| Complaint Case No. CC/188/2016 |
| | | | 1. PRASHANT BUSINESS PREMISES CO.OPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD., | | 74/78, PRASHANT CHAMBERS, BHANDARI LANE, MASJID BUNDER(WEST), MUMBAI 400 003. |
| ...........Complainant(s) | |
| Versus | | 1. PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PRIVATE LTD, & 20 ORS | | 115, UMRIGAR BUILDING, 1ST FLOOR, CARNAL ROAD, OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 2. KANTILAL NAGARDAS SHAVDIA | | 9, MAHESH CHAMBERS, 391, NARSHI NATHA STREET, MUMBAI 400009 | | 3. HEMANT VASANT CHHEDA | | 111/5, MALINATH BHUVAN, ROAD NO.2, SCHEME NO.6, MATUNGA, MUMBAI 400 019. | | 4. PREMJI MEGHJI RAMBHIYA | | KAMAL KUNJ, PLOT NO.582, JAMA JAMSHEDJI ROAD, MATUNGA, MUMBAI 400 019. | | 5. DALICHAND JUTHALAL SANGHAVI | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 6. VRAJLAL CHUNILAL SHETH | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 7. PRABHA VRAJLAL SHETH | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 8. VASANJI VELJI CHHEDA | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 9. MAHESH KANTILAL SHAVDIA | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 10. KAMLESH VRAJLAL SHETH | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 11. KIRIT DALICHAND SANGHAVI | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 12. LAXMIDAS CHANDA RAMJI | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 13. PRAGJI DAYAL HARIANI | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 14. KHIMJI NAGJI | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 15. MOTIRAM WAGHJI | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 16. TOKERSEY DOSSA | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 17. SURJI TRICAMDAS | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 18. PURUSHOTTAM CHATURBHUJ | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 19. ODHAVJI CHANABHAI | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 20. JAMNADAS CHATURBHUJ SETHIA | | 115, OOMRIGAR BUILDING, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP. CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | | 21. BOMBAY MUNICIPAL CORPORATION | | MAHANAGAR PALIKA MARG, MUMBAI 400 001. |
| ............Opp.Party(s) |
|
|
| Final Order / Judgement | SOUTH MUMBAI DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM, SOUTH MUMBAI | Puravatha Bhavan, 1st Floor, General Nagesh Marg, Near Mahatma Gandhi Hospital | Parel, Mumbai-400 012 |
| | Miscellaneous Application No. MA/72/2016 | In | Complaint Case No. CC/188/2016 |
| Date of filing : 25/07/2016 | 1. PRASHANT BUSINESS PREMISES CO.OPERATIVE SOCIETY LTD., | 74/78, PRASHANT CHAMBERS, BHANDARI LANE, MASJID BUNDER(WEST), MUMBAI 400 003. Duly represented by its Secretary, Mr. Dipen Sheth |
| ...........Complainant | | | Versus | | 1. PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PRIVATE LTD, | 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 2. KANTILAL NAGARDAS SHAVDIA | 9, MAHESH CHAMBERS, 391, NARSHI NATHA STREET, MUMBAI 400 009. ANOTHER ADDRESS AT : 27/28, KAILASH NIWAS NO.2, R.B. MEHTA ROAD, GHATKOPAR (E), MUMBAI – 400 077. | 3. HEMANT VASANT CHHEDA, | 111/5, MALINATH BHUVAN, ROAD NO.2, SCHEME NO.6, MATUNGA, MUMBAI 400019. | 4. PREMJI MEGHJI RAMBHIYA, | KAMAL KUNJ, PLOT NO.582, JAMA JAMSHEDJI ROAD, MATUNGA, MUMBAI 400019. | 5. DALICHAND JUTHALAL SANGHAVI, | 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 6. VRAJLAL CHUNILAL SHETH | 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 7. PRABHA VRAJLAL SHETH | 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 8. VASANJI VELJI CHHEDA | 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 9. MAHESH KANTILAL SHAVDIA | 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 10. KAMLESH VRAJLAL SHETH | 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 11. KIRIT DALICHAND SANGHAVI | 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 12. LAXMIDAS CHANDA RAMJI | C/o PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD., 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 13. PRAGJI DAYAL HARIANI | C/o PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD., 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 14. KHIMJI NAGJI | C/o PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD., 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 15. MOTIRAM WAGHJI | C/o PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD., 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 16. TOKERSEY DOSSA | C/o PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD., 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 17. SURJI TRICAMDAS | C/o PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD., 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 18. PURUSHOTTAM CHATURBHUJ | C/o PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD., 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 19. ODHAVJI CHANABHAI | C/o PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD., 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 20. JAMNADAS CHATURBHUJ SETHIA | C/o PRASHANT DEVELOPERS PVT. LTD., 115, OOMRIGAR BLDG, LOKMANYA TILAK RD., OPP.CRAWFORD MARKET, MUMBAI 400 003. | 21. BOMBAY MUNICIPAL CORPORATION | MAHANAGAR PALIKA MARG, MUMBAI 400 001. |
| ...........Respondent(s) |
|
| | BEFORE: | | | HON'BLE MR. G.K. RATHOD PRESIDENT | | HON'BLE MR. S.R. SANAP MEMBER |
| | PER : MR. G.K. RATHOD, PRESIDENT | |
| Dated : 23 Nov 2017 | | //ORDER PASSED BELOW CONDONATION APPLICATION // Read the application and say thereon. I have gone through the contents of the documents placed on record. From the facts it appears that the Agreement executed between the parties on 22/8/1988. The Ld. Counsel for the Complainant has submitted that the cause of action is continued. On the contrary, the Opponent’s Counsel has submitted that from the contents of the complaint and the documents placed on record, the MOFA Act is not applicable, there is no justified reason to condone the delay. The subject matter is not covered under the provisions of the Consumer Protection Act. (2) From the submission of both the parties we came to the conclusion that we do not find any substance in the application of condonation of delay of the Complainant as there is no justified explanation for delay condoned. With due respect, we can say that the Case-law cited by the Complainant not applicable to this case as the facts are different from this case and therefore, the delay application is rejected and also complaint is also liable for dismissed. | sd/-xxx | [HON'BLE MR. G.K. RATHOD] | PRESIDENT | sd/-xxx | [HON'BLE MR. S.R. SANAP] | MEMBER |
|
| |
