BEFORE THE A.P.STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION:

HYDERABAD.

C.D.No. 3 OF 2008

Between:

Residents Welfare Association, Regd. No.1631/1007

SanskrutiTownship, Hyderabad-500 008

Represented by its General Secretary

Sri M.Raghava Rao.                                                             

And

Vice Chairman and Housing Commissioner

Andhra Pradesh Housing Board

Gruhakalpa, M.J.Road, Hyderabad-500 001.                              

For the Complainant: Mr.M.Raghava Rao, Party in person

Counsel for the Opposite party: Mr.J.Prabhakar.

QUORUM:THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE D.APPA RAO, PRESIDENT

AND

SMT.M.SHREESHA, MEMBER.

WEDNESDAY, THE ELEVENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY,

TWO THOUSAND NINE

Oral Order:(Per Smt.M.Shreesha, Hon’ble Member)

***

The complainant is Residents Welfare Association, represented by its General Secretary and  SingaporeClassIntegratedTownship” Phase I, 4 types, 2080 flats at Pocharam. SanskrutiTownship” with design, construction and architectural services by M/s.CESMA INTERNATIONAL   townshipSingapore Quality SanskrutiTownshipHyderabadHyderabad 

1.   This project is the first of its kind in the country

2.   World renowned CESMA International,Singapore

3.   The project is being executed on fast track for completion in 18 months

4.   Designed as per vaasthu

5.   An integrated township with all modern facilities like swimming pool, club house, sewerage treatment plant, school and commercial centre

6.   Construction with high quality specifications

7.   10 passenger automatic door lift for each block comprising of 32 units

8.   Lights and fans in common areas

9.   Fully underground water, electrical water supply an sewerage lines.

10.          Secondary roof over terrace for heat insulation

11.          Environment friendly sewerage treatment point

12.          Room with attached toilet in stilt floor of each block for common use.

The complainant submitted that as per terms and conditions, the allotment will be made by draw of lots after full payment. 

i) Maintenance and upkeep of common areas, facilities etc. the residents 

 shall form a ‘Residents’ Society

ii) Maintenance and upkeep of common areas and structures therein along with facilities to be provided to the allottees shall be undertaken initially by the Board for a maximum period of two years.

iii) One time fixed maintenance corpus find shall be payable to the Board at the time of possession and on formation of the “Resident’s society’, balances, if any of maintenance corpus fund shall be transferred to the society.

The complainant submitted that possession shall be given after full payment of the cost along with all other dues, charges, fees, one time maintenance amount, maintenance corpus fund etc. and after execution of sale deed. Specifications given in the brochure are as follows:

Foundation & Structures: R.C.C. Framed structure

Walls: Luppam finish for all inside walls & sponge finish for all external

Doors: Custom designed shutters for main door. 

Windows: Glazed aluminum powder coated windows with safety grills

Flooring: Good quality ceramic tiles

Toilets:Anti Skid Ceramic tiles with ceramic tile dadooing upto 2.1 M

Kitchen: Polished green marble, stainless steel sink & wall dadooing

Painting: Inside coloring with two coats of plastic emulsion, External

Electrical: Concealed wiring with adequate points for T.V. telephone,

Lift: Ten passenger automatic door lift for each block

Fire Fighting: Provision for fire fighting equipment at appropriate places

Security System: Security posts at suitable locations.

        8-11-2006, 300 residents represented to the committee and brought to their notice the deficiency in service, construction defects and non provision of common facilities in the township etc. 

        15-9-2007  2-1-2008 26-3-200730-8-2007and when it failed        31-11-200731-12-2007.        11-3-2005  The Association on behalf of its members submit that adequate compensation for their facilities must be given.  

1. Ducts:       
2. Common Corridors:
3. Water Tanks, Gauges and Ladders:
4. Electrical cables:
5. Main Common Water Pipe Lines:
6. Security system:
7. Fire Protection: 
8. Telephone Land line cables: 
9. Provision for Incinerator:   

10.Lifts: Power failure and low voltage has become a routine feature in the township due to which lifts are getting stuck up in between the floor, creating panic situations.      

