NCDRC

NCDRC

CC/1318/2017

MITUL PRAKASH & 82 ORS. - Complainant(s)

Versus

M/S. UNITECH LTD. - Opp.Party(s)

MR. N. PRABHAKAR & MR. DHRUV SHARMA

19 Dec 2018

ORDER

NATIONAL CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION
NEW DELHI
 
CONSUMER CASE NO. 1318 OF 2017
 
1. MITUL PRAKASH & 82 ORS.
S/O. DR. BRAHAM PRAKASH R/O. C-9/14, QUTAB ENCLAVE, DLF CITY PHASE I,
GURGAON-122002
HARYANA
2. SANDEEP BANSAL
S/O. AMRIT LAL BANSAL, FLAT NO. 902, TOWER NUMBER 7, BELMONT GOLF COURSE ROAD,
GURGAON-122002
HARYANA
3. PRASHANT BHATIA
S/O. SURESH BHATIA R/O. C-2034, GROUND FLOOR, SUSHANT LOK I,
GURGAON-122009
HARYANA
4. RAMKRISHNA GARG,
S/O. BABU RAM GARG, R/O. 307, GODHULI SENIOR CITIZEN HOME SECTOR 2, PLOT NO. 7, DWARKA
NEW DELHI-110075
5. DR. YOGENDER SINGH KADYAN
S/O. LT. SHRI ISHWAR SINGH, R/O. 8-UH, MEDICAL CAMPURS PGI M SM
ROHTAK-124001
HARYANA
6. NYMPHAEA WALECHA
W/O. PANKAJ WALECHA, R/O. 715/716, FIRST FLOOR, DOUBLE STORY BLOCK NEW RAJENDER NAGAR
NEW DELHI-110060
7. NEELAM ASNANI
W/O. GURUMUKH ASNANI, R/O. C-10, PANCHSHEEL ENCLAVE,
NEW DELHI-110017
8. MR. KAMLESH TAGGAR
W/O. MICHAEL TAGGAR R/O. H-62, G.S. APARTMENTS PLOT NO. 38, SECTOR 13 ROHINI
NEW DELHI-110085
9. JAYDEEP SATHAYE
S/O. JAYAWANT SATHAYE, R/O. L-071, RIDGEWOOD ESTATE WHO DLF CITY PHASE IV,
GURUGRAM-122009
HARYANA
10. PUNEET GOENKA AND SRIKA AGGARWAL
THROUGH KRISHNA KUMAR GOENKA, S/O. J.L. GOENKA, R/O. MS-01, FLAT NO. 203, KENDRIYA VIHAR, SECTOR 56,
GURGAON-122002
HARYANA
11. RAJASEKHARA BABU NALLURI
S/O. SUBBA RAO NALLURI R/O. A-105, FIRST FLOOR, SUSHANT LOK PHASE I, NEAR MG ROAD, METRO STATION,
GURGAON-122002
HARYANA
12. YOGENDRA KUMAR
S/O. BAJRANG SINGH, R/O. A-12, P.W.O COMPLEX SECTOR 43,
GURGAON-122009
HARYANA
13. ASHOK KUMAR GUPTA
S/O. LT. MOTI LAL GUPTA R/O. P-48B, ARCADIA EXTN. BEHALA WEST BENGAL, KOLKATA-700034
14. BRIJESH DATTA
A/O. LT. COL ID SHARMA, R/O. 1201, FRANGIPANI, NAHAR AMRIT SHAKTHI CHANDIVALI
MUMBAI-400 007.
MAHARASHTRA
15. PRADEEP PRABHAKARAN ELEDATH,
S/O. C PRABHARAKARAN, C 1, VASANT KUNJ,
NEW DELHI-110070
16. PRASHANT CHAUDHARY,
S/O. R.S. CHAUDHARY, R/O. E-72, 7TH FLOOR, RICHMOND PARK, DLF PHASE IV,
GURGAON-122001
HARYANA
17. MONICA MITTAL,
W/O. ANURAG MITTAL, R/O. TOWER NO. 9, 503, ORCHID PETALS SOHNA ROAD,
GURUGRAM-122018
HARYANA
18. COL. SUKHBIR SINGH SUHAG
