Maharashtra

Ahmednagar

cc/05/122

Shivaji Bandu Kshirsagar - Complainant(s)

Versus

Executive Engg. MSEB, - Opp.Party(s)

Batuke/Budhawant

08 Jul 2010

ORDER


District Consumer ForumParag Building, Opp To Collector Office, District Ahmednagar. Maharashtra
CONSUMER CASE NO. 05 of 122
1. Shivaji Bandu KshirsagarGhotan, Tal Shevgaon, Dist Ahmednagar ...........Respondent(s)


For the Appellant :
For the Respondent :

Dated : 08 Jul 2010
ORDER

Consumer Court Lawyer

Best Law Firm for all your Consumer Court related cases.

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!
5.0 (615)

Bhanu Pratap

Featured Recomended
Highly recommended!

Experties

Consumer Court | Cheque Bounce | Civil Cases | Criminal Cases | Matrimonial Disputes

Phone Number

7982270319

Dedicated team of best lawyers for all your legal queries. Our lawyers can help you for you Consumer Court related cases at very affordable fee.

ãä•ãÊÖã ØãÆãև㊠¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ãÌããÀ¥ã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã,‚ãֽ㪶ãØãÀ.                                  

 

          ½ãã.‚㣾ãàã  : Ñããè.Ôãì£ãã‡ãŠÀ.‡ãñŠ.ãäºã¶ãÌã¡ñ.      

                                                ½ãã.ÔãªÔ¾ãã  : ‚ãù¡.Ôããõ.½ããä¶ãÓãã ‡ãõŠËãÔã Œã¡ã½ã‡ãŠÀ.

                                               ----------------------------------------------

                                                   Ôããè.¹ããè.†.¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ‰ãŠ½ããâ‡ãŠ    :   122/2005.

                                               ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ªãŒãË  ã䪶ããâ‡ãŠ      :   21/04/2005.

                                               ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ã‡ãŠãËãè ã䪶ããâ‡ãŠ     :   08/07/2010.

                                              -----------------------------------------------

 

ãäÎãÌãã•ããè ºãâ¡ì ãäàãÀÔããØãÀ.                                     ----- ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ.

Àã.Üããñ›¶ã,¦ãã.ÎãñÌãØããâÌã,

ãä•ã.‚ãֽ㪶ãØãÀ.

 

          ãäÌãÁ£ª

 

[1]    ‚ããä¼ãâ¾ã¦ãã,                                                      ----- Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ.

½ãÖãÀãÓ›È À㕾ã ãäÌã²ãì¦ã

½ãÖã½ãâ¡ß [ØãÆã½ããè¥ã]‚ãֽ㪶ãØãÀ.

Ôã½ãàã Ñããè.¹ãƪãè¹ã Àã£ãñÎãã½ã ÔããÌãâ¦ã.

¼ãÀãÀãè ¹ã©ã‡ãŠ ‚ãֽ㪶ãØãÀ.

 

[2]    „¹ã ‚ããä¼ã¾ãâ¦ãã,

½ãÖãÀãÓ›È À㕾ã ãäÌã•ã ½ãÖã½ãâ¡ß

ÎãñÌãØããâÌã,ãä•ã.‚ãֽ㪶ãØãÀ.

Ôã½ãàã Ñããè.ºã¶Îããè ‡ãŠãòã䡺ãã ¹ããâØãÀñ.

ÎãâÌãØããâÌã ¾ããâÞãñ ÌãÀ ºã•ããÌã¥ããè ÌÖãÌããè.

 

[3]    †‡ãŠ¶ãã©ã ¶ããÀã¾ã¥ã ‡ãŠßâºãñ.

Ìãã¾ãÀ½ã¶ã,Üããñ›¥ã,¦ãã.ÎãñÌãØããâÌã,

ãä•ã.‚ãֽ㪶ãØãÀ.

 

 

„¹ããäÔ©ã¦ããè

[¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ ¾ããâÞãñ Ìã‡ãŠãèË : Ñããè.†.¡ãè.Þããõ£ãÀãè.]

 [Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞãñ Ìã‡ãŠãèË : Ñããè.ãäºãÖã¥ããè.]