11.Common facilities at Each block:Room with attached toilet in the 

12.Maintenance: Maintenance services are not provided to the satisfaction of residents for the last two and half years. Lot   th  

1. One senior township Maintenance knowledgeable person to be hired through out sourcing agency by the APHB need to be deputed full time to look after/to supervise the maintenance.
2. A joint committee comprising of the APHB, Facility Management services company and the Registered “Residents Welfare Association” functioning in the township” to be formed to monitor day to day maintenance problems of the residents. 
3. Payments to the Facility Management Services Company to be made only after obtaining the “Service Satisfactory Certificate” wise from the above committee.
4. As already mentioned in our letter dated30^th 
5. APHB failed to provide ‘Maintenance Accounts Statements’ to all the residents, failed to form ‘Residents Society’ till date and conduct elections to install an ‘Executive body’ for smooth maintenance of the Township as per the sale deed conditions and brochure.  11-3-2007

13.          Inclusion of Township in the GHMC:Proposal to be submitted by the APHB to the Commissioner of Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation for inclusion of the Greater Hyderabad Municipal Corporation or Hyderabad Metropolitan authority.

14.          Maintenance of Roads, Parks, Illumination and Sanitation:

15.          Providing of Senior Citizens Day Care Center at Block A7 stilt floor at unallotted non car parking area for common use of senior citizens in the Township, Providing of 1 acre site in favour of ‘Registered body of “Senior citizens forum” Singapore Township at club house premises for the setting up of the Senior Citizens Multi service center:The Andhra Pradesh Housing Board has not planned any Senior Citizens recreational facilities for the senior citizens. As a matter of national policy of Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment, Government of India, Old Age homes, multi service center for senior citizens need to be provided in the integrated township.

16.          Provision for Burial ground: Place, building, water, power to be provided for Burial ground.

17.          This claim is in respect of the ‘Residents Welfare Association’ members who have included in the list herein enclosed. 

We, therefore, call upon A.P.Housing Board

                                                                             to pay the amount of Rs.95,00,000/- as damages for not providing modern facilities as promised from 11-3-2005 together with further damages within two weeks of the receipt of notice

                                                                          To direct to create modern facilities within reasonable time

                                                                        To direct rectification of defective works and provide for such other facilities as required in integrated Township listed above within two months

                                                                        To provide a modern club, swimming pool facility and Senior Citizen Multi Services Center within 8 acres earmarked for the club

                                                                           To give 2 acres to the ‘Residential Welfare Association” Regd. No.1631/2007 for creating a recreation center, community hall, Township Maintenance office for 2080 flats, residents of the township along with appropriate building within 6 months

                                                                        To give 1 acre to the senior Citizens forum Regd. No.1420/07 dt.6-8-2007 for creating a Multi services center to the senior citizens of the township within one month.

The complainant submitted that he corresponded with opposite party personally and through letters and final notice on2-1-2008requesting for release of compensation amount of Rs.95,00,000/- due to the 97 complaints but there are no fruitful results.   

i)     to pay the complainant the sum of Rs.95,00,000/-

ii) to pay the complainant a sum of Rs.5,000/- towards expenses he incurred in making correspondence on the issues

iii) to pay Rs.50,000/- towards mental agony/suffering.

iv) to pay costs of the petition

v) to direct to create modern facilities promised within reasonable time.

vi) to direct rectification of defective works and provide for such other facilities as required in integrated Township listed above within two months.

vii) to provide a modern club, swimming pool facility and senior citizens Multi Services Centre within 8 acres earmarked for the club

viii) to give 2 acres to the ‘Residents Welfare Association’ Regd. No.1631/2007 for creating a recreation center, community hall, Township Maintenance office, for 2080 flats, Residents of the Township along with appropriate building within 6 months.

ix) to give 1 acre to the Senior Citizens forum Regd. No.1420/07 dt.6-8-2007 for creating a Multi services center to the senior citizens of the township within one month.

x) to appoint a ‘Advocate Commission’ or Approved Engineer to inspect the construction defects and to estimate in the flats atSanskruthiTownship, Hyderbad.

xi) Grant such any other orders and further relief’s as the Hon’ble State Commission deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.

