Maharashtra

Wardha

CC/07/56

Haridas Sakharamji Talwekar - Complainant(s)

Versus

Incharge Provinicial Automobile Co. Ltd. - Opp.Party(s)

Adv, A.A. Sadawarte

21 Jul 2008

ORDER


District Consumer Forum
Sewagram Road, Opposite Yashwant College
consumer case(CC) No. CC/07/56

Haridas Sakharamji Talwekar
...........Appellant(s)

Vs.

Incharge Provinicial Automobile Co. Ltd.
...........Respondent(s)


BEFORE:
1. Sau.Sushama W/O Pradeep Joshi 2. Shri Ramlal Bhavarlal Somani

Complainant(s)/Appellant(s):
1. Haridas Sakharamji Talwekar

OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
1. Incharge Provinicial Automobile Co. Ltd.

OppositeParty/Respondent(s):
1. Adv, A.A. Sadawarte

OppositeParty/Respondent(s):




ORDER

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.

ftYgk xzkgd rØkj fuokj.k eap] o/kkZ

 

 rØkj izdj.k Øekad % 56@2007                             nk[ky fnukad          % 30-07-2007

                                                                                    uksVhl rkehyhpk fn-% 27-11-2007

  fudky fnukad         % 25-07-2008

                         izdj.kkpk dkyko/kh  % 7 e- 28 fnol

 

 

gjhnkl l[kkjketh rGosdj]                                                                       ---rØkjdrkZ

o; 45 o”kZs] O;olk; % d`”kh]

jk-ok?kksyh] rk- fgax.k?kkV] ft- o/kkZ-

  

             & fo  #  /n  &

 

        bapktZ]                                                                                     ----fo#/ni{k@xSjvtZnkj

             izksfOgaf’k,y vkWVkseksckbZy da-fy-]

czkap ihaijh ¼es?ks½] vkohZ jksM] o/kkZ-

        egsanz vWaM egsanz da- fy- VªWDVj fMOghtu]

            }kjk eWusftax Mk;jsDVj] efganzk VkWoj]

            ojGh jksM ua-13] eqacbZ 400 018

        viksyks Vk;lZ da- fy-]

            }kjk eWusftax Mk;jsDVj] viksyks gkml]

            7] bafLVV~;w’kuy ,jh;k] lsDVj&32]

 xqjxko&122 001 ¼gjh;k.kk½

            fMOghtuy bapktZ vkWQ viksyks Vk;lZ da-fy-]

            Jhjke VkWoj] 8 ok ekGk] ,u vk; Vh fcYMhax]

            Lknj] ukxiwj-

 

U;k;eap x.kiqrhZ                         %                  Jh- jkeyky Hk-lksek.kh] ek-v/;{k

                                                            lkS- lq”kek  iz- tks’kh] ek-lnL;k

 

 

vtZnkj  ;kaps rQsZ                  %            vWM- Jh- ,-,-lnkorZs-

fo#/n Ik{k Ø-1 rQsZ                   %            xSjgtj-

fo#/n Ik{k Ø-2 rQsZ                   %            xSjgtj-

fo#/n Ik{k Ø-3o 4 rQsZ             %            Jh lat; tSu] eWustj] yhxy vWaM dkWaLVhVÓqVsM vkWFkkjhsVh-

 

vk  ns   ‘k

¼ ikjhr fnukad % 21-07-2008½

 

 

lkS- lq”kek tks’kh] ek- lnL;k] ;kaps dFkukuqlkj-

 