ãä¶ã‡ãŠã˹ã¨ã

{ ´ãÀã : ½ãã.‚㣾ãàã,Ñããè.Ôãì£ãã‡ãŠÀ.‡ãñŠ.ãäºã¶ãÌã¡ñ.}

................................................................................................

 

[1]              ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¹ãÆÔ¦ãì¦ãÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞãã •ããñ ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌãŸã ºã⪠‡ãñŠËã Öãñ¦ãã ¦ããñ ¹ãìÌãÃÌã¦ã •ããñ¡î¶ã ªñ¥¾ããÔããŸãè Ìã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ‡ãŠã¤î¶ã ¶ãñËñËñ ãä½ã›À ¹ãìÌãÃÌã¦ã •ããñ¡î¶ã ãä½ãߥ¾ããÔããŸãè ªŒãË ‡ãñŠËãè ‚ããÖñ.  ¦¾ããâÞãñ ½Ö¥ã¥ãñ ©ããñ¡‡ã‹¾ãã¦ã ŒããËãèË ¹ãƽãã¥ãñ ‚ããÖñ.

 

                   ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ªì‡ãŠã¶ããÔããŸãè Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ½ãâ¡ß㠇㊡î¶ã Ôã¶ã 2000 ÔããËãè ãäÌã²ãî¦ã •ããñ¡¥ããè ‡ãŠÁ¶ã Üãñ¦ãËãè Öãñ¦ããè.  ãäª.09-08-2004 Àãñ•ããè Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ªì‡ãŠã¶ãã¦ã ‚ããËñ.  ¹ãÀâ¦ãî ¦¾ããÌãñßãè ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌãŸã ºã⪠‚ãÔãʾãã½ãìßñ ¦ãñ ¹ãÀ¦ã ØãñËñ.  ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ Öñ ¹ãì¶Öã ãäª.10-08-2004 Àãñ•ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ªì‡ãŠã¶ãã¦ã ‚ããËñ.  ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ã㠽֥㥾ãã ¶ãìÔããÀ ¦¾ãã ãäªÌãÎããè Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¶ãâ.2 ¾ããâÞãñ ‚ããªñÎããÌãÁ¶ã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¶ãâ.3 ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ªì‡ãŠã¶ãã¦ã ºãÔããäÌãËñËñ ãä½ã›À ‡ãŠã¤î¶ã ¶ãñËñ Ìã ºãñ‡ãŠã¾ãªñÎããèÀ ãäÀ¦¾ãã ¦¾ããâÞãã ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌãŸã Œãâ¡ãè¦ã ‡ãñŠËã.  †Ìã¤ñÞã ¶ãÌÖñ ¦ãÀ ãäª.12-08-2004 Àãñ•ããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.87,850/- Þãñ ãäºãË ¦¾ããâ¶ãã ªñ…¶ã ¦ããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã ¼ãÀ¥¾ããÔã ÔããâãäØã¦ãËñ.   ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ãäÌãÁ£ª Œããñ›¾ãã ½ã•ã‡ãîŠÀãÞããè Ìããè•ã ÞããñÀãèÞããè ãä¹ãŠ¾ããê ‡ãŠãñ›ãæ㠪ãŒãË ‡ãñŠËãè.   ¾ãã ÔãÌãà ‡ãŠãÀ¥ããÌãÁ¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãŠÀãÌããè ‚ãÎããè ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ÎãñÌã›ãè ãäÌã¶ãâ¦ããè ‡ãñŠËãè. 

 