S/O. CHHOTU RAM, R/O. 109, CEDAR CREST NIRVANA COUNTRY, SECTOR 50
GURGAON
HARYANA
19. VARUN VIJ
R/O. 12/2, ACACIA, VATIKA CITY, SECTOR 49,
GURGAON-122018
HARYANA
20. MANISHA KUMAR
D/O. LT. JUSTIC HR KHANNA, R/O. A-30/2, DLF CITY PHASE I,
GURGAON-122002
HARYANA
21. DEEPAK JAGWANI
S/O. LT. SHRI PURSHOTTAM JAGWANI, R/O. 44, I.T. COLONY, AISHBAGH,
LUCKNOW-226004
UTTAR PRADESH
22. RAVINDRA SAWHNEY
S/O. OM PRAKASH SAWHNEY, R/O. M-62, SOUTH CITY I,
GURGAON-122001
HARYANA
23. DR. RUCHI TANDON,
D/O. LT. SHRI RAM KISHORE TANDON, R/O. 963, FIRST FLOOR, SECTOR 15, PART II,
GURGAON
HARYANA
24. SHITIZ SHARMA,
S/O. MR. KIRAN SHARMA, R/O. C-4E/158, POCKET 11, JANAK PURI,
NEW DELHI-110058
25. RITU CHAWLA,
D/O. CHANDER PRAKASH CHAWLA, R/O. FLAT NO. 1103, SECTOR B, POCKET I, VASANT KUNJ,
NEW DELHI-110070
26. RUPINDER KUMAR KAPOOR,
S/O. BALWANT SINGH KAPOOR, R/O E-83, GROUND FLOOR, GREATER KAILASH,
NEW DELHI-110048
27. ROHIT DAHUJA
THROUGH SUBHASH DAHUJA S/O. THAKUR DAS, R/O. C-17/4, SF ARDEE CITY
GURGAON
HARYANA
28. MRS. SHIVANI HANS
THROUGH SATISH KUAMR S/O. O.P. KUMAR R/O. A-128, 2ND FLOOR, SARASWATI VIHAR, PITAMPURA
NEW DELHI-110034
29. ASHIT GROVER,
S/O. PRITAM LALL GROVER, R/O. HOUSE NO. 460, SECTOR 8, POCKET C-8, ROHINI
NEW DELHI-110085
30. PREMVATI W/O. RAGHBIR SINGH
R/O. HOUSE NO. 326, BHURAWAS TEHSIL JHAJJAR,
DISTRICT-JHAJJAR,
HARYANA-124146
31. DR. S.V. SINGH,
S/O. K.C. SINGH, R/O. A-8/110, SECTOR 16, ROHINI
NEW DELHI-110089
32. SURENDRA SINGH,
S/O. CHANDAN SINGH, R/O. A-305, SANSKRITI APARTMENT, SECTOR 43
GURGAON-122009
33. DR. SANJEEV CHANDANA
S/O. HARI SINGH CHANDNA, R/O. ND-37, UPPAR GROUND FLOOR, PITAMPURA
NEW DELHI-110034
34. RAJAT BHARDWAJ
S/O. RAJINDER BHARDWAJ, R/O. B-1/333, JANAK PURI,
NEW DELHI-110058
35. BHAWANA SHARMA
D/O. PAWAN KUMAR SHARMA, R/O. A-401, RAIL VIHAR, SECTOR 47, SOHNA ROAD,
GURGAON-122002
HARYANA
36. SUMIT BATRA
S/O. GANESH DAS BATRA, R/O. A-401, COSMOS EXECUTIVE APART. PALAM VIHAR
GURGAON-122017
HARYANA
37. HARISH UDHARAM BHATIA
R/O. G-125, RIDGEWOOD ESTATE DLF PHASE 4, NEAR GLLERIA MARKET,
GURGAON-122009
HARYANA
38. SANJESH KUMAR THAKUR
S/O. SAMBHU SHARAN THAKUR, R/O. 801, TOWER NO. 15, SOUTH CLOSE NIRVANA COUNTRY,
GURAGON-122018
39. RAJANI W/O. KISHNA LAL MAKHIJA
R/O. H.NO. 1354, SECTOR 4, URBAN ESTATE
GURAGON-122001
40. RAHUL SINGH S/O. LALJI SINGH
R/O. HNO. 494 2ND FLOOR, SECTOR 40,
