Oriental Insu.Co.Ltd; Ahmednagar. V/S Santosh Manik Karkhele,Tribhuvanwadi,Post Deorai, Tal Pathardi, Dist Ahmednagar. - Consumer Court Case

Maharashtra

Ahmednagar

CC/10/223

Santosh Manik Karkhele,Tribhuvanwadi,Post Deorai, Tal Pathardi, Dist Ahmednagar. - Complainant(s)

Versus

Oriental Insu.Co.Ltd; Ahmednagar. - Opp.Party(s)

Adv.Darade.

16 Jun 2010

ORDER


District Consumer ForumParag Building, Opp To Collector Office, District Ahmednagar. Maharashtra
CONSUMER CASE NO. 10 of 223

1. Santosh Manik Karkhele,Tribhuvanwadi,Post Deorai, Tal Pathardi, Dist Ahmednagar. Devrai, Tal pathardiAhmednagar						...........Appellant(s)
Vs.
1. Oriental Insu.Co.Ltd; Ahmednagar.AhmednagarAhmednagar						...........Respondent(s)

For the Appellant :

For the Respondent :

Dated : 16 Jun 2010

ORDER

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended

Highly recommended!

5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended

Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.

ãä•ãÊÖã ØãÆãÖ‡ãŠ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ãÌããÀ¥ã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã,‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ.

½ãã.‚ã£¾ãàã : Ñããè.†Ôã.‡ãñŠ.ãäºã¶ãÌã¡ñ.

½ãã.ÔãªÔ¾ãã : ‚ãù¡.Ôããõ.½ããä¶ãÓãã ‡ãõŠËãÔã Œã¡ã½ã‡ãŠÀ.

----------------------------------------------

Ôããè.¹ããè.†.¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ‰ãŠ½ããâ‡ãŠ : 223/2010.

¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ªãŒãË ãäª¶ããâ‡ãŠ : 6/04/2010.

¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ã‡ãŠãËãè ãäª¶ããâ‡ãŠ : 16/06/2010.

-----------------------------------------------

Ñããè. Ôãâ¦ããñÓã ½ãããä¥ã‡ãŠ ‡ãŠãÀŒãñËñ ----- ¦ã‡ãÆŠãÀªãÀ

ãä¨ã¼ãìÌã¶ãÌãã¡ãè ½ãì.¹ããñ. ªñÌãÀãƒÃ

¦ãã. ¹ãã©ã¡ãê,ãä•ã.‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ.

ãäÌãÀŠ£ª

½ãù¶ãñ•ãÀ

ãäª.‚ããñãäÀ†â›Êã ƒ¶ÍãìÀ¶Ôã ‡ãâŠ¹ã¶ããè ãäÊã., ----- Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ.

‚ãâºãÀ ¹Ëã¢ãã, Ô›ñÎã¶ã Àãñ¡,

‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ

„¹ããäÔ©ã¦ããè

[¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ ¾ããâÞãñ Ìã‡ãŠãèÊã : Ñããè.ªÀã¡ñ.]

[Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ ¾ããâÞãñ Ìã‡ãŠãèÊã : Ñããè. ºãâØã ]

................................................................................................

ãä¶ã‡ãŠãË¹ã¨ã

{ ´ãÀã : ½ãã.ÔãªÔ¾ãã,‚ãù¡.Ôããõ.½ããä¶ãÓãã ‡ãõŠËãÔã Œã¡ã½ã‡ãŠÀ.}

................................................................................................

[1] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¹ãÆÔ¦ãì¦ãÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ãäÌã½¾ããÞããè Ôãâ¹ãî¥ãÃ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.30,000/- ª.Ôãã.ª.Îãñ.18 ›‡ã‹‡ãñŠ Ì¾ãã•ããÔãÖ ãä½ãßãÌããè ¦ãÔãñÞã ½ãã¶ããäÔã‡ãŠ ¨ããÔãã¹ããñ›ãè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á. 5000 ‚ãããä¥ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀãèÞãã ŒãÞãÃ ãä½ãßãÌãã ¾ããºããºã¦ã ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËãè ‚ããÖñ.