                    NOVEON,USA) under brand name ASTRAL FLOW GUARD CPVC.        

                                               They are required to maintain a register for complaints and the works thereon and accordingly the individual complaints are registered and attended to after which the signature of the person is recorded confirming the factum of their attending to the work. 17-4-2008constituted a high power committee with the following officers to sort out the grievances of the flats owners ofSanskrutiTownship

i)     Sri Siva Prasad, superintending Engineer

ii) Sri N.Krishnam Raju, Quality Control Consultant

iii) Sri T.V.S.Ratnam, PRO & OSD

Out of the above three, Sri N.Krishnam Raju is a retired Engineer in R&B Department, Government of A.P. and was also Quality Control Engineer (Consultant) at the time when the project was underway.    A.P.H.B. is also taking steps to realize its due for maintenance. Further the maintenance charges collected are directly related to the expenditure. 

DCB OF ALL CATEGORIES OF FLATS i.e. PENT HOUSE, DUPLEX, C.A. & A.B. BLOCKS INSINGAPORECLASSTOWNSHIP

1.   Ducts:Ducts are internal parts of the flat and do not come under common facilities as claimed.    India 

2.   COMMON CORRIDORS:

3.   Water tanks, gauges and Ladders: 

4.   Electrical cables:  

5.   Main common water Pipe Lines:    

6.   Security system: 

7.   FIRE PROTECTION:

8.   Telephone, Land Line Cables:  

9.   Provision for incinerator: 

10.          Lifts:  8 AM6.30 PM.

11.          A room with attached toilet is provided in stilt floor for common use.   

12.          APHB is maintaining the township by outsourcing and doing its best to keep the residents in a happy living environment.  

13.          The roads, parks etc are presently being maintained in the township, involving outsiders in the maintenance would also require  

14.          So far as provision for burial ground is concerned, the concerned municipality provides for the same and making such provision in the township would create several problems including religious and may disturb the overall environment and communal harmony and is outside the purview of the allotment conditions.

Opposite party further stated that out of the alleged 84 complainants, who are part of complainant association, about 28 flat owners are purchased after March, 2005 i.e. the flats were completed in all respects and ready for occupation.     Further in March, 2005 when the subsequent announcements were made for sale, it was clear that the facilities offered are only conceptual. Opposite party further submitted that certain persons have been threatening the security personnel and the workers at the site and have been complaints during past in this regard.      

Complainant filed the affidavit of its Secretary Mr.M.Raghava Rao, in lieu of evidence reiterating the facts in the complainant and got marked Exs.A1 to A56 on his behalf. 

Opposite party also filed affidavits of its Executive Engineer (Hg)SanskrutiTownship SanskrutiTownship 

The point for consideration is whether there is any deficiency of service on behalf of the opposite party and if the complainant is entitled for the relief prayed for in the complaint?