GURGAON-
41. LALIT KUMAR MAHAJAN
R/O. 430A, NEW SHASTRI NAGAR, PATHANKOT,
PUNJAB-145001
42. ATUL KUMAR S/O. M.P. SINGH
R/O. FLAT NO. 610, MAITRI RBI APART. GH-30, SECTOR 56,
GURGAON
43. ASHUTOSH SETIA S/O. PREM SAGAR SETIA,
R/O. L2/11, GROUND FLOOR DLF PHASE II,
GURGAON
HARYANA
44. ANJU GURDASANI
THROUGH NEELAM ASNANI W/O. SH. GURUMUKH ASNANI, R/O. C-10, PANCHSHEEL ENCLAVE
NEW DELHI
45. SANT KUMAR VERMA
S/O. KRISHNA MANOHAR, R/O. FLAT NO. 1001, TOWER NO. 1, VIPUL GREENS
GURGAON
HARYANA
46. NAND KISHORE SHARMA,
S/O. LT. SHRI S.N. SHARMA, R/O. 393, SECTOR 21D,
FARIDABAD
HARYANA
47. VINITA DAS W/O. SUDHIR DEY,
R/O. G-141, 2ND FLOOR, SOUTH CITY II,
GURAGON-122018
48. S. SUNDRAM,
S/O. A. SANKARA NARAYANAN, R/O. C-66/C, GANGOTRI ENCLAVE, ALAKNANADA
NEW DELHI-110019
49. ANOOP KUMAR BANSAL
S/O. SHRI ASOK KUMAR BANSAL, R/O. W2B/142, WELLINGTON ESTATE, DLF PHASE 5,
GURGAON-122009
50. TARUN SINHA
S/O. KRISHNA KUMAR SINHA, R/O. G-67, FIRST FLOOR, SOUTH CITY 2, SECTOR 50,
GURGAON-122018
51. SUBASH KATARIA
S/O. SHRI BANWARI LAL, R/O. H.NO. 819, SECTOR 10-A,
GURGAON-122001
52. DR. JYOTI ARORA,
W/O. DR. HARSH SAPRA, R/O. C-6, ROYAL CORUT, OPP. MEDANTA HOSPITAL SECTOR 39,
GURGAON--122003
53. DR. SUDHIR DUBEY,
S/O. GIRISH CHANDER DUBEY, R/O. A-3-81, PASCHIM VIHAR,
NEW DELHI-110063
54. PAYAL MASCARA
W/O. GOUTAM AGRAWAL, R/O. 85, KASHMIRI LANE DR. R.R. ROAD, RANIGANJ
DISTRICT-BURDWAN
WEST BENGAL-713347
55. VIJAY BHUSHAN S/O. HAR PRAKASH
R/O. C-6/6110, VASANT KUNJ,
NEW DELHI-110070
56. ARUN GARG S/O. S.N. GARG,
R/O. B-111, TRINITY TOWERS, DLF PHASE 5,
GURGAON-122002
HARYANA
57. DEEPAK DALAL S/O. LT. YASHWANT DALAL
R/O. FLAT NO. 1002, TOWER NO. 4, THE CLOSE SOUTH, NIRVANA COUNTRY, SECTOR 56,
GURGAON-122018
58. SIDDHARTH GUPTA
S/O. DAYA KRISHAN GUPTA R/O. 36, NEW MARKET BEGUM BRIDGE,
MEERUT-280001
59. DANISH KUMAR YADAV
S/O. SWANTANTAR SINGH YADAV, R/O. VPO SAMASPUR, SECTOR 51
GURGAON
HARYANA
60. JOLLY VATSA,
THROUGH Y.P. VASTA, R/O. H-81, RIDGEWOOD ESTATE DLF 4,
GURGAON-122009
HARYANA
61. SANJAY VATSA
THROUGH Y.P. VASTA, R/O. H-81, RIDGEWOOD ESTATE DLF 4,
GURGAON-122009
HARYANA.
62. SABINA CHAWLA, D/O. MANMOHAN CHHABRA
R/O. ASPEN TOWER 2-B-501, GODREJ WOODSMAN ESTATE HEBBAL,
BANGALURU-560024
KARNATAKA
63. PUJA CHOPRA D/O. D.K. CHOPRA
R/O. 903, ELITIS LODHA AURUM, KANJURMARG EAST
MUMBAI-400042
