Tamil Nadu

Thiruvallur

CC/32/2018

Tr.V.M.Elangovan - Complainant(s)

Versus

Mr.Gopi, Advocate - Opp.Party(s)

M/s G.Kothandaraman

04 Jan 2019

ORDER

DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL FORUM
THIRUVALLUR
No.1-D, C.V.NAIDU SALAI, 1st CROSS STREET,
THIRUVALLUR-602 001
 
Complaint Case No. CC/32/2018
( Date of Filing : 07 Aug 2018 )
 
1. Tr.V.M.Elangovan
S/o Murugan, Lifetime Prisoner, Convicted Prisoner No.5472, Central Prison-1, Puzhal, Chennai-66.
Thiruvallur
Tamil Nadu
...........Complainant(s)
Versus
1. Mr.Gopi, Advocate
Reg. No.78/2002, No.2, Morden City, Chennai-Thiruvallur High Road, Near Hindu College, Chennai-600 072.
Thiruvallur
Tamil Nadu
............Opp.Party(s)
 
BEFORE: 
  THIRU.J.JUSTIN DAVID, M.A., M.L., PRESIDENT
  TMT.K.PRAMEELA, M.Com., MEMBER
  THIRU.D.BABU VARADHARAJAN, B.Sc., B.L., MEMBER
 
For the Complainant:M/s G.Kothandaraman, Advocate
For the Opp. Party: M/s B.Balamurali & V.Srinivasaragavan OP, Advocate
Dated : 04 Jan 2019
Final Order / Judgement

                                            KiwaPL jhf;fy; nra;j Njjp 23.07.2018

                                            MizAiu toq;fg;gl;l Njjp 04.01.2019

 

khtl;l Efu;Nthu; FiwjPu; kd;wk; - jpUts;Su;

 

Kd;dpiy jpU N[.[];bd; Nltpl;. vk;.V. vk;.vy;        ... jiytu;

jpUkjp. Nf. gpukpsh vk;.fhk;                       ...cWg;gpdu;-1

jpU.ghG tujuh[d;.  gp.v];.rp. gp.vy;.                 ..cWg;gpdu;-2

 

2019 Mk; Mz;L [dtup; khjk; 04Mk; ehs; nts;sp;f;fpoik

 

Efu;Nthu; KiwaPl;L vz;.32/2018

V.M.,sq;Nfhtd,;

s/o.KUfd;,

MAs; ifjp, vz;-5472,

kj;jpa rpiw -1,

Goy,; nrd;id -66.                            ..kDjhuu;

 

                      -vjpuhf-

 

Nfhgp, (tof;fwpQu;)

gjpT vz; 78/2002,

vz;.2, khlu;d; rpl;b,

nrd;id - jpUts;Su; i`NuhL,

,e;Jf;fy;Yup mUfpy;

nrd;id- 72.                            .. vjpu;kDjhuh;

 

,k;KiwaPL 21.12.2018 md;W ,k;kd;wj;jpy; ,Wjp tprhuizf;F tug;ngw;W KiwaPl;lhsu; rhu;ghf M/S. G. Nfhjz;luhkd; (,ytr rl;l ikak;) mtu;fs; Kd;dpiyahfpAk; vjpu;jug;gpdu; tf;fhyj;J jhf;fy; nra;j gpd;du; tUifapy;yhjjhYk; tUifapy;yh jug;gpduhf jPu;khdpf;fg;gl;Lk,; KiwaPl;lhsu; jug;gpy; vOj;J %ykhd thJiufs; jhf;fy; nra;ag;gl;Lk;,  Mtzq;fis guprPypj;Jk;, ,Jehs;tiu ,k;kd;wj;jpd; guprPyidapy; ,Ue;Jk; ,d;W ,e;j kd;wk; toq;Fk;

 

 

MizAiu

;jpU.N[. [];bd; Nltpl; mtu;fs;, jiytu;