[2] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ Öñ Àã.¦ãã.¹ãã©ã¡ãê ãä•ã. ‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ ¾ãñ©ããèË ÀãäÖÌããÔããè ‚ãÔãî¶ã ¦¾ããâÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ©ããñ¡‡ã‹¾ãã¦ã ‚ãÎããè ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠãß¾ãã-¹ããâ¤-¾ãã ÀâØããÞ¾ãã, ãäÎãâØãñ ØããñË,Îãñ¹ã›ãèÞãã Øããò¡ã ¹ããâ¤Àã, ‚ãÎãã Ìã¥ãÃ¶ããÞ¾ãã Øãã¾ããèÞãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.30,000/- Þãã †‡ãŠ ÌãÓããÃ ‡ãŠãäÀ¦ãã ãäÌã½ãã „¦ãÀãäÌãËã Öãñ¦ãã. Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ÔãªÀ Øãã¾ããèËã ãäºãÊËã ¶ãâºãÀ 103285 ‚ãÔãã ãäªËã Öãñ¦ãã. ªìª÷Ìãã¶ãñ ÔãªÀ Øãã¾ã Öãè ãäª.31/08/2008 Àãñ•ããè ½ã¾ã¦ã ¢ããËãè. ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ ãä¦ãÞãã ¹ãâÞã¶ãã½ãã ¦ãÔãñÞã ÎãÌã ãäÌãÞœñª¶ã ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËñ. ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËò‡ãŠ¡ñ ‚ããÌãÎ¾ã‡ãŠ ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÔãÖ ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã ‚ãÔã¦ãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËò¶ããè ½ãìß ¹ããùãäËÔããèÞãñ ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ã¹ã¨ã ¶ããÖãè Ìã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ãã¦ããèË ãäºãÊËã Öã ‡ãŠã¶ããÞ¾ãã ¦ãì‡ãŠ¡¾ããÔãÖ ¶ããÖãè ‚ãÔãñ ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ªãŒãÌãî¶ã 1/09/2009 Àãñ•ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãªãÀãÞ¾ãã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ¶ãã½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãñŠËã ‚ãããä¥ã ¦ãÔãñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ‡ãŠßãäÌãËñ ‚ããÖñ. ‚ãÎãã ¦ã-Öñ¶ãñ ¦¾ããâ¶ããè Œããñ›ñ ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ªãŒãÌãî¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ¶ãã½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãñŠËã ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦¾ããâ¶ãã ‚ãããä©ãÃ‡ãŠ, ½ãã¶ããäÔã‡ãŠ Ìã ÎããÀãèãäÀ‡ãŠ ¨ããÔã ¢ããËã. ½Ö¥ãî¶ã ¦¾ããâÞããè ½ããØã¥ããè ½ãã¶¾ã ‡ãŠÀãÌããè ‚ãÍããè ÍãñÌã›ãè ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ãäÌã¶ãâ¦ããè ‡ãñŠÊããè ‚ããÖñ.