[2]              Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞããè ‡ãõŠãä¹ãŠ¾ã¦ã ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.15 Ëã ªãŒãË ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ãäÌãÁ£ª ‡ãñŠËñËñ ‚ããÀãñ¹ã ¶ãã‡ãŠãÀËñ.   ¦ã©ãããä¹ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ Öñ ¦¾ããâÞãñ ØãÆãև㊠‚ãÔãʾããÞãñ ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ½ã㶾㠇ãñŠËñ.    Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞãñ ¾ãã Ôã⪼ããæ㠂ãÔãñ ½Ö¥ã¥ãñ ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ã㠹㊇㋦ã 0.3 ãä‡ãŠËãñ ÌÖù› Þãã ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌãŸã ½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãñŠËã ‚ãÔã¦ããâ¶ãã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ÌãñØãÌãñØãß¾ãã ̾ãÌãÔãã¾ããÔããŸãè •ããªãÞããè Ìããè•ã Ìãã¹ãÀËãè.   †Ìã¤ñÞã ¶ãÌÖñ ¦ãÀ ¼ãÀãÀãè ¹ã©ã‡ãŠã¶ãñ •¾ãã ÌãñßñÔã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ªì‡ãŠã¶ããÔã ¼ãñ› ãäªËãè ¦¾ããÌãñßãè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ‚ãÔãñ ãä¶ãªÎãöããÔã ‚ããËñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ãäÌã²ãî¦ã Ìãã¹ãÀã ºããºã¦ã ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ãä½ã›À½ã£¾ãñ ºãÀñÞãÔãñ ¹ãñŠÀºãªË ‡ãñŠËñËñ Öãñ¦ãñ.   ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ãä½ã›À ½ã£ããèË ¦ããÀã ‡ãŠã¤î¶ã ¦¾ããâÞããè •ããñ¡¥ããè ©ãñ› [¡ã¾ãÀñ‡ã‹› ‡ãŠ¶ãñ‡ã‹Îã¶ã] ªìÔã-¾ãã Ìãã¾ãÀËã ‡ãñŠËñËãè Öãñ¦ããè.   ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦¾ãã ãä½ã›À½ã£¾ãñ ãäÌã²ãî¦ã Ìãã¹ãÀãÞããè ¶ããòª Öãñ¦ã ¶ãÌÖ¦ããè.   ‚ãÎãã ¹ãƇãŠãÀñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè Ìããè•ãñÞããè ÞããñÀãè ‡ãñŠËãè Öãñ¦ããè.   ¦¾ããºãªªáË ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ‡ãŠã¾ãªã 2003 Þ¾ãã ¦ãÀ¦ãìªãè ¶ãìÔããÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ãäÌãÁ£ª ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ÞããñÀãèÞãã ¾ããñؾ㠦ããñ Œã›Ëã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã Ìã ¦ããñ Œã›Ë㠂㪾ãã¹ãÖãè ¹ãÆËâºããè¦ã ‚ããÖñ.   ¾ãã ÔãÌãà ‡ãŠãÀ¥ããÌãÁ¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ Àªªá ‡ãŠÀãÌããè ‚ãÎããè ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ÎãñÌã›ãè ãäÌã¶ãâ¦ããè ‡ãñŠËãè. 

 

[3]              ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ Ìã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ã㠽֥㥾ããÞ¾ãã ¹ãðÓ›¾ã©ãà ¹ãìÀãÌãã ½Ö¥ãî¶ã Íã¹ã©ã¹ã¨ã Ìã ‡ãŠãØ㪹ã¨ã ¹ãƇãŠÀ¥ãã¦ã ªãŒãÊã ‡ãñŠÊãñ ‚ããÖñ¦ã.    ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞãñ ãäÌã´ã¶ã Ìã‡ãŠãèÊã Ñããè.†.¡ãè.Þããõ£ãÀãè, Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããÊãñ ¾ããâÞãñ ãäÌã´ã¶ã Ìã‡ãŠãèË Ñããè.ãäºãÖã¥ããè ¾ããâ¶ããè ‡ãñŠÊãñÊãñ ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌã㪠†ñ‡ãŠÊãñ.   ªãñ¶ÖãèÖãè ¹ãàã‡ãŠãÀãâ¶ããè ªãŒãÊã ‡ãñŠÊãñÊãñ Íã¹ã©ã¹ã¨ã Ìã ‡ãŠãØ㪹ã¨ã ¦ãÔãñÞã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã Ìããä‡ãŠÊããâÞãã ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌã㪠†ñ‡ãŠÊ¾ããÌãÁ¶ã ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞ¾ãã ãäÌãÞããÀã©ãà ŒããÊããèÊã ½ã쪪áñ „¹ããäÔ©ã¦ã Öãñ¦ãã¦ã.

          ½ã쪪áñ :                                                                ãä¶ãÓ‡ãŠÓãà :

 

          [‚ã] Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ  ¾ããâ¶ããè  ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ªñ¥¾ããÞ¾ãã             : ¶ããÖãè.

                ÔãñÌãñ½ã£¾ãñ  ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã  ŸñÌãËãè  ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠã¾ã  ?         

