khtl;l Efh;Bthh; FiwjPh; kd;wk;, BtY]h;, BtY]h; khtl;lk; Kd;dpiy jpU.m. rk;gj;, gp.v. gp.vy;. jiyth; jpUkjp. $p. kyh;tpHp, gp.n., cWg;gpdh;-1 jpU. jahsK}h;j;jp, gp.v!;.rp., cWg;gpdh;-2 rp.rp.vz;.36/2003 2010-Mk; tUlk; Bk jpA;fs; 31-Mk; ehs; jpA;fs; fpHik. b$. uA;fehjd;, j/bg j.b$aBtY, f/bg. 31, bgUkhs; Bfhapy; tPjp Mk;g{h; tl;lk;, BtY]h; khtl;lk; .. kDjhuh; ..vjph; .. 1. jiyik bghJ Bkyhsh; jkpH; ehL bjhiyBgrp Jiw, brd;id -2. 2. khtl;l bghJ Bkyhsh; BtY}hh; khtl;l bjhiyBgrp, BtY]h;, BtY]h; khtl;lk;, 3. jiyik fzf;F mYtyh; BtY]h; khtl;l bjhiyBgrp, tUtha; gphpt[, BtY]h;, BtY]h; khtl;lk. 4. cjtp jiyik fzf;F mYtyh; BtY]h; khtl;l bjhiyBgrp, tUtha; gphpt[, BtY]h;, BtY]h; khtl;lk. 5. fzf;F mYtyh;, (TR) bghJ (AO General), BtY]h; khtl;l bjhiyBgrp, tUtha; gphpt[, BtY]h;, BtY]h; khtl;lk;. 6. Bfhl;lbghwpahsh;, Mk;g{h; bjhiyBgrp epiyak;, Mk;g{h; BtYhh; khtl;lk;. 7. Jizf; Bfhl;l epiya mjpfhhp, bjhiyBgrp (SDO), Mk;g{h; bjhiyBgrp epiyak;, Mk;g{h;, BtY]h; khtl;lk;. 8. nsepiy bjhiyBgrp mYtyh; Mk;g{h; g[jpa bjhiyBgrp epiyak;, Mk;g{h;, BtY]h; khtl;lk;. .. vjph; kDjhuh;fs; ne;j KiwaPL nWjp tprhuizf;F 30.4.2010 Bjjpapy; vA;fs; Kd;dpiyapy; te;J, KiwaPl;lhsUf;fhf jpU.uhkK}h;j;jp, tHf;fwpqh; mth;fs; vjph;KiwaPl;lhsUf;fhf jpU. o.vd;.Bf. bry;tuh$;, tHf;fwpqh; mth;fs; Kd;dpiyahfp KiwaPl;L, vjph; ciu, gpukhz thf;FK}yk; kw;Wk; MtzA;fis ehA;fs; fz;L ghprPyid bra;J ne;j kd;wk; nWjpahf gpwg;gpf;Fk; M iz a[ iu jpU. m. rk;gj;, jiyth; 1. kDjhuhpd; kDciu RUf;fk; gpd;tUkhW:- kDjhuh; Mk;g{h; efuk;, vk;.rp.BuhL, vy;.Mh;.Bf. tzpf tshfj;jpy; 72/rp vd;w vz;Zs;s fil fl;olj;jpid kDjhuh; thliff;F vLj;J, mjpy; vjph;kDjhuh;fs; epWtdj;jplkpUe;J bjhiyBgrp vz;fs; 244911 kw;Wk; 247595 Mfpaitfis bgw;W bjhHpy; elj;jp, chpa fl;lzj;ij Kiwahf brYj;jp te;Js;shh;. kDjhuhpd; Bkw;go fl;olj;jpw;F mUBf kDjhuhpd; rBfhjuh; b$. BtY 72/o filia thliff;F vLj;J mjpy; bjhiyBgrp vz;.242311 bfhz;l bghJ bjhiyBgrp nizg;gpid bgw;W gad;gLj;jp te;jhh;. b$.BtY elj;jp te;j bjhHpy; rhptu eilbgwhjhy;, mtuJ filapid fhyp bra;J tpl;L, mtuJ bjhiyBgrpapid kDjhuupd; tpyhrj;jpw;F khw;wp mikf;Fk;go Bfl;Lf;bfhz;ljd; Bghpy; 7-k; vjph;kDjhuh; Bkw;go bjhiyBgrpis kDjhuUf;F khw;wk; bra;ag;gl;L mth; gad;gLj;jp tUfpwhh;. ne;epiyapy; ve;jtpj Kd;dwptpg;g[k; nd;wp, ve;jtpj fhuzkpd;wp Bkw;go bjhiyBgrp vz;.244911, 247595 kw;Wk; 242311 Mfpa Kd;W nizg;g[fisa[k; 6,7,8 