[3] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞããè ‡ãõŠãä¹ãŠ¾ã¦ã ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ‰ãŠ. 13 Ëã ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠÊããè ‚ãÔãî¶ã, ¦¾ãã¦ã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ‚ã•ããÃ¦ããèË ‡ãŠ©ã¶ãñ Ìã ½ã•ã‡ãîŠÀ ¶ãã‡ãŠãÀËã ‚ããÖñ. ¹ãÀâ¦ãî ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã †‡ãŠã Øãã¾ããèÞãã ãäª.16/03/2008 ¦ãñ 15/03/2009 ¾ãã ‡ãŠãËãÌã£ããè ‡ãŠãäÀ¦ãã ãäÌã½ãã „¦ãÀãäÌãÊ¾ããÞãñ ½ãã¶¾ã ‡ãñŠËñ ‚ããÖñ ‚ãããä¥ã ¦¾ãã Øãã¾ããèÔã ãäºãÊËã ¶ãâºãÀ 103285 ãäªÊ¾ããÞãñÖãè ¹ãÆãä¦ã¹ããª¶ã ‡ãñŠËñ ‚ããÖñ. ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¹ãì¤ñ ‚ãÔãñÖãè ¶ã½ãîª ‡ãñŠËñ ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞããè Øãã¾ã ½ã¾ã¦ã ¢ããÊ¾ããÞããè ÔãîÞã¶ãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ãã ãäªËãè Öãñ¦ããè. ‚ãããä¥ã ‚ããÌãÎ¾ã‡ãŠ ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããÔãÖ ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌããÖãè ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã ‚ããÖñ. ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãÞãñ ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌ¾ããÔãÖ ‚ãÔã¥ãã-¾ãã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÞãñ ‚ãÌãËãñ‡ãŠ¶ã ‡ãñŠËñ ‚ãÔã¦ãã ‚ãÔãñ ãäªÔãì¶ã ¾ãñ¦ãñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¹ããùãäËÔããèÞããè ½ãîß¹ãÆ¦ãÖãè ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËãè ¶ããÖãè. ‚ãããä¥ã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ãã¦ããèË ãäºãÊËã Öã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ããÞ¾ãã ¦ãì‡ãŠ¡¾ããÔãÖ ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã ¶ããÖãè. ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãÞ¾ãã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã Öã 1/09/2009 Þ¾ãã ¹ã¨ãã¶ãñ ¾ããñØ¾ãÞã ‡ãŠãÀ¥ãã¶ãñ ¶ãã½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãñŠËã ‚ããÖñ. ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ãäÌã½ãã ‡ãŠÀãÀãÞ¾ãã ‚ã›ãè Ìã Îã¦ããêÞãã ¼ãâØã Öãñ¦ã ‚ããÖñ. ¾ãã ‚ã©ããÃ¶ãñ ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ÔãñÌãã ªñ¥¾ãã¦ã ‡ãŠãñ¥ã¦ããèÖãè ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ŸñÌãËãè ¶ããÖãè. Ôãºãºã ¦¾ããâÞãñ ãäÌãÁ£ªÞãã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ‚ã•ãÃ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á 2000 ‡ãŠãù½¹ãòÔãñ›Àãè ‡ãŠãùÔ›ÔãÖ Àÿ ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ¾ããÌãã ‚ãÎããè ÎãñÌã›ãè ãäÌã¶ãâ¦ããè ‡ãñŠËãè ‚ããÖñ.

[4] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ, Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞããè ‡ãõŠãä¹ãŠ¾ã¦ã, „¼ã¾ã¹ãàããâ¶ããè ¹ãìÀãÌ¾ãã‡ãŠã½ããè ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËñËãè Îã¹ã©ã¹ã¨ãñ Ìã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ãñ ‚ãããä¥ã „¼ã¾ã¹ãàããâÞãñ ãäÌã´ã¶ã Ìã‡ãŠãèË Ñããè.ªÀã¡ñ Ìã Ñããè ºãâØã ¾ããâ¶ããè ‡ãñŠËñËã ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌããª ¾ããâÞãã ãäÌãÞããÀ ‡ãŠÀ¦ãã ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ ãäÌãÞããÀã©ãÃ ŒããËãèË ½ãìÿñ „¹ããäÔ©ã¦ã Öãñ¦ãã¦ã.

½ãìªªáñ : ãä¶ãÓ‡ãŠÓãÃ :

[‚ã] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ãäªÊãñÊ¾ãã

ÔãñÌãñ¦ã ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠã¾ã ? : Öãñ¾ã.

[ºã] ‚ããªñÍã ‡ãŠã¾ã ? : ‚ãâãä¦ã½ã ‚ããªñÍãã ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ.