                                                                                                                                     

         [ºã] ‡ãŠã¾ã ‚ããªñÎã ?                                                 : ‚ãâãä¦ã½ã ‚ããªñÎãã ¹ãƽãã¥ãñ.

 

‡ãŠãÀ¥ãñ :

 

[4]              ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ Öñ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞãñ ØãÆãև㊠‚ãÔãʾã㠺㪪áË Ìã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ªì‡ãŠã¶ããÔããŸãè ãäÌã²ãî¦ã •ããñ¡ Üãñ¦ãʾã㠺㪪áË „¼ã¾ã¹ãàãã¦ã Ìã㪠¶ããÖãè.    ¦ãÔãñÞã 9 Ìã 10 ‚ããùØãÓ› 2004 Àãñ•ããè Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ªì‡ãŠã¶ããÔã ¼ãñ› ªñ…¶ã ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ãä½ã›ÀÞããè ¦ã¹ããÔã¥ããè ‡ãñŠËãè Ìã ¦¾ãã¶ãâ¦ãÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞãã ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌãŸã ºã⪠‡ãñŠËã ¾ã㠺㪪áË ªñŒããèË „¼ã¾ã¹ãàãã¦ã Ìã㪠¶ããÖãè.   ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ã㠽֥㥾ãã ¶ãìÔããÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ‡ãŠãÖãèÖãè ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ¶ãÔã¦ããâ¶ãã ãäª.10-08-2004 Àãñ•ããè ¦¾ããâÞãã ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌãŸã Œãâ¡ãè¦ã ‡ãñŠËã.   ¾ãã „Ë› Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞãñ ‚ãÔãñ ½Ö¥ã¥ãñ ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ãä½ã›À ½ã£¾ãñ ¹ãñŠÀ ºãªË ‡ãŠÁ¶ã Ìã Ìãã¾ãÀÞããè ©ãñ› •ããñ¡¥ããè ‡ãŠÁ¶ã Ìããè•ãñÞããè ÞããñÀãè ‡ãñŠËñËãè ‚ããÖñ.  ¦¾ããâÞãñ ¹ãì¤ñ ‚ãÔãñÖãè ½Ö¥ã¥ãñ ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ‚ãÎãã ¹ãƇãŠãÀñ Ìããè•ãñÞããè ÞããñÀãè ‡ãñŠÊ¾ã㠺㪪áË ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã ãäÌãÁ£ª ¹ãŠãõ•ãªãÀãè Œã›Ëã ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã ‚ãÔãî¶ã ¦ããñ Œã›Ë㠂㪾ãã¹ãÖãè Ôã¨ã ¶¾ãã¾ãã˾ã, ‚ãֽ㪶ãØãÀ ¾ãñ©ãñ ¹ãÆËâãäºã¦ã ‚ããÖñ. 

 

[5]              ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀ Ìã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã ¾ãã ¹ãÀÔ¹ãÀ ãäÌãÀãñ£ããè ‡ãŠ©ã¶ããÞ¾ãã Ôã⪼ããæ㠦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞãñ ãäÌã´ã¶ã Ìã‡ãŠãèË Ñããè.Þããõ£ãÀãè ¾ããâ¶ããè ‡ãŠãØ㪠ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.6/3 ‡ãŠ¡ñ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ Ëàã Ìãñ£ãî¶ã ‚ãÔãã ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌã㪠‡ãñŠËã ‡ãŠãè, Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã                  ãäª.12-08-2004 Àãñ•ããè †‡ãã À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.87,850/- Þãñ ãäºãË ãäªËñ.  ¹ãÀâ¦ãî Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ÎãñÌãØããâÌã ‡ãŠãñ›ãý㣾ãñ •ããñ ¹ãŠãõ•ãªãÀãè Œã›Ëã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀã ãäÌãÁ£ª ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã ¦¾ãã½ã£¾ãñ ½ãã¨ã À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.37,850/- Þããè ÞããñÀãè ‡ãñŠÊ¾ããÞãã ‚ããÀãñ¹ã ‡ãñŠËã.  ¾ãã ‚ãã£ããÀñ ‚ãù¡.Ñããè.Þããõ£ãÀãè ¾ããâ¶ããè ¹ãì¤ñ ‚ãÔããÖãè ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌã㪠‡ãñŠËã ‡ãŠãè, Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀã ãäÌãÁ£ª ‚ãÎãã ¹ãƇãŠãÀñ ÔãâãäªØ£ã [Vague] ‚ããÀãñ¹ã ‡ãñŠËñ ‚ãÔãʾãã¶ãñ ¦ãñ Þãì‡ãŠãèÞãñ ‚ãÔãʾããÞãñ ªÎãÃãäÌã¦ãñ.  ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãŠÀãÌããè ‚ãÎããè ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ÎãñÌã›ãè ãäÌã¶ãâ¦ããè ‡ãñŠËãè.

