Kerala

Alappuzha

CC/08/10

Annie[30] - Complainant(s)

Versus

Govt; of Kerala represented by The District Collector,Alappuzha - Opp.Party(s)

K.R.Chandrasekharan Nair

29 Sep 2009

ORDER

 
Complaint Case No. CC/08/10
 
1. Annie[30]
W/O Viswanathan,Thazhathil veedu,Pavumpa North,Pavumpa P.O,Karunagappally.
 
BEFORE: 
 HONORABLE JIMMY KORAH PRESIDENT
 HONORABLE K.Anirudhan Member
 HONORABLE Smt;Shajitha Beevi Member
 
PRESENT:
 
ORDER

 

                                       {io. sI. A\ncp²³ (sa¼À)

Filed on 16.1.2008

 

        {ioaXn. B\n Cu t^mdw ap¼msI FXnÀI£nI¡v FXnsc 16.01.2008- ]cmXn t_m[n¸n¨n«pÅXmWv.  ]cmXnbpsS {]kà `mKw C{]ImcamWv.   tIcfm kÀ¡mcnsâ BtcmKyhIp¸nsâ t\XrXz¯n amthen¡c Kh¬saâv Bip]{Xnbn \S¯nb IpSpw:_mkq{XW Iym¼n sh¨v hÔywIcW ikv{X{Inbbv¡v (Sterilization) lÀPn¡mcn hnt[bbmbn.   11.12.2003- Bbncp¶p sterilization.  Strerilization \S¡pt¼mÄ lÀPn¡mcnbv¡v c­v Ip«nIÄ D­mbncp¶p.  AhcpsS km¼¯nI \ne ]cnKWn¨v lÀPn¡mcn {]khw \nÀ¯m³ Xocpam\nbv¡pIbmbncp¶p.  AhcpsS imcocnI £oW¯n\pw aäpw sImÃw hnIvtSmdnb Bip]{Xnbn Ahsc ]cntim[n¨ kabw AhÀ ho­pw KÀ`nWnbmsW¶dnªp.  X·qew hfscb[nIw am\knI {]bmkw D­mbn.  6.7.2006- Sn Bip]{XnbnÂsh¨v AhÀ Hcp B¬Ip«nsb {]khn¨p.  imcocnIØnXn tamiamIpIbpw km¼¯nI ØnXn hjfmIpIbpw sNbvXp.  c­mw FXnÀ I£n A{i²ambpw DZmko\ambpw sterilization \S¯nbXp sIm­mWv lÀPn¡mcn KÀ`w [cn¨Xpw {]khn¨Xpw.   X·qew lÀPn¡mcnbv¡p­mb IjvS\jvS§Ä¡v FXnÀI£nIÄ _m²yØcmWv.  BbXn\m lÀPn¡mcnbv¡v \mev e£w cq] FXnÀI£nIfn \n¶pw CuSm¡n Xcp¶Xn\p th­nbmWv Cu ]cmXn.

 

        2.  Cu t^md¯n \n¶pw FXnÀI£nIÄ¡v t\m«okv Ab¨n«pÅXpw

FXnÀI£n t\m«okv ssI¸än t^md¯n lmPcmbn hniZamb tÌävsaâv ^b sNbvXn«pÅXmWv. 

 