vjph;kDjhuh;fs; 21.7.03 md;W Jz;og;g[ bra;Jtpl;ldh;. nJFwpj;J vjph;kDjhuh;fsplk; tprhhpj;jjpy; bjhiyBgrp vz;.245378-d; chpikahsuhd v!;.rj;jP!;Fkhh; vd;gth; bjhiyBgrp fl;lzk; U}.9886/- ghf;fp itj;Js;sjhy; kDjhuhpd; K}d;W bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fisa[k; Jz;of;Fk;go 3,4,5 vjph;kDjhuh;fs; bjhptpj;jjhft[k; mjd;go 4-k; vjph;kDjhuh; 15.7.03 md;W cj;jput[ gpwg;gpj;jjhft[k; Twpdhh;fs;. 2. kDjhuh; 22.7.03 md;W fhiy 10.00 mstpy; 3,4,5 vjph;kDjhuh;fis re;jpj;J kDjhuhpd; bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fis Jz;oj;jjJ rl;l tpBuhjkhdJ vd vLj;Jf;Twp kPz;Lk; nizg;g[ mspf;Fk;go Bfl;Lk; vjph;kDjhuh;fs; kWj;Jtpl;ldh;. bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fSf;Fz;lhd fl;lz gpy;fisa[k;, MtzA;fisa[k; 23.7.03 md;W vLj;J brd;W 3-k; vjph;kDjhuuplk; fhz;gpj;;J bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[ bfhLf;Fk;go Bfl;lbghGJ khtl;l fz;fhzpg;g[ gphpt[f;F Ml;Brgidia mDg;gp, gpd; KG mwpf;if fpilj;j gpwFjhd; kPz;Lk; bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[ mspf;fg;gLk; vd bjhptpj;Jtpl;ldh;. 25.7.03 md;W 2k; vjph;khDjhuiu kDjhuh; mZfp jdJ Ml;Brgid kDtpid mspj;J kPz;Lk; bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[ tHA;Fk;go Bfl;Lk; gadspf;ftpy;iy. 30.7.03 md;W 2-k; vjph;kDjhuhUf;F je;jp K}yk; cldoahf tprhuizBah (m) kW nizg;g[fisBah mspf;Fk;go Bfl;fg;gl;lJ. gpd; 11.8.03 md;W kPz;Lk; 7-k; vjph;kDjhuiu mZfp Kiwapl;ljd; Bghpy; 244911 kw;Wk; 242311 Mfpa nuz;L bjhiyBgrpfSf;F kl;Lk; nizg;g[ tHA;fpa[s;sdh;. gpw;ghL bjhlh;e;J Kiwapl;ljd; Bghpy; bjhiyBgrp vz;.247595 nizg;gpid 11.9.03 md;W kPz;Lk; bfhLj;jdh;. K}d;W bjhiyBgrp vz;fis Kd;dwptpg;gpd;wp ve;jtpj fhuzkpd;wp Jz;of;fg;gl;ljd; K}yk; kDjhuUf;F bjhHpy; hPjpahf e&;lKk;, mjdhy; kd cisr;rYk;, mtbgaUk; Vw;gl;Ltpl;lJ. vdBt tUtha; nHg;gpw;Fk,; jdpj;jdpahft[k;, Tl;lhft[k; bghWg;ghthh;fs; mjd;go kDjhuhpd; bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fis Jz;og;g[ bra;jjpd; K}}yk; Vw;gl;l tpahghu e&;lj;jpw;fhf U}.1,00,000/-k;, bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fis Jz;og;g[ bra;jjpd; K}yk; kDjhuUf;F Vw;gl;l kdcisr;ry; kw;Wk; cly; cisr;rYf;fhf U}. 3,85,000/-k;, bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fis kPz;Lk; jpUk;g bgWtjw;fhf Btz;o Vw;gl;l bryt[f;fhf U}.10,000/k; nt;tHf;F bryt[f;F U}.5000/-k; kDjhuUf;F 1 Kjy; 8 tiuapyhd vjph;kDjhuh;fs; tHA;f cj;jputpl Btz;Lbkd Btz;lg;gLfpwJ. 