Efu;Nthu; ghJfhg;G rl;lk; 1986 gpupT 12-fPo; jhf;fy;

nra;ag;gl;Ls;s KiwaPL

 

,k;KiwaPL kDjhuuhy; Efu;Nthu; ghJfhg;Gr; rl;lk; gpupT 12-d; fPo; vjpu;kDjhuUf;F vjpuhf xg;Gf;nfhz;lgb gzj;jpidg; ngw;Wf;nfhz;Lk; tof;F jhf;fy; nra;ahjjhy; kpFe;j kdNtjidAk; ftiyAk; Vw;gl;Ls;sjhfTk; vjpu;kDjhuUila Nritf;FiwghL fhuzkhf kDjhuUf;F Vw;gl;l kd cisr;rYf;F ,og;gPlhf &.1,00,000/- toq;ff;Nfhup vjpu;jug;gpdu;fSf;F vjpuhf ,k;KiwaPL Kd;dplg;gl;Ls;sJ.

2. kDjhuu; jhf;fy; nra;Js;s KiwaPl;bd; RUf;fk; gpd;tUkhW:-

kDjhuu;; xU MAs; ifjp kw;Wk; rl;lg;gl;ljhup Mthu,; mtu; fle;j 12 Mz;Lfshf (IBS) vd;w Fly; Nehapdhy; fLikahf mt];ijg;gl;L tUtjd; fhuzkhf Neha;f;F nghUj;jkhd czit cau;ePjpkd;wk; %yk; ngWtjw;fhf vjpu;jug;gpdiu KiwaPl;lhsUila mg;gh tof;fwpQuhf epakpj;Js;shu;. mjidj;njhlu;e;J kDjhuUila Ke;ija tof;F, kUj;Jt Mtzq;fs; kw;Wk; (IBS) njhlu;ghd Internet Medical Journals  MfpaitfsAk; kw;Wk; Neha;f;F vLj;J nfhs;s Ntz;ba,; jtpu;f;f Ntz;ba czT gl;bay; kw;Wk; tof;fwpQu; fl;lzkhf &7,500/-I 25.10.2016 k; Njjp nrYj;jpAsshu; me;j fl;lzj;ij ngw;Wf;nfhz;l gpd;dUk; vjpu;kDjhuh; mtUf;fhf ve;j upl;kDTk; jhf;fy; nra;atpy;iy. Nfl;ljw;F rpy jfty;fis KiwaPl;lhsuplk; rpiwf;F nrd;W tprhupf;f Ntz;bAs;sJ vd;Wk; $wpAs;shu;. mjidj;njhlu;e;J tof;Fj;jhf;fy; nra;a vz;zpAs;sjhfTk; &8,000/- mtuJ tq;fpf;fzf;fpy; clNd nrYj;JkhWk; clNd mgpltpl; jahupj;J ifnaLj;Jf;F mDg;GtjhfTk; nrhy;ypAs;shu;. me;j rkak; fLikahd Demonitisation period MFk.; ,Ue;Jk,;  jQ;rhT+u; kj;jpaf; $l;LwT tq;fp, ePlhkq;fyk; fpisapd; fzf;F vz; 92852 ypUe;J tf;fPy; Nfhgpapd; Mtb ,e;jpad; tq;fp fpis fzf;fpy;  & 8,000/- I KiwaPl;lhsUila mg;gh nrYj;jpAs;shu;.  vjpu;kDjhuh; Nfhgpapd; rl;l njhopy; jpwik kw;Wk; mtupd; Neu;ikaw;w eltbf;ifapy; mtek;gpf;if mile;j KiwaPl;lhsUila mg;gh &16,000/- gzj;ijAk; tof;F Mtzq;fisAk; jpUg;gp ju NfhupAs;shu;. vjpu;kDjhuh; KiwaPl;lhsupd; je;ijaplk; tf;fPyplk; nfhLj;j gznky;yhk; jpUg;gp tuhJ vd;W nrhy;yp jpUg;gpj;ju kWj;jJld; Vw;fdNt nfhLj;j gzk; NghJkhdjy;y NkYk; &7,500/- jd; fzf;fpy; nrYj;jpdhy; clNd upl;kD jhf;fy; nra;tjhf nrhy;ypAs;shu;.  Vw;fdNt gzj;ij ngw;W nfhz;L Vd; tof;F Nghltpy;iy vd;W Nfl;L gzj;ijAk; Mtzq;fisAk; Nfl;ljw;F kpul;lyhf kPz;Lk; &7,500/- gzk; Nfl;L mtUila mg;ghit kpul;bAs;shu;.  vjpu;kDjhuh; KiwaPl;lhsupd; mg;ghtplk; mtUf;fhf nrd;id cau;ePjp kd;wj;jpy; upl;kD jhf;fy; nra;tjhf $wp &16,000/- ngw;W nfhz;L xj;Jf;nfhz;lgb upl;kD jhf;fy; nra;ahkYk,; kDjhuh; kw;Wk; kDjhuupd; mg;gh Mfpa ,UtUk; gzj;ijAk; Mtzq;fisAk; jpUg;gp ju NfhupAk;, kDjhuh; fbjk; vOjpAk; gzj;ij jpUg;gp juhky; epahakw;w tzpf eltbf;if Nkhrb kw;Wk; Nrit Fiwghl;ilAk; nra;Js;shu;.  kDjhuupd; ,Wjp tha;g;ghf gzj;ijAk; tof;F Mtzq;fisAk; jpUg;gp xg;gilf;ff;Nfhup rpiwapypUe;J gjpTj; jghy; xg;Gjy; ml;ilAld; 01.08.2017 Njjpapl;L mDg;gpAs;shu;.  mjid 21.05.2017-k; Njjp vjpu;kDjhuu; ngw;W nfhz;Ls;shu;. mjd;gpwFk; vjpu;kDjhuu; mjw;F vt;tpj gjpiyAk; mDg;gtpy;iy gzj;ijAk; jpUg;gpj;jutpy;iy, mjd;fhuzkhf kDjhuUf;F kdNtjidAk; ftiyAk; Vw;gl;Ls;sJ. Nkw;gb vjpu;kDjhuupd; Nritf;Fiwg;ghl;lhy; KiwaPl;lhsu; kpfTk; ghjpf;fg;gl;Ls;sjhf KiwaPl;by; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;shu;