Ex.A1 are brochures of A.P.H.B. issued in 2003 & 2005. 11-4-200320-3-2005. 9-11-2006.  26-3-200730-8-2007. 10-9-2007. 15-9-2007. 17-9-200712-11-2007. 7-11-2007. 19-11-2007.   22-12-2007.  2-1-2008. 01-12-2007. 31-12-2007. 30-11-20076-1-2008. 19-7-2005. 26-3-2007. 29-1-200826-1-2008. 29-1-2008. 29-1-200831-1-2008. Ex.A23 is APHB letter for enhancement of Maintenance charges dated13-2-2008. 16-2-2008. Ex.A25 is letter dt.22-2-2008 to refund the maintenance deposit amount. 11-3-2008. 13-3-2008. Ex.A28 is RWAS letter dated20-3-2008 24-3-2008 27-3-2008.  3-4-2008. 3-4-2008. 1-4-2008. 3-4-2008.  4-4-2008. 14-6-2008. Ex.A39 is A.P.Govt. G.O.Rt.No.229 dated15-9-2001. 1-8-2002. 28-12-2007. SanskruthiTownship, HUDA has accorded only technical approval for the plans submitted by APHB under Building Regulations G.O.Ms.No.423 dated31-7-1998.  9-4-2008 29-5-2007  29-6-2004from Director General of Fire & Emergency Services, supply of information under RTA Act Sanskruthi Township-Plans should be Multistoried Buildings Regulations, 1981 and NBC. 14-12-2006 SanskruthiTownshipHon’ble A.P.High Court9-8-2006 14-12-2006. 29-5-2008 9-6-2008to Chief Minister to implement G.Os. and brochure commitments to provide amenities. 9-6-2008. 31-7-2002. Ex.A53 is Permit No.3946/mp2/h/02 letter No.3964 dt.31-7-2002 Ex.A54 is Huda technical approved vide letter no.3964.mp2/h/2002 dt.1-8-02 Disallowed C& D blocks. 21-6-2008.  1-8-2002. 1-4-2008. 17-4-2008. 25-4-2008 30-4-2008. 27-5-2008. 29-5-2008. 9-6-2008. 9-6-2008. 21-6-2008. 20-6-2008. 21-6-2008. 23-7-2008. 28-6-2008. 7-7-2008. 31-12-2007.         19-3-2005   14-6-2008,20-10-20083-11-2008. Sale2-4-2008.       Ex.B14 is copy of complaint in HRC No.3736/08.  

       10-9-2007SanskrutiTownship, Ghatkeswar is registered under the A.P. Societies Act, 2001.     LUCKNOW DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY v. M.K.GUPTA reported inAIR 1994 SC 787held that the activities of Housing Construction Bodies can be defined as ‘service’. (1998) CPJ page-7 (NC) Vice Chairman, A.P.Housing Board and others v. A.P.Housing Board (LIG) Housing Beneficiaries Association, Bhimavaram,the National Commission has considered that A.P.Housing Board (LIG) Housing Beneficiaries Association as a complaint and has upheld the order of the State Commission which has allowed the complaint with respect to certain deficiencies. 

        The complainant further submits that the opposite party would pay a sum of Rs.3,000/- per month as penalty as per G.O.Rt.No.229. 

a)Ducts: 

CPVC pipes and bad workmanship, there is leakage of water and sewerage through the ducts from top to bottom and the same has to be replaced with G.I pipes and cost iron sewerage pipelines and accordingly the duct size needs to be modified.

b)   Common Corridors: The ‘floor tiling’ work in the corridors and stair cases of four storied buildings blocks is incomplete.

c)    Roof Leakages, Water Tanks leakages to be rectified, water level gauges and ladders to be fixed for each tank.

d)   Electrical cables:

e)   Main Common Water Pipe Lines:

f)     Security system:

g)   Fire Protection:

h)   Telephone lines:

i)     There is no provision for incinerator and garbage yard and the waste material is thrown all around and there is no dumping yard and it has become a 

j)     Lifts:There is no

k)   Common facilities at each block, room with attached toilet in the

l)     Maintenance: The maintenance services are not provided to the satisfaction of residents. 

availability of water due to failure of water pipe lines and sewerage pipelines and opposite party failed to provide.

The complainant submits that they are seeking a direction to opposite party to allow them to supervise the maintenance of township and conduct elections block wise for the welfare of all the 65 blocks and to handover the maintenance to the residents association and that the maximum period of maintenance by the opposite party is for two years full, which expired on 30-6-2007 and therefore opposite party cannot charge maintenance charges to the complainant association. 

