Maharashtra

StateCommission

CC/10/156

M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD - Complainant(s)

Versus

M/S TATA MOTORS LTD - Opp.Party(s)

R G LONDHE

12 Oct 2010

ORDER

BEFORE THE HON'BLE STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL
COMMISSION, MAHARASHTRA, MUMBAI
 
Complaint Case No. CC/10/156
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/157
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/158
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/159
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/160
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/161
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/162
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARAHSTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/163
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/164
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/165
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/166
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/167
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/168
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/169
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
Complaint Case No. CC/10/170
 
1. M/S MAHALAXMI DHANESH TRANSPORT AND AP CONSTRUCTION PVT LTD
O/AT 250/5B FR 4 VASANT NIVARA NEAR MAHAVIR COLLEGE KOLHAPUR
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
BOMBAY HOUSE 24 MODY STREET MUMBAI
MUMBAI
MAHARASHTRA
2. M/S TATA MOTORS LTD
AREA OFFICE CITY MALL 1 ST FLOOR GANESHKINDH ROAD NEAR PUNE UNIVERSITY PUNE
PUNE
MAHARASHTRA
3. M/S CHETAN MOTORS
R.S. 308/2 B P O ICHGAON HUPARI ROAD TAL KARVEER
KOLHAPUR
MAHARASHTRA
............Opp.Party(s)
 
BEFORE: 
 Hon'ble Mr. S.R. Khanzode PRESIDING MEMBER
 Hon'ble Mr. Dhanraj Khamatkar Member
 
PRESENT:Mr.Deshpande,Advocate, Proxy for R G LONDHE, Advocate for for the Complainant 1
 Mrs.Anita Marathe, Advocate for the Opp. Party 1
ORDER

 Per Mr.Dhanraj Khamatkar, Hon’ble Member

 

                  Advocate Mrs.Anita Marathe undertakes to file Vakalatnama on behalf of O.P.

          These are 15 complaints bearing Nos.156 to 170/2010 filed by the complainants alleging deficiency in service by the O.P./Company.  Complainant is a Private Limited Company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 and the vehicles are purchased for the business purpose.  Section 2(1)(d)(i) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 defines the word ‘consumer’.  However, ‘consumer’ does not include a person who obtains such goods for resale or for any commercial purposes. 

In view of the aforesaid facts, the complainants in all the complaints are not consumers.  Moreover, for the alleged manufacturing defects, complainants have not adduced any evidence to prima-facie substantiate the allegation of manufacturing defect.  For these reasons, these complaints could not represent any consumer disputes.  Hence, we pass the following order :-

                             -: ORDER :-

1.       Complaint Nos.156 to 170/2010 are not admitted and accordingly stand dismissed. 

2.       No order as to costs.

3.       Copies of the order be furnished to the parties.

 

 

 
 
[Hon'ble Mr. S.R. Khanzode]
PRESIDING MEMBER
 
[Hon'ble Mr. Dhanraj Khamatkar]
Member

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.