‡ãŠãÀ¥ãñ

[5] ªãŒãÊã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÞãñ ‚ãÌãÊããñ‡ãŠ¶ã ‡ãñŠÊãñ ‚ãÔã¦ãã, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀã¶ãñ ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠãß¾ãã-¹ããâ¤-¾ãã ÀâØããÞ¾ãã, ãäÎãâØãñ ‚ããŒãì¡, Îãñ¹ã›ãèÞãã Øããò¡ã ¹ããâ¤Àã, ‚ãÎãã Ìã¥ãÃ¶ããÞ¾ãã Øãã¾ããèÞãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ ãäª.1/04/2008 ¦ãñ31/03/2009 ¾ãã ‡ãŠãËãÌã£ããè ‡ãŠãäÀ¦ãã À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.30,000/- Þãã ãäÌã½ãã „¦ãÀãäÌãËã Öãñ¦ãã ¾ãã ØããñÓ›ãè „¼ã¾ã¹ãàããâ¶ãã ½ãã¶¾ã ‚ããÖñ¦ã ‚ãããä¥ã ãäÌã½ãã ¹ããùãäËÔããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠÌÖÀ¶ããñ›ÌãÁ¶ãÖãè ¦ãñ Ô¹ãÓ› Öãñ¦ã ‚ããÖñ. ¾ããÞã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããÌãÁ¶ã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ÔãªÀ Øãã¾ããèËã ãäºãÊËã ¶ãâºãÀ 103285 ãäªËã Öãñ¦ãã ÖñÖãè ãäªÔãî¶ã ¾ãñ¦ã ‚ããÖñ. ¾ããÞã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããÌãÁ¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ãäÌã½ãã Ö¹¦¾ãã¹ãõ‡ãŠãè 50 ›‡ã‹‡ãñŠ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ÔÌã¦ã: ¼ãÀËãè ‚ãÔãî¶ã „ÌãÃÀãè¦ã 50 ›‡ã‹‡ãñŠ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ÎããÔã¶ãã ½ãã¹ãÃŠ¦ã ¼ãÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËãè ‚ããÖñ ÖñÖãè ãäªÔãî¶ã ¾ãñ¦ã ‚ããÖñ.

[6] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞããè Øãã¾ã ãäª.31/08/2008 Àãñ•ããè ½ã¾ã¦ã ¢ããÊããè. ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ‚ããÌãÎ¾ã‡ãŠ ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÔãÖ ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã, ¾ããÖãè ºããºã¦ã „¼ã¾ã¹ãàãã¦ã Ìããª ¶ããÖãè. ‚ãÔãñ ‚ãÔãî¶ãÖãè Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãÞ¾ãã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ¦ããâãä¨ã‡ãŠ ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ªãŒãÌãî¶ã ¶ãã½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãñŠËã. ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌ¾ããÞããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ¦ãÔãñÞã ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ã ¼ãÀ¹ããƒÃ¹ããñ›ãè ‡ãŠãÖãè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ãä½ãß¥¾ãã ‡ãŠãäÀ¦ãã ¹ãÆÔ¦ãì¦ãÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ªãŒãË ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ ¼ããØã ¹ã¡Ëñ ‚ããÖñ.

[7] ¾ãã Ôãâª¼ããÃ¦ã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ ¾ããâÞãñ ãäÌã´ã¶ã Ìã‡ãŠãèË Ñããè. ºãâØã ¾ããâ¶ããè ‚ãÔãã ¾ãì‡ã‹¦ããèÌããª ‡ãñŠËã ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ŒããËãèË ‡ãŠãÀ¥ããÔ¦ãÌã ¶ãã½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãñŠËã ‚ããÖñ.

‚ãã¹ã‡ãŠã „¹ãÀãñ‡ã‹¦ã ªãÌãã ãä¶ã½¶ããäËŒã¦ã ‡ãŠãØã•ãã¦ã ¶ã Öãñ¶ãñ ‡ãñŠ ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ªñ¾ã ¶ããÖãè Öõ.

‚ããñÀãè•ã¶ãË ‡ãŠÌÖÀ ¶ããñ› Ôããä›Ããä¹ãŠ‡ãñŠ› •ã½ãã ¶ãÖãè ãä‡ãŠ¾ãã Øã¾ãã Öõ.