 

[6]              ¾ãã „Ë› Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞãñ ãäÌã´ã¶ã Ìã‡ãŠãèË Ñããè.ãäºãÖã¥ããè ¾ããâ¶ããè ¹ãƇãŠÀ¥ãã¦ã ªãŒãË ¢ããËñʾãã ‡ãŠãØ㪹ã¨ããâ‡ãŠ¡ñ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ Ëàã Ìãñ£ãî¶ã ‚ãÔãã ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌã㪠‡ãñŠËã ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ½ãâ•ãîÀ ‚ãÔãËñʾãã ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌ㟾ãã¹ãñàãã •ããÔ¦ã àã½ã¦ãñÞãã ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌãŸã Ìãã¹ãÀËã.  †Ìã¤ñÞã ¶ãÌÖñ ¦ãÀ, ¦¾ããâÞ¾ã㠽֥㥾ãã ¹ãƽãã¥ãñ, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ãä½ã›À½ã£¾ãñ ºãÀñÞãÔãñ ¹ãñŠÀºãªË ‡ãŠÁ¶ã Ìããè•ãñÞããè ÞããñÀãè ‡ãñŠËãè.   ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ‡ãŠã¾ãªã 2003 Þ¾ãã ¦ãÀ¦ãìªãè ¶ãìÔããÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀã ãäÌãÁ£ª ‡ãŠã¾ãªñÎããèÀ ‡ãŠãÀÌããƒÃ ‡ãñŠËãè ‚ãÔãʾãã½ãìßñ ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ªñ¥¾ããÞ¾ãã ÔãñÌãñ¦ã ‡ãŠÔãËãèÖãè ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ŸñÌãËñËãè ¶ããÖãè.   ¾ãã ‡ãŠãÀ¥ããÌãÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ Àªªá ‡ãŠÀãÌããè ‚ãÎããè ÎãñÌã›ãè ãäÌã¶ãâ¦ããè ‡ãñŠËãè. 

 