3. vjpu;jug;gpdu; tf;fhyj;J jhf;fy; nra;j gpd;du; tUifapy;yhjjhYk; tUifapy;yh jug;gpduhf jPu;khdpf;fg;gl;Ls;shu;

4. ,k;KiwaPl;by; vjpu;kDjhuu; Njhd;whj; jug;gpduhfpa epiyapy; KiwaPl;lhsu; jk; tof;fpid cupa rhl;rp kw;Wk; rhd;whtzq;fs; mbg;gilapy; epUgpf;fNtz;baJ mtrpakhdnjhd;whFk;.

5. KiwaPl;lhsu; jug;gpy; KiwaPl;lhsupd; epUgz gpukhz thf;F%yk; rku;g;gpf;fg;gl;;;lJ kw;Wk; k.rh.M 1 Kjy; k.rh.M 9 tiu jhf;fy; nra;j rhz;whtzq;fs; Kd; itf;fg;gl;lJ.

6. ,f;fhyf; fl;lj;jpy; ,k;KiwaPl;ilg; nghWj;jkl;by; ,k;kd;wj;jpd; Kd;Gs;s Kf;fpag; nghUz;ik ahnjdpy;?

1)KiwaPl;by; nrhy;yg;gl;lthW vjpu;jug;gpdu; nray;ghl;by; VNjDk; Nrit FiwghL Vw;gl;Ls;sjh?

2),k;KiwaPl;by; NfhupAs;sthW ,og;ggPlhf &1,00,000/- ngw KiwaPl;lhsUf;F jFjp cs;sjh?