3. 3-k; vjph;kDjhuh; jug;gpy; vjph; ciuapy; cs;s tptuk; gpd;tUkhW: kDjhuhpd; kD rl;lj;jpd;goa[k; bghUz;ikapd;goa[k; Vw;Wf;bfhs;s Toajpy;iy. kDtpy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;l mk;rA;fspy; Fwpg;ghf xg;g[f;bfhz;Ls;sit jtpu kw;w mk;rA;fs; midj;ija[k; kDjhuBu epU}gpf;f Toath; Mthh;. kDtpy; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s fhuzA;fspd; mog;gilapy; ghpfhuk; Bfhhp Mk;g{h; TLjy; chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; mry; tHf;F vz;.4/2004 vjph;kDjhuh;fSf;F vjpuhf, Vw;fdBt jhf;fy; bra;agl;L epYitapYs;s ne;epiyapy; mBj fhuzA;fspd; mog;gilapy; mBj ghpfhuj;jpw;fhf vjph;kDjhuh;fSf;F vjpuhf kPz;Lk; nk;kd;wj;jpy; jhf;fy; bra;Js;s nk;kD js;Sgo bra;a ToajhFk;. Mk;g{h;, vk;.rp.BuhL, vy;.Mh;.Bf fhk;gsf;!; vz;.72/rp fl;olj;jpy; kDjhuhpd; bjhiyBgrp vz;fs;.244911, 247595 vjph;kDjhuh;fshy; 27.5.96 kw;Wk; 23.3.2000 Mfpa BjjpapYk; KiwBa tHA;fg;gl;lJ. Bkw;go fhk;gsf;!; vz;. 72/o filapy; kDjhuhpd; rBfhjuh; b$.BtYf;F bjhiyBgrp vz;. 242311 nizg;g[ 14.6.2000 md;W Btiyapy;yhjth;fSf;fhd jpl;lj;jpd; fPH; tHA;fg;gl;lJ. Bkw;go BtYtpd; bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[ kDjhuhpd; fl;olj;jpw;F Btz;LBfhspd; bgahpy; khw;wg;gl;ljhf Twg;gLtJ rhpahdjy;y. vjph;kDjhuh;fspd; bjhiyBgrp Jiwapd; mDkjpapd;wp Bkw;go BtYtpd; bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[ kDjhuhpd; fl;lj;jpw;F khw;wk; bra;ag;gl;lJ tprhuizapy; bjhpa te;jJ. bjhiyBgrp Jiwapd; mDkjpapd;wp khw;wk; bra;ag;gLk; bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fis Jz;og;gjw;F bjhiyBgrp rl;lj;jpy; tHptFf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ. Btiyapy;yhjth; jpl;lj;jpd; fPH; b$.BtYt[f;F tHA;fg;gl;l bjhiyBgrp vz;.242311 kDjhuhpd; fl;olj;jpw;F bjhiyBgrp Jiwapd; mDkjpapd;wp khw;wk; bra;J kDjuuhy; jtwhf gad;gLj;jp te;jpUg;gJk; KG tprhuizf;F gpwF bjhpa te;jJ. 4. jpU. v!;.rjP&;FkhUf;F tHA;fg;gl;l bjhiyBgrp vz;.245378, vy;.Mh;.Bf. fhk;gsf;!; fil vz;.72/o-f;F khw;wk; bra;ag;gl;L bjhiyBgrp fl;lzk; U}.8886/- ghf;fp nUe;J kDjhuh; gad;gLj;jp te;jJ bjhpa te;jJ me;j nizg;g[ 19.9.02y; Jz;of;fg;gl;lJ. bjhiyBgrp tUtha; Ma;thspd; 11.2.03 Bjjp mwpf;ifapy; Bkw;go bjhiyBgrp nizg;ig kDjhuh; gad;gLj;jp te;jpUg;gJ bjhpa te;jJ. Bkw;go bjhiyBgrp nizg;ig kDjhuh; jtwhf gad;gLj;jpajpd; BghpYk;, bjhiyBgrp