BEFORE THE A.P.STATE CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL COMMISSION: ATHYDERABAD.

F.A.No. 372 HYDERABAD

Between

1.  M/s Narne Estates (P) Ltd.,
rep. by its Managing Director
Office at No.1, Gunrock Enclave
Karkhana, Secunderabad-009

2.  The General Manager,
Narne Estates Pvt., Ltd.
Gunrock Enclave, Karkhana
Secunderabad-009

Lt. Col.D.Sivarama Prasad
S/o late Sri D.Ankamma, Aged 47 yrs
R/o H.No.A-17, Vedvihar, AWHO
Tirmulgherry, Secunderabad

                                                               Counsel for the Appellants                    

Counsel for the Respondents                

 QUORUM:SRI SYED ABDULLAH, HON’BLE MEMBER

Oral Order ( As per R.Lakshminarsimha Rao, Member)
     

       The opposite parties no.1 and 2 in C.C.No.404 of 2008 on the file of District Forum-III,Hyderabad 

             The opposite parties collected an amount of Rs.25,000/- towards developmental charges, Rs.6,000/- towards registration charges and Rs.5,000/- towards club fees from the complainant by issuing a nil balance due receipt on 23.1.2002.        

         The complainant never approached the appellants/opposite parties to clear the outstanding dues and get the plot registered and that the relief sought by the respondent/complainant is that of a civil nature and to enforce a contractual obligation of registering sale deed pertaining to immovable property a suit has to be instituted before the appropriate civil court for specific performance of contract. 

        Ex.B4 shows that the complainant has paid Rs.15,000/- towards the cost of the plot, Rs.62,500/- towards developmental charges, Rs.25,000/- towards registration charges.   

        Ex.A12 as well as Ex.A10 clearly indicates the payment of entire developmental charges by the complainant by the respective dates of issue of the documents. Ex.A10 was issued on 30.3.2000 whereas Ex.A12 was issued on 23.1.2000, admittedly both the documents were issued subsequent to the date of issue of Ex.B3.     

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                     KMK*