MAHARASHTRA
64. SANJIV KUMAR SHARMA,
S/O. TILAK RAJ SHARMA, R/O. 32, EAST LAKSHMI MARKET PATPADGANJ ROAD,
DELHI-110092
65. KANWAR KRISHNA PURI,
S/O. KRISHNA KUMAR PURI, R/O. H.NO. 3/8, DLF PHASE I,
GURGAON-122002
HARYANA
66. ANURAG TRIVEDI
THROUGH ARUN GARG, S/O. S.N. GARG, R/O. 111, TRINITY TOWERS DLF PHASE V,
GURGAON-122009
HARYANA.
67. RAJESH TANEJA S/O. CHIRANJI LAL TANEJA
R/O. H.NO. 178, GROUND FLOOR, J.BLOCK SAKET,
NEW DELHI-110017
68. RITI D/O. JAGDEEP SINGH
R/O. POCKET A/6A, HARI NAGAR JAIL ROAD,
NEW DELHI-110064
69. AMIT RAJ BATHLA
S/O. WING COMMANDER LD BATHLA, R/O. H.NO. 91, SECTOR 17A,
GURAGON-122001
70. ANKIT RAGHAV
D/O. VP SINGH RATHOUR, R/O. 503, SHIV SHAKTI C.H.G.S., PLOT NO. 94, SECTOR 54
GURGAON
HARYANA
71. SACHIN LUTHRA
S/O. LT. SHRI JAGADISH LUTHRA, R/O. 204, SECTOR 7,
GURGAON
72. PRASHANT BHALLA
S/O. GOPAL KRISHNA BHALLA,R/O. B3-002, UNI WORLD CITY,
GURGAON-122001
HARYANA.
73. AMIT KUMAR SINGH
THROUGH ASHOK KUMAR SINGH, S/O. KESHAV P.D. SINGH, R/O. KESHAV BHAWAN, CHURCH ROAD,
RANCHI-834001
JHARKHAND
74. RAJAT VIG S/O. DR. ASHWANI VIG,
R/O. H.NO. 2554, SECTOR 35-C,
CHANDIGARH
75. ARUN DEVNATHAN
S/O. C.R. DEVNATHAN, R/O. FLAT NO. 1004, BUILDING 50, NRI COMPLEX, NERUL
NAVI MUMBAI-400706
MAHARASHTRA
76. SOMNATH GOYAL
S/O. KRISHNA CHAND GOYAL, R/O. A-2, FLAT NO. 608, PRINTERS APARTMENT, SECTOR 13, ROHINI
NEW DELHI-110085
77. DEEPAK DHAWAN
S/O. ARJUN D DHAWAN, R/O. D-42, THE ICON GOLF COURSE ROAD, DLF PHASE V,
GURGAON-122009
HARYANA
78. DR. MOHIT LATHAR S/O. O.P. LATHAR
R/O. B-1004, AWHO SOCIETY, SECTOR 49, SISPAL VIAHR
GURGAON
HARYANA
79. MRIDULA
D/O. TARA CHAND, R/O. WZ 267, BASAI DARA PUR,
NEW DELHI-110015
80. HARISH GOEL S/O. R.C. GOEL,
R/O. SU 18, PITAM PURA,
NEW DELHI-110034
81. SANKALAP MEHROTRA S/O. S.K. MEHROTRA
R/O. C2, 7173, WINDMILL OF YOUR MIND, 5B, EPIP ZONE, NEAR INFOTECH WHITEFILED,
BANGALURU-560066
KARNATAKA
82. SHARMILA D/O. TARA CHAND
R/O. C-604, K.M. APARTMENTS, SECTOR 12, PLOT NO. 12,
NEW DELHI-110078
83. RAM DEEP KAUR
THROUGH MITUL PRAKASH S/O. DR. BRAHAM PRAKASH, R/O. C-9/14, QUTAB ENCLAVE, DLF CITY, PHASE I,
GURGAON-122002
HARYANA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus 
1. M/S. UNITECH LTD.
THROUGH ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR, 6, COMMUNITY CENTRE, SAKET,
NEW DELHI-110017
...........Opp.Party(s)