Jiwapd; mDkjpapd;wp b$.BtYf;F tHA;fg;gl;l bjhiyBgrp nizg;ig kDjhuh; khw;wk; bra;J jtwhf gad;gLj;jp te;jjpd; BghpYk;, kDjhuhpd; bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fs; Jz;of;fg;gl;lJ. ey;byz;zj;jpd; mog;gilapy; kPz;Lk; 244911 kw;Wk; 242311 Mfpa bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fs; 2.8.03 md;Wk;, kw;Wk; vz;. 247595 bjhiyBgrp nizg;gp 28.8.03 md;Wk; kPz;Lk; nizg;g[ tHA;fg;gl;lJ. Bkw;go nizg;g[fs; jhkjkhf tHA;fg;gl;ljhf Twg;gLtJ jtwhFk;. bjhiyBgrp Jiwapd; rl;lj;jpw;F Kwzhf ele;J bfhz;ljd; milg;gilapy;, KG tprhuizf;F gpw;ghL kDjhuhpd; bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fs; Jz;of;fg;gl;lJ. gpw;ghL nizg;g[ tHA;fg;gl;lJ. vdBt, nk;kD js;Sgo bra;agl Btz;Lk;. 5. kDjhuh; jug;gpy; gpukhz thf;FK}yk; jhf;fy; bra;J, k.rh.M1 Kjy; k.rh.M-35 tiuapyhd rhd;whtzA;fis FwpaPL bra;ag;gl;lJ. vjph;kDjhuhfs; jug;gpy; gpukhz thf;FK}yk; jhf;fy; bra;J, v.rh.M1 Kjy; v.rh.M6 tiu rhd;whtzA;fis FwpaPL bra;ag;gl;lJ. nU jug;gpdUk;, tha;bkhHp rhl;rpak; vJkpy;iy. 6. ghprPyidf;Fhpa tpdhf;fs; gpd;tUkhW:- m) nk;kD ne;j ePjpkd;wj;jpd; Ms;tiuf;F cl;gl;ljh ? M) vjph;kDjhuhfs; jug;gpy; Britf;FiwghL VBjDk; cs;sjh?. n) kDjhuh; bgwjFe;j ghpfhuA;fs; vd;d? 7. jPh;t[f;Fhpa tpdh - m: kDjhuh; jug;gpy; Mk;g{h; efuk;, vk;.rp.BuhL, vy;.Mh;.Bf. tzpf tshfj;jpy; 72/rp vd;w vz;Zs;s fil fl;olj;jpDs; bjhiyBgrp vz;fs; 244911 kw;Wk; 247595 Mfpa nU bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fis vjph;kDjhuh;fs; epWtdj;jplkpUe;J bgw;W gad;gLj;jp te;J chpa bjhiyBgrp fl;lzj;ij Kiwahf brYj;jp te;jjhft[k;, kDjhuhpd; rBfhjuh; b$.BtYapd; bjhiyBgrp vz;. 242311 nizg;gpid kDjhuhpd; filapy; khw;wp mikf;Fk;go Bfl;Lf;bfhz;ljpd; Bghpy; 7-k; vjph;kDjhuuhy; Bkw;go bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[ khw;wp mikj;J bfhLj;J mjd;go K}d;W bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fisa[k;, kDjhuh; gad;gLj;jp tUifapy; 21.7.03 md;W 6,7,8 Mfpa vjph;kDjhuh;fs; ve;jtpj Kd;dwptpg;g[kpd;wp, fhuzkpd;wp Bkw;go K}d;W nizg;g[fis Jz;oj;Jtpl;lij Fwpj;J Beuoahft[k;, Ml;Brgid kD K}ykhft[k; Bfl;lbghGJk;, bjhiyBgrp vz;.245378-d; chpikahsuhd v!;. rj;jP!;Fkhh; vd;gth; U}.9886/- bjhiyBgrp fl;lzk; ghf;fp itj;jpUe;j epiyapy; me;j bjhiyBgrpapy; jtwhf kDjhuh; gad;gLj;jp te;jjhft[k; mjdhy; kDjhuhpd; K}d;W bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fisa[k; Jz;oj;Jtpl;ljhf