        3.  c­mw FXnÀI£nbpsS tÌävsaânÂ, lÀPn¡mcnbv¡v C§s\ Hcp lÀPn ^b sN¿m³ AhImiansöpw, H¶mwI£nbv¡v lÀPn ^b sN¿p¶Xn\v t\cn«v Statutory Notice \evInbn«nsöpw ]dbp¶p.  H¶mw FXnÀI£nbpsS `mK¯v bmsXmcphn[amb tkh\hogvNbpw A{i²bpw h¶n«nÃsb¶pw ]dbp¶p­v.  AhÀ sterilization \S¯nb hnhcw aäpw k½Xnbv¡pIbpw Tube sterilization kzoIcn¨n«pÅXpamWv.  Sterilization kab¯v lÀPn¡mcntbmSpw `À¯mhnt\mSpw Tube Sterilization \S¯p¶Xnsâ FÃm hcpwhcmbvIIfpw FXnÀI£n hniZambn ]dªp a\Ênem¡n sImSp¡pIbpw AXv ]cn]qÀ® {]Xnhn[n Asöpw Ahsc [cn¸n¨n«pÅXpamWv.  KÀ`[mcW¯n\v B´cnIambn km²yXIÄ Cu Sterilization--\v Ds­¶pÅ Imcyhpw hfsc hyàambn hmZntbbpw `À¯mhnt\bpw [cn¸n¨n«pÅXmWv.  Cu hn[amb km²yX DÅXv AdnªpsIm­mWv 11.12.2003- Mini Lap Technique Sterilization kzoIcn¨Xv.  Sterilization ap³]v hmZnbptSbpw `À¯mhntâbpw ]qÀ®k½Xw hm§nbncp¶p.  c­mw FXnÀI£n {]kvXpX operation \S¯nbXv AXoh {i²tbmSpw bmsXmcp hogvNbpw kw`hnbv¡msXbmbncp¶p.  c­v hÀj¯n\pta KÀ`[mcWw D­mIm³ km²yX Ds­¶pÅ hnhcw Ahsc [cn¸n¨ncp¶XpamWv.  c­mw hÀjw IgnªmWv hmZn KÀ`nWnbmbXv.  AXp Xs¶ c­mw {]XnbpsS `mK¯v 11.12.2003- sterilization- A{i² kw`hn¨psh¶v ]dbm³ IgnbnÃ.  hÔoIcW ikv{X{Inb Nnet¸mÄ ]cmPbs¸Sm³ km²yX DÅXmbn XnI¨pw Adnbmambncp¶p.  adn¨v kw`hn¨m tUmIvSÀs¡Xnsc \S]Snbv¡v Xp\nbpIbnsöv AhÀ c­mw FXnÀI£nsb [cn¸n¨n«pÅXpamWv.  Xs¶bpaà sterilization operation IgnªpÅ check up-\v H¶pw hmZn c­mw FXnÀI£nsb kao]nbv¡pItbm aäpw sNbvXn«nÃ.  Minilap Technique Sterilization--\v BtKmfambn AwKoIcnbv¡s¸«n«pÅXpw, KÀ`[mcW¯n\v km²yXbpÅXmsW¶pw I­n«pÅXmWv.  B hnhc§sfÃmw hmZntbbpw `À¯mhnt\bpw [cn¸n¨n«pÅXpamWv.  adn¨pÅ Zpcmtcm]W§Ä XnI¨pw kXyhncp²hpw kmam\y \oXnbv¡p \nc¡m¯XpamWv.  FXnÀI£nbpsS `mK¯v bmsXmcphn[¯nepÅ hogvNbp­mbn«nÃm¯Xpw hmZnbpsS bmsXmcp hn[amb ]cnlmc¯n\pw c­mw FXnÀI£n D¯chmZnbÃm¯XpamWv.  10,000/- cq] \jvS]cnlmcw FXnÀI£nbv¡p \evIn lÀPn XÅn D¯chp­mIWw. 

 

        3.  1-)o FXnÀI£nbpw Bt£]w t_m[n¸n¨n«pÅXpw Bt£]§sfÃmw c­mw FXnÀI£nbpsS tÌävsaân\v Xpeyambn«pÅXpamWv.  bmsXmcp ASnØm\hpanÃmsX ^b sNbvXncnbv¡p¶ lÀPn H¶mw FXnÀI£nbpsS sNehv \evIn XÅn D¯chp­mIWsa¶v t_m[n¸n¨n«pÅXmWv.