[7]              ¹ãƇãŠÀ¥ãã¦ã ªãŒãË ¢ããËñʾãã ‡ãŠãØ㪹ã¨ããâÞãñ ºããÀ‡ãŠãƒÃ¶ãñ ‚ãÌãËãñ‡ãŠ¶ã ‡ãñŠËñ ‚ãÔã¦ãã ‚ãù¡.Ñããè.ãäºãÖã¥ããè ¾ããâ¶ããè ‡ãñŠËñʾãã ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌããªã½ã£¾ãñ ¦ã©¾ã ‚ãÔãʾããÞãñ ãäªÔãî¶ã ¾ãñ¦ãñ.  ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã ¼ãÀãÀãè ¹ã©ã‡ãŠã¶ãñ ãäª.09-08-2004 Àãñ•ããè ªì¹ããÀãè 4.00 Þãñ ªÀ½¾ãã¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ªì‡ãŠã¶ããÔã ¼ãñ› ãäªÊ¾ããÞãñ Ìã ¦¾ãã ªì‡ãŠã¶ãã½ã£¾ãñ •ããñ ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌãŸã ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËã Öãñ¦ãã ¦¾ããÞããè ¦ã¹ããÔã¥ããè ‡ãñŠÊ¾ããÞãñ ‡ãŠãØ㪠ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.16/1 ÌãÁ¶ã Ô¹ãÓ› Öãñ¦ãñ.   ¦¾ãã ‡ãŠãØãªãÌãÁ¶ã ¹ãì¤ñ ÖñÖãè Ô¹ãÓ› Öãñ¦ãñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ã㠹㊇㋦ã 0.3 ‡ãñŠ.ÌÖãè. ãäÌã²ãî¦ã Ìãã¹ãÀ¥¾ããÞããè ¹ãÀÌãã¶ãØããè ãäªËãè ‚ãÔã¦ããâ¶ãã ¦¾ããâ¶ããè •ãÌãß •ãÌãß 6 †Þã.¹ããè.Þ¾ãã Ìããè•ãñÞãã Ìãã¹ãÀ ‡ãñŠËñËã ‚ããÖñ.  †Ìã¤ñÞã ¶ãÌÖñ ¦ãÀ ¼ãÀãÀãè ¹ã©ã‡ãŠã¶ãñ •ãñÌÖã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞ¾ãã ãä½ã›ÀÞããè ¦ã¹ããÔã¥ããè ‡ãñŠËãè ¦¾ããÌãñßãè ¦¾ãã ãä½ã›À½ã£¾ãñ ¹ãñŠÀºãªË ‡ãñŠÊ¾ããÞãñ Ìã ¦¾ããËã •ããñ¡Ëñʾãã ¦ããÀã ¦ããñ¡î¶ã ¦¾ãã ¦ããÀã ©ãñ› ƒ¦ãÀ ¦ããÀãâ¶ãã •ããñ¡Ê¾ããÞãñ ªñŒããèË ¼ãÀãÀãè ¹ã©ã‡ãŠãËã ãäªÔãî¶ã ‚ããËñ.    ¦¾ã㠺㪪áËÞãã ÔããäÌãÔ¦ãÀ ¦ã¹ããäÎãË ¼ãÀãÀãè ¹ã©ã‡ãŠã¶ãñ ‡ãŠãØ㪠ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.16/1 Þ¾ãã ¹ããäÀÞœñª 16 Ìã 17 ½ã£¾ãñ ãäªËñËã ‚ããÖñ.  ¾ãã ã䟇ãŠã¥ããè Öñ ¶ã½ãîª ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ ½ãÖ¦ÌããÞãñ ‚ããÖñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦¾ãã Ô©ãß ¦ã¹ããÔã¥ããè ‚ãÖÌããËãÌãÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞããè ÔãÖãè ‚ãÔãî¶ã ¦ããè ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ãäª.09-08-2004 Àãñ•ããè ‡ãñŠÊ¾ããÞãñ ãäªÔã¦ãñ. 

 

[8]              ‡ãŠãØ㪠ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.16/2 Þãñ ‚ãÌãËãñ‡ãŠ¶ã ‡ãñŠËñ ‚ãÔã¦ãã ¦¾ããÞã ãäªÌãÎããè •ããñ ¦ã¹ããÔã¥ããè ‚ãÖÌããË ãäËãäÖ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËã ¦¾ããÌãÀ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ÔãÖãè ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ããÔã ¶ãã‡ãŠãÀʾããÞãã „ÊËñŒã ‚ããÖñ.  ¼ãÀãÀãè ¹ã©ã‡ãŠã¶ãñ ¦ã¾ããÀ ‡ãñŠËñËã ‚ãÖÌããË ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.16/1 ÌãÁ¶ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ãä‡ãŠ¦ããè ¾ãìãä¶ã› Ìããè•ãñÞããè ÞããñÀãè ‡ãñŠËãè ¾ããÞãã ãäÖÎããñºã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâÞãã ‚ãÖÌããË ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.16/3 Ëã ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËã ‚ããÖñ.   ¦¾ãã ‚ãÖÌããËãÌãÁ¶ã ‚ãÔãñ ãäªÔã¦ãñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.18,925/- ƒ¦ã‡ã‹¾ãã ãä‡ãŠ½ã¦ããèÞ¾ãã Ìããè•ãñÞããè ÞããñÀãè ‡ãñŠËãè Ìã ãä¦ã¦ã‡ãŠãèÞã ¦¾ããâÞããè •ãºããºãªãÀãè £ãÁ¶ã ¦¾ããâÞ¾ãã Ìããè•ãñÞããè †‡ãã À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.37,850/- ãä¶ããäÎÞã¦ã ‡ãñŠËãè ØãñËãè.   ¾ãã À‡ãŠ½ãñ½ã£¾ãñ ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ‡ãŠã¾ãªã 2003 Þ¾ãã ¦ãÀ¦ãìªãè ¶ãìÔããÀ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.50,000/- Þã㠪⡠Ôã½ãã¾ããñ•ããè¦ã ‡ãŠÁ¶ã ¦¾ããÞãñ À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.87,850/- Þãñ ãäºãË ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãÔã ãäª.12-08-2004 Àãñ•ããè ãäªÊ¾ããÞãñ ‡ãŠãØ㪠ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.3 ÌãÁ¶ã ãäªÔã¦ãñ.   ¾ãã ºããºããéÞãã ãäÌãÞããÀ ‡ãŠÀ¦ãã ‚ãù¡.Ñããè.Þããõ£ãÀãè ¾ããâ¶ããè ¾ãã Ôã⪼ããæ㠇ãñŠËñËã ¾ãìãä‡ã‹¦ãÌã㪠ÔÌããè‡ãŠãÀ¥¾ãã ÔããÀŒãã ¶ããÖãè ‚ãÔãñ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ ½ã¦ã ‚ããÖñ. 