¾ããâ¶ããè ¹ãì¤ñ ‚ãÔãñÖãè ¹ãÆãä¦ã¹ããª¶ã ‡ãñŠËñ ‡ãŠãè, ãäÌã½ãã ‡ãŠÀãÀãÞ¾ãã ‚ã›ãè Ìã Îã¦ããê¶ãìÔããÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãÞ¾ãã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ¾ããñØ¾ãÞã ‡ãŠãÀ¥ãã¶ãñ ¶ãã½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãñŠËã ‚ããÖñ. Ôãºãºã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ãäÌãÁ£ªÞãã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ‚ã•ãÃ Àÿ ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ¾ããÌãã. ‚ãã¹ãÊ¾ãã ½Ö¥ã¥¾ããÞ¾ãã ¹ãðÓ›©ãÃ ¦¾ããâ¶ããè 15/1 ÌãÀãèË ãäÌã½ãã ‡ãŠÀãÀãÞãã ‚ãã£ããÀ Üãñ¦ãËã.

[8] Öñ ŒãÀñ ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠãè, ¹ãÆÔ¦ãì¦ã ‡ãŠÀãÀã¦ã ‚ãÎãã ºããºããè „¹ããäÔ©ã¦ã ‡ãñŠËñÊ¾ãã ‚ããÖñ¦ã ãä‡ãâŠÌãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãŠÀ¦ããâ¶ãã „¹ãÀãñ‡ã‹¦ã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÞããè ¹ãì¦ãÃ¦ãã ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ ‚ããÌãÎ¾ã‡ãŠ ‚ããÖñ ¹ãÀâ¦ãì ¾ãã †Ìã¤¾ããÞã †‡ãŠã ‡ãŠãÀ¥ããÌãÁ¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãÞ¾ãã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ¶ãã½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ ¾ããñØ¾ã Öãñ¥ããÀ ¶ããÖãè. ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ¹ããùãäËÔããèÞããè ½ãìß ‡ãŠÌÖÀ¶ããñ› ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀã¶ãñ •ã½ãã ‡ãñŠËãè ¶ããÖãè ãä‡ãâŠÌãã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ããÞãã ãäºãÊËã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ããÞ¾ãã ¦ãì‡ãŠ¡¾ããÔãÖ ãäªËã ¶ããÖãè ¾ãã½ãìßñ ‡ãŠÀãÀãÞ¾ãã ½ãìË¼ãî¦ã ‚ã›ãéÞãã ¼ãâØã Öãñ¦ã ¶ããÖãè ‚ãÔãñ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ ½ã¦ã ‚ããÖñ.

[9] ¾ãã ØããñÓ›ãéÞãã ªìÔã-¾ãã ‚ã©ããÃ¶ãñ ãäÌãÞããÀ ‡ãñŠËã ¦ãÀãè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀã¶ãñ ¹ããùãäËÔããèÞããè œã¾ããâãä‡ãŠ¦ã ¹ãÆ¦ã ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËãè ‚ããÖñ ¾ããÞããÞã ‚ã©ãÃ ¹ããùãäËÔããèÞããè ½ãìß ¹ãÆ¦ã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ããÞã‡ãŠ¡ñ ‚ãÔããÌã¾ããÔã ÖÌããè ‚ããÖñ.