              9-3-200727-1-2007 17-4-2008  A.P.H.B. is absorbing the expenses for the present  

       20-10-2008, hence the main C.D. along with the application is being disposed of. 

a)  However since the opposite party in para 5 of their affidavit submitted that if there are any leakages, they are prepared to look into this aspect and requested the allottees to hand over one set of keys to the facilitator to enable them to attend to the repair works as and when necessary.  

b): It is the case of the complainant that floor tiling work in the  

c) Water Tanks, Gauges and Ladders: The contention of the complainant is that water tank leakages are to be rectified and ladders are to be fixed properly and water level gauges are to be fixed for each tank. We direct the opposite party to rectify the leakages and though the opposite party contended that a movable ladder is provided for each terrace, these ladders are to be fixed properly and water level gauges are also to be fixed for each tank. 

Lift: the matter. 

d) Fire Fighting system:Opposite party is directed to provide fire fighting equipment at appropriate places as stated in the brochure and also obtain a fit for occupancy certificate from the statutory authorities.

e) Secuirty system: 

f) Telephone landline cables: 

With respect to complainant’s claim of incinerator, since there is no such  

SPEFICIATIONS

Windows                    

Flooring                     

Toilets                       

Kitchen                      

Painting                     

Electrical                            

Lift                           

Fire Firghting            

Security system

The High Power Committee submitted its final report on20-10-2008

a)       The Committee inspected (54) flats in I & II inspections and 52 flats in final inspection i.e. total 106 flats. 

b)      The flooring in the toilets are as per the specifications adopted in the agreement item No.25 of Project Specification (Appendix-3) and as per the decisions given by the Monitoring Committee and to that extent the Public were offered to visit the show unit in Gruhakalpa Complex for better understanding of the specification before issuing demand survey.

c)       The flat wise details like nature of defects, suggested to rectifications to be attended by the construction agency are shown in annexure (2) enclosed.

d)      The Committee has observed that no allottee has changed the bath room floor tiles as claim in the case provided by the A.P.Housing Board except in one or two flats for their convenience like vasthu. 

With respect to other prayers of the complainant i.e. to provide modern club, school, hospital, commercial complex, the learned counsel for the opposite party has submitted that the work has been started and land has been allotted for some of these facilities as mentioned in his affidavit which is as follows:

a)    School:With respect to school, the learned counsel for the opposite party contended that an extent of 7 ½ acres was handed over to Srividya Niketan Education Trust and the plans were already approved by HUDA and it is functioning 

b)    Hospital: An extent of 2 Acs. of land is allotted to NIMS 

c)     Shops: 10 temporary shops are provided on the temporary space in the stilt floor for grocery, tea, snacks, vegetables, pharmacy, dry cleaning, milk booth, men parlour etc.  

d)    Club House:An extent of Ac.8.00 is allocated for club house and swimming pool and no bidder has come forward yet.

        With respect to the complainant’s prayer of Maintenance, elections, inclusion of township in GHMC, senior citizens day care centre, maintenance of roads, parks, illumination and sanitation, burial ground etc. the complainant is directed to make a representation to the High Power Committee for their consideration since their claims do not all within the purview of jurisdiction of this Commission.

 Ducts:to conduct repair works on the leakages of ducts and the complainant is directed to co-operate with the opposite party and hand over one set 

Water Tanks, gauges and ladders: Opposite party are directed to see that the ladders are fixed properly and also fix the water level gauges for each tank.

Lift:

Fire Fighting system:Opposite party are directed to provide fire fighting equipment at appropriate places as stated in the brochure and also obtain a ‘fit for occupancy certificate’ from the statutory authorities.

Secuirty system: 

Telephone landline cables: 

Plastering: Plastering, painting, electrical works, opposite party are directed to provide these facilities as per the specifications stated in the brochure and which are also aforementioned in the High Power Committee Report.

Common Corridors: The prayer of the complainant to  

Maintenance:With respect to maintenance, since this Commission does not have jurisdiction to fix maintenance charges or to direct for payment of arrears, if any, it is open to the complainant to make a fresh representation to High Power Committee which may consider the report.