bjhptpf;fg;gl;ljht[k; gpw;ghL Beuoahft[k;, je;jp kw;Wk;, kDf;fs; K}ykhft[k; gyKiw bjhptpj;jjpd;Bghpy; fhyjhkjhf kPz;Lk; Bkw;go K}d;W bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fis bfhLj;jjhft[k; mjdhy; kDjhuUf;F bjhHpy; hPjpahf e&;lKk;, mjid bjhlh;e;J kdcisr;rYk; kw;Wk; mtbgaUk; Vw;gl;ljhft[k; mjid NL bra;a 1 Kjy; 8 tiuapyhd vjph;kDjhuh;fs; kDtpy; Bfhhpagoahd bjhifia tHA;f cj;jputpl Btz;Lbkd thjplg;gl;lJ. 8. vjph;kDjhuh;fs; jug;gpy; kDtpy; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s fhuzA;fspd; mog;gilapy; ghpfhuk; Bfhhp Vw;fdBt Mk;g{h; TLjy; chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; mry; tHf;F vz;.4/2004 kDjhuuhy; jhf;fy; bra;agl;L epYitapy; cs;s epiyapy; mBj fhuzA;fSf;fhf ghpfhuk; Bfhhp vjph;kDjhuh;fs; kPJ kPz;Lk; nk;kd;wj;jpy; tHf;F jhf;fy; bra;a KoahJ vdt[k; mjd;go nk;kD js;Sgo bra;a ToajhFk; vd thjplg;gl;L mjw;F Mjukhf Bjrpa Efh;Bthh; ghpfhuk; BfhUk; Mizak;, g[J oy;ypapy; tHA;fg;gl;l fPH;fz;l cj;juit Rl;of;fhl;lg;gl;lJ. III (1994) CPJ 130 (NC) INDIAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION HOUSING SOCIETY LTD., Versus M/S. RUSTUMJI DEVELOPMENTS Wherein the Hon’ble N.C.D.R.Commisison, New Delhi is held that “Consumer Protecitoln Act 1986 – Section 21 – “Complaint” – Sub-judice – Arbitration – Housing – Same matter pending before Arbitrator and also in a Civil suit before a Civil Court – Whether Commision has Has jurisdiction to entertain the complaint – (NO) Held: As has been repeatedly pointed out by us it is not by us it is not appropriate that this Commission should conduct a concurrent adjudication of the identical issues covering same subject matter when they are already pending adjudication before some other competent authority. An other fact brought to our notice is htat the Opposite party has instiuted a suit in the City Civil Court, Bangalore, as Original Suit No.536/91 and some of the issues forming the subject matter of the present complaint are at issue between the same parties in the said suit which is also peinding. In these circumstances we decline to go into the merits of the Original Petition on the aforesaid ground. “ 9. ve;jtpj Kd;dwptpg;gpd;wp, ve;jtpj fhuzkpd;wp kDjhuhpd; K}d;W bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fis