[10] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞãñ ªìÔãÀñ ½Ö¥ã¥ãñ ÔÌããè‡ãŠãÀ¥¾ãã ÔããÀŒãñ ¶ããÖãè, ‚ãÔãñ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ ½ã¦ã ‚ããÖñ. ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌ¾ããÔãÖ ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ãã¦ããèË ãäºãÊËã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ããÞ¾ãã ¦ãì‡ãŠ¡¾ããÔãÖ ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã ¶ããÖãè ‚ãÔãñ ¦¾ããâÞãñ ‡ãŠ©ã¶ã ‚ãÔãËñ ¦ãÀãèÖãè ƒ¦ãÀ ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÌãÁ¶ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ãã¦ããèË ãäºãÊËã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠÊ¾ããÞãñ Ô¹ãÓ› Öãñ¦ã ‚ããÖñ. ‚ã©ããÃ¦ã ‡ãŠãÖãè ‡ãŠãÀ¥ããÔ¦ãÌã ¦ããñ Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ããÞ¾ãã ¦ãì‡ãŠ¡¾ããÔãÖ ãä¶ãÜããËã ¶ãÔããÌãã. ¹ãÀâ¦ãî •ãÀãè ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌ¾ããÔãÖ ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ãã¦ããèË ãäºãÊËã ‡ãŠã¶ããÞ¾ãã ¦ãì‡ãŠ¡¾ããÔãÖ ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã ¶ãÔãñË ¦ãÀãè ƒ¦ãÀ ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÌãÁ¶ã ãä‡ãâŠÌãã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã Ìã¥ãÃ¶ããÌãÁ¶ã •ãÀ ãäÌã½ãã „¦ãÀãäÌãËñËãèÞã Øãã¾ã ½ã¾ã¦ã ¢ããËãè Öñ Îããºããè¦ã Öãñ¦ã ‚ãÔãñË ¦ãÀ ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ãã¦ããèË ãäºãÊËã ‡ãŠã¶ããÞ¾ãã ¦ãì‡ãŠ¡¾ããÔãÖ ªãŒãË ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ ‚ããÌãÎ¾ã‡ãŠÞã ‚ããÖñ ‚ãÔãñ ¶ããÖãè. ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ãäºãÊËã Öã ãäÌã½ãã „¦ãÀãäÌãËñËãèÞã Øãã¾ã ½ã¾ã¦ã ¢ããËãè ¾ããÞããè ‚ããñßŒã ¹ã›ãäÌã¥¾ããÔããŸãè ‚ããÌãÎ¾ã‡ãŠ ‚ãÔã¦ããñ. ¹ãÀâ¦ãî ƒ¦ãÀ ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÌãÁ¶ã •ãÀ ¦ãÎããè ‚ããñßŒã ¹ã›¦ã ‚ãÔãñË ¦ãÀ Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ããÞ¾ãã ¦ãì‡ãŠ¡¾ããÔãÖ ãäºãÊÊãã ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËãÞã ¹ããÖãè•ãñ ‚ãÔãñ ¶ããÖãè. ½ãã. ÌããäÀÓ› ¶¾ãã¾ããË¾ããâ¶ããè ‚ãã¹ãÊ¾ãã ãäÌããäÌã£ã ãä¶ãÌãã¡¾ãã´ãÀñ ‚ãÔãñ ¶¾ãã¾ã¦ã¦Ìã ½ããâ¡Ëñ ‚ããÖñ.