With respect to complainant’s claim of incinerator, since there is no such  With respect to the prayer of the complainant to provide modern facilities like school, hospital, club house, shops, commercial complex etc. opposite party are directed to provide these facilities as promised by them in the brochure within a period of six months. 

PRESIDENT.        .

JM                                                                                          

//APPENDIX OF EVIDENCE//

Witnesses examined for

Complainant:                                                                                 

Exhibits marked on behalf of the complainant:

Ex.A-Brochures of A.P.H.B. issued in 2003 & 2005. 

Exs.A2 & A3-Advertisements of A.P.H.B. in the newspaper dt.11-4-2003  

                  20-3-2005. 

Ex.A4-News item about visit of House Committee dated9-11-2006. 

Ex.A5-News item about dampness/health hazard. 

Ex.A6-Representation of residents of A.P.H.B. requesting Vice Chairman to

        26-3-200730-8-2007. 

Ex.A7-Registration Certificate of Residents Welfare Association along with

        10-9-2007. 

Ex.A8-Representation to Residents Welfare Association to A.P.H.B. on

        15-9-2007. 

Ex.A9-Representation to Housing Minister on 16 issues/joint meeting with

        17-9-200712-11-2007. 

Ex.A10-Reminder to APHB on 16 issues dated7-11-2007. 

Ex.A11-Invitation of Residents Welfare Association (RWAS for short)

         19-11-2007. 

Ex.A12-List  

on all issues dated22-12-2007. 

Ex.A13-Final notice dated 2/4/1/12008 for payment of Rs.95,00,000/-. 

Ex.A14-Final notice for payment of Rs.99,22,000/- dated2-1-2008. 

Ex.A15-Resolution of RWS E.C. Members dated01-12-2007. 

Ex.A16-Resolution of RWS General Body Members dated31-12-2007. 

Ex.A17-Claims submitted by 97 residents requesting RWS to take up with

         30-11-20076-1-2008. 

Ex.A18-Regd. Sale deed No.5158/05 dated19-7-2005. 

Ex.A19-Complainant letter to form an Association dated26-3-2007. 

Ex.A20-Letter from Officer on Special Duty APHB for conducting joint

         29-1-0826-1-08. 

Ex.A21-Minutes of meeting held on29-1-2008. 

Ex.A22-Letter of Officer on Special duty to depute two persons from

         29-1-2008

          31-1-2008. 

Ex.A23-APHB letter for enhancement of Maintenance charges dt13-2-08.

Ex.A24-Letter by complainant objecting enhancement of maintenance

          16-2-2008.

Ex.A25-Letter dt.22-2-2008 to refund the maintenance deposit amount. 

Ex.A26-Letter of E.E., A.P.H.B. letter about water supply dt11-3-2008.

Ex.A27-Reply letter by RWAS to APHB on water losses dated13-3-2008. 

Ex.A28-RWAS letter dated20-3-2008

Ex.A29-RWAS letter dated24-3-2008

Ex.A30-Petition before A.P.State Human Right Commission dt27-3-2008.

Ex.A31-Receipt of RTA Act fee for Rs.10/-. 

Ex.A32-List of residents prepared by the Association dated3-4-2008. 

Ex.A33-Letter offering voluntary services to maintenance monitoring

         3-4-2008. 

Ex.A34-Resolution of RWS Executive Body Members dated1-4-2008. 

Ex.A35-List of issues block-wise and flat wise submitted by the Residents

          3-4-2008. 

Ex.A36-Resident Complainant for Rs.30,000/-. 

Ex.A37-Pamphlet ofSingaporeClassTownship

         4-4-2008. 

Ex.A38-List of 139 complainants list filed before opposite party High Power

         14-6-2008. 

Ex.A39-A.P.Govt. G.O.Rt.No.229 dated15-9-2001. 

Ex.A40-HUDA Technical permission for Development of Group Housing in

          1-8-2002. 