 

[9]              Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀã ãäÌãÁ£ª •ããè ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ÞããñÀãèÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËãè Öãñ¦ããè ¦ããè ‚ãª¾ãã¹ãÖãè ¹ãÆËâãäºã¦ã ‚ãÔãʾãã¶ãñ ‡ãŠãØ㪠ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.39/1 ÌãÁ¶ã ãäªÔã¦ãñ.  ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ªãŒãË ‡ãñŠËñËã ‡ãŠãØ㪠ãä¶ãÎãã¥ããè ¶ãâ.42/1 ÌãÁ¶ã ‚ãÔãñÖãè ãäªÔã¦ãñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦¾ããâ¶ããè ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞãã¶ãñ ¹ãìÌããê ãäªËñËã ãä¶ã‡ãŠãË ãäª.09-08-2005 ½ã£¾ãñ ‡ãñŠËñʾãã ‚ããªñÎãã ¶ãìÔããÀ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâÞ¾ãã‡ãŠ¡ñ ãäª.16 ‚ããù‡ã‹›ãñºãÀ 2006 Àãñ•ããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Á.26,308/- ¼ãÀËñ ‚ããÖñ¦ã.  ¹ãÀâ¦ãî ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞãã¶ãñ ¹ãìÌããê ãäªËñËã ãä¶ã‡ãŠãË ½ãã.À㕾㠂ãã¾ããñØã ½ãìâºãƒÃ Œã⡹ããèŸ ‚ããõÀâØããºã㪠¾ããâ¶ããè ¹ããäÖËñ ‚ã¹ããèË ¶ãâºãÀ 1696/2005 ½ã£¾ãñ ‚ããªñÎã ‡ãŠÁ¶ã Àªªá ‡ãñŠËã ‚ããÖñ.  ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ‚ãÎããè À‡ã‹‡ãŠ½ã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËò‡ãŠ¡ñ •ãÀãè ¼ãÀËãè ‚ãÔãËãè ¦ãÀãè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ‡ãñŠÌãß ¾ãã ‡ãŠãÀ¥ããÌãÁ¶ã ½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ ¶¾ãã¾ããÞ¾ãã ÒÓ›ãè¶ãñ ¾ããñؾã Öãñ¥ããÀ ¶ããÖãè.   ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ‡ãñŠËñʾãã Ìããè•ãñÞ¾ãã ÞããñÀãè ºããºã¦ã ‚㪾ãã¹ãÖãè ¾ããñؾ㠦¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ãã˾ã㠽㣾ãñ Œã›Ëã ¹ãÆËâãäºã¦ã ‚ããÖñ.   ‚ãÔãã Œã›Ëã ¹ãÆËâãäºã¦ã ‚ãÔã¦ããâ¶ãã ¦¾ãã½ã£¾ãñ ÖÔ¦ãàãñ¹ã ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ããÞãã ‚ããä£ã‡ãŠãÀ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÔã ¶ããÖãè.