[11] ÌããÔ¦ããäÌã‡ãŠ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞããè Øãã¾ã Öãè ãäª.31/08/2008 Àãñ•ããè ½Ö¥ã•ãñÞã ãäÌã½ãã ‡ãŠãËãÌã£ããè¦ã ½ã¾ã¦ã ¢ããËãè ‚ããÖñ. ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ‚ããÌãÎ¾ã‡ãŠ ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÔãÖ ½Ö¥ã•ãñÞã ÎãÌããäÌãÞœñª¶ã ‚ãÖÌããË,½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãñ ½ãìÊ¾ããâ‡ãŠ¶ã ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ã¹ã¨ã,½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãñ ½ãð¦¾ãì ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ã¹ã¨ã ¦ãÔãñÞã Øãã¾ããèÞãñ ÎãÌã ãäÌãÞœñª¶ã ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã ‡ãŠãäÀ¦ãã ¼ãÀËñÊ¾ãã ¹ãŠãè Þããè ÎããÔã‡ãŠãè¾ã ¹ããÌã¦ããè,¹ãâÞã¶ãã½ãã, ƒ¦¾ããªãèÔãÖ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã Öãñ¦ãã Öñ ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.5 Ôããñºã¦ãÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããâÌãÁ¶ã Ô¹ãÓ› Öãñ¦ã ‚ããÖñ. ÌãÀãèË ÔãÌãÃ ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ãã¦ã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãñ Ìã¥ãÃ¶ã ¦ãÔãñÞã ãäºãÊËã ¶ãâºãÀ 103285 ¶ã½ãîª ‡ãñŠËñËã ‚ããÖñ. ¦ãÔãñÞã ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.5/3 ÌãÀ ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãñ ½ãð¦¾ãì ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ã¹ã¨ã ‚ããÖñ. ¦¾ãã¦ã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠã¶ããÔã ½ãð¦¾ãìÔã½ã¾ããè ãäºãÊËã Öãñ¦ãã ‡ãŠã¾ã ? ¾ããÞãñ „¦¦ãÀ "Öãñ¾ã" ‚ãÔãñÞã ªñ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËñ ‚ããÖñ. ¦ãÔãñÞã ¹ãÆÔ¦ãì¦ãÞ¾ãã ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ãã¦ã ãä¶ã. 5/4 ÌãÀ Øãã¾ããèÞãã ¹ãâÞã¶ãã½ãã ‚ãÔãî¶ã ¦¾ãã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãã ãäºãÊËã ¶ãâºãÀ 103285 ¦ãÔãñÞã Øãã¾ããèÞãñ Ìã¥ãÃ¶ã ÀâØã ‡ãŠãßã ¹ããâ¤Àã,Îãñ¹ã›ãèÞãã Øããò¡ã ¹ããâ¤Àã,Øãã¾ã ½ã¾ã¦ã ¢ããÊ¾ããÞããè ¦ããÀãèŒã ƒ¦¾ããªãè Ô¹ãÓ› ãäªËñ ‚ãÔãî¶ã ¦¾ããŒããËãè ¹ããÞã ¹ãâÞããâÞ¾ãã ÔÌããàã-¾ããÖãè ‚ããÖñ¦ã. ¾ãã ÔãÌãÃ ‡ãŠãØãª¹ã¨ããÌãÀãèË Øãã¾ããèÞãñ Ìã¥ãÃ¶ã ‚ãããä¥ã ãäÌã½ãã ¹ããùãäËÔããè¦ããèË Øãã¾ããèÞãñ Ìã¥ãÃ¶ã Öñ ÔããÀŒãñÞã ‚ããÖñ. ¦ãÔãñÞã ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.5/3 Þ¾ãã ½ããØããèË ºãã•ãîÔã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãã ÎãÌããäÌãÞœñª¶ã ‚ãÖÌããË ªñ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËã ‚ãÔãî¶ã ¦¾ãã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãñ Ìã¥ãÃ¶ã, ãäºãÊËã ¶ãâºãÀ 103285, Øãã¾ã ½ã¾ã¦ã ¢ããÊ¾ããÞããè ¦ããÀãèŒã Ìã ½ãð¦¾ãìÞãñ ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ƒ¦¾ããªãè ÔããäÌãÔ¦ãÀ ãäªËñËñ ‚ããÖñ. ‚ãÔãñ ‚ãÔã¦ããâ¶ãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ããâ¨ããè‡ãŠ ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ªãŒãÌãî¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞãã ãäÌã½ãã ªãÌãã ¶ãã½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ Öñ ãä¶ããäÎÞã¦ãÞã ‚ã¶ãìãäÞã¦ã, ‚ã¾ããñØ¾ã Ìã ‚ã¶¾ãã¾ããÞãñ ‚ããÖñ.

[12] ÌããÔ¦ããäÌã‡ãŠ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ãäÌã½¾ããÞããè Ôãâ¹ãî¥ãÃ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ªñ¥ãñ ºãâ£ã¶ã‡ãŠãÀ‡ãŠ ‚ãÔãî¶ãÖãè ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ¶ã ªñ¥ãñ Öãè ãä¶ããäÎÞã¦ãÞã ÔãñÌãñ¦ããèË ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ‚ããÖñ, ¾ãã ãä¶ãÓ‡ãŠÓããÃ¹ãÆ¦ã Öñ ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã ¾ãñ¦ã ‚ããÖñ. Ôãºãºã ½ãìÿã ‰ãŠ "‚ã" Þãñ „¦¦ãÀ Öãñ‡ãŠãÀã©ããê ªñ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËñ ‚ããÖñ.