3)NtW gupfhuk; toq;fg;gl Ntz;Lkh?

7.gpur;rid vz;.1kw;Wk;2:-

KiwaPl;lhsu; KiwaPL kw;Wk; mtu; jhf;fy; nra;Js;s gpukhz thf;F%yj;jpYk; vjpu;kDjhuh; xU tof;fwpQu; vd;Wk,; vjpu;kDjhuuplk; nrd;id cau;ePjpkd;wj;jpy; upl;kD jhf;fy; nra;tjw;fhf 24.10.2016 md;W vjpu;kDjhu; KiwaPl;lhsiu nrd;id kj;jpa rpiwapy; re;jpj;jNghJ Neuhf &500/-k; 25.10.2016 md;W KiwaPl;lhsupd; mg;gh %ykhf &7,500/-k; NkYk; 2016 brk;gupy; KiwaPl;lhsu; mg;gh %ykhf &8,000/-k; Mfnkhj;jk; &16,000/- ngw;Wf;nfhz;Ls;shu;. Mdhy; vjpu;kDjhuh; kDjhuUf;F nrhd;dJNghy; upl;kD jhf;fy; nra;ahky; Nritf;FiwghL Vw;gLj;jpAs;shu;.  NkYk; KiwaPl;lhsu; NtnuhU tof;fwpQu; %yk; cau;ePjpkd;wj;jpy; tof;F jhf;fy; nra;J cj;juT ngw;Wf;nfhz;Ls;shu; mjw;fhf me;j tof;fwpQUf;F fl;lzkhf &10,000/- nryT nra; Js;shu;.; NkYk; vjpu;kDjhuu; kDjhuUila tof;F Mtzq;fisAk; gzj;ijAk; jpUg;gp xg;gilf;ff;Nfhup gjpTj;jghy; 01.08.2017 Njjpapy; ngw;Wf;nfhz;l gpd;dUk; ve;j gjpiyAk; vjpu;kDjhuh; kDjhuUf;F mspf;ftpy;iy. vdNt ,J Nritf;FiwghL MFk;.