vjph;kDjhuh;fs; Jz;of;fg;gl;L, gpd; Beuoahft[k; kw;Wk; kDf;fs; K}yk; Kiwapl;l gpw;ghL fhyjhkjhf kPz;Lk; nizg;g[ bfhLj;jjhft[k; mjdhy; tUtha; nHg;g[ kd cisr;ry; Vw;gl;ljhf kDjhuhpd; kDtpYk; gpukhz thf;FK}yj;jpYk; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;sJ Fwpj;Jk;, kDjhuhpd; rBfhjuUf;F Btiyapy;yhjth;fSf;fhd jpl;ljpd; fPH; tHA;fg;gl;l bjhiyBgrp nizg;ig, bjhiyBgrp Jiwapd; mDkjpapd;wp khw;wk; bra;J te;jJk;, bjhiyBgrp vz;.245378d; chpikahsuhd rjP&; Fkhh; bjhiyBgrp fl;lzk; bjhif U}.9886/- ghf;fp itj;jpUe;j epiyapy; me;j bjhiyBgrpiaa[k; kDjhuh; jtwhf gad;gLj;jp te;jJk; bjhiyBgrp Jiwapd; GK tprhuizapy; bjhpa te;;jjd; mog;gilapy; kDjhuhpd; bjhiyBgrp nizg;g[fs; Jz;of;fg;gl;L gpw;ghL mtuJ Btz;LBfhspd; bgahpYk; ey;byz;zj;jpd; mog;gilapYk; kPz;Lk; nizg;g[ bfhLf;fg;gl;ljhf vjph; kDjhuh;fsps; vjph;ciu kw;Wk; gpukhz thf;FK}yj;jpy; Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;sJ. 10. kDtpy; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s fhuzA;fspd; mog;gilapy; ghpfhuk; Bfhhp Vw;fdBt Mk;g{h; TLjy; chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; mry; tHf;F vz;.4/2004 kDjhuuhy; vjph;kDjhuh;fs; kPJ jhf;fy; bra;agl;L epYitapy; nUe;J tUtjhf vjph;kDjhuh;fs; jug;gpy; Twg;gLtJ Fwpj;J kDjhuh; jug;gpy; kWf;fg;gltpy;iy. vjph; kDjhuh;fs;; jug;gpy; Rl;of;fhl;lg;gl;l Bkw;go Bjrpa Efh;Bthh; ghJfhg;g[ Mizak;, g[Joy;ypapd; jP;h;g;g[iuapy; nUjug;gpdUf;fpilBa cs;s xU gpur;rid Vw;fdBt chpikapy; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; epYitapy; nUe;J tUtJ bjhpa tUk; epiyapy; mBj gpur;ridf;fhf Efh;Bthh; kd;wj;jpy; ghpfhuk; Bfhhp tHf;F jhf;fy; bra;tJk;, mjid tprhhpg;gJk; rhpahdjy;y vdt[k; chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; Vw;fdBt epYit tHf;fpy; ghpfhuk; Bfhhp jPh;t[ bgw;W bfhs;syhk; vdt[k; Fwpgplg;gl;Ls;sJ. 10. ne;j tHf;fpYk; kDtpy; Fwpg;gpl;L fhuzA;fspd; mog;gilapy; Mk;g{h; TLjy; chpikapay; ePjpkd;wj;jpy; mry; tHf;F vz;.4/2004 kDjhuuhy; Vw;fdBt jhf;fy; bra;agl;L epYitapy; nUe;j tUtjhf vjph;kDjhuh;fs; jug;gpy; Twg;gLtij kDjhuh; kWf;fg;gltpy;iy. ne;epiyapy; kDtpy; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s fhuzA;fspd; mog;gilapy; ghpfhuk; Bfhhp kPz;Lk; nk;kd;wj;;jpy; tHf;F jhf;fy; bra;a KoahJ vd vjph;kDjhuh;fs; jug;gpy; Twg;gLtJ Vw;f ToajhFk; vd Kot[ bra;ag;gLfpwJ. vjph;kDjhuh;fs; jug;gpy; Rl;ofhl;lg;gl;l Bkw;go Bjrpa Efh;Bthh; ghpfhuk; BfhUk; Mizaj;jpd; jPh;g;g[iu nt;tHf;fpd; bghUz;ikf;Fk; kw;Wk; R{H;epiyf;Fk; bghUe;jToajhf mike;Js;sJ. mjd;go nt;tHf;F nk;kd;wj;jp;d Ms;tiuf;Fs; cl;glhJ vd Kot[ bra;J tpdh vz;(m) f;F tpilaspf;fg;gLfpwJ. 