Ex.A41-HUDA Technical approval of building plans for Commercial

          28-12-2007. 

Ex.A42-HUDA supply of information under RTA Act dt.8-12-2007 that

        SanskruthiTownship, HUDA has accorded only technical approval     

         31-7-1998. 

Ex.A43-Dt.24-10-2007 HUDA supply of information along with statement. 

Ex.A44-Dated9-4-2008

Ex.A45-Letter dated29-5-2007

Ex.A46-Dated29-6-2004

Services, supply of information under RTA Act SanskruthiTownship-Plans should be Multistoried Buildings Regulations, 1981

and NBC. 

Ex.A47-Dated14-12-2006 

         Sanskruthi

          Hon’ble A.P.High Court

         9-8-2006           

Ex.A48-Notice for Violation of Fire Prevention and Fire Safety Measures

          14-12-2006. 

Ex.A49-Letter dated29-5-2008

Ex.A50-Complainant letter dated9-6-2008

Ex.A51-Complainant letter to V.C.HUDA and APHB to develop 5 parks

          9-6-2008. 

Ex.A52-Details of site plan of proposed development in S.No.2 and 10 of

          31-7-2002.

Ex.A53-Permit No.3946/mp2/h/02 letter No.3964 dt.31-7-2002

Ex.A54-Huda technical approved vide letter no.3964.mp2/h/2002 dt.1-8-

Ex.A55-Information by APHB under RTA Act dated21-6-2008. 

Ex.A56-Photos. 

Ex.A57-HUDA Approval letter dated1-8-2002. 

Ex.A58-Resolution of Executive Committee dated1-4-2008. 

Ex.A59-Letter of Officer on Special Duty, A.P.H.B. dated17-4-2008. 

Ex.A60-Circular dated25-4-2008 

Ex.A61-Reply submitted by APHB to Human Rights Commn. dt30-4-08. 

Ex.A62-Reply affidavit in HRC No.968/2008 dated27-5-2008. 

Ex.A63-Deficiencies in approval of plans dated29-5-2008. 

Ex.A64-Representation of Residents Welfare Association to Chief Minister

          9-6-2008. 

Ex.A65-Representation of Residents Welfare Association to V.C. HUDA and

          9-6-2008. 

Ex.A66-FIR No.158/2008 of Ghatkesar Police Station dated21-6-2008. 

Ex.A67-Notice by OSD, APHB to Mr.M.Raghava Rao dated20-6-2008. 

Ex.A68-Reply of Mr.M.Raghava Rao to OSD notice dated21-6-2008. 

Ex.A69-Appeal by OSD, APHB to the residents dated23-7-2008. 

Ex.A70-CRL M.P.No.1051/08 in CR.No.158/08 dated28-6-2008. 

Ex.A71-Anticipatory Bail grant order in 158/08 dated7-7-2008. 

Ex.A72-Representation of Association to United Federation of Residents

         31-12-2007.

Exhibits marked on behalf of Opposite party:

Ex.B1-Printout of Website. 

Ex.B2-Product catalogue issued by Astral-regarding PVC pipes. 

Ex.B3-Notification dated19-3-2005 

Ex.B4-List of details for 84 complainants in C.C.No.4/2008. 

Ex.B5-Quantity of water received/requirement per day at the township. 14-6-2008, 20-10-

        3-11-2008. 

Ex.B7-Extract of contract agreement between APHB & M/s.CESMA dt.30-

        Ex.B8-Sale deed dated2-4-2008. 

Ex.B9-Paper publication extract of Saakshi dt.17-4-08. 

Ex.B10-Statement showing status of complainants in C.C.No.3/2008.  

Ex.B12-List of details for 99 claimants in C.C.No.3/2008. 

Ex.B13-List of details for 84 claimants in C.C.No.4/2008. 

Ex.B14-Copy of complaint in HRC No.3736/08. 

Ex.B15-Extract of register for rectification. 

Ex.B16-Pamphlet dt.13-3-2008.

 PRESIDENT.       .