State Commission has dismissed the appeal by a non-speaking order.

        State Commission, being the first court of appeal, is the final court of fact and was required to record reasons in support of the conclusions arrived at after referring to the contentions raised by the counsel for the parties.

        In view of the law laid down by this Commission in Terex Vectra Equipment Pvt. Ltd. vs. Meharchand & Ors. – Revision petition No.3736/2012 dated 9.4.2013, the order of the State Commission cannot be sustained and is accordingly set aside.  The case is remitted back to the

2

State Commission to decide it afresh in accordance with law in the light of the observations made by this Commission in Terex Vectra Equipment Pvt. Ltd. case (supra), copy of which has already been sent to the State Commission.

        Parties, through counsel, are directed to appear before the State Commission on 27.5.2013.