11. jPh;t[f;Fhpa tpdh (M) kw;Wk; (n):- nt;tHf;F nk;kd;wj;jpd; Ms;tiuf;Fs; cl;glhJ vd tpdh vz;. (m) tpy; Kot[ bra;Js;s epiyapy;, nk;kDtpy; kDjhuUf;F ghpfhuk; vJt[k; fpilf;f Toajpy;iy vd Kot[ bra;J tpdh vz;.(M) kw;Wk; (n)-f;F tpilaspf;fg;gLfpwJ. 13. nWjpapy; nk;kD js;Sgo bra;ag;gLfpwJ. bryt[ bjhif ny;iy. ne;j cj;jut[ jiyth; mth;fshy; RUf;bfGj;J jl;lr;rhplk; bkhHpjy; bra;ag;gl;L, jl;lr;rpy; tof;fg;bgw;W, jiyth; mth;fshy; ghh;itaplg;gl;L gpiHjpUj;jA;fs; bra;J, 2010-Mk; Mz;L Bk; jpA;fs; 31-k; ehshfpa nd;W nj;jpwe;j kd;wj;jpd; Kd; gfug;gLfpwJ. cWg;gpdh;-1 cWg;gpdh; - 2 jiyth;. kDjhuh; jug;g[ rhd;whtzA;fs;: - k.rh.M1 – 23.7.03 - Kjd;ik fzf;F mYtyUf;F mspj;;j kDjhuhpd; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh.M2.- 23.7.03 - BtY]h; khtl;l bghJ BkyhsUf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[ jghy; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh.M3- 23.7.03 - j.eh.jiyik bghJ BkyhsUf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[ jghy; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh.M4-25.7.03 - j.eh.jiyik bghJ Bkyhsh;, brd;idf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[ jghy; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh.M5-25.7.03 - BtY]h; khtl;l bghJ Bkyhsh;, BtYhUf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[ jghy; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh. M6- 30.7.03 – BtY]h; khtl;l bghJ BkyhsUf;F mDg;gpa je;jpapd; efy;. k.rh.M7- 31.7.03 - khtl;l fzf;fpay; mYtyh; kDjhuUf;F mspj;j kW nizg;g[ cj;jutpd; efy;. k.rh.M8-31.7.03 - BtYhh; khtl;l fzf;fpay; mYtyh; mth;fs; mDg;gpa jtwhf Kfthp foj ciuapd; efy;.. k.rh.M9-2.8.03 - j.eh. jiyik Kjd;ik Bkyhsh; brd;id, mth;fSf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[ jghy; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh.M10-2.2.03 - BtY]h; khtl;l bghJ Bkyhsh; BtYhh; mth;fSf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[ jghy; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh.M11-2.8.03 - khtl;l fzf;fpay; mYtyh;, BtY[]h; mth;fSf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[ jghy; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh.m12- 