 

        4..  Cu `mKw Imcy§Ä ]cnKWn¨v Xmsg ]dbp¶h hniIe\w sN¿m³ t^mdw Xocpam\n¨p.

        1) FXnÀI£nIfpsS `mK¯v tkh\¯n hogvN h¶n«pt­m?

        2)lÀPn¡mcnbv¡v \jvS]cnlmc¯n\pw aäp sNehpIÄ¡pw AÀlXbpt­m?

 

         5.Imcy§Ä(1)& (2):-  lÀPn¡mcnbpsS `mK¯v \n¶v sXfnhv kXyhmMvaqehpw sXfnhv tcJIfpw  lmPcm¡pIbpw lÀPn¡mcnsb hnkvXcnbv¡pIbpw FXnÀ`mKw

t{ImÊv hnkvXmcw \S¯nbn«pÅXpamWv.  sXfnhv tcJIÄ A1 apX A8 hsc A¡an«n«pÅXmWv.  A1  ENT specialist acp¶p Ipdn¨p sImSp¯ No«mWv.  A2 - A4 sImÃw Victoria Hospital þ \n¶pw acp¶p Ipdn¨ No«mWv.  A5   Dr.M.K. Kavitha----bpsS prescription BWv.  Ext.A6 sImÃw Victoria Hospital-se Antenatal Card.  A7 Dr.Srasa-bpss prescription BWv.  Ext.A8  operation---\p tijw P\n¨ Ip«nbpsS P\\ kÀ«n^n¡ämWv.

 

        6.  FXnÀI£nbpsS `mK¯v \n¶pw sXfnhv kXyhmMvaqehpw tcJIfpw lmPcm¡pIbpw FXnÀI£nsb hnkvXcnbv¡pIbpw hmZn`mKw FXr hnkvXmcw \S¯nbncp¶XpamWv.  tcJIÄ B1- Dw B2--Dw lmPcm¡nbncp¶p.  B1 tcJ sterilization kabw hmZn ssI¸änb XpIbpsS hnhcw ImWnbv¡p¶ tcJbmWv.  B2 tcJ hmZnbpsS hÔoIcW ikv{X{Inbbv¡pÅ k½X]{Xhpw At]£bpw.  CXn 1 apX 10 hscbpÅ hnhc§fn hÔoIcW ikv{X{Insb kw_Ôn¨v FÃm \n_Ô\Ifpw hniZambn {]Xn]mZn¨n«pÅXmWv.  Cu tIÊn Dr. Lalithambika, Prof: HOD., Medical College Hospital, Alappuzha--sb km£nbmbn hnkvXcn¨n«pÅXmWv.  AhÀ {]kvXpX Hm¸tdj³ hnPb{]Zasöpw  ovulation \S¡m³ km²yXbps­¶pw AhcpsS {]hÀ¯n ]cnNb¯n sterilization ]cmPbs¸« Hcp]mSv  kw`h§Ä D­mbn«ps­¶pw Hm¸tdj³ sN¿pt¼mÄ tUmIvSÀamÀ CXv

]dªpsImSp¡mdps­¶pw samgn \evInbn«p­v. 

 