1-                 lnj rØkj rØkjdR;kZus fn-03-08-2007 jksth nk[ky dsyh vlwu rØkjdRkkZ gk fo#/ni{kkpk xzkgd vlwu R;kus fn-07-10-2006 jksth VªWDVj ekWMsy 575 ljiap gk [kjsnh dsyk o rks ?ksrsosGsl rØkjdR;kZus R;kps ekfxy Vk;lZ gs pkaxY;k izrhps ukgh vls y{kkr vkY;koj fo#/ni{kkyk lkafxrys- ijarw R;kauh Hkfo”;ke/;s dqBYkkgh iz’u ;s.kkj ukgh vls lkafxrY;kus R;kus VªWDVj gk ?ksryk- FkksM;kp fnolkae/;s VªWDVjps ekfxy Vk;lZoj Hksxk IkMysY;k vkgsr vls y{kkr vkY;keqGs R;kauh fo#/ni{kkyk lkafxrys o rs cnyowu pkaxY;k izrhps Vk;lZ ns.;kph fouarh dsyh- R;kosGsl Vk;lZph fLFkrh cnyok vls lkax.;kr vkys- ijarw R;kpk dkgh mi;ksx >kyk ukgh o fn-16-03-2007 jksth ekfxy Vk;j VªWDVj R;kaP;k ?kjkleksj mHkk vlrkauk QqVyk- rØkjdR;kZl ‘ksrkrhy dkekdjhrk gk VªWDVj vko’;d vlY;kus R;kus rkcMrksc #-12]110@& ps ufou Vk;j o VîqCl [kjsnh dsys- fo#/ni{kkus v’kkizdkjph nks”kiw.kZ Vk;lZ rØkjdR;kZl iqjowu vuqfpr O;kikjh izFkspk voyac dsysyk vkgs- Eg.kwu lnj rØkj eapkr nk[ky d#u fouarh dsyh dh] fo#/ni{kkus ufou Vk;j o VîqClph fdaer #-12]110@&] rlsp tqus Vk;lZ cnyowu ufou Vk;lZ ns.;kr ;kos] ekufld =klkdjhrk #-10]000@&] #-3]000@& rØkjhpk [kpZ o eapkl ;ksX; okVsy rks vkns’k ns.;kr ;kok v’kh fouarh dsysyh vkgs-

 

2-                 fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 o 2 ;kauk eapkekQZr uksVhl ikBfoY;koj R;kauh eapkleksj gtj gksmu vkiys ys[kh mRrj nk[ky dsys ukgh- Eg.kwu R;kaP;kfo#/n mRrjkf’kok; vkns’k ikfjr dj.;kr ;smu izdj.k R;kapkfo#/n ,drQhZ lquko.khdjhrk Bso.;kr vkys-

 

 

3-                 fo#/ni{k Ø- 3 o 4 ;kauh vkiys ys[kh mRrj nk[ky dsys- R;kauh rØkjdR;kZps vk{ksi QsVkGys vlwu rØkjdR;kZauh fo#/ni{k Ø- 3 o 4 fo#/n dqBY;kgh izdkjph ys[kh rØkj fnyh ukgh- fo#/ni{kkaP;k dLVej ÝsaMyh ikWfylhuqlkj Vk;lZe/khy mRiknukrhy nks”k vlY;kl izksMkVk csflloj cnyowu ns.;kr ;srs- rØkjdR;kZus lknj dsysys Vk;lZ fo#/ni{kkaP;k VsDuhdy lfOgZl baftfu;jus rikl.kh dsyh vlrk R;ke/;s dqBY;kgh mRiknukrhy nks”k vk<Gwu vkyk ukgh- rlsp Vk;lZ QqV.;kps dkj.k gs  baEiWDV czsd (impact break) “tyre stroke with any sharp external object while in speed and got damaged” vkgs- R;keqGs fo#/ni{kkauh dks.krhgh nks”kiw.kZ lsok fnysyh ukgh- rØkjdR;kZauh ;kiwohZ dks.krhgh uksVhl fnysyh ukgh- rlsp rØkjdR;kZauh lnj Vk;lZe/;s mRiknukrhy nks”k gksrk] ;kdjhrk dks.krkgh rK vgoky eapkl lknj dsysyk ukgh- Eg.kwu ;k eqn~n;koj lnj rØkj [kjht djkoh v’kh fouarh fo#/ni{kkauh dsysyh vkgs-

 

4-                 lnj izdj.kkr rØkjdR;kZpk vtZ] R;kauh ;knhizek.ks nk[ky dsysyh dkxni=s] rlsp dfe’uj Jh- /kuat; ,djs ;kapk vgoky] fo#/ni{k Ø- 3 o 4 ;kaps ys[kh mRrj] R;kauh nk[ky dsysyh dkxni=s] rlsp ‘kiFki= bR;knhaps lq{ejhR;k voyksdu o iMrkG.kh dsyh vlrk eapklel{k iq<hy eqn~ns mifLFkr >kys o vkns’k ikfjr dj.;kr vkyk-

¼1½            fo#/ni{kkauh rØkjdR;kZyk mRiknukrhy nks”k vlysys Vk;j fodwu lsosr =qVh o vuqfpr O;kikjh izFkspk voyac dsyk vkgs dk; \