BEFORE: 
 HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE DEEPA SHARMA,PRESIDING MEMBER

For the Complainant :
Mr. N. Prabhakar, Adv.
For the Opp.Party :
Mr. Babanjeet Singh Mew, Advocate

Dated : 19 Dec 2018
ORDER

The opposite party has not filed the affidavit evidence despite giving an opportunity subject to cost.  Cost has also not been paid by the opposite party.

2.         It is prayed by the counsel for the complainants that in identical matter i.e. Consumer Case no. 1442 of 2016 titled Arvind Nevita  Vs. M/s Unitech Limited relating to same project of the opposite party, this Commission had ordered refund of the deposits made by the complainant alongwith compensation @ 10% p.a. from the respective date of deposits and litigation cost of Rs.10,000/-.  It is prayed that order in this class suit may also be passed in those terms.

3.         No ground has been shown by the opposite party for giving any further opportunity for filing affidavit evidence.  Their right to file affidavit evidence is closed.

4.         I  have heard argument of counsel for the parties.  This is a class suit filed by 83 complainants, whose name appear in the memo of parties, alleging that they are allottees of the residential units in the project of the opposite party called ‘Crestview Apartment’ township called Wildflower  Country located at Sector 70, Gurgaon which was to be developed by the opposite party.  It is submitted that opposite party promised to hand over the physical possession of their subjective residential units within 39 months from the date of sale agreement. More than  2 ½  years have already been passed, yet there is no progress of the construction at the site and also the possession of the subjective units have not been offered to the complainants despite the fact that they have been regularly making the payments of the consideration amount.  It is submitted that there is clear deficiency in service and complainants are entitled for the relief as prayed and given in various other pronouncements of the similar project by this Commission.

5.         Written version has been filed by the opposite party but it was filed beyond the statutory period of limitation and hence it was not taken on record.  However, on perusal of the written version, it is apparent that contention of the complainants that their residential units have not been offered to them for possession within the stipulated period has not been controverted.  By this uncontroverted fact and also by way of affidavit, complainants have proved that opposite party has failed to hand over the subjective units to them within the stipulated period.  This amounts to deficiency in service and the complaint is, therefore, allowed with following directions:

  1. Opposite party is directed to refundthe entire deposited amount received from the respective complainants alongwith compensation to each of them in the form of simple interest @ 10% p.a. on their deposits from the respective dates of such deposits till its realization;

  2. Litigation cost of Rs.10,000/- in toto is also awarded to the complainants.

  3. The payment in terms of this order shall be made within three months from today.

 
......................J
DEEPA SHARMA
PRESIDING MEMBER

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.