                7.   tIÊnse FÃm Imcy§fpw R§Ä  hniZambn hniIe\w sN¿pIbpw t^md¯n lmPcm¡nbncp¶ FÃm tcJIfpw th­hn[w ]cntim[nbv¡pIbpw aäpw sNbvXn«pÅXmWv.  lÀPn¡mcnbpsS CjvS{]Imcw c­mw FXnÀI£n Sn operation \S¯nbncp¶XmWv.  Bkabw Cu operation--s\ ¡pdn¨v FÃm Imcy§fpw  hniZambn c­mw FXnÀI£n lÀPn¡mcntbmSv ]dªn«pÅXpw, Cu operation KÀ`w XSbm\pÅ ]cn]qÀ® {]Xnhn[nbsöpw [cn¸n¨n«pÅXpw consent H¸n«psImSp¯n«pÅXpamWv (Ext.B2).  Sterilization operation Ignªv 2 hÀj¯n\p tijamWv lÀPn¡mcn KÀ`nWnbmbXv.  {]kvXpX Hm¸tdj³ KÀ`[mcWw XSbm³ ]cn]qÀ®amb Hcp operation AÃm¯ ØnXnbv¡v 2 hÀjw Ignªv lÀPn¡mcn KÀ`hXnbmbXv operation \S¯nb tUmIvSdpsS tkh\¯n DÅ hogvNbpw A{i²bpw aqeamsW¶v ]dbm³ IgnbnÃ.  IqSmsX Expert km£n F¶ \nebn Dr. Lalithambika, Medical College Hospital, Alappuzha--bpsS A`n{]mb¯nepw {]kvXpX operation KÀ`[mcWw XSbm³ ]cn]qÀ®ambpw Ignbnà F¶p samgn \evInbn«p­v.  am{Xaà C¯cw KÀ`[mcWw [mcmfw \S¡mdps­¶v Ext.A5 I­Xn \n¶pw lÀPn¡mcn KÀ`nWnbmsW¶v Xncn¨dnª kabw \nba]camb M.T.P. bmsXmcp XSÊhpw D­mbncp¶nsöv km£n samgn X¶n«pÅXmWv.  tIÊnse FÃm Imcy§fpw samgnIfpw aäp tcJIfpw hniZambn ]cntim[n¨Xn c­mw FXnÀI£nbpsS `mKs¯ tkh\¯n hogvNtbm A{i²tbm Is­¯m³ Ignbm¯ ØnXnbv¡v lÀPn¡mcnbpsS ]cmXn A\phZnbv¡m³ IgnbmsX h¶ncnbv¡p¶p. 

       

                Cu kmlNcy¯n lÀPn XÅn hn[n¨ncnbv¡p¶p.

       

                2009 sk]väw_À amkw 9-)o XobXn Hm¸¬ t^md¯n Cu D¯chv ]pds¸Sphn¨ncnbv¡p¶p.

 

                                                                H¸v/-    {io.sI.A\ncp²³.

                                                                H¸v/-    {io.Pn½n tImc .

                                                        H¸v/-    {ioaXn.F³.jmPnXm _ohn.

A\p_Ô tcJIÄ:-

]cmXn¡mcnbpsS sXfnhpIÄ:-

 

PW1            --               B\n (km£n)

Ext.A1             -                       ENT Specialist acp¶v Ipdn¨p sImSp¯ No«v

Ext.A2 - A4     -                       Victoria Hospital--\n¶pw acp¶p Ipdn¨ No«pIÄ

Ext.A5             -                       Dr.M.K.Kavitha-bpsS prescription

Ext.A6             -                       Kollam Victoria Hospital-se Antenatal card

Ext.A7             -                       Dr.Sarasa--bpsS prescription

Ext.A8             -                       Birth Certificate (True Copy)

 

FXnÀI£nbpsS sXfnhpIÄ:-

 

RW1                -                       Dr.Lalithambika (km£n)

RW2                -                       Dr.Usha.S. (km£n)

Ext.B1              -                       Sterilization kabw hmZn ssI¸änb XpIbpsS hnhcw

                                ImWnbv¡p¶ tcJ

Ext.B2         ----               hmZnbpsS k½X]{Xhpw At]£bpw

 

// icn]IÀ¸v //

 

                                                                                                                                                                        D¯chn³ {]Imcw

 

 

                                                                                                                                                                        ko\nbÀ kq{]­v

To

                ]cmXn¡mcn/FXnÀI£nIÄ/S.F.   

 

Typed by:-pr/- 

 

 Compared by:-

 
 
[HONORABLE JIMMY KORAH]
PRESIDENT
 
[HONORABLE K.Anirudhan]
Member
 
[HONORABLE Smt;Shajitha Beevi]
Member

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.