¼2½            rØkjdrkZ gk uwdlku HkjikbZ o dksVZ [kpZ ?ks.;kl ik= vkgs dk; \

 

fu”d”kZ

5-            rØkjdR;kZus fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 ;kapsdMwu rØkjdR;kZus VªWDVj [kjsnh dsyk o R;kpk Vk;j gk fo#/ni{k Ø- 3 o 4 ;kauh mRikfnr dsysyk vkgs ;k eq|koj mHk; Ik{kkr okn ukgh- rØkjdR;kZus fn-07-10-2007 jksth VªWDVj [kjsnh dsyk o R;kuarj rkcMrksc fn-30-01-2007 jksth Vk;je/;s Hksxk vk<Gwu vkY;k- Eg.kwu fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 ;kauh R;kauk rkcMrksc dGfoys o Vk;j cnyowu ns.;kph ekx.kh dsyh- ijarw fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 ;kauh R;kph rØkj gh fo#/ni{k Ø- 3 o 4 ;kapsi;Zar iksgkspfoyh ukgh vls dkxni=ko#u fnlwu ;srs-  rlsp rØkjdR;kZus rØkjh ;k fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 ;kapsdMs fn-30-01-2007] 13-03-2007 jksth dsY;k gksR;k o R;kph iksp ns[khy dkxni=kaoj vkgs- ijarw R;kP;k rØkjhph mphr n[ky fo#/ni{kkdMwu ?ksrY;k xsyh ukgh o R;kuarj fn-16-03-2007 jksth lnj Vk;j gk QqVyk ghlq/nk rØkj fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 ;kapsdMs rØkjdR;kZus dsysyh vkgs- fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 ;kauk eapkpk uksVhl feGkyk- ijarw R;kauh lnj izdj.kh ys[kh mRrj nk[ky dsys ukgh o ;k eq|koj dks.krsgh Li”Vhdj.k eapkl fnys ukgh- Eg.kwu fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 ;kauh LFkkfud foØsrk ;k ukR;kus rØkjdR;kZl ;ksX; R;k lsok u nsmu lsose/;s =qVh dsysyh vkgs-

 

5-                 fo#/ni{k Ø- 3 ;kauh R;kaP;k ys[kh mRrjke/;s lnj Vk;j gk v.kdqphnkj oLrwpk rMk[kk clY;kus rks QqVyk vkgs o gk mRiknukrhy nks”k ukgh] Eg.kwu rs dqBY;kgh izdkjph uwdlku HkjikbZ ns.;kl tckcnkj ukgh vls dFku dsys vkgs o R;kdjhrk R;kauh R;kaps}kjk rK vgoky nk[ky dsyk vkgs- ijarw gk vgoky R;kaP;k fujh{k.kk[kkyh cufoyk gksrk] R;kaps ‘kiFki= ;k vgokykP;k iq”VîFkZ nk[ky dsys ulY;kus gk vgoky eapkl xzkg; /kjrk ;s.kkj ukgh- R;keqGs rØkjdR;kZP;k VªWDVjpk Vk;j gk baEiWDV czsdeqGs QqVyk vls Li”V gksr ukgh-

 

6-                 rØkjdR;kZus eapkl lnj Vk;jph rikl.kh gh rK O;DrhadMwu dj.;kr ;koh] ;kdjhrk vtZ nk[ky dsyk gksrk rks eatwj gksmu Jh- /kuat; ,djs ;kauh lnj Vk;jph rikl.kh dsyh o R;kapk vgoky] Vk;jps QksVksxzk¶l eapkleksj nk[ky dsys- R;kaP;k ers lnj vk;j gk brD;k deh vo/khe/;s {krhxzLr gks.;kps dkj.k gs R;krhy mRiknukrhy nks”kkeqGs vkgs- lnj vgoky gk nk[ky >kkY;kuarj R;koj fo#/ni{kkus dks.krhgh gjdr la/kh nsmugh ?ksryh ukgh- Eg.kwu eapkus lnj vgokykuqlkj Vk;je/;s mRiknukrhy nks”k gksrk] R;keqGs rks QqVyk gs eapkle{k Li”V >kysys vkgs- rØkjdR;kZl ufou Vk;j [kjsnh djkos ykxys vkgs- R;keqGs rØkjdrkZ gk Vk;jph fdaer fo#/ni{k Ø- 3 o 4 ;kaP;kdMwu olqy d#u ?ks.;kl ik= vkgs- lnj izdj.kh oknxzLr Vk;j rØkjdR;kZus cnywu ?ksrysys vkgs- Eg.kwu oknxzLr mRiknukpk nks”k nwj dj.ks ‘kD; ukgh- Eg.kwu xzk-la-dk- 1986 ps dye 14 ¼d½ uqlkj Vk;jph fdaer eatwj dj.ks U;k;ksfpr jkghy- ijarw lnj Vk;j izFken’kZuh QksVkso#u okijysys o ?kklysys fnlr vkgs o R;kpk ?klkjk >kysyk vkgs Eg.kwu  fdaer olqy djrkauk uO;k Vk;jPkh fdaer #-12]110@& e/kwu 30 VDds ?klkjk deh d#u jDde fo#/ni{k Ø- 3 o 4 g;kauh  rØkjdR;kZyk n;koh vls vkns’khr dj.ks U;k;ksfpr jkghy-