8. KiwaPl;lhsu; nrd;id kj;jpa rpiwapy; MAs; ifjpahf ,Ue;jhu.; mtiu vjpu;kDjhuh; tof;F rk;ke;jkhf 24.10.2016 kw;Wk; 01.12.2016 md;W rpiwapy; nrd;W re;jpj;Js;shu;. ,jid cWjpnra;tjw;fhf kh.rh.Mtzk;-6  FwpaPL nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. mjd;%yk; MAs; jz;lid rpiwthrp ,sq;Nfhtid vjpu;jug;gpdu; rpiwapy; re;jpj;Js;sJ njs;sj;njspthfpwJ. mt;thW re;jpj;jg;NghJ KiwaPl;lhsu; utp vd;gtu; %ykhf &500/- vjpu;kDjhuUf;F nfhLj;Js;shu;. Nkw;nfhz;L vjpu;jug;gpdu; KiwaPl;lhsUf;fhf cau;ePjp kd;wj;jpy; tof;F jhf;fy; nra;tjhff;$wp mjw;Ff; fl;lzkhf &7,500/- ia 25.10.2016 md;W KiwaPl;lhsupd; mg;gh KUfd; vd;gtu; mtUila tq;fpf;fzf;fpypUe;J; vjpu;kDjhuh; tq;fpf;fzffpw;F; nrYj;jpAs;shu;.  ,jid epUgpg;gjw;fhf kh.rh.Mtz vz; 3 jhf;fy; nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.  kh.rh.Mtzk;-3 vd;gJ ,e;jpad; tq;fp fzf;F vz; 607406297f;F &7,500/- ia 25.10.2016 md;W nrYj;jg;gl;ljw;fhd urPjhFk;.  mJkl;Lkpd;wp KiwaPl;lhsupd; mg;gh vjpu;;kDjhuUf;F mtUila; jQ;rhT+u; kj;jpaf; $l;LwT tq;fp ePlhkq;fyk; vd;w tq;fpf; fzf;fpypUe;J vjpu;kDjhuUila ,e;jpad; tq;fp fpis Mtb fzf;F vz;zpw;F &8,000/- ia 2016 brk;gupy; nrYj;jpAs;shu;.  KiwaPl;lhsu; nrd;id cau;ePjpkd;wj;jpd; %ykhf rpy gupfhuq;fis Nfl;L tof;F jhf;fy; nra;tjw;F vjpu;kDjhuUf;F fl;lzkhf nkhj;jk; &16,000/-I nrYj;jpAs;shu.; Mdhy; vjpu;kDjhuh; mtu;nrhd;dJNghy tof;F jhf;fy; nra;ahky; Nritf;FiwghL Vw;gLj;jpAs;shu;.  ,Jrk;ke;jkhf KiwaPl;lhsu; vjpu;kDjhUf;F 07.08.2017 Njjpapl;l mwptpg;ig mDg;gpAs;shu.; me;j mwptpg;gpy; vjpu;kDjhuu; ngw;Wf;nfhz;l &16,000/-ia jpUg;gpf;nfhLf;f Ntz;Lnkd Nfl;Ls;shu.; me;j Mtzk; KiwaPl;lhsu; jug;G rhd;whtzk;-1 vdf; FwpaPL nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. me;j mwptpg;ig ngw;Wf;nfhz;l gpd;dUk; vjpu;kDjhuh; ve;j gjpYk; KiwaPl;lhsUf;F mDg;gptpy;iy vjpu;kDjhuh; me;j mwptpg;ig ngw;Wf;nfhz;ljw;fhd rhd;whtzk;-2 Mf FwpaPL nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.  vjpu;kDjhuh; KiwaPl;lhsu; mDg;gpa mwptpg;ig ngw;Wf;nfhz;l gpd;dUk; ve;j gjpYk; mDg;ghjjhy; vjpu;kDjhuh; mwptpg;gpy; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s tptuq;fis mtu; xj;Jf;nfhz;ljhfjhd; fUjNtz;bAs;sJ. NkYk; vjpu;kDjhuh; tof;F jhf;fy; nra;tjw;fhf &16,000/- I ngw;Wf;nfhz;l gpd;dUk; tof;F jhf;fy; nra;ahky; ,Ug;gJ Nritf;FiwghlhFk;.

9. Nkw;nfhz;L KiwaPl;lhsu; NtnwhU tof;fwpQu; %ykhf &10,000/-I fl;lzkhf nrYj;jp nrd;id cau;ePjp kd;wj;jpy; upl;kD jhf;fy; nra;J cj;juTg;ngw;Ws;shu.; me;j cj;juT efy; kh.rh.Mtzk;- 8Mf FwpaPL nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. NkYk; vjpu;kDjhuh; fl;lzj;ij ngw;Wf;nfhz;l gpd;dUk; tof;F jhf;fy; nra;ahky; KiwaPl;lhsUf;F kdcisr;ry; kw;Wk; f\;l el;;lj;ij Vw;gLj;jpAs;shu;.  vdNt KiwaPl;lhsu; KiwaPl;by; Fwpg;gpl;lJNghy; vjpu;kDjhuu; Nritf;FiwghL Vw;gLj;jpAs;shu; vd;Wk; mjdhy; Vw;gl;l kdcisr;ry; kw;Wk; f\;l el;lj;jpw;F ,og;gPL ngw KiwaPl;lhsUf;F jFjpAz;L vd;Wk; ,e;j gpur;ridfSf;F jPu;T fhz;fpd;wJ.