2.8.03 - kDjhuh; Mk;g{h; epiya bjhiyBgrp mjpfhhp mth;fSf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[ jghy; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh.M13- 2.8.03 - kDjhuh; Mk;g{h; epiya bjhiyBgrp mjpfhhp mth;fSf;F mDg;gpa je;jpapd; efy;. k.rh.M14- 4.8.03 - kDjhuh; Mk;g{h; epiya bjhiyBgrp mjpfhhp mth;fSf;F Thpah; K}yk; mDg;gpa foj efy;. k.rh.M15- 7.8.03 - kDjhuh; bgwg;gl;l foj ciu efy;. k.rh.M16- 4.8.03 - kDjhuh; BtY]h; khtl;l bghJBkyhsh; mth;fSf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[jghy; foj efy;. k.rh.M17- 8.8.03 - kDjhuh; BtY]h; khtl;l bghJBkyhsh; mth;fSf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[jghy; foj efy;. k.rh.M18- 11.8.03 - Mk;g{h; bjhiyBgrp epiya mjpfhhp kDjhuUf;F kDg;gpa je;jpapd; efy;. k.rh.M19- 17.8.03 - kDjhuhpd; bjhiyBgrp fl;lz urPJ-2d; efy;. k.rh.M20- 20.8.03- BtY]h; khtl;l bghJ Bkyhsh; mth;fSf;F kDjhuh; mDg;gpa gjpt[jghy; foj efy;. k.rh.M21- 20.8.03 - BtY]h; khtl;l fzf;fpay; mjpfhhp mth;fSf;F mDg;gpa gjpt[jghy; foj efy;. k.rh.M22- 11.9.03 - tpLgl;l bjhiyBgrp gpy;-d; efy;. k.rh.M23- 15.9.03 - bjhiyBgrp gpy;-d; efy;. k.rh.M24- 29.8.03 - vjph;kDjhuh;-1-f;F mDg;gpa gjpt[jghy; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh.M25- 29.8.03 – vjph;kDjhuh;-2-f;F mDg;gpa gjpt[jghy; kDtpd; efy;. k.rh.M26- 3.12.01 – urPJ vz;.154-d; efy;. k.rh.M27- 7.9.00 - vjph;kDjhuh;-7f;F kDjhuh; mDg;gpa fojj;jpd; efy;. k.rh.M28- 8.9.03 - b$.BtY, vd;gth; Mk;g{h;, bjhiyBgrp epiya myt yUf;F mDg;gpa fojj;jpd; efy;. k.rh.M29- 20.5.02 - Mk;g{h; rjP&;Fkhh; bjhiyBgrp vz;.45378, U}.10299/- epYit rk;ge;jkhd fojj;jpd; efy;. k.rh.M30- -- - vjph;khDjhuh;-6 mDg;gpa fojj;jpd; efy;. k.rh.M31 - -- - 3-vk; vjph;kDjhuh; rjP&;FkhUf;F mDg;gpa fojj;jpd; efy;. k.rh.M32- -- - cWjpbkhHp (U}.10299/-) gj;jpuj;jpd; efy;. k.rh.M33-}}} ] k.rh.M34- ] --- - bjhiyBgrp fl;lz urPjppd; efy;. k.rh.M35- ] vjph;kDjhuh;fspd; jug;g[ rhd;whtzA;fs;: v.rh.M1- 17.7.58 - foj vz;.16-13/58 PHC Rule-d; efy;. v.rh.M2- 2.9.03 - 8-k; vjph;kDjhuhpd; foj efy;. v.rh.M3- 4.9.03 - 6k; vjph;kDjhuh; 5-k; vjph;kDjhuUf;F mDg;gp foj;jpd; efy;. v.rh.M4- 11.2.03 –1-k; vjph;kDjhUf;F fpilf;f bgw;w hpg;Bghh;l;. v.rh.M5- 15.7.03 -4-k; vjph;kDjhuh; kDjhuUf;F mDg;gpa fojj;jpd; efy;. v.rh.M6- 30.4.00 - Btiyapy;yhjth;fSf;fhd rhd;wpjHpd; efy;. cWg;gpdh;-1 cWg;gpdh; - 2 jiyth;. | 