 

 

8-                 rØkjdR;kZph fo#/ni{k Ø- 2 ;kauh mRikfnr dsysY;k VªWDVjyk ykxysY;k Vk;jcn~ny okn mifLFkr dsysyk vkgs- ;ksX; o nks”kjfgr lkeku@Vk;j ykowu o foØhiwoZ ijh{k.k d#u VªWDVj ekdZsVe/;s foØhlkBh ikBfo.ks o fod.ks g;kaph tckcnkjh fo#/ni{k Ø- 2 ph uDdhp vkgs- Eg.kwu nks”kiw.kZ Vk;j rØkjdR;kZi;Zar iksgkspys o R;kP;k =klkps fujkdj.k fo#/ni{k Ø- 2 ;kauh dsys ukgh- Eg.kwu fo#/ni{k Ø- 2 gs brj fo#/ni{kk brdsp tckcnkj vkgsr-

 

9-                 fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 ;kauh R;kauk osGksosGh lnj Vk;jckcr rØkjh izkIr gksmuns[khy R;kph dks.khgh n[ky ?ksryh ukgh- Eg.kwu R;kauh lsose/;s =qVh dsyssyh vkgs o ;kdjhrk rs rØkjdR;kZl uwdlku HkjikbZ ns.;kl tckcnkj vkgsrvls eapkps er vkgs-  fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 rs 4 ;kauh rØkjhps fuokj.k R;kaP;kp ikrGhoj dsys ukgh] R;keqGs rØkjdR;kZl eapkleksj ;smu rØkj nk[ky djkoh ykxyh- Eg.kwu rØkjdrkZ gk fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 rs 4 ;kaP;kdMwu dksVZ [kpZ feG.;kl ik= Bjrks gs U;k;skfpr] fo/khxzkg; vkf.k la;qDrhd vkgs- djhrk eap lnj izdj.kh [kkyhyizek.ks vkns’k ikfjr djhr vkgs-

 

vkns’k

 

            rØkjdR;kZph rØkj va’kr% eatwj dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-

2&v½            fo#/ni{k Ø- 3 o 4 ;kauh rØkjdR;kZauk ufou fodr ?ksrysY;k Vk;jph fdaer #-12]110@& e/kwu 30 VDds ?klkjk  otk d#u jDde ns; djkoh-

                                                fdaok

2&c½            fo#/ni{k Ø- 3 o 4 ;kauh rØkjdR;kZauk Vk;jph fdaer iw.kZ fnyh rj rØkjdR;kZus tqus Vk;j lkWYOgst Eg.kwu fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 ;kaP;kdMs ijr djkos-

            fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 rs 4 ;kauh lnj rØkjhpk [kpZ Eg.kwu #- 500@& izR;sdh rØkjdR;kZauk |kos-

            fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 o 2 ;kauh lsosrhy =qVhdjhrk #-2]000@& uwdlku HkjikbZiksVh rØkjdR;kZauk |kos-

        ojhy vkns’kkph iwrZrk fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 rs 4 ;kauh vkns’kkph izr feGkY;kiklwu 30 fnolkP;k vkr djkoh vU;Fkk ojhy vkns’khr jdesoj n-lk-n-‘ks- 15 VDds O;kt ns; jkghy-

 

        mHk; Ik{kkauk ;k vkns’kkph lgh f’kDD;kph izekf.kr izr fu%’kqYd ns.;kr ;koh- fo#/ni{k Ø- 1 o 2 eapkr xSjgtj vlY;kus R;kauk lnj vkns’kkph izr iksLVk}kjs ikBfo.;kr ;koh-

            eapke/;s ek- lnL;kadjhrk fnysys ¼c½ o ¼d½ QkbZYlP;k izrh rØkjdR;kZauh ?ksowu tkO;kr-

 

¼lkS- lq”kek tks’kh½                     ¼jkeyky lksek.kh½

                                lnL;k                                     v/;{k

 




......................Sau.Sushama W/O Pradeep Joshi
......................Shri Ramlal Bhavarlal Somani