 

gpur;rid vz;:3:-

Kbthf ,k;KiwaPL, gFjpahf mDkjpf;fg;gLfpwJ, ,jd; njhlu;r;rpahf KiwaPl;lhsh; KiwaPl;by; NfhupathW vjpu;jug;gpdu;  tof;F fl;lzkhf ngw;w &16,000/- I (& gjpdhW Mapuk; kl;Lk;) nfhLf;f Ntz;LnkdTk; kw;Wk; vjpu;jug;gpdupd; Nritf;  Fiwg;ghl;lhy; KiwaPl;lhsUf;F Vw;gl;l kd cisr;ry; kw;Wk; ,og;gPLf;F xl;Lnkhj;jkhf &5,000/- (Ie;J Mapuk; kl;Lk;) ,og;gPlhf toq;fNtz;Lk; vdTk; kw;Wk; ,e;j KiwaPl;L nryTj;njhifahf &3,000/- (&gha; %d;W Mapuk; kl;Lk;) vjpu;jug;gpdh; KiwaPl;lhsUf;F toq;fNtz;Lk; vdTk; Mizg; gpwg;gpf;fg;gLfpwJ.

 

NkYk; ,t;thizg; ngwgl;l ehspy; ,Ue;J ,uz;L khjj;jpw;Fs; (16,000+  5,000+3,000=&24,000/-) njhifia nrYj;jNtz;Lk; vdTk; jtWk; gl;rj;jpy; nrYj;Jk; ehs; tiuapy; 9% tl;bAld; nrYj;jNtz;Lk; vdTk; Miz gpwg;gpf;fg;gLfpwJ.

RUf;nfOj;J jl;lr;rUf;F xyp tbtpy; nrhy;yg;gl;L mtuhy; RUf;nfOj;jpy; vOjp fzpdpapy; jl;lr;R nra;ag;gl;lij jiytuhy; jpUj;jk; nra;ag;gl;L vq;fshy; ,d;W 2019 Mk; Mz;L [dtup khjk; 04-k; ehs; jpwe;j kd;wj;jpy; gfug;gLfpwJ.

 

  -xk;-                    -xk;-                 -xk;-

cWg;gpdu;-II               cWg;gpdu; -I            jiytu;

 

kDjhuu; jug;G rhd;whtzg; gl;bay;:-

 

 

 

k.rh.M.1

07.08.2017

vjpu;kDjhuUf;F 07.08.2017 Njjpapl;L kDjhuu; mDg;gpa Nehl;B];

efy;

k.rh.M.2

........

xg;Gjy; ml;il

efy;

k.rh.M.3

25.10.2016

kDjhuu; mg;ghtpd; ,e;jpad; tq;fpf; fzf;fpypUe;J vjpu;kDjhuupd; tq;fpf; fzf;fpy; nrYj;jpa nry;yhd; urPJ.

efy;

k.rh.M.4

..........

kDjhuupd; mg;ghtpd; jQ;rhT+u; kj;jpa $l;LwT tq;fp fzf;F vz;.92852.

efy;

k.rh.M.5

13.02.2017

kDjhu; je;ij kDjhuUf;F mDg;gpaf; fbjk;

efy;

k.rh.M.6

........

vjpu;kDjhuu; rpiwapy; te;J kDjhuiu re;jpj;jJ kw;Wk; kDjhuu; mtUf;F vOjpa fbjk; njhlu;ghd RTI gjpy;

efy;

k.rh.M.7

05.02.2015

kDjhuUila Ke;ija H.C.P.No.3490/2014

efy;

k.rh.M.8

07.06.2017

CRI.O.P.No.7138/2017

efy;

k.rh.M.9

 

 IBS njhlu;ghd internet medical journals

efy;

 

 

      -xk;-                  -xk;-                  -xk;-

cWg;gpdu;- II             cWg;gpdu; -I             jiytu;

 

 

 

 
 
[ THIRU.J.JUSTIN DAVID, M.A., M.L.,]
PRESIDENT
 
[ TMT.K.PRAMEELA, M.Com.,]
MEMBER
 
[ THIRU.D.BABU VARADHARAJAN, B.Sc., B.L.,]
MEMBER

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.