[13] „¹ãÀãñ‡ã‹¦ã ÔãÌãÃ ºããºããéÞãã ãäÌãÞããÀ ‡ãŠÀ¦ãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ãäÌã½ãã ¹ããùãäËÔããèÞããè Ôãâ¹ãî¥ãÃ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.30,000/- ªñ¥ãñ ¾ããñØ¾ã Ìã ÀãÔ¦ã ÖãñƒÃË, ‚ãÔãñ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ Ô¹ãÓ› ½ã¦ã ‚ããÖñ. Ôãºãºã ¶¾ãã¾ããÞãñ ÒÓ›ãè¶ãñ ŒããËãèË ‚ããªñÎã ¹ãããäÀ¦ã ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ¾ãñ¦ã ‚ããÖñ.

‚ããªñÎã

[‚ã] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ¾ãñ¦ã ‚ããÖñ.

[ºã] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ ¾ããâ¶ããè, ÔãªÀ ãä¶ã‡ãŠãÊããÞãñ ¦ããÀŒãñ ¹ããÔãî¶ã ¹ãì¤ãèÊã 45 ãäªÌãÔããâÞãñ ‚ããâ¦ã.

[1] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ½ã¾ã¦ã Øãã¾ããèÞ¾ãã ãäÌã½¾ããÞããè Ôãâ¹ãî¥ãÃ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á¹ã¾ãñ 30,000/- [Á.¦ããèÔã Ö•ããÀ ½ãã¨ã] ª¾ããÌãñ¦ã.

[2] ÔãªÀ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ½ãìª¦ããè¦ã ¶ã ãäªÊ¾ããÔã, ¦¾ããÌãÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ªãŒãË ¦ããÀŒãñ ¹ããÔãî¶ã ¦ãñ Ôãâ¹ãî¥ãÃ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ªñ¾ã ÖãñƒÃ¹ã¾ãÄ¦ãÞãñ ‡ãŠãËãÌã£ããèÔããŸãè ª.Ôãã.ª.Íãñ. 10 ›‡ã‹‡ãñŠ ¹ãÆ½ãã¥ãñ Ì¾ãã•ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ª¾ããÌãñ.

[3] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ªñ¥¾ããÞãñ ÔãñÌãñ½ã£¾ãñ ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ŸñÌãÊããè ½Ö¥ãî¶ã, ¶ãì‡ãŠÔãã¶ã ¼ãÀ¹ããƒÃ¹ããñ›ãè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á. 2,000/- [Á.ªãñ¶ã Ö•ããÀ ½ãã¨ã] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ª¾ããÌãñ¦ã.

[4] ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ½ãã¶ããäÔã‡ãŠ ¨ããÔã Ìã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀãèÞãã ŒãÞãÃ ½Ö¥ãî¶ã †‡ãîŠ¥ã À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á¹ã¾ãñ 1,000/- [ÀŠ.†‡ãŠ Ö•ããÀ ½ãã¨ã] ª¾ããÌãñ¦ã.

[‡ãŠ] Ôãâºãâãä£ã¦ããâ¶ãã ‚ããªñÎã ‡ãŠßãäÌã¥¾ãã¦ã ¾ããÌãã.

‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ.

ãäª¶ããâ‡ãŠ : 16/06/2010.

{‚ãù¡.Ôããõ.½ããä¶ãÓãã ‡ãõŠËãÔã Œã¡ã½ã‡ãŠÀ} {Ñããè.†Ôã.‡ãñŠ.ãäºã¶ãÌã¡ñ}

ÔãªÔ¾ãã ‚ã£¾ãàã

ãä•ãÊÖã ØãÆãÖ‡ãŠ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ãÌããÀ¥ã ãä•ãÊÖã ØãÆãÖ‡ãŠ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ãÌããÀ¥ã

¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã,‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ. ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã,‚ãÖ½ãª¶ãØãÀ.


,	HONORABLE test, PRESIDING MEMBER	,