHAN.
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991.
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/P. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD,CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN, PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR UN NABI KHAN. R/I. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG,VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICES LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, ROHIT SURI AT PRESENT IN CENTRAL JAIL. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1882 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 89/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8028/2018(Placing Record),IA/15658/2017(Stay),IA/15659/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER. C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR.
2. ARUN BANSL.
S/O. LATE SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, 8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. SHRI. PAWAN LASKARI.
S/O. SHI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
4. JITENDER AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR(EAST)\, AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. RAVI BHATIA & 5 ORS.
S/O. SHRI. CHANER PRAKASH BHATIA . R/O. MOHALLA DARU KUTTA STREET NO.-11.
ALWAR.
RAJASTHAN
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS..
S/O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1883 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 90/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8029/2018(Placing Record),IA/15660/2017(Stay),IA/15661/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER. C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR
2. ARUN BANSAL.
S/O. LATE. SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, 8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. SHRI. PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-02
4. JITENDER AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR (EAST)AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. ANANT GUPTA & 5 ORS.
S/O. SHRI. JAGAN PRASAD GUPTA. R/O. 23/50, GANDHI MARG MANSAROVAR.
JODHPUR.
RAJASTHAN.
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUG MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991
3. SHANKAR M. JATHANI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1884 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 93/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8030/2018(Placing Record),IA/15662/2017(Stay),IA/15663/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER.C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR
2. ARUN BANSAL.
S/O. LTE. SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, 8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PVT. LTD.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04
4. SHRI. PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR(E), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. MOHIT BANSAL & 5 ORS.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DISPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04
2. .
.
.
3. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991.
4. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD,CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
5. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN, PARTNERS, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR UN NABI KHAN. R/I. S-1, K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
6. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER, M/S/ GOLD FRAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG,VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
7. AMAY HOME SERVICES LIMITES.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, ROHIT SURI AT PRESENT IN CENTRAL JAIL. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1891 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 88/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8031/2018(Placing Record),IA/15664/2017(Stay),IA/15665/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER. C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR.
2. ARUN BANSAL.
S/O. LATE SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, 8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PVT. LTD.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DSPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04
4. SHRI PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR(E), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. SANDEEP SACHDEVA & 5 ORS.
S/O. SHRI. S.P. SACHDEVA. R/O. H.NO.30, KALKAJI,NEAR DESHBANDHU COLLEGE.
NEW DELHI-11001929/052
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991
3. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
4. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR UN NABI KHAN. R/O. D-1,K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
5. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
6. AMAY HOME SERVICES LTD.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, ROHIT SURI.AT PRESENT IN CENTRAL JAIL. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
...........Respondent(s)
FIRST APPEAL NO. 1897 OF 2017
 
(Against the Order dated 10/05/2017 in Complaint No. 94/2010 of the State Commission Rajasthan)
WITH
IA/8032/2018(Placing Record),IA/15666/2017(Stay),IA/15667/2017(Condonation of delay)
1. M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS & DEVELOPERS & ANR.
THROUGH ERSTWHILE PARTNER. C-24, BHAGWAN DAS ROAD,C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR.
2. ARUN BHANSAL
S/O. LATE SHRI. R.N. BANSAL. R/O. G-2, PARK VIEW SCHEME, 8 GANDHI PATH, QUEENS ROAD.
JAIPUR-21
3. KRISHNA VILLA APARTMENTS PVT. LTD.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR. SHOP NO.22-23, 3RD FLOOR, ORBIT MALL, NEAR DSPENSARY NO.4, SODALA.
JAIPUR-04
4. SHRI. PAWAN LASHKARI.
S/O. SHRI. SHYAM/SUNDER LASHKARI. R/O. B-304, JANTA COLONY.
JAIPUR-04
5. JITENDRA AGARWAL.
S/O. SHRI. RAJ KUMAR AGARWAL. R/O. 281, GOVIND NAGAR(E), AMER ROAD.
JAIPUR-02
6. SHANKAR M. JETHANI, PARTNER, M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. M.R. JETHANI. R/O. F-4, MAYUR APARTMENT, RAJ BHAWAN ROAD, CIVIL LINES.
JAIPUR-06
7. MERAJ UN NABI KHAN, PARTNER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. SHRI. NISAR UN NABI KHAN. R/O. D-1,K-55, KRISHNA NAGAR, SHYAM NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
8. NAVED SAIDI, PARTNEER M/S. GOLD DREAMS BUILDERS AND DEVELOPERS.
S/O. DR. AJMAL SAIDI. R/O. A-8, VAISHALI MARG, VAISHALI NAGAR.
JAIPUR-19
9. AMAY HOME SERVICES LIMITED.
THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR, ROHIT SURI.AT PRESENT IN CENTRAL JAIL. F-6, ROYAL VILLA, GAUTAM MARG, RANI SATI NAGAR, AJMER ROAD, NIRMAN NAGAR.
JAIPUR.
...........Appellant(s)
Versus 
1. Y.N. REDDY & ORS.
S/O. SHRI. Y. RANGA REDDY. R/O. FLAT NO.101, PLOT NO.1-7-15/3, VAMSEE KUTEER, KAMALA NAGAR, ECIL.
HYDERABAD-500063
2. HDFC LTD.
THROUGH MANAGER. O-19 A, ASHOK MARG, C-SCHEME.
JAIPUR-302991
...........Respondent(s)

BEFORE: 
 HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE D.K. JAIN,PRESIDENT

For the Appellant :
Ms. Archana Pathak Dave and
Mr. Utsav, Advocates
For the Respondent :

Dated : 26 Apr 2018
ORDER

Learned Counsel appearing for the Appellants states that as per her instructions, the Appellants do not propose to press these Appeals if liberty is granted to them to raise the objections with regard to their

-25-

liability for the alleged acts of omission or commission by the erstwhile partners of the Firms - M/s Gold Dreams Builders & Developers and Krishna Villa Apartments, in the Execution proceedings.

        In view of the submission, all the Appeals are dismissed as not pressed with liberty as prayed.

        It goes without saying that I have not expressed any opinion on the merits of these Appeals.  As and when the Execution proceedings or any other proceedings, under any law, are initiated against the Appellants, the same shall be considered on merits, on due consideration of the objections, as may be raised on behalf of the Appellants.

        All the Appeals stand disposed of in the above terms.

        The statutory deposits made at the time of filing of the Appeals shall be refunded to the Appellants.

 

 
......................J
D.K. JAIN
PRESIDENT

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.