 

[10]           ©ããñ¡¾ããÌãñßã ‡ãŠãäÀ¦ãã ÌãÀ ¶ã½ãîª ‡ãñŠËñÊããè ºããºã ªìËÃàããè¦ã ‡ãñŠËãè ¦ãÀãèÖãè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ‡ãñŠËñËãè ½ããØã¥ããè ½ãâ•ãîÀ ‡ãŠÀ¥ãñ Öñ ¶¾ãã¾ããÞ¾ãã ÒÓ›ãè¶ãñ ¾ããñؾã Öãñ¥ããÀ ¶ããÖãè.  ‡ãŠãÀ¥ã ¹ãƇãŠÀ¥ãã¦ã ªãŒãË ¢ããËñʾãã ‡ãŠãØ㪹ã¨ããâÌãÁ¶ã Öñ Ô¹ãÓ› Öãñ¦ãñ ‡ãŠãè, ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ããè ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ãä½ã›À½ã£¾ãñ ¹ãñŠÀºãªË ‡ãñŠËñËñ ‚ããÖñ¦ã.  †Ìã¤ñÞã ¶ãÌÖñ ¦ãÀ ¦¾ãã ãä½ã›ÀËã •ããñ¡Ëñʾãã ¦ããÀã ‡ãŠã¤î¶ã ¦¾ãã  ©ãñ› ªìÔã-¾ãã ¦ããÀãâ¶ãã •ããñ¡î¶ã ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌ㟾ããÞãã Ìãã¹ãÀ ‡ãñŠËã ‚ããÖñ.    ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ‡ãŠã¾ãªñÎããèÀ ½ããØããÃÞãã ‚ãÌãËâºã ‡ãŠÁ¶ãÞã ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞãã ãäÌã²ãî¦ã ¹ãìÀÌãŸã Œãâ¡ãè¦ã ‡ãñŠËñËã ‚ããÖñ.   ¾ãã ºããºããèÞãã ãäÌãÞããÀ ‡ãŠÀ¦ãã Ôãã½ã¶ãñÌããËñ ¾ããâ¶ããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâ¶ãã ªñ¥¾ããÞ¾ãã ÔãñÌãñ¦ã ‡ãŠÔãËãèÖãè ‡ãŠ½ã¦ãÀ¦ãã ŸñÌãËãè ¶ãÔãʾããÞãñ ãäÔ㣪 Öãñ¦ãñ.   ¦¾ãã½ãìßñ ¹ãÆÔ¦ãì¦ãÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ Àªªá Öãñ¥¾ããÔã ¹ãã¨ã ‚ãÔãʾããÞãñ ¾ãã ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞããÞãñ ½ã¦ã ‚ããÖñ.  ‡ãŠãäÀ¦ãã Öñ ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã ŒããËãèË ¹ãƽãã¥ãñ ‚ããªñÎã ‡ãŠÀãè¦ã ‚ããÖñ.

‚ããªñÎã

 

          [‚ã]    ¦ã‰ãŠãÀªãÀãâÞããè ¦ã‰ãŠãÀ Àªªá ‡ãŠÀ¥¾ãã¦ã ‚ããËãè ‚ããÖñ.

[ºã]     ªãñ¶ÖãèÖãè ¹ãàã‡ãŠãÀãâ¶ããè ‚ãã¹ã‚ãã¹ãËã ŒãÞãà ÔããñÔããÌãã.

          [‡ãŠ]    Ôãâºãâãä£ã¦ããâ¶ãã ‚ããªñÍã ‡ãŠßãäÌ㥾ãã¦ã ¾ããÌãã.

 

‚ãֽ㪶ãØãÀ.

ã䪶ããâ‡ãŠ :  08/07/2010.

 

 

 

           {‚ãù¡.Ôããõ.½ããä¶ãÓãã ‡ãõŠËãÔã Œã¡ã½ã‡ãŠÀ}                   {Ñããè.Ôãì£ãã‡ãŠÀ.‡ãñŠ.ãäºã¶ãÌã¡ñ}

                        ÔãªÔ¾ãã                                              ‚㣾ãàã

          ãä•ãÊÖã ØãÆãև㊠¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ãÌããÀ¥ã                  ãä•ãÊÖã ØãÆãև㊠¦ã‰ãŠãÀ ãä¶ãÌããÀ¥ã

              ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã,‚ãֽ㪶ãØãÀ.                          ¶¾ãã¾ã½ãâÞã,‚ãֽ㪶ãØãÀ.

 

 


, HONORABLE test, PRESIDING MEMBER ,